Form Customization Tab Rank not saving or random number after editing. Bug?

[mdehaan]

When editing a "Form Customization" set and modifying a "Region Rank" from the column after saving everything looks fine.
After reloading the page or re-opening the set the changed values are back to default or even random numbers.

MODX version 2.3.2-pl

Is this a bug?
Can anyone confirm the same problem?
Is there a workaround?
http://forums.modx.com/thread/95943/form-customization-tab-rang-not-saving-or-random-number-after-editing-bug#dis-post-519292

[pepebe]

Confirmed for modx 2.5.5 region rank is not saved.

After reloading the form customization all values are set to 0.

[pepebe]

I guess the problem is located here:

https://github.com/modxcms/revolution/blob/2.x/core/model/modx/processors/security/forms/set/update.class.php

As far as I understand rank is only saved if region is not "modx-panel-resource-tv". It should be modified by +20 then but for unknown reasons its only +10 in the end).

I'm confused...

[pepebe]

Oh, I get it. Everytime a FC is saved, the value of rank is modified by -10. Until the value is 0 or less at which moment the value is permanently set to 0.

So far I also haven't found a single line of code that effects how tvs are ranked in "modx-panel-resource-tv".

[pepebe]

#modxbughunt I've confirmed this problem a few days ago on different MODX instance. Today I had slightly different results.

• If a Tv is not relocated, then the rank is 0 after saving the customisation form.
• If a TV is relocated it the rank rises by 10 every time I save the form.

Initial values (random numbers for the first group which stays on the TV tab), incremental numbers for the second group.

Initial Values:

After saving:

Saving again:

This makes it impossible to change the order of appearance on the TV tab. For relocated tabs, the rank is constantly rising which is very annoying.

[vierkantemeter]

Same here with 2.5.4 and 2.5.5.

[pepebe]

Still an issue in 2.7.0. Region Rank is not saved.

[DettRoxx]

I researched code, and consclusion:

(core\model\modx\processors\security\forms\set\update.class.php)

~ 289 line (modx 3.x branch)

=>
if you dont change region from modx-panel-resource-tv, you cannot set order for this tv, because result - tvs disappearing from everywhere from the page (i manually change condition if (!empty($tvData['tab']) && $tvData['tab'] != 'modx-panel-resource-tv') and remove 'modx-panel-resource-tv' from it

=> this is not a bug, it is made specially