Status
Confirmed as a design/contract gap in Parmesan 3.0.2. This issue does not assume that every kind of equivalence must be collapsed into one fingerprint.
Observed behavior
Semantic snapshots fingerprint current nodes (including revision UUIDs), graphs, triples, and tags. The lineage comparator currently compares node content hashes only. Registered extension schemas receive drift checks, but extension contents, custom views, and triggers do not participate in the semantic snapshot fingerprint.
Desired outcome
Return explicit, separately named comparison facts rather than a single ambiguous notion of "same":
- corpus identity and authority head;
- current visible-node state;
- current revision state and revision-history coverage;
- graph, triple, tag, lifecycle, and sentinel state;
- extension/schema/machinery coverage;
- materialization-byte equality.
When custom SQL or semantic extensions are outside the comparator's declared coverage, report that incompleteness rather than implying full semantic equivalence.
Acceptance evidence
Tests distinguish identical visible content with different revision identity, triple-only and tag-only changes, extension-data changes, and custom executable-schema changes.
Related to #22.
Status
Confirmed as a design/contract gap in Parmesan 3.0.2. This issue does not assume that every kind of equivalence must be collapsed into one fingerprint.
Observed behavior
Semantic snapshots fingerprint current nodes (including revision UUIDs), graphs, triples, and tags. The lineage comparator currently compares node content hashes only. Registered extension schemas receive drift checks, but extension contents, custom views, and triggers do not participate in the semantic snapshot fingerprint.
Desired outcome
Return explicit, separately named comparison facts rather than a single ambiguous notion of "same":
When custom SQL or semantic extensions are outside the comparator's declared coverage, report that incompleteness rather than implying full semantic equivalence.
Acceptance evidence
Tests distinguish identical visible content with different revision identity, triple-only and tag-only changes, extension-data changes, and custom executable-schema changes.
Related to #22.