Skip to content

Tracking issue: Initial findings #20

Description

@sshine

docs/FINDINGS.md split one section per issue, verbatim, so the file can be removed without
losing anything. Section numbers map straight onto issue numbers: §7 is #7. Cross-references
inside the sections were rewritten from §N to #N; the one exception is §7 of
docs/protocol.md, which is a different document and reads as before.

What the file said above its first section:

Two batches, from two different kinds of work.

#1#9 changed the implementation, and were found by reading source rather than
documentation. Each says what the mechanism is, what would have gone wrong, and what the code
does about it.

#10#19 were found by running the Go provider this replaces, and are correlated against
this codebase here rather than acted on. They come from external-dns-desec-provider#26
— a year of production fixes — from the review of it, and from
sshine/external-dns-desec-provider#2, another operator's account of the same failure
from a four-cluster deployment. Some describe holes this design has that the Go provider does
not. Some describe problems this design retired outright, recorded so they are not
re-litigated. One is a correction to #4. None of them is a decision; several are almost
certainly not worth their complexity.

Corrections to claims I had already written into comments or docs are marked, because a wrong
reason in a comment is worse than no reason at all.

Read from source, implemented, pinned by tests

Correlated against the Go provider, not acted on

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    docsImprovements or additions to documentationfindingRecorded in docs/FINDINGS.md

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions