Skip to content

BENCHMARK_v1.12.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
231 lines (154 loc) · 6.77 KB

BENCHMARK_v1.12.md

File metadata and controls

231 lines (154 loc) · 6.77 KB

🏆 PAMPA v1.12 Performance Analysis

📊 Overview

This document analyzes PAMPA v1.12's semantic search capabilities and compares architectural approaches with general-purpose IDE semantic search tools.

Test Environment:

  • PAMPA Version: v1.12.0
  • Test Project: Medium-scale web application (~680 indexed functions)
  • Test Date: September 25, 2025
  • Languages: PHP, TypeScript, JavaScript

🎯 Architectural Comparison

PAMPA v1.12 Approach

Specialized Code Search Engine:

  • Pre-built Index: Persistent SQLite database with code-specific embeddings
  • Hybrid Search: BM25 + Vector similarity fusion
  • Code-Aware: Symbol extraction, function signatures, AST analysis
  • Advanced Ranking: Cross-encoder reranking, symbol boosting
  • Scoped Search: Filter by file paths, languages, tags

General IDE Semantic Search

Real-time Text Search:

  • On-demand Processing: Searches files as needed
  • General Embeddings: Text-based semantic matching
  • Workspace Scope: Limited to current project context
  • Basic Ranking: Primary similarity-based ordering

Test Queries

Common code search scenarios tested:

  1. "create checkout session"
  2. "payment processing"
  3. "user authentication"
  4. "database operations"
  5. "email notifications"

📈 Performance Analysis

PAMPA v1.12 Results

Strengths:

  • Consistent Results: Reliable semantic matching with similarity scores 0.45-0.65
  • Fast Response: ~1-2 seconds average (pre-indexed)
  • Advanced Features: Scoped search, hybrid ranking, multi-project support
  • Code Specialization: Function-level granularity, symbol awareness

Sample Query Performance:

pampa search "create checkout session"
✅ Found 5 results in 1.2s
- ServiceClass::createSession (similarity: 0.57)
- CheckoutController::create (similarity: 0.54)
- PaymentService::initSession (similarity: 0.52)

IDE Semantic Search Comparison

General IDE Approach:

  • Variable Performance: Depends on project size and indexing state
  • Real-time Processing: No persistent index, searches on demand
  • Broad Scope: Full-text semantic matching across all file types
  • Simple Interface: Integrated with IDE workflow

Trade-offs:

  • ⚡ PAMPA: Faster, specialized, requires setup
  • 🔄 IDE: Integrated, general-purpose, no setup required

🔬 Technical Architecture Analysis

PAMPA v1.12 Specialized Features

🎯 Scoped Search Filters:

# Search only in specific directories for PHP files
pampa search "database operations" --path_glob "app/Models/**" --lang php
✅ Results: 5 relevant model files

# Multi-language search with tagging
pampa search "user authentication" --lang php,ts --tags auth
✅ Results: Cross-language authentication implementations

🔄 Hybrid Search (BM25 + Vector):

# Enhanced recall with keyword + semantic fusion
pampa search "checkout flow" --hybrid on --reranker transformers
✅ Results: Higher precision with cross-encoder reranking

🛠️ Multi-Project Support:

# Work seamlessly across different projects
pampa search "payment processing" --project /path/to/project-a
pampa search "payment processing" --project /path/to/project-b
✅ Results: Instant context switching between codebases

📊 Performance Metrics

PAMPA v1.12 Measured Performance

Synthetic Benchmark Results:

Benchmark results
| setting    | P@1   | MRR@5 | nDCG@10 |
| ---        | ---   | ---   | ---     |
| Base       | 0.750 | 0.833 | 0.863   |
| Hybrid     | 0.875 | 0.917 | 0.934   |
| Hybrid+CE  | 1.000 | 0.958 | 0.967   |

Key Metrics:

  • Precision@1: 87.5% with hybrid search
  • Mean Reciprocal Rank: 91.7% average
  • Normalized DCG: 93.4% relevance quality
  • Response Time: ~1-2 seconds (pre-indexed)

Comparison Considerations

PAMPA Advantages:

  • ✅ Specialized for code search with persistent indexing
  • ✅ Advanced ranking algorithms (BM25 + Vector + Cross-encoder)
  • ✅ Code-aware features (symbol extraction, function signatures)
  • ✅ Multi-project support with context switching

General IDE Advantages:

  • ✅ Zero-setup, integrated workflow
  • ✅ Real-time file watching and updates
  • ✅ Broader file type support beyond code
  • ✅ Native IDE integration and shortcuts

🔬 Technical Architecture

PAMPA v1.12 Stack

🏗️ Specialized Code Search Engine:
├── 📊 SQLite database with function-level indexing
├── 🎯 Code-specific embeddings (AST-aware)
├── 🔄 Hybrid search (BM25 + Vector fusion)
├── 🧠 Cross-encoder reranking pipeline
├── 🌲 Symbol-aware boosting algorithms
└── 📦 Context packs for domain scoping

Key Differentiators

1. Indexing Strategy:

  • PAMPA: Persistent, function-level granularity
  • General IDE: On-demand, file-level processing

2. Search Algorithms:

  • PAMPA: Multi-modal (keyword + semantic + reranking)
  • General IDE: Primary semantic similarity

3. Code Understanding:

  • PAMPA: AST parsing, symbol extraction, signature matching
  • General IDE: Text-based semantic analysis

4. Specialization:

  • PAMPA: Purpose-built for code search workflows
  • General IDE: General-purpose text search with semantic layer

📈 PAMPA v1.12 New Features

🎯 Scoped Search

Filter results by file paths, languages, and custom tags for precise targeting.

🔄 Hybrid Search

BM25 keyword matching fused with vector similarity for improved recall and precision.

🧠 Cross-Encoder Reranking

Advanced neural reranking for higher quality result ordering.

🛠️ Multi-Project Support

Context switching between different codebases with --project flags.

📦 Context Packs

Reusable search profiles for domain-specific code discovery.

🎯 Use Case Recommendations

Choose PAMPA when:

  • Working with large, complex codebases
  • Need specialized code search features
  • Require multi-project context switching
  • Want persistent, optimized search performance

Choose IDE Semantic Search when:

  • Need integrated, zero-setup workflow
  • Working with mixed content (docs + code)
  • Prefer real-time file watching
  • Want simple, general-purpose search

🏆 Conclusion

PAMPA v1.12 represents a specialized approach to code search, optimized for developer productivity through advanced indexing, hybrid algorithms, and code-aware features. While general-purpose IDE tools excel at integration and simplicity, PAMPA fills the gap for teams requiring sophisticated semantic code discovery capabilities.

Analysis based on synthetic benchmarks and architectural comparison. Performance may vary based on project size, configuration, and usage patterns.