Skip to content

Shrinking an array with length = and growing it back loses the patches for the truncated indices #1355

Closed as not planned

Description

@trackoor

🐛 Bug Report

With enablePatches(), if a recipe shrinks a draft array by assigning .length and then grows it back to at least its original length, no replace patch (and no inverse patch) is produced for the truncated indices. Replaying the patches on the base gives a different state than the recipe, and the inverse patches do not restore the base. The same recipe written with splice(0) produces correct patches.

Link to repro

Not applicable: no CodeSandbox account; the script below and the unit test at the end reproduce it.

To Reproduce

npm i immer@11.2.9, save as t.mjs, run node t.mjs:

import { produceWithPatches, applyPatches, enablePatches } from "immer";
enablePatches();

const base = [1];
const [result, patches, inverse] = produceWithPatches(base, d => {
  d.length = 0; // truncate index 0
  d[1] = 2;     // grow again
});

console.log(result);
console.log(patches);
console.log(inverse);
console.log(applyPatches(base, patches));
console.log(applyPatches(result, inverse));

const [r2, p2, i2] = produceWithPatches([1, 2], d => { d.length = 0; d.length = 2; });
console.log(r2, p2, i2);

Observed behavior

[ <1 empty item>, 2 ]
[ { op: 'add', path: [ 1 ], value: 2 } ]
[ { op: 'remove', path: [ 1 ] } ]
[ 1, 2 ]
[ <1 empty item> ]
[ <2 empty items> ] [] []

applyPatches(base, patches) keeps the stale 1 at index 0, and applyPatches(result, inverse) does not bring it back. The second recipe changes both elements but produces no patches at all.

Expected behavior

The same patches as for d.splice(0); d[1] = 2, which immer already gets right:

[
  { op: 'replace', path: [ 0 ], value: undefined },
  { op: 'add', path: [ 1 ], value: 2 }
] [
  { op: 'replace', path: [ 0 ], value: 1 },
  { op: 'remove', path: [ 1 ] }
]

so that applyPatches(base, patches) gives [ undefined, 2 ] and applyPatches(result, inverse) gives [ 1 ].

generateArrayPatches_ in src/plugins/patches.ts only emits a replace for an index below base.length when assigned_.get(i) is set (or allIndicesReassigned_). Assigning a smaller length truncates copy_ without marking the dropped indices as assigned, so they are skipped once the array is long again.

Unit test:

test("length shrink then grow produces replace patches", () => {
  const base = [1]
  const [result, patches, inverse] = produceWithPatches(base, d => {
    d.length = 0
    d[1] = 2
  })
  expect(applyPatches(base, patches)).toEqual(result)
  expect(applyPatches(result, inverse)).toEqual(base)
})

Environment

We only accept bug reports against the latest Immer version.

  • Immer version: 11.2.9 (also main 75a290e, built from source), Node.js v26.13.0
  • I filed this report against the latest version of Immer
  • Occurs with setUseProxies(true)
  • Occurs with setUseProxies(false) (ES5 only)

Credit: https://ucsbplse.github.io/

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions