Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
84 lines (63 loc) · 5.63 KB

File metadata and controls

84 lines (63 loc) · 5.63 KB

Feature Comparison -- TotalReclaw Integrations

TotalReclaw works across multiple AI agent platforms. The core encryption, storage, search pipeline, and v1 taxonomy are identical everywhere -- the differences are in automation (lifecycle hooks) and available tools. This table shows what each platform supports.

All clients ship v1 by default. Stable production versions: core 2.5.6 (npm; 2.5.5 on PyPI/crates.io), plugin 3.3.13, mcp-server 3.4.0, nanoclaw 3.0.0, python 2.4.6.


Platform Feature Matrix

Feature OpenClaw MCP (Claude Desktop, Cursor, Windsurf) NanoClaw Hermes (Python) IronClaw (NEAR AI) — paused ZeroClaw (Rust)
Memory Taxonomy v1
6-type taxonomy (claim/preference/directive/commitment/episode/summary) Yes (default) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes
source / scope / volatility axes Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes
reasoning field for decision-style claims Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes
Retrieval v2 Tier 1 (source-weighted rerank) Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes
Protobuf v4 outer wrapper Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes
Automatic Memory
Auto-recall (every message) Yes -- Yes Yes -- Yes
Auto-extract (G-pipeline, every 3 turns) Yes -- Yes Yes -- Yes
Pre-compaction flush Yes -- Yes -- -- --
Session debrief (v1 summary, source=derived) Yes Yes (tool) Yes Yes Yes (tool) Yes
Explicit Tools
Remember / Recall / Forget / Export Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Status (billing & usage) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pin / Unpin (v1) Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) --
Retype (v1) Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) --
Set scope (v1) Yes Yes Yes (via MCP) Yes Yes (via MCP) --
Import from Mem0 / ChatGPT / Claude / Gemini Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes --
Upgrade to Pro Yes Yes Yes -- Yes --
Consolidate (bulk dedup) Self-hosted only Self-hosted only Self-hosted only -- Self-hosted only --
Dedup
Cosine near-duplicate prevention Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
LLM-guided dedup (contradictions) Yes -- Yes Yes -- --
Content fingerprint (exact match) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Search
BM25 + Cosine + RRF reranking Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Source-weighted final score (v1 Tier 1) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Broadened search fallback Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Hot cache (skip remote on repeat) Yes -- -- -- -- Yes

Import is Pro-only on the managed service. Importing from Mem0 / ChatGPT / Claude / Gemini is a Pro feature on the managed service (the free tier includes one lifetime import). Self-hosted deployments have no such limit.


Platform Notes

OpenClaw -- Fully automatic. Memory extraction and recall happen via lifecycle hooks with no user intervention. Best experience for users who want set-and-forget memory.

MCP (Claude Desktop, Cursor, Windsurf) -- Tools only. The host agent (Claude, Cursor, etc.) decides when to call memory tools based on context. No automatic extraction -- the agent uses tools when contextually appropriate. Setup via npx @totalreclaw/mcp-server setup (run it yourself in a terminal, never via your AI agent -- the wizard prints your recovery phrase).

NanoClaw -- Automatic, like OpenClaw. The NanoClaw agent-runner spawns the MCP server as a background process. Memory is shared within the NanoClaw group. No user setup required -- the admin configures the recovery phrase.

Hermes (Python) -- Automatic via pre/post LLM call hooks. LLM extraction with heuristic fallback. Full tool parity with OpenClaw plugin since 2.3.x: remember / recall / forget / export / status / account-setup (totalreclaw_pair) / pin / unpin / retype / set_scope / import_from / upgrade. Consolidate is self-hosted-only (no batch delete on the managed service) and is exposed via the plugin / MCP server.

IronClaw (NEAR AI) -- First-class integration has been paused since 2026-04-18; IronClaw works via the generic MCP server only (no ironclaw mcp add CLI, no lifecycle hooks). It uses the MCP server for tools; auto-extraction requires setting up routines (cron). The TEE protects the runtime; TotalReclaw protects the data.

ZeroClaw (Rust) -- Native Rust implementation via the Memory trait. Automatic recall and extraction. Includes hot cache, decay handling (7-day half-life), and conflict resolution. Import not yet implemented.


Setup Guides


Storage Modes

All platforms support two storage modes. The encryption is identical -- the difference is where encrypted data is stored.

Managed Service (default) Self-Hosted
Storage On-chain (Gnosis Chain) via The Graph Your PostgreSQL database
Free tier 250 memories/month on Gnosis mainnet, permanent Subject to your infrastructure
Pro tier 1,500 memories/month on Gnosis mainnet, permanent (see totalreclaw_status for current pricing) N/A
Setup Nothing -- works out of the box Set TOTALRECLAW_SELF_HOSTED=true + server URL
Consolidation tool Not available (no batch delete on-chain) Available