Is it expected marks behaviour?

[michael (michaelsamoilenko)]

I'm using Rider and ideavim. I don't have ideamarks command set in my .ideavimrc so I'm using default behaviour which is:
Maps Vim's global marks to IDE bookmarks.

Everything is working fine if I'm in a single solution. However if I open 2 solutions A and B then I face strange behaviour:

• (Solution A) m1 command
• (Solution B) m1 command
• (Solution A) `1 command. A FILE IS OPENED from Solution B where I had my 1 bookmark

I expect it to open file from Solution A when I'm in Solution A however it seems it just opens whatever last file had mark with that index. Is it expected behaviour? The default Rider IDE behaviour will be as I would expect. Bookmarks with same values won't interleave between solution and when I'm in Solution A, only Solution A bookmarks will be opened.

I had empty .ideavimrc to remove an option that something can be wrong with my config so it seems something is wrong with plugin itself. Can anybody comment on that please? I wasn't able to find any related issues

[michael (michaelsamoilenko)]

any thoughts?

[Matt Ellis (citizenmatt)]

IdeaVim's global marks (numbered and uppercase) are global to the application, while they should probably be global to the current project (solution in Rider terminology). So last write to a mark wins, regardless of which IDE instance you're in. There is a ticket for this, but there's no priority or ETA for a fix: VIM-1516.

The 'ideamarks' option doesn't make any difference to this behaviour - when setting a global mark in Vim, IdeaVim will also set the bookmark of the same name. These IDE bookmarks are per-project, but IdeaVim is per-application.

[michael (michaelsamoilenko)]

got it thanks!