Skip to content

Commit b9d5388

Browse files
SisyphusZhengDevBot
SisyphusZheng
and
DevBot
authored
test(v0.44): record Beta.1 closure verification — verifier PASS at dc3ee19 (#1150) (#1279)
Fresh release-verifier closure battery at candidate SHA dc3ee19: full test suite, scoped parity/hostile/security suites, gate-of-gates, pack/artifacts/packaged consumer, workspace-qualification regression gate, CI browser matrix and benchmark SHA-gap re-confirmation all green; constitution 6.2 conditions verified (no unresolved 4.3 failure, single 5.4-compliant frozen-path touch in #1277 with ADR-0151 citation). Verifier verdict PASS, GO. Part of #1150, #1155. Co-authored-by: DevBot <devbot@openelement.dev>
1 parent dc3ee19 commit b9d5388

1 file changed

Lines changed: 228 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

‎docs/evidence/2026-09-03-v044-beta1-closure-verification.md‎

Lines changed: 228 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,228 @@
1+
# Beta.1 closure verification — fresh release verifier (stage #1150)
2+
3+
Independent closure verification of the v0.44 Beta.1 (Framework Qualification +
4+
Governance Freeze) candidate by a fresh release-verifier session with no
5+
implementer conversation history, per the constitution §5.1 release-verifier
6+
role and the release contract §4.1 (fresh release verifier GO). Method per the
7+
configured release-verifier profile under `.agents/`: re-derive every claim,
8+
rerun every gate at the exact candidate SHA, fail closed.
9+
10+
- Candidate SHA: `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11` (branch `dev`).
11+
Verified with `git rev-parse HEAD` (exact match) and `git status --porcelain`
12+
(empty) before and after the battery.
13+
- Environment: macOS arm64, Deno 2.9.0, Node v24.18.0.
14+
- Scope: packets B1.1–B1.6 (issues #1222, #1223, #1224, #1188 Beta.1 slice,
15+
#1187 Beta.1 slice, #1225). This report is the verifier cell of the §4.1
16+
unanimous-GO requirement; it does not by itself close the stage.
17+
18+
STATUS: PASS
19+
20+
## CANDIDATE_SHA
21+
22+
`dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`
23+
24+
- `git rev-parse HEAD` → `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11` (exit 0)
25+
- `git status --porcelain` → empty before the battery and empty after it
26+
(exit 0); the battery leaves the tree clean.
27+
28+
## ARTIFACT_FINGERPRINTS
29+
30+
Dry-run packs built from the candidate tree by `deno task pack:dry-run`
31+
(exit 0), SHA-256:
32+
33+
| Tarball | SHA-256 |
34+
| ----------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ |
35+
| `packages/adapter-vite/openelement-adapter-vite-0.43.3.tgz` | `8ba8a427299cdfac679338c81c5e386a3b4d343312e45b0604e6540d6cb5cb1f` |
36+
| `packages/app/openelement-app-0.43.3.tgz` | `88431fa73036b368720c17d610d99da7eabf7c7a0e424cdc92c72e34b240c148` |
37+
| `packages/create/openelement-create-0.43.3.tgz` | `9dc5ddba65ae04c88b3e8742febe5a6e55b51a23b136f3cab962e093764bf658` |
38+
| `packages/element/openelement-element-0.43.3.tgz` | `0e9cd0e2af3961a85c9fad35931dcf83b406a3690e57bc4420346641c48ce45e` |
39+
| `packages/ui/openelement-ui-0.43.3.tgz` | `8fc5c36731e016e6baef6bac52b11827fdc61e9c464eeac1f65efb6fc00e3119` |
40+
41+
These are the qualified-artifact fingerprints for this candidate. Per §2.2 the
42+
published bytes must be byte-identical to bytes packed from this same SHA; any
43+
repack at publication time must reproduce these hashes or publication is
44+
invalid.
45+
46+
## CRITERION_TEST_MATRIX
47+
48+
| Battery cell | Evidence | Verdict |
49+
| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------- |
50+
| 1. Full test suite | `deno task test` at candidate → exit 0 (main suite green; Supabase starter 150 passed, 0 failed) | PASS |
51+
| 2a. Hostile compiler suites | adversarial/convergence/compiled-element corpus → 18 passed (29 steps), 0 failed, exit 0 | PASS |
52+
| 2b. Compiler boundary + provenance | fail-closed matrix, module analysis, semantic-core boundary, intrinsic provenance → 44 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
53+
| 2c. Source-map v3 consumer | `compiler-source-map-v3.test.ts` → 9 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
54+
| 2d. SSR/fresh/claim parity | compiled-claim + compiled-runtime + SSG/request-time admission parity → 98 passed (9 steps), exit 0; `request-time-parity.test.ts` (dev Hono vs build Nitro) → 1 passed (23 steps), exit 0 | PASS |
55+
| 2e. Context interop | `signal-context.test.ts` (real @lit/context provider) → 6 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
56+
| 2f. Route parity | route-manifest, static-paths, route-scanner-enhance/mdx, entry-descriptor → 60 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
57+
| 2g. Security projection | `entry-render-runtime-security.test.ts` → 4 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
58+
| 2h. Remediation parity corpora | renderer-scope-parity (#1271), compiled-escape-parity byte corpus (#1272), page-route-tag-resolution (#1276) → 16 passed, exit 0 | PASS |
59+
| 3. Gate-of-gates | `fmt:check`, `lint`, `docs:truth`, `docs:check-public`, `docs:check-strategy`, `docs:check-current`, `docs:check-claims`, `text-integrity:check`, `package-surface:check`, `interface:snapshot`, `freeze:semantics:check`, `graph:check`, `arch:check` → all exit 0 | PASS |
60+
| 4. Clean-clone + packed consumer | `pack:dry-run` → exit 0 (5 tarballs @ 0.43.3); `package-artifacts:check` → exit 0 (5 packages); `consumer:packaged` → exit 0 (packed starter typecheck + SSG build + import-map smoke) | PASS |
61+
| 5. #1276 regression gate | `deno task fullstack:workspace-qualification` at candidate → exit 0 (starter request-time routes serve; 10001-row dataset, two-page cursor fetch, 1 JWT handoff) | PASS |
62+
| 6. Browser matrix | CI at candidate (below) | PASS |
63+
| 7. Benchmark SHA-gap re-confirmation | see below | PASS |
64+
65+
## CI evidence at the candidate SHA (authoritative matrix, contract §2.1)
66+
67+
- AutoFlow CI run `33718081067` at `dc3ee191…`: conclusion `success`
68+
(`gh run view 33718081067`, exit 0). Job legs: `autoflow-ci` success,
69+
`dist/server Node smoke (Node 24)` success, `dist/server Node smoke
70+
(Node 20)` success, `workspace-qualification` success (the required job
71+
added by #1277). The AutoFlow gate step reports 49 `PASS` gate lines and
72+
zero `FAIL`/`BLOCKED` lines, including the browser legs: `test:e2e`
73+
(Chromium full), `test:e2e:firefox-smoke` PASS, `test:e2e:webkit-smoke`
74+
PASS, `fixture:request-time:gate` (request-time fixture on all three
75+
engines) PASS, and `test:coverage:check` PASS.
76+
- CodeQL run `33718080819` at `dc3ee191…`: conclusion `success`.
77+
- Browser matrix therefore rests on CI evidence per the packet; local browser
78+
rerun not required.
79+
80+
## Battery 7: benchmark evidence SHA-gap proof at the candidate
81+
82+
The B1.6 admission record's benchmark baseline sits at `493548a6`. At the
83+
candidate:
84+
85+
```sh
86+
git diff --stat 493548a6..dc3ee191 -- packages/element/src packages/adapter-vite/src \
87+
packages/app/src packages/ui/src packages/create/src
88+
```
89+
90+
→ exactly 11 files, 85 insertions, 32 deletions, all belonging to the two
91+
parity-proven remediations and nothing else (exit 0):
92+
93+
- #1274 (merge `18778c95`): `element/src/internal/compiled/escape-text.ts`
94+
(new shared owner), `runtime.ts`, `server/index.ts` — the F3 escape-text
95+
convergence. Parity proof: the byte-level corpus in
96+
`compiled-escape-parity.test.ts`, rerun green at the candidate (cell 2h).
97+
- #1277 (merge `dc3ee191`): `adapter-vite/src/internal/ssg/entry-*.ts`,
98+
`route-scanner.ts` — the route-tag binding repair. Parity proof:
99+
`page-route-tag-resolution.test.ts` plus the entry-descriptor tag-binding
100+
tests, rerun green at the candidate (cells 2f/2h), and the
101+
`workspace-qualification` gate green both locally (cell 5) and in CI.
102+
103+
No other `packages/*/src` change exists between the benchmark SHA and the
104+
candidate, so the measured semantics at `493548a6` remain the semantics at
105+
`dc3ee191` except for the two parity-proven remediations. Harness integrity at
106+
the candidate: `deno test -A benchmarks/` → exit 0, 12 passed, 0 failed.
107+
108+
## TESTS_OR_FIXTURES_ADDED
109+
110+
None. This verification added no tests, fixtures or snapshots; it reran the
111+
committed suites at the exact candidate SHA. The only repository write is this
112+
report.
113+
114+
## MEANINGFULNESS_EVIDENCE
115+
116+
- The hostile/adversarial corpora are fail-closed by construction (OEC9xxx
117+
diagnostic matrices, boundary probes) and rerun green; the B1.1 audit's own
118+
negative probes (deliberate boundary-separator drift fails the
119+
renderer-scope corpus; #1271) document that these suites can fail.
120+
- The #1276 regression gate is proven meaningful by the B1.3 record: the same
121+
command exited 1 at `18778c95` (request-time 500s on `/workspace-records`,
122+
`/magic-link`, `/reset-password`) and exits 0 at the candidate — the gate
123+
distinguishes the broken from the repaired binding.
124+
- No assertion was weakened; all exit codes are recorded verbatim.
125+
126+
## COMMANDS_AND_EXIT_CODES
127+
128+
All at `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`, macOS arm64, Deno 2.9.0.
129+
Scoped test commands used
130+
`deno test --allow-read --allow-write --allow-env --allow-net --allow-run --allow-ffi --allow-sys <paths>`
131+
(the full task permission set; the B1.1 audit showed the reduced set breaks
132+
rolldown native binding loads, not the code).
133+
134+
| Command | Exit |
135+
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- |
136+
| `git rev-parse HEAD` / `git status --porcelain` | 0 / empty |
137+
| `gh run view 33718081067` (AutoFlow CI) / `gh run view 33718080819` (CodeQL) | 0, conclusion success / 0, conclusion success |
138+
| `deno task test` (full) | 0 |
139+
| hostile compiler corpus (adversarial, when/void convergence, compiled-element-v1) | 0 — 18 passed (29 steps) |
140+
| compiler boundary corpus (fail-closed matrix, module-analysis, semantic-core-boundary, intrinsic-provenance) | 0 — 44 passed |
141+
| `compiler-source-map-v3.test.ts` | 0 — 9 passed |
142+
| compiled-claim + compiled-runtime + ssg/request-time admission parity | 0 — 98 passed (9 steps) |
143+
| `request-time-parity.test.ts` | 0 — 1 passed (23 steps) |
144+
| `signal-context.test.ts` | 0 — 6 passed |
145+
| route parity corpus (route-manifest, static-paths, route-scanner-*, entry-descriptor) | 0 — 60 passed |
146+
| `entry-render-runtime-security.test.ts` | 0 — 4 passed |
147+
| remediation parity corpora (renderer-scope, escape byte corpus, page-route-tag-resolution) | 0 — 16 passed |
148+
| `deno task fmt:check` / `lint` / `docs:truth` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
149+
| `deno task docs:check-public` / `docs:check-strategy` / `docs:check-current` / `docs:check-claims` | 0 / 0 / 0 / 0 |
150+
| `deno task text-integrity:check` / `package-surface:check` / `interface:snapshot` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
151+
| `deno task freeze:semantics:check` / `graph:check` / `arch:check` | 0 / 0 / 0 |
152+
| `deno task pack:dry-run` | 0 — 5 tarballs @ 0.43.3 |
153+
| `deno task package-artifacts:check` | 0 — 5 packages |
154+
| `deno task consumer:packaged` | 0 |
155+
| `deno task fullstack:workspace-qualification` | 0 |
156+
| `deno test -A benchmarks/` | 0 — 12 passed |
157+
| `git diff --stat 493548a6..dc3ee191 -- packages/*/src` | 0 — only #1274 + #1277 files |
158+
| `git log --name-only dd475619..dc3ee191 -- <ADR-0122 frozen paths>` | 0 — only `dc3ee191` touched `entry-codegen.ts` |
159+
160+
## FAILURES
161+
162+
None.
163+
164+
## Known exceptions validated (not relitigated)
165+
166+
- Desktop examples OEC9008 on full vite build — recorded by B1.3 at the base
167+
SHA, deferred to B2.5/B3.8, never consumer evidence. Consistent; not rerun.
168+
- Local-only visual-baseline drift on architecture-islands-deep mobile — the
169+
B1.3 record documents 4 local failures; the candidate CI Chromium leg
170+
(`test:e2e`) is PASS, so CI is authoritative and green.
171+
- SIGSEGV (exit 139) flake in `test:coverage:check` under concurrency — tracked
172+
as #1278 (OPEN, Beta.2 milestone, verified). Dev run `33715486563` at
173+
`73a79000` confirmed `autoflow-ci: failure` with both Node smoke legs
174+
success; candidate run `33718081067` has `test:coverage:check` PASS. The
175+
flake is infrastructure, not a product signal, and the candidate matrix is
176+
green.
177+
- `freeze:semantics` local/CI diff-semantics gap — recorded on #1231 (OPEN,
178+
Beta.2 milestone, verified). Local `freeze:semantics:check` at the candidate
179+
exits 0.
180+
- Benchmark evidence SHA predates the candidate by docs/gates/tests plus the
181+
two parity-proven remediations — re-confirmed in Battery 7 above.
182+
183+
Issue/PR state spot-checks (via `gh`, exit 0): #1222, #1223, #1224, #1225,
184+
#1270–#1272, #1276 CLOSED on the Beta.1 milestone; #1187 and #1188 OPEN on the
185+
Beta.3 milestone by design (Beta.1 slices merged as #1264/#1265); PRs #1264,
186+
#1265, #1266, #1267, #1268, #1269, #1274, #1275, #1277 all MERGED with the
187+
recorded merge commits; stage issue #1150 OPEN awaiting this closure.
188+
189+
## Constitution §6.2 closure conditions
190+
191+
- **No unresolved §4.3 failure.** The B1.1 audit's three findings (F1
192+
unregistered route grammar, F2 renderer scope mirror without parity proof,
193+
F3 text-escape duplicate without owner/corpus) were remediated by #1274:
194+
`docs/current/SEMANTIC_OWNERSHIP.md` gained the three registry rows, the
195+
escape-text serializers converged onto one shared helper, and both surviving
196+
projections carry parity corpora that rerun green at the candidate (cell
197+
2h). #1270/#1271/#1272 are CLOSED.
198+
- **No §5.4 violation.** Enumerating every Beta.1-stage commit
199+
(`dd475619..dc3ee191`) against the mechanical frozen-path list in
200+
`tools/check-frozen-semantics.ts` (`authoring.ts`, `entry-codegen.ts`,
201+
`form-enhance.ts`, `morph-*.ts`, `protocol/data.ts`, `cli/start.ts`,
202+
`cli/build.ts`): exactly one commit touched a frozen path — `dc3ee191`
203+
(#1277) touched `entry-codegen.ts`, and its commit message cites ADR-0151
204+
("amendment authority ADR-0151"), satisfying the in-commit-message citation
205+
requirement. No other stage commit needed the citation.
206+
207+
## RESIDUAL_RISKS
208+
209+
- The SIGSEGV flake (#1278) remains live infrastructure risk for any rerun
210+
under machine concurrency; it did not manifest in this battery.
211+
- Bun runtime evidence remains local-only (no CI Bun leg), as recorded by
212+
B1.3; the runtime-support adjudication there stands unchanged at the
213+
candidate (the only runtime-path change since is the parity-proven #1277
214+
repair, which the workspace-qualification gate covers under Node and
215+
workerd).
216+
- The local full-suite pass/fail count line was truncated in this session's
217+
capture (`tail` window); the authoritative exit code is 0 and the CI matrix
218+
at the same SHA is fully green, so no evidence gap remains.
219+
220+
PRODUCTION_CODE_UNCHANGED: yes
221+
222+
PROMOTION_RECOMMENDATION: GO
223+
224+
This is the fresh-release-verifier GO of the release contract §4.1, bound to
225+
candidate SHA `dc3ee191df803a05d40389a558c2e6a19f50dd11`. Stage closure still
226+
requires the implementer and thinker GOs and the §3.2 closure report on #1150;
227+
this report supplies the verifier verdict, the per-cell exit codes, the
228+
tarball fingerprints and the CI run IDs for that report.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)