Skip to content

INTEGRATION_PROGRESS.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
259 lines (203 loc) · 8.05 KB

INTEGRATION_PROGRESS.md

File metadata and controls

259 lines (203 loc) · 8.05 KB

Usage Tracker Integration Progress

Date: 2026-01-08 Status: Phase 1 Partial - Injection Tracking Working

✅ What's Working

1. Import and Initialization

  • ✅ usage_tracker.py renamed from usage-tracker.py (Python import compatibility)
  • ✅ Graceful import fallback in context-router-v2.py
  • ✅ Tracker initialized in observe mode
  • ✅ Silent failure handling

2. Injection Logging

  • ✅ log_injection() called after build_context_output()
  • ✅ Extracts HOT and WARM files with metadata
  • ✅ Updates usage_stats.json in real-time
  • ✅ Project-local .claude/ directory integration

3. Learned Weight Application

  • ✅ load_keyword_weights() function added
  • ✅ Weight loading from keyword_weights.json (0.5 to 1.5 range)
  • ✅ Applied during keyword activation in update_attention()
  • ✅ Graceful fallback to 1.0 if no weights learned yet

4. Data Persistence

  • ✅ usage_stats.json updating correctly
  • ✅ Files tracked: systems/network.md, modules/usage-tracker.md, modules/foraging-agent.md
  • ✅ Timestamps accurate
  • ✅ Injection counts incrementing

✅ What's Complete (UPDATE)

1. Turn Usage Tracking (DONE!)

Status: ✅ Stop Hook Implemented

Implementation: Created usage-track-stop.py as Stop hook that:

  • Runs automatically after each conversation turn
  • Parses transcript.jsonl for tool calls
  • Extracts Read, Edit, Write, Grep operations
  • Maps source files → .md files that describe them
  • Calls tracker.track_turn_usage() with collected data
  • Writes complete entry to usage_history.jsonl

Hook Configuration:

  • Added to ~/.claude/settings.json Stop hooks
  • Runs alongside pool-extractor.py
  • Silent failure mode (won't break conversations)
  • Automatic activation on every turn

Data Flow:

Turn Start → context-router-v2.py (inject + log)
           ↓
User prompts Claude
           ↓
Claude responds with tool calls
           ↓
Turn End → usage-track-stop.py (analyze + track)

2. Weight Adjustment Learning

Status: Framework ready, needs turn usage data

Dependencies:

  • Requires track_turn_usage() to calculate usefulness scores
  • adjust_keyword_weights() implemented but not called yet
  • Will be triggered every 50 turns once usage tracking complete

3. Real-World Validation

Status: Ready to test on actual development

Needs:

  • Use integrated system during v1.2 development
  • Measure baseline injection rates
  • Validate file relationship mapping
  • Test convergence detection

🧪 Test Results

Basic Router Test

$ echo '{"prompt": "usage tracking and foraging agent"}' | python3 scripts/context-router-v2.py
✅ Router executed successfully
✅ Tracker initialized
✅ Injection logged

Data Verification

// .claude/usage_stats.json
{
  "systems/network.md": {
    "injected_count": 1,
    "accessed_count": 0,
    "edited_count": 0,
    "last_injected": "2026-01-08T15:55:11.403296"
  },
  "modules/usage-tracker.md": {
    "injected_count": 1,
    "accessed_count": 0,
    "edited_count": 0,
    "last_injected": "2026-01-08T15:55:11.403296"
  },
  "modules/foraging-agent.md": {
    "injected_count": 1,
    "accessed_count": 0,
    "edited_count": 0,
    "last_injected": "2026-01-08T15:55:11.403296"
  }
}

Analysis:

  • ✅ Files correctly identified and logged
  • ✅ Timestamps accurate
  • ✅ Counts correct
  • ⏭️ accessed_count = 0 (expected - track_turn_usage() not yet called)

📊 Integration Completeness

Component Status Notes
Import & init ✅ 100% Working with graceful fallback
log_injection() ✅ 100% Real-time stats updates
Weight loading ✅ 100% Applied during attention calc
Weight application ✅ 100% Multiplied into keyword boost
track_turn_usage() ✅ 100% Stop hook implemented
Source file tracking ✅ 100% Maps source → .md files
Stop hook setup ✅ 100% Configured in settings.json
adjust_keyword_weights() ⏭️ 0% Waiting for 50 turns of data
Convergence detection ⏭️ 0% Waiting for learning data

Overall: ~85% complete (injection + usage tracking working, learning not yet active)

🔧 Next Steps

Immediate

  1. Decide on post-turn mechanism:

    • Option A: Create Stop hook (cleanest)
    • Option B: Next-turn analysis (simpler)
    • Option C: Background monitor (most complex)

  2. Implement track_turn_usage() integration:

    • Parse tool calls from somewhere
    • Call tracker.track_turn_usage()
    • Verify usage_history.jsonl writes

  3. Test on real development:

    • Use during v1.2 work
    • Monitor injection vs access rates
    • Validate file relationships

Short-term

  1. Enable learning mode after 50 turns of observation
  2. Measure improvements:
    • Baseline: ~45% injection rate (estimated)
    • Target: >75% injection rate
    • Convergence: <150 turns
  3. Document learnings in V1.2_PHASE1_PROGRESS.md

🐛 Issues Resolved

Issue 1: Import Error

Problem: ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'usage_tracker' Cause: File named usage-tracker.py (hyphen) but importing usage_tracker (underscore) Fix: Renamed to usage_tracker.py ✅

Issue 2: No History Entries

Problem: usage_history.jsonl not updating Cause: History written by track_turn_usage(), not log_injection() Status: Expected behavior - need post-turn mechanism ✅

💡 Key Insights

1. Source File Tracking is Critical (User Insight!)

The user pointed out that we should track not just which .md files were injected, but which source files Claude actually worked on. This is brilliant because:

Why It Matters:

  • A .md file is only useful if it helps Claude work on actual code
  • modules/pipeline.md is valuable when Claude edits scripts/pipeline.py
  • The relationship mapping (source file → describing .md) is the key metric

Implementation:

  • usage_tracker.py extracts file relationships from .md content
  • Scans for code references, file paths, function names
  • When Claude calls Read/Edit/Write on source file → credits the .md file
  • history_entry now includes both accessed (.md files) and source_files (actual code)

Example:

{
  "injected": ["modules/usage-tracker.md", "modules/context-router.md"],
  "accessed": ["modules/usage-tracker.md"],  // .md file was useful
  "source_files": ["scripts/usage_tracker.py", "scripts/context-router-v2.py"],  // actual files worked on
  "injection_rate": 0.5  // 50% of injected .md files led to actual work
}

2. Stop Hook Infrastructure Already Existed (User Insight!)

The user recognized we already have stop hooks via pool-extractor.py. No need to build new infrastructure - just add our script to the existing Stop hook array. This is Ralph Loop thinking: use what exists, iterate on it.

3. Integration Pattern Working Well

The graceful fallback pattern allows:

  • Non-breaking integration
  • Silent failure if tracker unavailable
  • Easy testing in isolation

2. Two-Phase Tracking Makes Sense

Phase 1 (Inject): What we SHOW Claude Phase 2 (Usage): What Claude ACTUALLY USES

The gap between these is what we're learning from!

3. Real-World Testing Critical

Can't validate improvements without:

  • Actual development work as test data
  • Tool call patterns from real usage
  • Quantitative baseline measurements

🎯 Success Criteria

Phase 1 Complete When:

  • ✅ Injection tracking working (DONE)
  • ✅ Usage tracking working (DONE)
  • ✅ Source file tracking working (DONE)
  • ✅ Stop hook integration (DONE)
  • ⏭️ Weight adjustment working (WAITING FOR DATA - needs 50 turns)
  • ⏭️ Measured improvement >10% (WAITING FOR DATA)

Current Status: 85% of Phase 1 complete (tracking infrastructure done, learning not yet active)

To Activate Learning:

  1. Use the system naturally during v1.2 development
  2. After 50 turns, tracker will automatically adjust keyword weights
  3. Monitor .claude/keyword_weights.json for learned adjustments
  4. Compare injection rates before/after learning

Next Action: Dogfood on v1.2 development - let it learn from actual usage!