Ansible hosts with non-standard ssh port

[tazmad]

Hi there,

I'm trying to setup rundeck with ansible and so far I have been partially successful. The ansible hosts are correctly all detected and imported as nodes, however the hosts which are not using the standard port 22 for ssh have their port missing and I cannot see any option for specifying this.

I have tried setting the "extra ansible arguements" with "-e ansible_port=999", but this results in the job failing with the error "ERROR! the playbook: ansible_port=999 could not be found
23:08:23 Failed: AnsibleNonZero: ERROR: Ansible execution returned with non zero code."

Any help would be much appreciated.

[tazmad]

I forgot to mention that within the ansible host file the server is defined as servername:port

[xpufx]

https://docs.rundeck.com/docs/administration/projects/node-execution/ssh.html

I'm trying to figure this out now.

It looks like rundeck's ansible node plugin is not importing the ssh port.

[hesne]

any news about this topic. If I define the port as mention in docs it cannot resolve the hostname.

[Scifire]

running currently in the same issue...
Since in my case it´s only one node I could add it to a Rundeck Node File but ofc this is not the nice way.

[martin-gerdes]

I am running into the same problem.
I am currently evaluating ansible+rundeck (to replace awx) for our company.
However, all our servers are running ssh on the (same) non-standard port.
So currently it looks to me as if the evaluation just failed...
Unless there is any news on this topic?

I see there is an open pull request in this direction: #281
That would at least be a functional workaround.

What would be really ideal though, would be just honoring the setting from ansible.cfg, which is read in after all:

[ssh_connection]
remote_port = an_integer

It seems pretty weird to me that rundeck itself doesn't have a setting for the standard ssh setting, just allowing overriding per host (which isn't discovered yet, so not an option), but that is of course outside of the scope of this plugin.

[martin-gerdes]

Workaround found, for our usecase of that ssh port being the same for all servers:
echo " Port an_integer" >> /etc/ssh/ssh_config

This doesn't help if any servers had a different ssh port, so this issue still deserves to stay open. But at least for our use case, this is good enough. :-)

[CorvetteCole]

any update on this issue?

[joe-speedboat]

I can confirm, that this issue still exists, have one server in wan, which has non default ssh-port and:
ansible -m shell -a id myhost
works, but adhoc id comand fails in rundeck.
Would be great to have this issue get fixed one time

[huapox]

+1

failed with:

[headless-arm64]
172.25.23.2 ansible_ssh_user=headless ansible_ssh_port=20022 hostname="172.25.23.2:20022" remote_port=20022
172.25.23.3 ansible_ssh_user=headless ansible_ssh_port=20022 hostname="172.25.23.3:20022" 

[djagoo]

Thats really bad, has anyone found a workaround for this when it's just one server using a different port for ssh and not all of them?

[huapox]

works with: /etc/ansible/hosts_city

#; ;标准配置示例:  `主机昵称备注 ansible_ssh_host=主机IP:端口 ansible_ssh_user=用户`
#; ;sample:  `hostNick ansible_ssh_host=$IP:$PORT ansible_ssh_user=$USER`  (if $PORT=22, can be `ansible_ssh_host=$IP`)
[t1]
t1-1.1 ansible_ssh_host=192.168.1.1:2221 ansible_ssh_user=root
t1-1.2 ansible_ssh_host=192.168.1.2:2222 ansible_ssh_user=root
t1-1.3 ansible_ssh_host=192.168.1.3:2223 ansible_ssh_user=root

[djagoo]

My hosts file is in yaml and has nearly every possible way included for this host to define a port. It seems like node discovery is working and using the right port but all commands etc. are using standard ssh port 22.

My current config:

testservers:
  hosts:
    test.test.example:9022:
      ansible_host: test.test.example
      ansible_port: 9022
      remote_port: 9022
      ansible_ssh_port: 9022

When I change this to:

testservers:
  hosts:
    test.test.example:     
      ansible_ssh_host: test.test.example:9022

the node disappears and I get a node source error "Failed Ansible Runner execution: ERROR: Ansible execution returned with non zero code."

When I try this:

[testservers]
test.test.example ansible_ssh_host=test.test.example:9022

I ended up with this error

test.test.example | UNREACHABLE! => {
    "changed": false,
    "msg": "Failed to connect to the host via ssh: ssh: Could not resolve hostname test.test.example:9022: Name or service not known",
    "unreachable": true
}

[0xlnz]

Any news on this? I'm hitting the same issue. Node gets discovered with the right port, but then Rundeck refuses to connect using the defined non-standard port.