Rubric_GQ.json

[
	{
		"Criteria": "Cohesion",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Contextually misused cohesive markers. May disrupt conversation",
			"2": "Ambiguous cohesive markers with partial context. Hinders conversation",
			"3": "Adequate cohesive markers with context. Maintains conversation",
			"4": "Well-contextualized cohesive markers. Natural conversation flow",
			"5": "Perfectly contextualized cohesive markers. Very natural conversation flow"
		}
	},
	{
		"Criteria": "Answerability",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Unclear or requires speculation. Impossible for ${answerer} to answer",
			"2": "Somewhat ambiguous or difficult. Challenging for ${answerer} to answer",
			"3": "Generally valid. Some difficulty for ${answerer} to answer",
			"4": "Clear and appropriate. Easy for ${answerer} to answer",
			"5": "Very clear and appropriate. ${answerer} can answer immediately"
		}
	},
	{
		"Criteria": "Respectfulness",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Rude and aggressive without consideration for others. Damages atmosphere",
			"2": "Somewhat rude, inconsiderate of others. Negative impact",
			"3": "Generally respectful but needs refinement. Neutral atmosphere",
			"4": "Respectful and considerate of others. Positive atmosphere",
			"5": "Highly respectful and considerate of others. Excellent atmosphere"
		}
	},
	{
		"Criteria": "Clarity",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Unclear structure making ${goal} intent impossible to grasp",
			"2": "Vague structure making ${goal} intent difficult to grasp",
			"3": "Generally clear with some ambiguity in ${goal} intent",
			"4": "Clear structure with easily understood ${goal} intent",
			"5": "Very clear structure with perfectly conveyed ${goal} intent"
		}
	},
	{
		"Criteria": "Coherence",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Irrelevant to topic with unclear purpose. Disrupts logical flow",
			"2": "Partially relevant with unclear purpose. Hinders logical flow",
			"3": "Generally relevant with clear purpose. Maintains logical flow",
			"4": "Well-connected to topic and purpose. Natural logical flow",
			"5": "Perfectly relevant and purposeful. Excellent logical flow"
		}
	},
	{
		"Criteria": "Informativeness",
		"Scoring": {
			"1": "Seeks irrelevant or speculative information, hindering ${goal}",
			"2": "Seeks low-relevance information, making ${goal} difficult",
			"3": "Shows potential for ${goal}",
			"4": "Shows high potential for ${goal}",
			"5": "Guarantees ${goal}"
		}
	}
]