You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
This is desirable for `axe vrs review`: the checker output must be a generated
138
+
This is desirable for `axe intent review`: the checker output must be a generated
139
139
artifact, not an arbitrary host file smuggled into review context.
140
140
141
141
## Tradeoffs
142
142
143
143
| Option | Result |
144
144
| --- | --- |
145
-
| Implement `axe vrs review` now | CAIC is ready enough, but the deterministic checker, baked prompt file, and review schema are not yet production-shaped. This would couple review quality to unstable inputs. |
145
+
| Implement `axe intent review` now | CAIC is ready enough, but the deterministic checker, baked prompt file, and review schema are not yet production-shaped. This would couple review quality to unstable inputs. |
146
146
| Keep review experimental until primitives exist | Preserves the accepted implementation order and gives review a bounded diagnostics packet later. Delays semantic smells, but avoids noisy or ungrounded review output. |
147
147
| Add only hidden/prototype review command | Useful for local tuning, but risks an untracked command contract unless it is clearly excluded from public docs and CI. |
148
148
149
149
## Conclusion
150
150
151
-
Keep production `axe vrs` focused on deterministic primitives first. In
152
-
parallel, create the baked semantic-review assets under VRS ownership:
151
+
Keep production `axe intent` focused on deterministic primitives first. In
152
+
parallel, create the baked semantic-review assets under Intent ownership:
153
153
154
-
-`context/vrs/16-enforcement/review-prompt.md` or a sibling prompt artifact
154
+
-`context/intent/16-enforcement/review-prompt.md` or a sibling prompt artifact
155
155
with the review rubric;
156
-
-`context/vrs/16-enforcement/review-result.schema.json` for
157
-
`axe.vrs.review.v1`;
158
-
- evaluation fixtures under `context/vrs/15-evaluation/` that tune the prompt
159
-
against known good and bad VRS examples.
156
+
-`context/intent/16-enforcement/review-result.schema.json` for
157
+
`axe.intent.review.v1`;
158
+
- evaluation fixtures under `context/intent/15-evaluation/` that tune the prompt
159
+
against known good and bad Intent examples.
160
160
161
-
Once `axe vrs check --json` emits stable diagnostics, `axe vrs review` should
161
+
Once `axe intent check --json` emits stable diagnostics, `axe intent review` should
162
162
compose those diagnostics with the prompt/schema and call CAIC exactly through
163
163
the command route above.
164
164
165
-
## VRS Impact
165
+
## Intent Impact
166
166
167
-
This prototype informed the current Axe VRS review command, the baked
168
-
semantic-review prompt and schema owned by `context/vrs/16-enforcement`, and the
167
+
This prototype informed the current Axe Intent review command, the baked
168
+
semantic-review prompt and schema owned by `context/intent/16-enforcement`, and the
169
169
manual-only real-provider eval policy. It is historical evidence only; current
170
170
readiness state lives in the spec, decisions, deltas, and real-provider evals.
0 commit comments