Context: one of a set of separate follow-ups to #7 (building on point 2 / PR #10), from evaluating m2ts packaging for broadcast primary distribution / contribution handed off to hardware IRDs (SRT/Zixi/RIST-style satellite replacement). Background: https://github.com/tdrapier-wbd/moq-mpegts-paper (public technical evaluation, not yet widely announced).
Problem
M2TS Mux Rate ({#m2ts-mux-rate}) is defined as "the nominal source mux rate of the transport stream in bits per second. This field is advisory." For handing a byte-accurate CBR TS to a hardware IRD (which locks a PLL to PCR), a few things are currently ambiguous:
- Clock authority is not stated. To avoid drift between a reconstructed egress clock and the carried PTS/DTS (a T-STD hazard), an egress should generally recover its output clock from the carried PCR (authoritative), and use
m2tsMuxRate as the null-stuffing / target-rate hint rather than as the timing source. The draft could say this explicitly.
- 188 vs 192 basis is unspecified. For
m2tsPacketSize: 192, it is unclear whether the rate counts the four-octet prefix or the 188-octet TS packet only.
- Precision. A "nominal" integer bits/s may be too imprecise to reproduce exact byte positions once null packets are removed; a note on precision (or a statement that PCR-to-byte position is authoritative) would help.
- No worked example.
m2tsMuxRate appears only in the field table and prose — none of the catalog examples show it, even though it is the field most relevant to null-removed CBR contribution.
Why it matters for contribution → IRD
This is the signaling a downstream groomer/stuffer needs to re-stuff to CBR and pass TR 101 290 on a hardware IRD. Getting the clock-authority and rate semantics right is what makes egress behavior interoperable across implementations.
Suggestion
- State that a reconstructing egress SHOULD recover its clock from PCR and treat
m2tsMuxRate as the stuffing/target rate.
- Clarify the 188 vs 192 rate basis.
- Add a short note on precision.
- Add a catalog example showing null removal +
m2tsMuxRate.
Problem
M2TS Mux Rate({#m2ts-mux-rate}) is defined as "the nominal source mux rate of the transport stream in bits per second. This field is advisory." For handing a byte-accurate CBR TS to a hardware IRD (which locks a PLL to PCR), a few things are currently ambiguous:m2tsMuxRateas the null-stuffing / target-rate hint rather than as the timing source. The draft could say this explicitly.m2tsPacketSize: 192, it is unclear whether the rate counts the four-octet prefix or the 188-octet TS packet only.m2tsMuxRateappears only in the field table and prose — none of the catalog examples show it, even though it is the field most relevant to null-removed CBR contribution.Why it matters for contribution → IRD
This is the signaling a downstream groomer/stuffer needs to re-stuff to CBR and pass TR 101 290 on a hardware IRD. Getting the clock-authority and rate semantics right is what makes egress behavior interoperable across implementations.
Suggestion
m2tsMuxRateas the stuffing/target rate.m2tsMuxRate.