RestedXP vs Zygor vs Guidelime vs Questie vs Joanna vs Dugi vs Sage #4928
Unanswered
donnaoepfi
asked this question in
Q&A
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
RestedXP vs Zygor vs Guidelime vs Questie vs Joanna vs Dugi vs Sage
Hey. So, you’re here.
You’re standing at the character select screen, you’ve just rolled a new alt (or your very first character, welcome!), and you’re staring down the long, long road to level 60 or 70. And you’re wondering: How do I do this without losing my mind?
How to Choose the Perfect WoW Leveling Guide - 100% Success Rate
How do I avoid spending six hours in Desolace only to realize I missed the flight path and I have to run... all the way back?
I’ve been there. We've all been there. Back in 2004, "leveling guide" meant a folded-up piece of paper, a friend's scribbled notes, or... Thottbot. Just alt-tabbing for twenty minutes, trying to figure out where the heck "Mankrik's wife" was.
The good news? We live in the future. The bad news? The future is confusing.
You’ve got a dozen addons all screaming for your attention. Questie. Guidelime. Zygor. RestedXP. It’s overwhelming. They all promise to be the "fastest" or "easiest" guide. But who’s telling the truth?
Well, I’ve used them all. (Yes, my addon folder is a mess. Don't judge me.)
I'm going to break down every single contender, from the free-and-simple to the premium-and-powerful. I’m going to tell you what they’re good for, who they’re for, and—most importantly—what they won't do.
My goal? By the end of this, you’ll know exactly which one is right for you.
Quick Comparison: The Leveling Guide Contenders
Here's the at-a-glance breakdown of every guide we're comparing today.
Part 1: The "Free" Tools (The Ones You Probably Have)
Let's start with the basics. These aren't so much "guides" as they are "essential utilities."
Questie: The Indispensable Map
Questie isn't a leveling guide. Let's just get that out of the way.
What it is, is the addon that Blizzard should have built into the game. It's the spiritual successor to the original QuestHelper. It puts quest icons on your map. It shows you where to pick up quests, where the mobs you need to kill are, and where the items you need to loot are.
My Take:
You need this. Period. It's not optional. Playing WoW Classic without Questie is like trying to build IKEA furniture without the instructions. You can do it, but you're going to be miserable, and you'll probably end up with a few screws left over.
But here’s the problem: Questie is a map, not a GPS.
It shows you all the quests. It doesn't tell you which ones to do. It doesn't tell you the order to do them in. It doesn't tell you to skip that awful "kill 20-of-this" quest and just go to the next zone.
It gives you the "what" and "where," but not the "how" or "why." It's an ingredients list with no recipe.
Verdict: 100% essential, but it is NOT a guide. You still need to do all the thinking.
Guidelime: The "Build-Your-Own" Framework
Guidelime is a bit different. It’s not a guide. It’s an addon that... runs guides.
Think of it like a blank cassette player. You still need to find a cassette (the guide file) to put into it. It’s a framework that lets community members upload their own, step-by-step leveling paths.
My Take:
This is for the tinkerers and the budget-conscious. If you're willing to go digging, you can find some absolute gems. You can find guides for different classes, guides for Horde, guides for Alliance.
But... (you knew there was a "but") the quality is all over the place.
You might get a guide written by a speedrunning god. Or you might get a guide written by some guy named "Steve" who forgot to include three zones and whose guide just... stops at level 42. It can be clunky. Sometimes the steps don't make sense. Sometimes it breaks.
It's free, and "free" is a great price. But you get what you pay for, which is a mixed bag that requires you to do the homework of finding a good guide to load into it.
Verdict: A great idea. But it puts the burden of quality control on you.
Part 2: The Niche & Old-School Guides
Now we're getting into the actual, dedicated guides. These are addons that tell you, step-by-step, "Do this. Now do this."
Joanna's Guide (The Speedrunning Legend)
If you look for a Guidelime guide, you're going to find Joanna's Guide. (Though now it often runs as its own addon, too!)
This guy is a legend. A speedrunning god. He holds (or held) world records for leveling. His guide is fast. It's optimized. It's ruthless. It's the guide that all other guides try to beat in terms of pure, raw speed.
My Take:
This guide is for Chads.
I'm serious. This guide is designed to do one thing: get you to max level as fast as humanly possible, assuming you are a solo Horde Hunter (because that's what he played).
It's rigid. It doesn't care if you want to do a dungeon. It doesn't care if you want to go level your professions. It tells you to "set your hearthstone to X," and if you didn't, you just messed up the whole route. It's a "follow this or fail" manual.
If you want to drink G-Fuel, listen to techno, and break personal records... this is your guide. If you want to, y'know... stop and fish for 20 minutes? Or level with your buddy? The guide will break.
Verdict: A masterpiece of speedrunning, but not a leveling experience for a normal, chill human being.
Dugi Guides & Sage Guide (The Solid B-Tiers)
I'm lumping these together because they fill a similar space.
Dugi Guides has been around forever. It’s a familiar name. It’s reliable. It works. It's a solid, dependable guide that will get you from A to B. It has some nice features, like a gear advisor, and it works well.
Sage Guide is a bit newer and focuses on being super lightweight and simple, primarily for Alliance. The UI is very clean. It’s for the minimalist who finds other guides too "loud."
My Take:
They're... fine.
And I don't mean that as an insult! They truly are. They work. They won't let you down.
But they lack the fire of the other guides. Dugi can feel a bit dated, a bit clunky compared to the modern ones. Sage is so minimal that it sometimes lacks the powerful, time-saving features of the big dogs.
They're like that old, reliable Toyota. It'll get you to work every day. It's not going to turn any heads, and it's not the most exciting drive, but it will get you there.
Verdict: Good, solid, reliable. But "good" isn't "great."
Part 3: The Premium Titans (The Real Showdown)
Okay. This is it. This is why you're here.
When people get serious about leveling, they end up looking at these two. These are the "premium," paid addons. And I know what you're thinking: "Pay for an addon? Am I crazy?"
I used to think so, too. Then I tried them.
Let's be clear: a paid guide isn't just a list of steps. You're paying for the polish. The research. The constant updates. The features. You're paying for a team of people whose entire job is to make your leveling experience feel like a luxury car, not that old Toyota.
Zygor Guides: The All-in-One Encyclopedia
Zygor is the king of Retail WoW. And that's not a knock.
This guide has been around for ages. It is, without a doubt, the most feature-complete, polished, and comprehensive guide on the entire planet.
Zygor doesn't just do leveling. It does... everything. Dailies. Reputations. Gold farming. Mount collecting. Pet collecting. Achievements. Dungeons. It’s not a guide; it’s an in-game encyclopedia with an arrow.
The UI is beautiful. It's customizable. The arrow is iconic. It dynamically detects your progress, so if you go off-script and do a dungeon, it knows. It says, "Oh, you already did that quest? Cool, I'll just skip it. No problem."
My Take:
Zygor is the Cadillac of WoW guides. It's safe. It's comfortable. It's incredibly smart. It makes the game feel... solved.
For a new player who is completely overwhelmed, Zygor is like having a patient, all-knowing mentor holding your hand. It's also fantastic for Retail WoW, so if you're a player who bounces between Classic and Retail, the value here is insane. You buy one subscription, and it covers everything.
It just works. Flawlessly.
The "Catch": Is it the fastest? For pure, 1-60 Classic speed? It’s very fast. But it's built to be comfortable and comprehensive, not brutally fast. It's a luxury car, not a race car.
> ## ⭐ Zygor Guides: The Ultimate All-in-One Solution > > **This is the play if you want a true "all-in-one" solution that covers every part of the game, from Retail to Classic.** > > 🎁 **[Click Here to See Why Zygor is the King of Comfort & Content!](https://tinyurl.com/zygorguideswowaddon)**
RestedXP: The Classic Speedrunning Machine
And that brings us to RestedXP.
If Zygor is the Cadillac, RestedXP is the Formula 1 rally car.
RestedXP was built by world-record speedrunners. Its home turf... its entire purpose... is WoW Classic. (Era, Hardcore, and Season of Discovery).
This guide is fast. Like, "wait, I'm level 30 already?" fast.
It's not just a guide; it's a route. It has been meticulously optimized, tested, and re-tested by the best players in the world to be the absolute, most efficient path to max level. It knows exactly what to skip. It tells you exactly when to use your Hearthstone. It minimizes travel time to a degree that is frankly insane.
But here’s its killer feature, the one that makes it a must-buy for so many: Hardcore Mode.
The guide has a specific, built-in "Hardcore" route. It's not just the speedrun route. It's an entirely new, smarter route that actively avoids dangerous quests, elite mobs, and treacherous caves. It will tell you, "WARNING: This quest is dangerous," or "SKIP: This area is known for ganking."
My Take:
In WoW Hardcore, RestedXP is non-negotiable. It is the single best tool for keeping your character alive. It's not just a guide; it's a survival manual.
It's also the undisputed king of Season of Discovery (SoD), with guides that are updated instantly when new phases drop, complete with all the new rune locations and leveling paths.
The "Catch": This is a leveling specialist. It's not the "do-everything" encyclopedia that Zygor is. It's getting bigger, adding dungeon and profession guides, but its heart and soul is leveling.
> ## ⭐ RestedXP: The Undisputed King of Classic, SoD & Hardcore > > **If your main focus is WoW Classic—especially Hardcore or SoD—and your #1 goal is raw speed and safety, this is the one. No question.** > > 🎁 **[Click Here to Get the Fastest, Safest Leveling Routes!](https://slothytech.com/restedxp)**
Part 4: The Final Verdict - So... Which One Do I Choose?
Okay. Deep breath. Here’s my final, honest-to-Elune advice.
First, install Questie. No matter what. Just do it.
Second, if you're on a zero-dollar budget and you're willing to do some homework and risk using a clunky guide, grab Guidelime and try to find a popular guide file for it.
But if you're like me, and you've realized that your time is more valuable than a few bucks a month... you're choosing between the Titans.
Here is my final breakdown:
RestedXP vs. Zygor
This is the real choice, and it's simple. It comes down to what you play.
Ultimately, you can't go wrong with either Zygor or RestedXP. They are the best of the best, the S-Tier of leveling addons. The "free" addons are tools, but these are solutions. They’re the difference between a frustrating grind and a fun, epic adventure.
Good luck out there. See you in Azeroth.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions