Skip to content

Commit 8137d40

Browse files
Revise K06 ATA 93 Tasklist and enhance content
Updated the title and description for clarity and expanded the content significantly to provide a comprehensive overview of the K06 ATA 93 Tasklist, including detailed sections on uncertainty resolution, tasks, global navigation, and control monitoring.
1 parent d76df07 commit 8137d40

File tree

1 file changed

+271
-12
lines changed

1 file changed

+271
-12
lines changed
Lines changed: 271 additions & 12 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,20 +1,279 @@
11
---
2-
title: "K06 ATA 93 Tasklist"
2+
title: "K06 ATA 93 — Partitioned Uncertainty Resolution Index"
33
type: IDX
4-
variant: "SPACET"
4+
variant: SPACET
55
status: Draft
6-
knot_id: "K06"
6+
knot_id: K06
77
ata: "93"
8+
lc_or_subbucket: "LC01"
9+
description: "GitHub-navigable hub for closing K06 (SSOT/Schemas/Identifiers) for ATA 93 (Traceability Graph & Evidence Link Semantics) with NKU control and TEKNIA sharing rules."
810
---
911

10-
# K06 — data-governance-ssot-schemas-identifiers
11-
## ATA 93 — Tasklist
12+
# K06 — Data Governance (SSOT / Schemas / Identifiers)
13+
## ATA 93 — Partitioned Uncertainty Resolution Index (IDX)
1214

13-
## Uncertainty to Resolve (ATA-specific)
14-
- ...
15+
This file is the **single navigation hub** for all artifacts required to close **K06** for **ATA 93** (your domain for **Traceability Graph and Evidence Link Semantics**).
16+
NKU progress is credited only when each partition is closed with **evidence + approval**.
1517

16-
## Tasks (minimum set)
17-
1. Define ATA-specific scope, interfaces, owners.
18-
2. Define decision criteria and evidence package.
19-
3. Execute validation/verification activities.
20-
4. Record decision; update baseline and trace links.
18+
> ATA 93 is where K06 becomes operational: if trace edges are ambiguous or broken, K06 cannot be closed program-wide.
19+
20+
---
21+
22+
## 1) Global Navigation (GitHub-navigable)
23+
24+
- Knot overview: [K06 overview](../../00_00_IDX_LC01_SPACET_k06-data-governance-ssot-schemas-identifiers_v01.md)
25+
_Comment:_ Canonical K06 scope, impacted ATAs, closure criteria, shared definitions.
26+
27+
- Portal index: [AMPEL360-SPACE-T-PORTAL index](../../../../../00_00_IDX_LC01_SPACET_stakeholder-entrypoints_v01.md)
28+
_Comment:_ Global entry point; use it to navigate stakeholders and the knot portfolio.
29+
30+
- Stakeholder entrypoint (AI): [STK_AI entrypoint](../../../../00_00_IDX_LC01_SPACET_stakeholder-ai-entrypoint_v01.md)
31+
_Comment:_ AI/ML execution lane; automation hooks and governance helpers.
32+
33+
- ATA 93 home (Traceability): [AMPEL360_SPACE-T/N-NEURAL_NETWORKS/ATA 93](../../../../../../AMPEL360_SPACE-T/N-NEURAL_NETWORKS/ATA_93-TRACEABILITY-GRAPH/)
34+
_Comment:_ Intended authoritative location for ATA 93 outputs. If your folder name differs, update only this link target.
35+
36+
---
37+
38+
## 2) ATA 93 K06 Focus (what uncertainty we are closing)
39+
40+
### Uncertainty to Resolve (ATA-specific)
41+
K06 within ATA 93 is the absence of a single governed SSOT for:
42+
- **Trace node identity:** canonical IDs for artifacts, requirements, hazards, tests, datasets, models, decisions.
43+
- **Trace edge semantics:** standardized edge types (e.g., *derives*, *verifies*, *mitigates*, *implements*, *depends-on*, *evidenced-by*).
44+
- **Evidence link rules:** how links point to files, commits, releases, signed packs; staleness detection rules.
45+
- **Graph integrity:** prevention of orphan nodes, broken edges, cycles (where prohibited), and duplicate identities.
46+
- **Publication:** deterministic export of trace graphs for audits, reviews, and DPP packs.
47+
- **Enforcement:** CI gates that block merges when trace integrity breaks.
48+
49+
### Primary consumers (typical)
50+
- Configuration management, safety/certification evidence, DPP exports, CI validation, sim/test evidence nodes (100+), agent automation.
51+
52+
---
53+
54+
## 3) Partitioned Uncertainty Resolution Pathway (P1–P8)
55+
56+
Each partition corresponds to a dedicated folder. **Do not credit closure** unless the partition’s “Done” definition is satisfied.
57+
58+
### P1 — Work Breakdown & Ownership (Execution Closure)
59+
- Folder: [01_WBS/](01_WBS/)
60+
_Comment:_ Converts uncertainty into executable work packages (tasks, owners, inputs/outputs).
61+
62+
- WBS index: [K06 ATA 93 Work Breakdown](01_WBS/93_00_IDX_LC01_SPACET_k06-ata-93-workbreakdown_v01.md)
63+
_Closes:_ “We don’t know what to do next / who owns it.”
64+
_Done when:_ T001–T009 exist with owners, acceptance criteria, and artifact links.
65+
66+
- RACI (CSV): [RACI](01_WBS/93_00_MAT_LC06_SPACET_k06-ata-93-raci_v01.csv)
67+
_Closes:_ Responsibility ambiguity (execution vs approval).
68+
_Done when:_ CM approval path is explicit and accepted.
69+
70+
**Task stubs (minimum set — expanded for trace graph domain):**
71+
- T001: [SSOT source & ownership](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t001-ssot-source-ownership_v01.md)
72+
_Comment:_ Declares SSOT for trace graph store, link conventions, and authority for edge semantics.
73+
74+
- T002: [Identifier grammar](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t002-identifier-grammar_v01.md)
75+
_Comment:_ Canonical IDs for nodes/edges, including stable URI-like references to repo artifacts.
76+
77+
- T003: [Edge semantics standard](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t003-edge-semantics-standard_v01.md)
78+
_Comment:_ Defines allowed edge types, directionality, and constraints (what can link to what).
79+
80+
- T004: [Evidence link standard](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t004-evidence-link-standard_v01.md)
81+
_Comment:_ Defines link targets (path/commit/tag/signed pack), and how staleness is detected.
82+
83+
- T005: [Graph integrity rules](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t005-graph-integrity-rules_v01.md)
84+
_Comment:_ Orphans, duplicates, prohibited cycles, minimum required edges for closure.
85+
86+
- T006: [Export publication](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t006-export-publication_v01.md)
87+
_Comment:_ Deterministic trace graph export (CSV/JSON) for audits and downstream consumption.
88+
89+
- T007: [CI validation gates](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t007-ci-validation-gates_v01.md)
90+
_Comment:_ Enforces trace integrity and evidence link rules in PRs.
91+
92+
- T008: [Cross-ATA adoption plan](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t008-cross-ata-adoption-plan_v01.md)
93+
_Comment:_ Onboarding checklist for ATAs to conform to trace rules.
94+
95+
- T009: [Baseline trace snapshot](01_WBS/93_00_ACT_LC06_SPACET_k06-t009-baseline-trace-snapshot_v01.md)
96+
_Comment:_ Frozen snapshot for a milestone; referenced by DPP packs and certification evidence.
97+
98+
---
99+
100+
### P2 — IDs & Registry (Identity Closure)
101+
- Folder: [02_IDS_REGISTRY/](02_IDS_REGISTRY/)
102+
_Comment:_ Ensures trace node and edge identifiers are unique, owned, and discoverable.
103+
104+
- Standard (STD): [Identifier grammar](02_IDS_REGISTRY/93_00_STD_LC03_SPACET_trace-identifier-grammar_v01.md)
105+
_Done when:_ Grammar is approved and referenced by schema + CI.
106+
107+
- Registry (TAB/CSV): [Trace node registry](02_IDS_REGISTRY/93_00_TAB_LC03_SPACET_trace-node-registry_v01.csv)
108+
_Done when:_ Nodes are uniquely identified and mapped to repo artifacts.
109+
110+
- Registry (TAB/CSV): [Trace edge registry](02_IDS_REGISTRY/93_00_TAB_LC03_SPACET_trace-edge-registry_v01.csv)
111+
_Done when:_ Edge types are enumerated with constraints and owners.
112+
113+
- Change log (LOG): [Registry change log](02_IDS_REGISTRY/93_00_LOG_LC03_SPACET_registry-change-log_v01.md)
114+
_Done when:_ Every change references a decision (P7).
115+
116+
---
117+
118+
### P3 — Schema & Versioning (Semantic Closure)
119+
- Folder: [03_SCHEMA/](03_SCHEMA/)
120+
_Comment:_ Defines machine-readable schemas for trace graphs and evidence links.
121+
122+
- Schema (SCH/JSON): [Trace graph schema](03_SCHEMA/93_00_SCH_LC03_SPACET_trace-graph-schema_v01.json)
123+
_Done when:_ Validates exported graphs and is used by CI.
124+
125+
- Schema (SCH/JSON): [Evidence link schema](03_SCHEMA/93_00_SCH_LC03_SPACET_evidence-link-schema_v01.json)
126+
_Done when:_ Validates link targets and metadata (commit/tag/hash/classification).
127+
128+
- Standard (STD): [Schema versioning policy](03_SCHEMA/93_00_STD_LC03_SPACET_schema-versioning-policy_v01.md)
129+
_Done when:_ Compatibility and breaking-change rules exist and are enforced.
130+
131+
---
132+
133+
### P4 — Exports (Consumable Data Closure)
134+
- Folder: [04_EXPORTS/](04_EXPORTS/)
135+
_Comment:_ Deterministic graph exports and audit-ready snapshots.
136+
137+
- Baseline export (TAB/CSV): [Baseline trace graph export](04_EXPORTS/93_00_TAB_LC04_SPACET_baseline-trace-graph-export_v01.csv)
138+
_Done when:_ Export is reproducible, validated, and milestone-referenced.
139+
140+
- Manifest (RPT): [Export manifest](04_EXPORTS/93_00_RPT_LC04_SPACET_export-manifest_v01.md)
141+
_Done when:_ Inputs/tools/versions are recorded; rebuild is deterministic.
142+
143+
- Diagram (DIA): [Trace graph map](04_EXPORTS/93_00_DIA_LC04_SPACET_trace-graph-map_v01.md)
144+
_Done when:_ Diagram references match registries and exports.
145+
146+
---
147+
148+
### P5 — CI Gates (Enforcement Closure)
149+
- Folder: [05_CI_GATES/](05_CI_GATES/)
150+
_Comment:_ Blocks merges that break trace integrity or evidence rules.
151+
152+
- Requirements (STD): [CI validation requirements](05_CI_GATES/93_00_STD_LC05_SPACET_ci-validation-requirements_v01.md)
153+
_Done when:_ Rules map to checks; failures are actionable.
154+
155+
- Checklist (LOG): [CI checklist](05_CI_GATES/93_00_LOG_LC05_SPACET_ci-checklist_v01.md)
156+
_Done when:_ Checklist matches CI outputs and reviewer expectations.
157+
158+
- Sample run (RPT): [CI validation sample run](05_CI_GATES/93_00_RPT_LC05_SPACET_ci-validation-sample-run_v01.md)
159+
_Done when:_ Demonstrates representative pass/fail cases (broken link, orphan node, invalid edge type).
160+
161+
---
162+
163+
### P6 — Evidence Pack (Proof Closure)
164+
- Folder: [06_EVIDENCE/](06_EVIDENCE/)
165+
_Comment:_ NKU credit requires reproducible evidence and stable links.
166+
167+
- Evidence pack index (IDX): [Evidence pack](06_EVIDENCE/93_00_IDX_LC06_SPACET_k06-ata-93-evidence-pack_v01.md)
168+
_Done when:_ All required evidence is linked and current.
169+
170+
- Evidence links (TRC/CSV): [Evidence links register](06_EVIDENCE/93_00_TRC_LC06_SPACET_k06-ata-93-evidence-links_v01.csv)
171+
_Done when:_ Each claim has evidence links and status (OK/STALE/MISSING).
172+
173+
- NKU ledger (TAB/CSV): [NKU ledger](06_EVIDENCE/93_00_TAB_LC06_SPACET_k06-ata-93-nku-ledger_v01.csv)
174+
_Done when:_ Partition scores are updated and backed by evidence + decision.
175+
176+
---
177+
178+
### P7 — Decisions & Approvals (Authority Closure)
179+
- Folder: [07_DECISIONS/](07_DECISIONS/)
180+
_Comment:_ Converts evidence into approved baseline outcomes for trace semantics.
181+
182+
- Decision minutes (MIN): [Decision minutes](07_DECISIONS/93_00_MIN_LC07_SPACET_k06-ata-93-decision-minutes_v01.md)
183+
_Done when:_ Decision, rationale, dissent/risks are recorded.
184+
185+
- Approvals log (LOG): [Approvals log](07_DECISIONS/93_00_LOG_LC07_SPACET_k06-ata-93-approvals_v01.md)
186+
_Done when:_ CM approval + trace authority sign-offs are referenced.
187+
188+
---
189+
190+
### P8 — Traceability & Adoption (Impact Closure)
191+
- Folder: [08_TRACEABILITY/](08_TRACEABILITY/)
192+
_Comment:_ Ensures every consumer adopts the trace rules; prevents “shadow traces”.
193+
194+
- Consumers (TRC/CSV): [Consumers list](08_TRACEABILITY/93_00_TRC_LC08_SPACET_k06-ata-93-consumers_v01.csv)
195+
_Done when:_ Consumers are listed with interface/version and owner.
196+
197+
- Adoption status (RPT): [Adoption status](08_TRACEABILITY/93_00_RPT_LC08_SPACET_k06-ata-93-adoption-status_v01.md)
198+
_Done when:_ Each consumer has status + remediation plan if blocked.
199+
200+
---
201+
202+
## 4) Cross-ATA Links (same Knot, coupled closures)
203+
204+
ATA 93 is a cross-ATA dependency. These couplings are mandatory.
205+
206+
- [ATA 90 — NN / Schemas / DPP spine](../ATA_90/)
207+
_Comment:_ Meta-registry, provenance expectations, TEKNIA packaging gates.
208+
209+
- [ATA 91 — Schemas](../ATA_91/)
210+
_Comment:_ Edge and evidence schemas must be defined and versioned consistently.
211+
212+
- [ATA 94 — DPP](../ATA_94/)
213+
_Comment:_ DPP export packs must reference trace graph snapshots and evidence links.
214+
215+
- [ATA 95 — SBOM / ModelBOM](../ATA_95/)
216+
_Comment:_ Supply-chain trace links must conform to edge semantics and evidence rules.
217+
218+
- [ATA 98 — Signed Export Packs](../ATA_98/)
219+
_Comment:_ Signed packs are the preferred evidence-link target for “released” states.
220+
221+
- [ATA 99 — Master Registers](../ATA_99/)
222+
_Comment:_ Consolidated registers and anti-duplication controls.
223+
224+
**Sim/Test Coupling (100+):**
225+
- [ATA 101](../ATA_101/), [ATA 107](../ATA_107/), [ATA 109](../ATA_109/)
226+
_Comment:_ Sim/test evidence nodes must export trace edges and evidence links that validate under ATA 93 schemas.
227+
228+
---
229+
230+
## 5) Control & Monitoring (NKU Values + TEKNIA Sharing Rules)
231+
232+
### 5.1 NKU Control Model
233+
**Primary metric:** NKU Progress Score for K06/ATA93
234+
**Source of truth:** [NKU ledger](06_EVIDENCE/93_00_TAB_LC06_SPACET_k06-ata-93-nku-ledger_v01.csv)
235+
236+
**Scoring:**
237+
- `score ∈ {0, 0.5, 1.0}`
238+
- **NKU Score** = `Σ(weight × score)` across partitions P1..P8
239+
240+
**No-false-closure (mandatory):**
241+
- `score = 1.0` requires:
242+
- evidence link(s) in `06_EVIDENCE/...evidence-links...csv`, and
243+
- decision reference in `07_DECISIONS/...decision-minutes...md` (and approvals if applicable).
244+
245+
### 5.2 Monitoring Cadence
246+
| Control Item | Owner | Frequency | Source | Comment |
247+
|---|---|---:|---|---|
248+
| NKU ledger updates | AI + DATA | Per PR affecting K06/ATA93 | NKU ledger + evidence links | No score uplift without links |
249+
| CI gate compliance | CM + Tooling | Per PR | CI gates + logs | Enforcement mechanism |
250+
| Graph integrity | Trace Authority + Tooling | Per PR + weekly sweep | CI outputs + integrity reports | Orphans/broken edges are blockers |
251+
| Evidence freshness | SE + V&V | Weekly / per gate | Evidence links register | Detect staleness |
252+
| Decision capture | CM WG + Trace Authority | At gate closure | Decisions + approvals | Required for closure |
253+
| Adoption tracking | Consumer owners | Biweekly | Consumers + adoption status | Prevent shadow traces |
254+
255+
### 5.3 Thresholds
256+
- Green ≥ 0.80; Amber 0.50–0.79; Red < 0.50
257+
Hard blockers: missing P2/P3/P5 closure, missing P7 decision, stale evidence for any closed item.
258+
259+
### 5.4 TEKNIA Sharing Rules
260+
TEKTOKs may be created only when:
261+
- Evidence is reproducible (P6 complete)
262+
- Decision exists (P7 complete, CM-approved)
263+
- Dedup passes (SHA-256)
264+
- NV threshold met (≥ 0.50 internal, ≥ 0.65 external recommended)
265+
266+
### 5.5 Enforcement
267+
CI should validate:
268+
- trace graph schema compliance
269+
- link target validity (path/commit/tag/signed pack) and required metadata
270+
- graph integrity constraints (no broken edges/orphans)
271+
- TEKNIA gate for “approved” TEKTOK status (NV + dedup)
272+
273+
---
274+
275+
## 6) Practical Notes (common failure modes)
276+
- If a consumer cannot ingest the trace export deterministically, K06 cannot be considered closed.
277+
- Prefer signed export packs as evidence targets for released states; raw file paths drift.
278+
- Avoid ambiguous edge types; if a new edge type is needed, register it (P2) and define semantics (P3) before use.
279+
```

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)