selectionBehavior in <Menu /> / <MenuSection />?

[arzatskis]

Didn't see selectionBehaviour on menu components. Is it not supported or should be used? It always defaults to toggle. Is it bug / missing in implementation or should be used / there are reasons for this?

Thought maybe prop is not exposed / tried passing it to MenuSection with @ts-expect-error - no success.

For now went with disallowEmptySelection={selectionMode === 'single} as workaround. Yet want to understand if I'm doing something wrong?

[snowystinger]

I'm sorry, I'm not quite following. It's not always replace, it's usually toggle for multiple selection https://react-spectrum.adobe.com/react-aria/Menu.html#multiple
There's also Section level controls for selection, those are described here https://react-spectrum.adobe.com/react-aria/Menu.html#section-level-selection

Can you provide more information about a real life use case with the expected behaviour vs the current behaviour?

[arzatskis]

Sorry for confusion, what I've meant is that default is toggle (updated my initial message).

Here's my use case: I have menu, that allows picking user and I would like to prevent de-selecting. My expectation was that I could set selectionBehaviour="replace" for like in other RAC components

[snowystinger]

Can you use disallowEmptySelection?

[arzatskis]

Yeah, that's how I worked around this. Just was not sure why in ListBox / other similar components there's selectionBehaviour prop, yet in menu it's missing (or shouldn't be there - just trying to understand)

[snowystinger]

I think it might be a complicated combination of interactions because the selectionMode single and none will both close the menu immediately by default, whereas multiple will stay open.
I don't think we're against it, but there's a lot of combinations of interactions that would need testing.

[arzatskis]

Thank you @snowystinger!