1260 public transport "The bus stop is part of a way, it should have public_transport=stop_position tag"

[kaligrafy]

Hi!

I think this is a false positive when the way is a sidewalk or footpath. stop_position is for ways on which the bus drive. In the Quebec province, we are snapping most bus stops to the sidewalks, footpaths or cycleways with foot=designated or foot=yes used as sidewalks alongside the bus stop sign so routing engines can bring you to the actual stop location where you can board/alight the bus. This should not trigger an error in osmose.

Thanks!

[frodrigo]

cc @nlehuby

[nlehuby]

Hi,

Thanks for the report. I agree, it should be ok to have bus stop on highway=footway/path and maybe also highway=platform.

[nlehuby]

🤔 hum, that's strange, it seems already ok https://github.com/osmose-qa/osmose-backend/blob/dev/analysers/analyser_osmosis_relation_public_transport.py#L284

@kaligrafy Do you have an example to provide so I can have a deeper look ?

[kaligrafy]

Yes, see here:

https://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/byuser/ChaireMobiliteKaligrafy?level=3

You can check the first one:

[kaligrafy]

Oh, I see it is triggering the errors only on highway=cycleway. But I think it should be removed on cycleways too, since most cycleways are for foot traffic too in North America (ours in the Montreal suburbs have foot=designated on them) and are used as sidewalks most of the time.

[nlehuby]

It sounds acceptable to me.

Do you want to make the PR yourself ?

We need to add cycleway in the list of exceptions here: https://github.com/osmose-qa/osmose-backend/blob/dev/analysers/analyser_osmosis_relation_public_transport.py#L284