diff --git a/lib/components/form/user-settings.js b/lib/components/form/user-settings.js
index 699ba6de3..e72c770ac 100644
--- a/lib/components/form/user-settings.js
+++ b/lib/components/form/user-settings.js
@@ -337,7 +337,11 @@ const TripRequest = ({
       // In previous versions of this code, tripRequest.id was passed to setQueryParam,
       // however that causes an extra entry to be added to the recent searches on click,
       // in addition to the entry added when clicking the "Plan" (magnifying glass) button.
-      setQueryParam(query)
+
+      // Also, exclude the mode and date/time setting of the the selected search
+      // to not overwrite settings the user was using prior to this action.
+      const { date, departArrive, modes, time, ...queryWithoutModes } = query
+      setQueryParam(queryWithoutModes)
       if (query.modeButtons) {
         setUrlSearch({ modeButtons: query.modeButtons })
       }