Submit Newpipe to Accrescent Store

[Grkrz]

Checklist

• I made sure that there are no existing issues - open or closed - which I could contribute my information to.
• I have read the FAQ and my question isn't listed.
• I have taken the time to fill in all the required details. I understand that the question will be dismissed otherwise.
• I have read and understood the contribution guidelines.

What is/are your question(s)?

Will NewPipe will be added to Accrescent _ store?

Additional information

No response

[opusforlife2]

Let's first let the store come out of alpha, at least? As far as I'm aware, they've only put test apps in it to see how everything works. Once the way is open for the general dev community to submit apps, I don't see why Newpipe can't be added.

[matchboxbananasynergy]

Accrescent is currently in Alpha, as @opusforlife2 mentioned above. Developers can submit their apps (the apps currently on the store are not test apps - they're production ready), but they have to be whitelisted to be able to submit their app.

As with all alpha software, developers who adopt Accrescent at this time should expect hiccups which NewPipe may not be open to at this time.

Also, there are the requirements of the store to take into account as defined by Accrescent's documentation:

https://accrescent.app/docs/index.html

As far as I can tell, NewPipe is currently on targetSDK 29, for example, which doesn't currently meet Accrescent's criteria (I believe the current minimum is targetSDK 31). That said, I do remember seeing an issue on the repo to raise the targetSDK, so when that happens, it should be good to go when the developers of NewPipe want to submit it (and assuming they're whitelisted - although I don't see an obvious reason why not).

EDIT: It seems that targetSdk 33 is in NewPipe's future, so the targetSdk requirements of Accrescent should be met at that point. If NewPipe continues to keep that up to date, it shouldn't be an issue going forward.

NewPipe's targetSdk is now 33. Assuming that it doesn't lag behind again, this is no longer an issue.

That said, it seems that currently NewPipe uses SYSTEM_ALERT_WINDOW which I understand is being used for PiP. There seems to be an issue about this and it seems like it's planned for this to eventually be changed, at which point this permission will probably be gone. I bring it up because it would likely be a blocker for Accrescent inclusion as things stand.

Another thing that comes to mind is NewPipe's "updater" which notifies people about a new version and takes them to GitHub to download it. I believe that the version in the main F-Droid repo doesn't have that, or I couldn't find it, at the very least, so there must be a flavor that removes that. That flavor would probably be the one that needs to be used for Accrescent, as having a feature that pushes people to update from another source would change the installer of record for NewPipe (or any other app) and break unattended updates until you updated the app through Accrescent manually once more to make Accrescent the installer of record again.

I will continue to look into things and update this post should I find anything else. It seems that while NewPipe may not fully meet the store's requirements just yet, most (if not all) of what it needs to change are planned already, so I'm hopeful that a day will come when it will be eligible without something that wouldn't be done anyway needing to be done.

[RokeJulianLockhart]

#9460

[Krvopije]

I would just like to second the request of @Grkrz and show demand with my post.
Obviously this isn't a high priority topic, but recently Molly submitted their app to the Accrescent Store and it would be great to see NewPipe do the same in the coming months/years.

_{Mod note: use the +1 reaction}