Skip to content

Please bump the vendored mlx-core so the batched single-token RoPE fix (ml-explore/mlx#3498) reaches mlx-swift #441

Description

@magicnight

Hi team, first — thanks a lot for mlx-swift. I've been building an in-process MLX inference app on top of it and it's been really solid.

I ran into a bug while working on continuous batching. When I decode a single token for a batch ([B, H, 1, D], scalar offset, B > 1), MLXNN.RoPE / MLXFast.RoPE only computes row 0 correctly — the other rows come out as garbage / NaN, looks like uninitialized memory. At B = 1 everything is fine, so I guess that's why it stayed hidden for so long.

After digging a bit I realized it's not a new problem — it's the same as ml-explore/mlx#3496 (Swift side) and ml-explore/mlx#3494 (Python side), and it was already fixed in mlx-core by ml-explore/mlx#3498 (76a977ca — the single-token Metal path was launching an N grid instead of B*N). That fix went into mlx-core 0.32.0.

The thing is, it hasn't reached mlx-swift yet: 0.31.6 (the latest) still pins Source/Cmlx/mlx at v0.31.1 (ce45c52), which is before the fix. So anyone doing batched decode on mlx-swift still hits it today.

Small repro on 0.31.6 (Apple Silicon, Metal):

let rope = RoPE(dimensions: 8, base: 10000)
let r = MLXRandom.normal([1, 1, 8]).asType(.float16)
let x = concatenated([r.expandedDimensions(axis: 0),
                      r.expandedDimensions(axis: 0)], axis: 0)  // [B=2,1,1,8], two identical rows
let y = rope(x, offset: 1)
// abs(y - y[0]).max() -> NaN / nonzero, expected 0.0
// Works with an array offset MLXArray([1, 1]), or on mlx-core >= 0.32.0

Would it be possible to bump Source/Cmlx/mlx to a commit that includes ml-explore/mlx#3498 (mlx-core >= 0.32.0), or cherry-pick those few lines onto the current pin? If it helps I'm happy to open the PR myself.

Thanks again for all the work on this.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions