CUERipper: non-EAC-style log does not add Test CRC when selected

[newhoa]

According to the documentation here, "Test & Copy" info should be added to the log file. While this is true in the EAC-style log, it doesn't seem to be for the non-EAC-style log (this EAC-Style Info Section).

I did two rips, one with EAC-style logs and one without. Both with "Test & Copy" checked.

EAC-style logs look like this:

Track  1

     Filename C:\01. Cringe.wav

     Pre-gap length  0:00:02.00

     Peak level 99.9 %
     Track quality 100.0 %
     Test CRC A0C415AE
     Copy CRC A0C415AE
     Accurately ripped (confidence 41)  [67538324]
     Copy OK

But non-EAC-style logs only have one CRC32 column, no Test CRC and Copy CRC columns. The log info is the same with and without "Test & Copy" checked.

Track Peak [ CRC32  ] [W/O NULL] 
 --   99.9 [D33A5F94] [C95D6F07]           
 01   99.9 [A0C415AE] [0B040DE6]           
 02   99.9 [78C3829A] [AC9C1844]           
 03   99.9 [BD79BF42] [991854A5]           
 04   99.9 [B00E95B8] [B23BFDE8]           

The EAC-style log changes when "Test & Copy" is checked, and Test and Copy CRCs are added. The non-EAC-style log stays the same whether "Test & Copy" is selected or not. I guess just changing the documentation would be one fix. But it would be nice to have the Test and Copy CRCs in all logs for further/future verification, especially if the user is taking twice the time for that validation/information.

[ha-korth]

No audio is extracted (copied) during the 'Test' pass.
The EAC-Style Info Section of the CUETools (*.accurip) Verification Log shows the actual [CRC32] and [CRC32 W/O NULL] hashes for the extracted audio (prior to any lossy compression). The [CRC32] hash(es) should match the 'Copy CRC' hash(es) of the corresponding track or range in the extraction log. When Verifying lossless rips with CUETools (with the extraction log file in the same folder as the audio) an extra column is added to show whether or not the audio [CRC32] hash(es) match the 'Copy CRC' hash(es) in the extraction log.

The [CRC32 W/O NULL] hashes are included because older versions of EAC had an option to exclude null samples in CRC calculations.

[ha-korth]

I'm sorry. I was confused above by your link to the CUETools (*.accurip) Verification Log document so I was describing the *.accurip log file and not thinking of the native CUERipper Extraction log.

The native CUERipper Extraction log does exclude Test & Copy CRC32 hash(es) but does instead include the CTDB, AccurateRip, and EAC-Style Info Sections of the (*.accurip) Verification Log.
I've updated the documentation.

The developer wasn't a fan of Test & Copy. The feature was added because of misinformation found in the 'EAC style' log template and by user request.
https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php?msg=793333
https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php?msg=831567