Skip to content

Organic supports on Overhangs Issue from v2.6.0Alpha3 come back in Release 2.7.1 #12104

Open
@Steamson

Description

@Steamson

Description of the bug

Hello everyone!

I use organic supports all the time, but paint it before with "Paint-on supports" tool. Recently rebuild my extruder and start to recalibrate printer and settings. I've found this with automatic generated supports:

  1. Overhanged supports over the threshold 35% with "Snug":
    1

  2. Similar Overhangs but with Organic:
    2

On GitHub I find some branches with problem and info that this problem was solved:

I download older version 2.6.0-alpha4 and with similar settings Organic Supports was fixed (as told in issues upper for this version).
It worked before as expected, but broken in new version 😐

When I write whis post, I've an idea to check some params and found problems in Top contact Z distance with 0 and 0.1 value:

v2.7.1:

  1. 0 (soluble)
    Overhang_Test v2 7 1 TcZd - 0 (soluble)

  2. 0.1 (detachable)
    Overhang_Test v2 7 1 TcZd - 0 1 (detachable)

v2.6.0 Alpha4:

  1. 0 (soluble)
    Overhang_Test v2 6 0 Alpha4 TcZd - 0 (soluble)

  2. 0.1 (detachable)
    Overhang_Test v2 6 0 Alpha4 TcZd - 0 1 (detachable)

Very interesting, that on clear downloaded v2.6.0 Alpha4 supports was different as last 2 screens and looks better and I cant reproduce them as expected at all. I think here is the problem with settings from older v2.6.0 Alpha3 that I used before:
3

Project file & How to reproduce

Organic Supports v2.7.1 vs v2.6.0 Alpha4.zip

Checklist of files included above

  • Project file
  • Screenshot

Version of PrusaSlicer

2.7.1+win64

Operating system

Windows 10

Printer model

Custom TEVO Black Widow with SKR 1.4 TURBO + Klipper

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions