Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
98 lines (71 loc) · 4.05 KB

ACCEPTANCE_REPORT.md

File metadata and controls

98 lines (71 loc) · 4.05 KB

ACCEPTANCE REPORT: ratelord Final Acceptance Run

Date: 2026-01-25
Environment: Local development, macOS, Go 1.x
Daemon Version: dev

Executive Summary

The ratelord system was subjected to a full acceptance test suite based on ACCEPTANCE.md criteria. The daemon starts successfully, persists data across restarts, generates forecasts, and handles basic intent approvals. However, policy engine hot-reloading and dynamic rule evaluation appear non-functional, and drift detection is not persistent across restarts.

Overall Status: Partial Pass - Core functionality works, but advanced features (policy rules, persistent drift) require fixes.

Test Results

1. Daemon Lifecycle & Persistence

ID Scenario Result Notes
D-01 Clean Start ✅ PASS DB created, system_started logged.
D-02 Crash Recovery ✅ PASS Events replayed, state recovered after restart.
D-03 Graceful Shutdown ⚠️ PARTIAL Shutdown logged, but tested via kill (not SIGINT).

1.2 Event Sourcing

ID Scenario Result Notes
D-04 Event Immutability ✅ PASS Events append-only, no updates/deletes.
D-05 State Derivation ✅ PASS Projections rebuilt from events on restart.

1.3 Identity Management

ID Scenario Result Notes
D-06 Identity Registration ✅ PASS Event logged, API returns success.
D-07 Initial Polling ✅ PASS Poller emits usage_observed events post-registration.

2. API & Agent Contract

ID Scenario Result Notes
A-01 Approve Intent ✅ PASS Returns 200, "approve", valid_until set.
A-02 Latency ✅ PASS <10ms RTT observed.
A-03 Wait Instruction ❌ FAIL Policy engine does not support wait/modify actions.
A-04 Denial ❌ FAIL Policy rules not evaluated; always approves.

3. Prediction & Drift

ID Scenario Result Notes
P-01 Forecast Emission ✅ PASS forecast_computed events logged with P50/P90/P99.
P-02 Reset Awareness ⚠️ PARTIAL Mock provider has reset logic, but not tested.
P-03 Detect External Usage ⚠️ PARTIAL Injection endpoint works, but state not persisted across restarts.
P-04 Variance Adjustment ❌ FAIL Not tested due to persistence issue.

4. Policy Engine

ID Scenario Result Notes
Pol-01 Hard Limit ❌ FAIL Policy file created, but rules not applied.
Pol-02 Load Shedding ❌ FAIL Not implemented.
Pol-03 Hot Reloading ❌ FAIL SIGHUP sent, but no effect observed.

5. TUI

ID Scenario Result Notes
T-01 Real-time Stream ❌ FAIL TUI not tested (binary exists but not run).
T-02 Status Indicators ❌ FAIL Not tested.
T-03 Identity List ❌ FAIL Not tested.

6. Constraints & Pools

ID Scenario Result Notes
C-01 Shared Pool ⚠️ PARTIAL Single provider/pool used; not tested with multiple agents.
C-02 Isolated Pool ❌ FAIL Not tested.

Critical Issues Identified

  1. Policy Engine Non-Functional: Dynamic policies not loaded/evaluated. Fallback to legacy logic.
  2. Drift Detection Not Persistent: Provider state resets on daemon restart.
  3. TUI Not Tested: Acceptance run focused on daemon/API; TUI requires separate testing.
  4. No Denial Scenarios: Unable to test throttling/denial due to policy issues.

Recommendations

  • Debug policy loading: Check LoadPolicyConfig and UpdatePolicies.
  • Persist provider state or detect drift on poll.
  • Implement wait/modify decisions in policy engine.
  • Test TUI separately.
  • Add more debug endpoints for state inspection.

Raw Test Logs

  • Daemon startup: system_started logged.
  • Events: 46+ events persisted (identity, usage, forecast).
  • API responses: All 200 OK.
  • Injections: Successful, but ephemeral.