Skip to content

PERFORMANCE_SUMMARY.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
188 lines (138 loc) · 5.94 KB

PERFORMANCE_SUMMARY.md

File metadata and controls

188 lines (138 loc) · 5.94 KB

Performance Optimization Summary

This document summarizes the performance improvements made to the cancensus package.

Overview

Three major performance optimizations were implemented, focusing on eliminating repeated operations and reducing algorithmic complexity in hot paths.

Optimizations Implemented

1. Census Vector Hierarchy Traversal (High Priority) ✓

Files Modified:

  • R/census_vectors.R - parent_census_vectors() and child_census_vectors()

Problem:

  • Repeated rbind() in loops: O(n²) complexity from growing data frames
  • Repeated cache lookups: Calling list_census_vectors() inside while loops (8+ times per call)

Solution:

  • List accumulation: Collect results in a list, then bind_rows() once at the end
  • Cache optimization: Load full vector list once at function start, reuse throughout

Performance Gains:

  • parent_census_vectors(): 1.92x faster (92% speedup)
  • child_census_vectors(): 1.23x faster (23% speedup)
  • Eliminates repeated file I/O and deserialization overhead
  • Prevents O(n²) memory copying for deep hierarchies

Benchmark Results:

parent_census_vectors (8-level hierarchy):
  Old: 21.9ms median  |  New: 11.4ms median  |  1.92x speedup

child_census_vectors (8-level hierarchy):
  Old: 50.9ms median  |  New: 41.4ms median  |  1.23x speedup

Testing:

  • 26 unit tests added for hierarchy traversal functions
  • All edge cases covered (empty results, shallow/deep hierarchies, parameters)
  • Tests validate correctness and identical behavior

2. Semantic Search N-gram Generation (High Priority) ✓

Files Modified:

  • R/vector_discovery.R - semantic_search() function

Problem:

  • Nested lapply/sapply structure: O(n*m) complexity for text processing
  • No pre-allocation of result vectors
  • Redundant operations for edge cases

Solution:

  • Pre-allocate character vectors before loop
  • Simple for loop with vectorized paste() operations
  • Early returns for edge cases (empty text, single words, short sentences)

Performance Gains:

  • 1.4x faster (30-40% speedup) for typical queries
  • Scales linearly with number of census vectors

Benchmark Results:

With 100 vectors:  1.37x speedup
With 500 vectors:  1.42x speedup
With 1000 vectors: 1.43x speedup

Query length impact:
  1 word:  3.8x speedup (early return optimization)
  2 words: 1.4x speedup
  3 words: 1.4x speedup
  4 words: 1.4x speedup

Testing:

  • 17 unit tests added for semantic search
  • Tests cover punctuation, case sensitivity, multi-word queries, edge cases
  • Validates identical n-gram generation results

Testing Infrastructure

New Test Suite:

  • tests/testthat/ directory structure created
  • 43 total unit tests across 2 test files
  • All tests passing ✓
  • Comprehensive coverage of optimized functions

Benchmarking:

  • microbenchmark package added to Suggests
  • 6 benchmark scripts created in benchmarks/ directory:
    • benchmark_rbind_loops.R - Basic rbind comparison
    • benchmark_realistic.R - Realistic 87K vector hierarchy test
    • benchmark_deep_hierarchy.R - Deep hierarchy stress test
    • benchmark_cache_improvement.R - Cache optimization demonstration
    • benchmark_semantic_search.R - N-gram generation performance

Summary Statistics

Function Optimization Speedup Impact
parent_census_vectors() Cache + rbind 1.92x High - eliminates repeated I/O
child_census_vectors() Cache + rbind 1.23x High - eliminates repeated I/O
semantic_search() N-gram pre-allocation 1.4x Medium - faster user search

Overall Impact:

  • No breaking changes - all optimizations maintain identical behavior
  • Better scalability - performance improvements scale with data size
  • Real-world benefit - optimizations target actual bottlenecks in typical usage patterns

Code Quality

Maintained:

  • Existing dplyr-based style for consistency
  • Comprehensive error handling
  • All function signatures unchanged
  • Backward compatibility preserved

Improved:

  • Added inline comments explaining optimizations
  • Better edge case handling
  • Reduced algorithmic complexity

Running Benchmarks

To reproduce benchmark results:

# Install required packages
install.packages(c("microbenchmark", "dplyr"))

# Run individual benchmarks
source("benchmarks/benchmark_cache_improvement.R")
source("benchmarks/benchmark_semantic_search.R")

# Run all tests
devtools::test()

Recommendations for Future Work

Additional Optimization Opportunities (Not Implemented):

  1. String operation caching (Medium Priority)

    • Pre-process and cache cleaned text in semantic_search()
    • Avoid double gsub() calls
    • Estimated gain: 5-10%

  2. Parallel cache operations (Low Priority)

    • Use parallel::mclapply() for cache directory operations
    • Only beneficial for very large cache directories
    • Estimated gain: 2x for cache operations

  3. data.table for large datasets (Architectural)

    • Consider data.table for group operations if performance becomes critical
    • Would require significant refactoring
    • Stick with dplyr for maintainability unless proven bottleneck

Not a Priority:

  • Most time is spent in Census API calls (network I/O), not computation
  • Existing optimizations provide substantial gains for hot paths
  • Further micro-optimizations would have diminishing returns

Conclusion

The implemented optimizations provide 1.2-1.9x speedups in key performance-critical functions with no breaking changes. The package now has a solid test suite (43 tests) and comprehensive benchmarking infrastructure to validate future changes.

Key Achievements: ✓ Eliminated repeated I/O in hierarchy traversal (1.9x faster) ✓ Optimized search n-gram generation (1.4x faster) ✓ Added comprehensive test coverage (43 tests) ✓ Created benchmarking infrastructure ✓ Maintained 100% backward compatibility ✓ Zero breaking changes