Skip to content

SANITY_CHECK.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
221 lines (164 loc) · 7.41 KB

SANITY_CHECK.md

File metadata and controls

221 lines (164 loc) · 7.41 KB

FINAL SANITY CHECK — v1.0.0 Pre-Release Review

Date: January 17, 2026
Status: ✅ PASSED
Reviewer: Senior Engineer (Pre-Release)

Checklist of Confirmations

1. Code Quality & Cleanliness

  • ✅ No unused files: Deleted api/main.py (old demo runner, unreferenced)
  • ✅ No dead code: Deleted evaluate.py (offline evaluation, not part of active system)
  • ✅ No TODOs/FIXMEs: Scanned src/**/*.py and app.py — zero TODOs found
  • ✅ No debug code: No print statements, no hardcoded paths
  • ✅ Professional imports: All imports are organized and necessary

Action Taken: Removed 2 unused files. Codebase is clean.

2. API Endpoints — Consistency with README

Documented in README_MAIN.md:

  • GET / — Health check
  • GET /health — Uptime monitoring
  • POST /login — Authentication
  • POST /recommend — Main recommendation endpoint
  • POST /explain — Eligibility explanation
  • POST /explain/natural — Natural language explanation (optional LLM)
  • GET /audit/{run_id} — Audit trail retrieval
  • DELETE/PATCH/PUT /audit/{run_id} — Immutability enforcement (409)
  • GET /analytics/summary — Overall statistics
  • GET /analytics/top-schemes — Top recommendations
  • GET /analytics/eligibility-rates — Per-scheme eligibility %
  • GET /analytics/scoring-distribution — Score range histogram
  • GET /analytics/model-drift — ML drift detection
  • GET /schemes — Scheme listing

Verified in app.py:

  • ✅ All 16 endpoints implemented
  • ✅ All endpoints match README descriptions
  • ✅ All RBAC requirements enforced (auth, auditor-only, public)
  • ✅ All response models defined in Pydantic

Status: ✅ 100% consistency

3. Services & Core Logic — Alignment with Architecture

Component Status Notes
eligibility_engine.py ✅ Rule-based, deterministic, unchanged from spec
scoring_engine.py ✅ Rule-based scoring, correctly designed
ml_ranker.py ✅ ML optional, returns confidence, deterministic
auth.py ✅ JWT, 3 roles (user/auditor/admin), HS256
rbac.py ✅ Role decorators, 403 enforcement
db.py ✅ WORM audit trail, immutable, SQLite persistent
config.py ✅ 3 scoring modes (rules/ml/hybrid), JSON config
llm_explainer.py ✅ Optional, read-only, deterministic fallback

Status: ✅ All services aligned with documentation

4. Test Suite — Coverage & Philosophy

Test Files Created:

  • ✅ tests/test_eligibility.py — 26 tests (boundary cases, edge cases, combined constraints)
  • ✅ tests/test_auth.py — 32 tests (RBAC, tokens, unauthenticated)
  • ✅ tests/test_audit.py — 20 tests (immutability, 409 enforcement)
  • ✅ tests/test_versioning.py — 12 tests (ML versioning, confidence, drift RBAC)

Total: 90 focused, deterministic tests

What IS tested:

  • ✅ Eligibility correctness (all constraints)
  • ✅ RBAC enforcement (all roles)
  • ✅ Audit immutability (WORM)
  • ✅ ML versioning & confidence tracking
  • ✅ No mocks, direct integration testing

What is NOT tested (intentionally):

  • ❌ UI/frontend (not in scope)
  • ❌ Performance/load testing (not in scope)
  • ❌ Database migration scripts (SQLite is simple)
  • ❌ External service integrations (none exist)

Status: ✅ Tests are appropriate and sufficient for scope

5. Scope Boundaries — No Creep

README Non-Goals (explicitly stated):

  1. ❌ Automated decision-making via ML — NOT implemented ✅
  2. ❌ Opaque models — Logistic regression only ✅
  3. ❌ Real-time scheme mutation — Config versioning per run ✅
  4. ❌ User profiling beyond request scope — Stateless recommendations ✅

Features NOT added (stayed disciplined):

  • ❌ Scheduled jobs or background workers
  • ❌ Real-time model updates
  • ❌ User profiling or behavioral tracking
  • ❌ Advanced ML (neural networks, ensemble)
  • ❌ A/B testing framework
  • ❌ Cache layer
  • ❌ Message queues
  • ❌ Microservices

Status: ✅ Zero scope creep, clear boundaries

6. Code Style & Consistency

Aspect Status Notes
Naming ✅ snake_case for functions, PascalCase for classes, consistent
Docstrings ✅ All functions have docstrings with Args/Returns/Purpose
Type hints ✅ Comprehensive type hints throughout
Comments ✅ Strategic comments (why, not what)
Line length ✅ Reasonable, no excessive nesting
Imports ✅ Organized, no unused imports
Error handling ✅ HTTPException for API, meaningful messages
Constants ✅ No magic numbers, config-driven

Status: ✅ Professional, consistent code

7. Documentation Completeness

README_MAIN.md includes:

  • ✅ Overview & features
  • ✅ Tech stack
  • ✅ Installation & setup
  • ✅ Running the application
  • ✅ Usage examples
  • ✅ Architecture diagrams (SVG)
  • ✅ Design decisions (5 detailed sections)
  • ✅ Non-goals (4 explicit non-goals)
  • ✅ Model versioning & drift monitoring
  • ✅ Compliance guarantees (WORM, RBAC)
  • ✅ Deployment guide (Render)
  • ✅ Contributing & license

Coverage: ✅ Comprehensive, zero gaps

8. Database & Persistence

  • ✅ Schema: UserProfileDB, RecommendationRunDB, SchemeDecisionDB defined
  • ✅ Immutability: WORM enforced (no UPDATE/DELETE), read-only GET only
  • ✅ Versioning: ml_model_version and ml_confidence tracked
  • ✅ SQLite: Simple, file-based, no external dependencies
  • ✅ Init: init_db() called on startup
  • ✅ Migrations: None needed (SQLAlchemy creates tables)

Status: ✅ Database is solid and compliant

9. Configuration Management

  • ✅ config.json: Scoring mode configurable (rules/ml/hybrid)
  • ✅ render.yaml: Environment variables for deployment
  • ✅ requirements.txt: All dependencies pinned and necessary
  • ✅ JWT_SECRET: Environment variable (not hardcoded)
  • ✅ DATABASE_URL: Configurable, defaults to SQLite

Status: ✅ Config is production-ready

10. Deployment Readiness

  • ✅ render.yaml: Complete, health check configured
  • ✅ /health endpoint: Proper status response
  • ✅ Error handling: 500 errors caught and logged
  • ✅ Logging: Meaningful error messages
  • ✅ CORS: Not needed (backend API only)
  • ✅ Graceful degradation: LLM, ML optional

Status: ✅ Ready for production deployment

Summary of Actions Taken

  1. ✅ Deleted api/main.py — Unused demo runner
  2. ✅ Deleted evaluate.py — Unused offline evaluation script
  3. ✅ Verified all 16 endpoints — Match README, proper RBAC
  4. ✅ Confirmed 90 tests — Comprehensive, appropriate, no mocks
  5. ✅ Scanned for TODOs — Zero found
  6. ✅ Checked scope boundaries — All non-goals respected
  7. ✅ Verified code style — Consistent, professional
  8. ✅ Confirmed documentation — Complete, comprehensive

Final Status

✅ APPROVED FOR v1.0.0 RELEASE

Repository is:

  • ✅ Clean (dead code removed)
  • ✅ Complete (all features documented and implemented)
  • ✅ Correct (consistent with specs)
  • ✅ Tested (90 focused tests)
  • ✅ Documented (comprehensive README)
  • ✅ Production-Ready (deployment config included)

No blocking issues found.

Next Step: Proceed to Testing Philosophy, Release Notes, Portfolio Review, and Resume Bullets.