error-handling.md

Error Handling in Cypress

Clear, consistent, errors are one of the important parts of the Cypress experience. When something goes wrong, there should be clear, actionable feedback for the user about exactly what went wrong, where it went wrong, and next steps on how to fix.

@packages/errors

All error related logic for the server should be added to @packages/errors.

Errors Development Workflow

Adding and editing errors is best done with the help of an ANSI Comparison tool. Cursor/VSCode offer the vscode-ansi comparison tool.

Errors can be compared directly in your code error. Comparing old vs new errors can be done via comparing the git diff or the snapshot diff.

Editing or Adding New Errors and Updating Snapshots

1. Add (or update) errors in packages/errors/src/errors.ts
2. Add test cases to visualSnapshotErrors.spec.ts.
3. Run yarn test in the packages/errors directory.
4. See the .ansi file generated/edited for your added test case. The file should be named by the error key. (e.g. AUTOMATION_SERVER_DISCONNECTED).
5. click the "Open Preview to the Side" icon in the top right portion of your code editor.
6. Verify the changes expected.
7. To make edits, re-run the yarn test -u command. -u will update the test snapshots.
8. Run yarn test after updating the snapshot to validate the changes were applied.
9. Commit the files changed in ./test/__snapshots__.

Technical Overview

• errors.ts: A key/value mapping of known errors to functions returning "ErrorTemplates", described below, also includes/re-exports several helper utilities:
  • get / getError: builds & retrieves the error as a CypressError, should be the main way we retrieve errors throughout Cypress. Aliased as errors.get for existing use in the server package
  • throw / throwErr: Get & throw the error, so we can spy/stub it in a test. Aliased as errors.throwErr for existing use in the server package
  • logWarning: Logs the error as a warning to the console, aliased as errors.log for existing use in the server package
• errTemplate.ts: Tagged template literal formatting the error as described below
• stackUtils.ts: Utilities for working with a stack trace, extended by the driver package

errTemplate

The errTemplate is a tagged template literal. It allows us to maintain consistent behavior & formatting in our error messages, when we see a variable, we format it depending on the target environment.

The error message returns a message that defaults to being formatted for the terminal, and has a forBrowser method which returns the error message where the variables are wrapped in backticks '`' for Markdown display in the browser.

Return Value of errTemplate (ErrTemplateResult):

{
  // Will always exist, this is the terminal-formatted error message
  message: string,
  // Will always exist, this is the browser-formatted error message
  messageMarkdown: string,
  details?: string, // Exists if there is `details()` call in the errTemplate
  originalError?: ErrorLike // Exists if an error was passed into the `details()`
}

Example:

CANNOT_TRASH_ASSETS: (arg1: string) => {
  return errTemplate`\
      Warning: We failed to trash the existing run results.

      This error will not affect or change the exit code.

      ${details(arg1)}`
},

In this case, arg1 will be highlighted in yellow when printed to the terminal.

FAKE_ERROR: (arg1: string, arg2: Error) => {
  return errTemplate`\
      The fake file is missing or invalid.

      Your \`fakeFile\` is set to ${arg1}, but either the file is missing, it contains a syntax error, or threw an error when required. The \`fakeFile\` must be a \`.js\`, \`.ts\`, or \`.coffee\` file.

      Or you might have renamed the extension of your \`fakeFile\`. If that's the case, restart the test runner.

      Please fix this, or set \`fakeFile\` to \`false\` if a plugins file is not necessary for your project.

      ${details(arg2)}
    `
},

arg1 will be highlighted in blue for the terminal, and wrapped in backticks when called with forBrowser. Details will be printed in yellow as a stack trace when printed to the terminal, or shown as a stack-trace in the browser.

Error Wrapping

Any time we know about an edge case that is an error, we should define an error in errors.ts. This error should be retrieved by getError, which converts it to a CypressError.

The CypressError is an Error containing the message returned from the errTemplate. The stack is set to that of the originalError if it exists (i.e. the error object passed into details), otherwise it's the stack from where the getError / throwError is called.

The CypressError has an isCypressErr prop which we use as a duck-type guard against exiting the process when logging exceptions. It also maintains a reference to the originalError if it exists.

Child-Process Errors

All errors that occur in a child process spawned by Cypress should be sent over the ipc bridge using util.serializeError.

This ensures the name, message, stack, and any other relevant details are preserved and can be handled by the standard process of Cypress' error standardization / wrapping.