Problem
Both convergence loops are monocultures by construction:
retrieve_similar deterministically returns the top-k nearest examples — the same examples win every time.
- hive
merger.rs resolves peer-vs-peer by confidence × evidence — high-evidence beliefs dominate and crowd out exploration.
Weng's post flags diversity collapse (bottleneck #4) as especially critical for open-ended, evolutionary loops. This is the one NCT failure mode (canalization / runaway reciprocal causation toward a narrow attractor) that docs/niche-construction.md does not currently address in its Safety Invariants.
Proposal
Why it matters
Prevents the auto-improving loop from collapsing onto a single locally-optimal pattern. Longer-horizon than the near-term wins but architecturally load-bearing before Tier 2/3.
Part of epic #358. Doc change to docs/niche-construction.md.
Problem
Both convergence loops are monocultures by construction:
retrieve_similardeterministically returns the top-k nearest examples — the same examples win every time.merger.rsresolves peer-vs-peer byconfidence × evidence— high-evidence beliefs dominate and crowd out exploration.Weng's post flags diversity collapse (bottleneck #4) as especially critical for open-ended, evolutionary loops. This is the one NCT failure mode (canalization / runaway reciprocal causation toward a narrow attractor) that
docs/niche-construction.mddoes not currently address in its Safety Invariants.Proposal
direction.rs, NC Phase 0: Sense only — direction.rs + charter.toml (ranked needs backlog, no actions) #359) an exploration term so it doesn't only ever service the loudest friction signal.docs/niche-construction.mdcovering diversity preservation.Why it matters
Prevents the auto-improving loop from collapsing onto a single locally-optimal pattern. Longer-horizon than the near-term wins but architecturally load-bearing before Tier 2/3.
Part of epic #358. Doc change to
docs/niche-construction.md.