Commit 66b1270
committed
Paper 12 v0.2: Complete rewrite as probe paper, not confirmation
Genre change: "First Observational Contact: Testing the Cascade Clock"
not "Cascade Clock Signatures." The paper is a probe of universality.
Key changes:
- Oscillation falsification is Result #1 in the body, not buried in S7
- Phi-slope tautology DELETED (was labeled [A], had zero content)
- Halo virial comparison REMOVED (strawman)
- Degeneracy warning stated UP FRONT (S1.3)
- Fe/Mg and ionization demoted to [C] with conventional explanations
- Section 8 (NS/DM/topology) CUT — different paper
- "What would discriminate" added as climax (S7): extrapolation,
cross-observable shared normalization, crossover energy prediction
- Classification honest: mostly [C], one falsified [A]
- Effective-DOF noted (correlations over 7-19 bins, not 443K points)
Follows advice to hold paper to the PACSeries state-of-series standard.
The failure IS the most informative content. Leading with it is stronger.1 parent fd00401 commit 66b1270
1 file changed
Lines changed: 125 additions & 159 deletions
File tree
- foundational/docs/preprints/PACSeries/v0.3/observational_contact_absorption_spectroscopy
0 commit comments