Run name: p3_market_27b_v1 (1 of 3 — all 3 STRUCTURAL_PASS)
Wall: 17.3 minutes (1037s), 71 iterations
Cost upper: $0.0225
Verdict: STRUCTURAL_PASS (citation validity is hand-grading placeholder — see caveat in task README)
Drove a multi-step internet-research workflow against the live web. Read documentation pages, vendor pricing pages, comparison articles. Wrote three structured deliverables (recommendation.md, comparison.md, sources.md) plus working notes and decisions.
Specific structural results from grade.json:
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Required files exist | ✓ all 3 (recommendation.md, comparison.md, sources.md) |
| Recommendation has named product | ✓ |
| Recommendation has tier name | ✓ |
| Recommendation has pricing | ✓ |
| Recommendation has 50-seat math | ✓ |
| Products evaluated in comparison | 5/5 (1Password, Bitwarden, Dashlane, Keeper, LastPass) |
| Inline citations | 18 |
| Distinct URLs cited | 33 |
| Recommendation word count | 1594 |
This is a complete, structurally-correct deliverable for an open-ended internet-research task — the kind of output you'd expect from a junior analyst given a few hours.
recommendation.md— the named-product recommendation with pricing mathcomparison.md— 5-product comparison table with feature/price/UX axessources.md— citation list with URLsresearch/— agent's working notes from reading pagesdecisions/— ADRs explaining recommendation choicesREADME.md— the agent's own readmegrade.json— structural verdict + countslabel.json—success-shippedreceipt.json,summary.json,cost.json,transcript.jsonl
Citation validity is the open question. STRUCTURAL_PASS asserts 33 distinct URLs are cited and that the cite tags appear inline in recommendation.md and comparison.md. It does not assert that those URLs exist, that they say what the agent quoted from them, or that the pricing numbers are accurate as of run date.
For an external reader sample-grading this output, the easiest thing to check first is the URL existence (do they 404?). After that, spot-check 3-5 specific factual claims against the cited URL — if the agent says "1Password Business is $7.99 user/month per the pricing page" and the page actually says that as of run date, the citation is valid; if the page says something different, the agent fabricated.
This is the highest-value hand-grading step still pending across the published microbench entries. See findings.md for the full list of hand-rating placeholders.
The Coder-Next entry next door (../Qwen3-Coder-Next-AWQ/) is a STRUCTURAL_FAIL — none of the required files exist. Same task spec, same input, same harness config (modulo model). 27B drives the workflow; Coder-Next gets stuck reading sources without producing structured output.