diff --git a/docs/MetaScience.md b/docs/MetaScience.md index ba8f81c..60529c3 100644 --- a/docs/MetaScience.md +++ b/docs/MetaScience.md @@ -27,6 +27,7 @@ This standard applies to papers that provide analysis of one or more methodologi - [ ] presents information that is useful for other researchers - [ ] makes recommendations for future research - [ ] presents clear, valid arguments supporting recommendations +- [ ] describes narrative and statistical methods used to compare studies @@ -38,7 +39,11 @@ This standard applies to papers that provide analysis of one or more methodologi - [ ] synthesizes related work from reference disciplines - [ ] provides insight specifically for software engineering; goes beyond summarizing methodological guidance from existing works or reference disciplines; +- [ ] describes all information sources and methods of extracting data - [ ] results integrated back into prior theory or research +- [ ] describes the methods for synthesizing study results +- [ ] addresses the adequacy of methods used +- [ ] describes the strengths and limitations of the evidence, including evidence of inconsistency, imprecision, risk of bias in the included studies, and risk of reporting biases - [ ] develops helpful artifacts (e.g. checklists, templates, tests, tools, sets of criteria)