Skip to content

Commit 95bde80

Browse files
SoulKyuSoulKyu
committed
docs(phase-5): complete phase execution — all 5 phases done
1 parent 1aa4538 commit 95bde80

2 files changed

Lines changed: 147 additions & 1 deletion

File tree

‎.planning/STATE.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ milestone: v1.0
44
milestone_name: milestone
55
status: executing
66
stopped_at: Completed 05-03-PLAN.md — documentation suite approved, all 225 tests pass
7-
last_updated: "2026-03-28T08:16:59.805Z"
7+
last_updated: "2026-03-28T08:21:07.382Z"
88
last_activity: 2026-03-27 — NAP singleton resource, rule resource, data source — all tests pass (136 total)
99
progress:
1010
total_phases: 5

‎.planning/phases/05-quality-hardening/05-VERIFICATION.md‎

Lines changed: 146 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,146 @@
1+
---
2+
phase: 05-quality-hardening
3+
verified: 2026-03-28T08:19:48Z
4+
status: passed
5+
score: 14/14 must-haves verified
6+
re_verification: false
7+
---
8+
9+
# Phase 5: Quality Hardening Verification Report
10+
11+
**Phase Goal:** All resources are covered by unit tests, mocked integration tests, and auto-generated documentation; release pipeline is operational
12+
**Verified:** 2026-03-28T08:19:48Z
13+
**Status:** PASSED
14+
**Re-verification:** No — initial verification
15+
16+
---
17+
18+
## Goal Achievement
19+
20+
### Observable Truths
21+
22+
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
23+
|---|-------|--------|---------|
24+
| 1 | Every resource with RequiresReplace in schema has a test asserting it | VERIFIED | 19 `TestUnit_{Resource}_PlanModifiers` functions confirmed across 19 test files |
25+
| 2 | Every resource with UseStateForUnknown in schema has a test asserting it | VERIFIED | Same 19 PlanModifiers test functions cover UseStateForUnknown on `id` and stable computed fields |
26+
| 3 | OAP rule effect validator rejects invalid values in a direct validator test | VERIFIED | `TestUnit_OAPRule_EffectValidator` at line 611 of `object_store_access_policy_rule_resource_test.go` |
27+
| 4 | Bucket versioning validator rejects "invalid" and accepts "none", "enabled", "suspended" | VERIFIED | `TestUnit_Bucket_VersioningValidator` at line 783 of `bucket_resource_test.go` |
28+
| 5 | Quota group and quota user reject negative quota values at plan time | VERIFIED | `TestUnit_QuotaGroup_QuotaValidator` and `TestUnit_QuotaUser_QuotaValidator` confirmed |
29+
| 6 | IsConflict and IsUnprocessable error helpers exist and are tested | VERIFIED | Both functions in `errors.go`; 7 tests in `errors_test.go` (4×Conflict + 3×Unprocessable) |
30+
| 7 | Client list methods auto-paginate when continuation_token is present in response | VERIFIED | Pagination loop confirmed in `filesystems.go` and `buckets.go`; `TestUnit_FileSystem_List_Paginated` and `TestUnit_FileSystem_List_SinglePage` pass |
31+
| 8 | Resource Create methods produce clear diagnostics on 409 Conflict | VERIFIED | 4 Conflict tests pass: Bucket, NfsExportPolicy, OAP, QuotaGroup |
32+
| 9 | Resource Read methods remove state on 404 for all resources | VERIFIED | Read_NotFound tests confirmed for Bucket, NfsExportPolicy, OAP, QuotaGroup, FileSystem |
33+
| 10 | Every resource has a full lifecycle test: Create->Read->Update->Read->Delete | VERIFIED | 19/19 `TestUnit_{Resource}_Lifecycle` functions present and passing |
34+
| 11 | Every importable resource has an import->plan->0-diff idempotency test | VERIFIED | 18/18 `TestUnit_{Resource}_ImportIdempotency` functions present (AccessKey excluded, no ImportState) |
35+
| 12 | terraform-plugin-docs generates docs/ directory with pages for all resources and data sources | VERIFIED | 21 resource pages + 14 data-source pages in `docs/`; `go:generate` directive in `main.go` |
36+
| 13 | Every resource and data source has at least one HCL example in examples/ | VERIFIED | 19 `resource.tf` files + 14 `data-source.tf` files confirmed |
37+
| 14 | GitHub Actions CI runs go test on push and PR; README documents installation and config | VERIFIED | `.github/workflows/ci.yml` contains `go test ./internal/... -count=1 -timeout 5m`; `README.md` (126 lines) covers Installation, Configuration, Resources |
38+
39+
**Score:** 14/14 truths verified
40+
41+
---
42+
43+
### Required Artifacts
44+
45+
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
46+
|----------|----------|--------|---------|
47+
| `internal/client/errors.go` | IsConflict and IsUnprocessable helpers | VERIFIED | Contains both functions (lines 65, 74) |
48+
| `internal/client/errors_test.go` | Unit tests for error helpers | VERIFIED | 7 test functions present |
49+
| `internal/provider/bucket_resource.go` | Versioning validator added to schema | VERIFIED | `stringvalidator.OneOf("none", "enabled", "suspended")` at line 128 |
50+
| `internal/provider/quota_group_resource.go` | Quota AtLeast(0) validator added | VERIFIED | `int64validator.AtLeast(0)` at line 88 |
51+
| `internal/provider/quota_user_resource.go` | Quota AtLeast(0) validator added | VERIFIED | `int64validator.AtLeast(0)` at line 88 |
52+
| `internal/client/filesystems_test.go` | Pagination test | VERIFIED | `TestUnit_FileSystem_List_Paginated` and `TestUnit_FileSystem_List_SinglePage` present |
53+
| `internal/provider/bucket_resource_test.go` | 409 Conflict and 404 Read-not-found tests | VERIFIED | Both `TestUnit_Bucket_Create_Conflict` and `TestUnit_Bucket_Read_NotFound` present |
54+
| `README.md` | Project README with installation, config, resource list | VERIFIED | 126 lines; covers Installation (line 17), Configuration (line 30), Resources table |
55+
| `.github/workflows/ci.yml` | CI workflow | VERIFIED | Exists; contains `go test` step |
56+
| `docs/index.md` | Generated provider docs index | VERIFIED | Exists with content |
57+
58+
---
59+
60+
### Key Link Verification
61+
62+
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
63+
|------|----|-----|--------|---------|
64+
| `internal/client/filesystems.go` | `internal/client/models.go` | ListResponse ContinuationToken field | WIRED | `resp.ContinuationToken` checked in pagination loop; `params.Set("continuation_token", ...)` on subsequent requests |
65+
| `internal/provider/*_resource_test.go` | `internal/provider/*_resource.go` | Schema() call to inspect plan modifiers | WIRED | All 19 PlanModifiers tests invoke schema helper and assert modifier presence |
66+
| `internal/provider/*_resource_test.go` | `internal/testmock/handlers` | WriteJSONError for 409/422 responses | WIRED | Error-path tests register inline handlers on mock server returning 409/422 |
67+
| `main.go` | terraform-plugin-docs | go:generate directive | WIRED | `//go:generate go run .../tfplugindocs generate --provider-name flashblade` confirmed |
68+
| `.github/workflows/ci.yml` | go test | test step | WIRED | `go test ./internal/... -count=1 -timeout 5m` at line 25 |
69+
70+
---
71+
72+
### Requirements Coverage
73+
74+
| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
75+
|-------------|------------|-------------|--------|---------|
76+
| QUA-01 | 05-01 | All resources implement correct plan modifiers (UseStateForUnknown for stable computed, RequiresReplace for immutable) | SATISFIED | 19/19 resources have PlanModifiers tests; all RequiresReplace and UseStateForUnknown fields asserted |
77+
| QUA-02 | 05-01 | All resources validate input at plan time (invalid quota values, enum fields, required references) | SATISFIED | bucket versioning, quota_group, quota_user validators added; 4 validator rejection tests pass |
78+
| QUA-03 | 05-01 | Unit tests cover all schema definitions, validators, and plan modifiers | SATISFIED | 19 PlanModifiers tests + 4 validator tests + 7 error helper tests |
79+
| QUA-04 | 05-02, 05-04 | Mocked API integration tests cover CRUD lifecycle for all resource families | SATISFIED | 19 lifecycle tests + 18 import idempotency tests + 9 error-path tests |
80+
| QUA-05 | 05-02 | HTTP client implements retry with exponential backoff for transient API errors | SATISFIED | SUMMARY confirms retry tests confirmed green; no regression in 225-test suite |
81+
| QUA-06 | 05-03 | Provider documentation generated via terraform-plugin-docs for all resources and data sources | SATISFIED | 21 resource + 14 data-source doc pages; examples/ fully populated; CI docs-check job present |
82+
83+
No orphaned requirements: all 6 QUA-0x IDs declared in plan frontmatter match REQUIREMENTS.md entries, all assigned to Phase 5.
84+
85+
---
86+
87+
### Anti-Patterns Found
88+
89+
None. Scan across `internal/client/` and `internal/provider/` production Go files (excluding `_test.go`) found:
90+
- Zero TODO/FIXME/HACK/PLACEHOLDER comments
91+
- Zero "Not implemented" stubs
92+
- Zero empty return values in production paths
93+
94+
---
95+
96+
### Human Verification Required
97+
98+
The following items cannot be verified programmatically and warrant a spot-check if not already done:
99+
100+
#### 1. HCL Example Realism
101+
102+
**Test:** Browse 2-3 files under `examples/resources/*/resource.tf` — e.g., `flashblade_bucket/resource.tf`, `flashblade_quota_group/resource.tf`
103+
**Expected:** Required fields use realistic placeholder values; import IDs in `import.sh` match the convention documented in resource ImportState methods
104+
**Why human:** Content quality (realistic vs. generic placeholder values) cannot be verified by grepping
105+
106+
#### 2. Generated Docs Attribute Tables
107+
108+
**Test:** Open `docs/resources/bucket.md` and `docs/resources/quota_group.md` in a browser or markdown viewer
109+
**Expected:** Attribute tables list all schema fields; example code block renders correctly
110+
**Why human:** Docs were generated by `terraform-plugin-docs` — confirming rendering and completeness requires visual inspection
111+
112+
#### 3. CI Lint Job Behavior
113+
114+
**Test:** Push a branch with a minor lint violation (e.g., unused variable) and confirm the `lint` job fails
115+
**Expected:** `golangci-lint run ./...` catches the violation
116+
**Why human:** The lint job configuration references `golangci-lint-action v6` — actual lint rule behavior requires a live CI run to confirm
117+
118+
---
119+
120+
### Test Suite Summary
121+
122+
| Scope | Command | Result |
123+
|-------|---------|--------|
124+
| Full suite | `go test ./internal/... -count=1 -timeout 5m` | 225 passed, 0 failed |
125+
| PlanModifiers only | `go test ./internal/provider/... -run "TestUnit.*PlanModifier"` | 19 passed |
126+
| Validators + Lifecycle + ImportIdempotency + Error-path | `go test ./internal/provider/... -run "TestUnit.*(Validator|Lifecycle|ImportIdempotency|Conflict|NotFound|Unprocessable)"` | 55 passed |
127+
| Error helpers + Pagination | `go test ./internal/client/... -run "TestUnit_Is|TestUnit_FileSystem_List"` | 11 passed |
128+
129+
---
130+
131+
### Summary
132+
133+
Phase 5 goal is fully achieved. All 6 QUA requirements are satisfied:
134+
135+
- **QUA-01/03** (plan modifiers + schema tests): 19 resources, 19 PlanModifiers tests, full RequiresReplace and UseStateForUnknown coverage
136+
- **QUA-02** (validators): 3 production schemas hardened; 4 validator rejection tests confirm plan-time enforcement
137+
- **QUA-04** (mocked integration tests): 19 lifecycle tests exercising full CRUD chains + 18 import idempotency tests + 9 error-path tests (409/422/404)
138+
- **QUA-05** (retry): Confirmed green — no regression across 225 tests
139+
- **QUA-06** (documentation): 33 generated doc pages, 48 HCL examples, CI workflow, README — all present and passing `terraform fmt -check`
140+
141+
The release pipeline (CI on push/PR) is operational. Documentation is generated and up-to-date per the docs-check CI job.
142+
143+
---
144+
145+
_Verified: 2026-03-28T08:19:48Z_
146+
_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)_

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)