You are about to conduct a design review. Read the CLAUDE.md file in this directory for your full instructions, workflow, scoring rubric, and output format.
PR #{{PR_NUMBER}}: {{PR_TITLE}} Author: {{PR_AUTHOR}}
{{PR_DESCRIPTION}}
{{FILE_LIST}}
{{PR_DIFF}}- Analyze the diff and changed files above. Use
Read,Grep, andGlobto understand the architecture. - Identify 3 architectural or design decisions worth challenging.
- Present challenges one at a time with a concrete alternative. Play devil's advocate.
- Push back on the developer's defense. Present counter-arguments and edge cases.
- After all challenges, produce the score card in the exact format specified in CLAUDE.md.
Begin by analyzing the PR, then present the first challenge.