Mistaken Evaluations by Classic Ara

[magicianfromriga]

Position 1:

r1b2kr1/bpp1qp2/p3nNn1/1P2P2p/P1B3p1/2P3B1/5PP1/RN2QRK1 w - - 0 23

Here Classic Ara wants to take on g8 with 23.Nxg8 at 1 million nodes, whereas it's a mistake. I ran a self play game from here and it ended up losing as White. Instead, 23.Bxe6 is stronger.

[QueensGambit]

Thanks for the information, it seems to me to be more of an evaluation rather than a search problem.

At approximately 1.6 million nodes, it switches to the better alternative move Bxe6 for me.

isready
position fen r1b2kr1/bpp1qp2/p3nNn1/1P2P2p/P1B3p1/2P3B1/5PP1/RN2QRK1 w - - 0 23
info string position r1b2kr1/bpp1qp2/p3nNn1/1P2P2p/P1B3p1/2P3B1/5PP1/RN2QRK1 w - - 0 23
go infinite
...
info depth 41 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1553147 nps 14461 tbhits 0 time 107406 pv f6g8 f8g8 g1h1 e6c5 e5e6 c8e6 b1d2 h5h4 g3h2 e7g5 c4e6 c5e6 f2f4 g5f5 e1e4 g6e7 e4b7 a8d8 d2e4 a7e3 b5a6 e7d5 b7b1 g4g3 e4g5 f5b1 a1b1 g3h2 f1d1 e6f4 c3c4 d8a8 c4d5 a8a6 b1b4 a6g6 b4e4 f4g2 g5h3 f7f5 e4e6
info depth 41 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1568100 nps 14465 tbhits 0 time 108407 pv f6g8 f8g8 g1h1 e6c5 e5e6 c8e6 b1d2 h5h4 g3h2 e7g5 c4e6 c5e6 f2f4 g5f5 e1e4 g6e7 e4b7 a8d8 d2e4 a7e3 b5a6 e7d5 b7b1 g4g3 e4g5 f5b1 a1b1 g3h2 f1d1 e6f4 c3c4 d8a8 c4d5 a8a6 b1b4 a6g6 b4e4 f4g2 g5h3 f7f5 e4e6
info depth 41 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1582583 nps 14465 tbhits 0 time 109407 pv f6g8 f8g8 g1h1 e6c5 e5e6 c8e6 b1d2 h5h4 g3h2 e7g5 c4e6 c5e6 f2f4 g5f5 e1e4 g6e7 e4b7 a8d8 d2e4 a7e3 b5a6 e7d5 b7b1 g4g3 e4g5 f5b1 a1b1 g3h2 f1d1 e6f4 c3c4 d8a8 c4d5 a8a6 b1b4 a6g6 b4e4 f4g2 g5h3 f7f5 e4e6
info depth 41 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1597043 nps 14465 tbhits 0 time 110407 pv f6g8 f8g8 g1h1 e6c5 e5e6 c8e6 b1d2 h5h4 g3h2 e7g5 c4e6 c5e6 f2f4 g5f5 e1e4 g6e7 e4b7 a8d8 d2e4 a7e3 b5a6 e7d5 b7b1 g4g3 e4g5 f5b1 a1b1 g3h2 f1d1 e6f4 c3c4 d8a8 c4d5 a8a6 b1b4 a6g6 b4e4 f4g2 g5h3 f7f5 e4e6
info depth 41 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1611855 nps 14468 tbhits 0 time 111407 pv f6g8 f8g8 g1h1 e6c5 e5e6 c8e6 b1d2 h5h4 g3h2 e7g5 c4e6 c5e6 f2f4 g5f5 e1e4 g6e7 e4b7 a8d8 d2e4 a7e3 b5a6 e7d5 b7b1 g4g3 e4g5 f5b1 a1b1 g3h2 f1d1 e6f4 c3c4 d8a8 c4d5 a8a6 b1b4 a6g6 b4e4 f4g2 g5h3 f7f5 e4e6
info depth 45 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 32 nodes 1626168 nps 14467 tbhits 0 time 112407 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 32 nodes 1640521 nps 14466 tbhits 0 time 113407 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 31 nodes 1655155 nps 14467 tbhits 0 time 114407 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1669855 nps 14469 tbhits 0 time 115408 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 56 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1684718 nps 14473 tbhits 0 time 116408 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 57 multipv 1 score cp 29 nodes 1699236 nps 14473 tbhits 0 time 117408 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 57 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1713431 nps 14471 tbhits 0 time 118408 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 57 multipv 1 score cp 30 nodes 1727877 nps 14470 tbhits 0 time 119408 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 57 multipv 1 score cp 29 nodes 1740290 nps 14453 tbhits 0 time 120409 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 58 multipv 1 score cp 29 nodes 1755131 nps 14456 tbhits 0 time 121409 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info depth 45 seldepth 59 multipv 1 score cp 28 nodes 1769336 nps 14454 tbhits 0 time 122409 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
sinfo depth 45 seldepth 59 multipv 1 score cp 28 nodes 1783975 nps 14456 tbhits 0 time 123409 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
top
info depth 45 seldepth 59 multipv 1 score cp 28 nodes 1786303 nps 14456 tbhits 0 time 123572 pv c4e6 c8e6 e1d2 g8h8 g3f4 f8g7 f4g5 g4g3 f6e4 g3f2 g1h1 e7d7 g5f6 g7g8 f6h8 d7d2 b1d2 g8h8 e4f2 g6e5 b5a6 b7a6 f2h3 e5g4 a1e1 a8d8 d2e4 h8g7 h3f4 e6c4 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4 g6g7 f1f3 d8h8 f3h3 h8e8 f4h5 g7g6 h5f4
info string r1b2kr1/bpp1qp2/p3nNn1/1P2P2p/P1B3p1/2P3B1/5PP1/RN2QRK1 w - - 0 23
bestmove c4e6
info string apply move to tree
root
  #  | Move  |    Visits    |  Policy   |  Q-values  |  CP   |    Type    
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
 005 |  Bxe6 |       951453 | 0.0491823 |  0.0888276 |    27 |  UNSOLVED
 001 |  Nxg8 |       781675 | 0.1461581 |  0.0758135 |    23 |  UNSOLVED
 003 |   Nd2 |         8454 | 0.1069315 | -0.0303140 |    -9 |  UNSOLVED
 016 |   Bh2 |         7658 | 0.0092326 |  0.0114365 |     3 |  UNSOLVED
 000 |   Qd2 |         5012 | 0.2016190 | -0.2909935 |  -102 |  UNSOLVED
 014 |   Kh1 |         3793 | 0.0142211 |  0.0135962 |     4 |  UNSOLVED
 007 |   Qe4 |         3164 | 0.0454862 | -0.1067264 |   -33 |  UNSOLVED
 002 |   Qc1 |         2664 | 0.1296973 | -0.3841136 |  -144 |  UNSOLVED
 006 |  Nxh5 |         2638 | 0.0470813 | -0.1691500 |   -55 |  UNSOLVED
 010 |    b6 |         1963 | 0.0257274 | -0.2000249 |   -66 |  UNSOLVED
 004 |  bxa6 |         1890 | 0.0539170 | -0.2332952 |   -78 |  UNSOLVED
 008 |   Na3 |         1874 | 0.0316380 | -0.4020756 |  -152 |  UNSOLVED
 024 |   Kh2 |         1829 | 0.0033132 | -0.6591701 |  -319 |  UNSOLVED
 026 |   Bf4 |         1827 | 0.0022162 | -0.8257015 |  -519 |  UNSOLVED
 009 |   Nd5 |         1822 | 0.0286614 | -0.3582073 |  -131 |  UNSOLVED
 012 |   Qe2 |         1815 | 0.0153767 | -0.3379607 |  -122 |  UNSOLVED
 017 |   Bd5 |         1803 | 0.0090022 | -0.5905833 |  -265 |  UNSOLVED
 011 |   Ra2 |         1800 | 0.0168569 | -0.5509640 |  -237 |  UNSOLVED
 031 |   Ne8 |         1791 | 0.0002281 | -0.8219324 |  -512 |  UNSOLVED
 027 |   Ne4 |         1784 | 0.0021167 | -0.7206165 |  -378 |  UNSOLVED
 019 |   Qe3 |         1778 | 0.0068171 | -0.8194686 |  -508 |  UNSOLVED
 018 |   Bh4 |         1773 | 0.0074562 | -0.6971052 |  -354 |  UNSOLVED
 013 |  Nh7+ |         1769 | 0.0143524 | -0.4566924 |  -181 |  UNSOLVED
 015 |   Bd3 |         1768 | 0.0101447 | -0.5096452 |  -211 |  UNSOLVED
 023 |   Ba2 |         1761 | 0.0038558 | -0.5718870 |  -252 |  UNSOLVED
 030 |  Nd7+ |         1748 | 0.0003076 | -0.8644255 |  -593 |  UNSOLVED
 025 |   Ra3 |         1743 | 0.0022574 | -0.6388571 |  -302 |  UNSOLVED
 022 |   Be2 |         1739 | 0.0040604 | -0.6588107 |  -319 |  UNSOLVED
 028 |   Bb3 |         1731 | 0.0021046 | -0.5230381 |  -220 |  UNSOLVED
 020 |   Qd1 |         1721 | 0.0049192 | -0.3331316 |  -120 |  UNSOLVED
 029 |  Nxg4 |         1718 | 0.0005117 | -0.7340518 |  -393 |  UNSOLVED
 021 |    a5 |         1710 | 0.0045495 | -0.2613443 |   -90 |  UNSOLVED
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
initial value:	0.0650842
nodeType:	UNSOLVED
isTerminal:	0
isTablebase:	0
unsolvedNodes:	32
Visits:		1807668
freeVisits:	21365/1807668

[magicianfromriga]

Position 2:

3qr3/5pk1/p2p2p1/Pr1Pn2n/4P2p/5P1P/3Q2P1/R2N1RKN w - - 0 28

Classic Ara prefers the immediate 28.f4 at 1 million nodes, but 28.Ne3! is so much stronger. Classic Ara thinks that after 28.Ne3 Qf6 Black is slightly better, but it misses the counter-trick 29.f4! after which White takes over.

[QueensGambit]

Yes, you are correct.
ClassicAra fails to find the correct move here, even for 15 million moves.
It is an interesting position.

info depth 67 seldepth 74 multipv 1 score cp 3 nodes 15041906 nps 13838 tbhits 0 time 1087013 pv f3f4 e5d7 f4f5 d7f6 f5g6 f6e4 d2d3 f7g6 d1c3 b5b3 d3d4 e4f6 f1f3 d8c7 h1f2 c7c5 d4c5 d6c5 f2e4 f6e4 c3e4 b3b2 a1a4 b2b1 g1f2 b1b2 f2g1 b2b1 g1f2 e8e5 d5d6 e5d5 a4c4 b1b5 f3e3 b5a5 e3b3 g7h6 f2e3 h5g7 b3d3 g7f5 e3d2 f5d4 e4c5 d5d6 c4d4 d6d4 d3d4 a5c5 d4h4 h6g5 h4a4 a6a5 d2e3 g5f5 h3h4 c5c3 e3f2 c3c5 f2f3 c5c3 f3f2 c3c5 f2f3 c5c3 f3f2
info string 3qr3/5pk1/p2p2p1/Pr1Pn2n/4P2p/5P1P/3Q2P1/R2N1RKN w - - 0 28
bestmove f3f4
info string apply move to tree
root
  #  | Move  |    Visits    |  Policy   |  Q-values  |  CP   |    Type    
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
 000 |    f4 |     17371011 | 0.2094160 | -0.0009397 |     0 |  UNSOLVED
 006 |   Ra2 |       109707 | 0.0400413 | -0.0385823 |   -11 |  UNSOLVED
 004 |  Nhf2 |       102367 | 0.0645766 | -0.0454895 |   -13 |  UNSOLVED
 001 |  Ndf2 |        95048 | 0.1702932 | -0.0774669 |   -23 |  UNSOLVED
 003 |   Ne3 |        74863 | 0.1322592 | -0.0825817 |   -25 |  UNSOLVED
 005 |   Ra4 |        37293 | 0.0574356 | -0.0845563 |   -26 |  UNSOLVED
 002 |   Nc3 |        24382 | 0.1560545 | -0.2879981 |  -100 |  UNSOLVED
 015 |    g4 |        17420 | 0.0073628 | -0.6909546 |  -348 |  UNSOLVED
 031 |   Qb4 |        17413 | 0.0004558 | -0.8954689 |  -671 |  UNSOLVED
 028 |   Qb2 |        17389 | 0.0007189 | -0.8948185 |  -669 |  UNSOLVED
 007 |   Kh2 |        17352 | 0.0271556 | -0.4212949 |  -162 |  UNSOLVED
 029 |   Rb1 |        17343 | 0.0005248 | -0.8733776 |  -614 |  UNSOLVED
 018 |   Qe2 |        17327 | 0.0024976 | -0.6908941 |  -348 |  UNSOLVED
 025 |   Qf4 |        17318 | 0.0009764 | -0.8999229 |  -684 |  UNSOLVED
 009 |   Rc1 |        17313 | 0.0214819 | -0.3968621 |  -150 |  UNSOLVED
 027 |   Qd3 |        17297 | 0.0007958 | -0.8938127 |  -666 |  UNSOLVED
 008 |   Nb2 |        17283 | 0.0254050 | -0.5751370 |  -254 |  UNSOLVED
 021 |   Qc1 |        17280 | 0.0020998 | -0.3985190 |  -151 |  UNSOLVED
 010 |   Rf2 |        17280 | 0.0180812 | -0.6067762 |  -277 |  UNSOLVED
 011 |   Qd4 |        17270 | 0.0137555 | -0.6640589 |  -324 |  UNSOLVED
 022 |   Kf2 |        17270 | 0.0017452 | -0.6794718 |  -338 |  UNSOLVED
 026 |   Ng3 |        17262 | 0.0008516 | -0.8604444 |  -585 |  UNSOLVED
 023 |   Qg5 |        17258 | 0.0010710 | -0.8983089 |  -679 |  UNSOLVED
 030 |  Qh6+ |        17246 | 0.0005101 | -0.8958765 |  -672 |  UNSOLVED
 013 |   Ra3 |        17220 | 0.0100406 | -0.3306279 |  -119 |  UNSOLVED
 019 |   Qe3 |        17190 | 0.0023259 | -0.3603110 |  -132 |  UNSOLVED
 016 |   Qf2 |        17188 | 0.0035012 | -0.6062883 |  -277 |  UNSOLVED
 017 |   Qe1 |        17168 | 0.0028504 | -0.6463145 |  -308 |  UNSOLVED
 024 |   Qc2 |        17152 | 0.0010655 | -0.6567678 |  -317 |  UNSOLVED
 014 |   Qc3 |        17150 | 0.0087677 | -0.6732755 |  -332 |  UNSOLVED
 012 |   Re1 |        17124 | 0.0132894 | -0.5471275 |  -235 |  UNSOLVED
 032 |    g3 |        17075 | 0.0004551 | -0.7847537 |  -456 |  UNSOLVED
 020 |   Qa2 |        16933 | 0.0021388 | -0.6860120 |  -344 |  UNSOLVED
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
initial value:	-0.0192518
nodeType:	UNSOLVED
isTerminal:	0
isTablebase:	0
unsolvedNodes:	33
Visits:		18263217
freeVisits:	3221311/18263217

The cause of this behaviour appears to be 4r3/5pk1/p2p1qp1/Pr1Pn3/4Pn1p/4N2P/3Q2P1/R4RKN w - - 0 30, where the policy assigns a low policy for the move Rxf4 and other moves return a negative value.

info depth 34 seldepth 34 multipv 1 score cp 180 nodes 12831 nps 6718 tbhits 0 time 981 pv f1f4 e5f3 f4f3 f6a1 f3f1 b5b1 f1b1 a1b1 g1h2 b1e4 e3g4 e4f5 d2c3 g7f8 c3h8 f8e7 h8h4 g6g5 h4e1 e7f8 e1c3 e8c8 c3h8 f8e7 h8d4 f5f4 d4f4 g5f4 h1f2 c8c5 f2d3 c5a5 d3f4 a5a3
info string 4r3/5pk1/p2p1qp1/Pr1Pn3/4Pn1p/4N2P/3Q2P1/R4RKN w - - 0 30
bestmove f1f4
info string apply move to tree
root
  #  | Move  |    Visits    |  Policy   |  Q-values  |  CP   |    Type    
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
 019 |  Rxf4 |         4856 | 0.0065165 |  0.4553454 |   180 |  UNSOLVED
 000 |  Nf5+ |         7284 | 0.1603656 | -0.1999621 |   -66 |  UNSOLVED
 002 |   Kh2 |          104 | 0.1050737 | -0.5004017 |  -206 |  UNSOLVED
 005 |   Nc2 |           78 | 0.0542117 | -0.4252425 |  -164 |  UNSOLVED
 001 |   Ng4 |           68 | 0.1292131 | -0.7310196 |  -390 |  UNSOLVED
 003 |   Nc4 |           39 | 0.0619402 | -0.6682963 |  -327 |  UNSOLVED
 007 |   Qf2 |           38 | 0.0485504 | -0.4988473 |  -205 |  UNSOLVED
 004 |   Nf2 |           36 | 0.0549643 | -0.6241783 |  -290 |  UNSOLVED
 006 |   Rf2 |           28 | 0.0492244 | -0.7570776 |  -420 |  UNSOLVED
 009 |  Rae1 |           28 | 0.0392993 | -0.6104448 |  -280 |  UNSOLVED
 010 |   Ra2 |           26 | 0.0366815 | -0.6284934 |  -294 |  UNSOLVED
 011 |   Ra3 |           22 | 0.0295558 | -0.6033075 |  -274 |  UNSOLVED
 012 |   Ra4 |           20 | 0.0287520 | -0.7068758 |  -364 |  UNSOLVED
 014 |  Rac1 |           20 | 0.0253386 | -0.7491503 |  -411 |  UNSOLVED
 008 |  Rab1 |           19 | 0.0430825 | -0.8368123 |  -538 |  UNSOLVED
 013 |   Nd1 |           19 | 0.0284889 | -0.6009980 |  -273 |  UNSOLVED
 015 |  Rad1 |           17 | 0.0237597 | -0.5897624 |  -264 |  UNSOLVED
 016 |    g3 |           16 | 0.0183263 | -0.7110055 |  -368 |  UNSOLVED
 032 |  Rfe1 |           14 | 0.0007332 | -0.8756111 |  -619 |  UNSOLVED
 030 |    g4 |           13 | 0.0011088 | -0.5848956 |  -261 |  UNSOLVED
 020 |   Ng3 |           12 | 0.0059991 | -0.8319822 |  -530 |  UNSOLVED
 033 |   Qb2 |           12 | 0.0007031 | -0.8558929 |  -575 |  UNSOLVED
 026 |   Kf2 |           11 | 0.0021702 | -0.8875625 |  -649 |  UNSOLVED
 022 |   Qe1 |           10 | 0.0034403 | -0.8559312 |  -575 |  UNSOLVED
 028 |   Rf3 |           10 | 0.0013380 | -0.9107407 |  -718 |  UNSOLVED
 017 |   Qd1 |            9 | 0.0144640 | -0.8448211 |  -553 |  UNSOLVED
 021 |   Qd4 |            9 | 0.0049347 | -0.8491605 |  -562 |  UNSOLVED
 027 |  Rfb1 |            9 | 0.0014888 | -0.8333483 |  -532 |  UNSOLVED
 029 |  Rfd1 |            9 | 0.0012289 | -0.8864361 |  -646 |  UNSOLVED
 036 |   Qd3 |            8 | 0.0004951 | -0.8890907 |  -653 |  UNSOLVED
 034 |   Qb4 |            8 | 0.0006669 | -0.8728283 |  -612 |  UNSOLVED
 024 |   Qa2 |            7 | 0.0027403 | -0.8513529 |  -566 |  UNSOLVED
 023 |   Qc3 |            7 | 0.0031890 | -0.8422033 |  -548 |  UNSOLVED
 031 |   Qc1 |            6 | 0.0008929 | -0.8673099 |  -600 |  UNSOLVED
 035 |  Rfc1 |            6 | 0.0005514 | -0.8819119 |  -634 |  UNSOLVED
 018 |   Qc2 |            6 | 0.0082565 | -0.8467021 |  -557 |  UNSOLVED
 025 |   Qe2 |            5 | 0.0022541 | -0.8713880 |  -609 |  UNSOLVED
-----+-------+--------------+-----------+------------+-------+------------
initial value:	0.0203327
nodeType:	UNSOLVED
isTerminal:	0
isTablebase:	0
unsolvedNodes:	37
Visits:		12889
freeVisits:	58/12889