Skip to content

Type error in generated BPL #575

@msaaltink

Description

@msaaltink
use prover::prover::{ensures, forall, requires};
use prover::vector_iter::{sum_range};


#[ext(pure)]
fun equal_range<T: copy+drop>(u: &vector<T>, v: &vector<T>, i:u64, j: u64): bool {
    forall!(|k| equal_in_range(u, v, i, j, *k))
}

#[ext(pure)]
fun equal_in_range<T: copy+drop>(u: &vector<T>, v: &vector<T>, i:u64, j: u64, k: u64): bool {
    k < i || k >= j || k >= u.length() || k >= v.length() || u[k] == v[k]
}

#[spec(prove, focus)]
fun sum_equal_test(u: &vector<u64>, v: &vector<u64>, i:u64, j: u64) {
    requires(i < u.length() && i <= v.length());
    requires(j < u.length() && j <= v.length());
    requires(equal_range(u, v, i, j));
    ensures(sum_range(u, i, j) == sum_range(v, i, j));
}

gives

~/bin/sui-prover 
✅ funs_abort_check
🔄 playground::sum_equal_test_Check
[internal] boogie exited with compilation errors:
output/playground::sum_equal_test_Check.bpl(5308,128): Error: invalid type for argument 4 in application of $0_playground_equal_in_range'u64'$pure: Vec int (expected: int)
output/playground::sum_equal_test_Check.bpl(5332,119): Error: invalid type for argument 4 in application of $0_playground_equal_in_range'u64'$pure: Vec int (expected: int)
2 type checking errors detected in output/playground::sum_equal_test_Check.bpl

Looking at the BPL, we have

// fun playgound::equal_range<u64> [baseline] at ./sources/playgound.move:481:1+132
function {:inline} $0_playgound_equal_range'u64'$pure(_$t0: Vec (int), _$t1: Vec (int), _$t2: int, _$t3: int) returns ($ret0: bool)
{
    (var $t5 := (forall x: Vec (int) :: $IsValid'vec'u64''(x) ==> $0_playgound_equal_in_range'u64'$pure(_$t0, _$t1, _$t2, _$t3, x));
    $t5)
}

with the definition

function {:inline} $0_playgound_equal_in_range'u64'$pure(_$t0: Vec (int), _$t1: Vec (int), _$t2: int, _$t3: int, _$t4: int) returns ($ret0: bool)
  { ... }

and a clear type mismatch. What happened?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions