This is the append-only VRE-side feature ledger for Phase 10 implementation
work. It maps the Phase 10 design requirement named phase10-feature-ledger.md
to the VRE filename convention phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md.
Do not create a parallel active phase10-feature-ledger.md.
| seq | date | wave | task | feature id | surface | paths | flags | tests | status | notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 001 | 2026-06-07 | 10.0 | T10.0.1 | W10-TRACKING-SCAFFOLD | Phase 10 tracking scaffold and dependency check | package.json, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md |
no functional runtime; scaffold/checker only | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js failed before modules existed; GREEN: npm run test:phase10-scaffold, npm run build:phase10-surface-index, npm run check:phase10-ledger, npm run test:phase9; HAT 3 probe: check-phase10-ledger --changed-file=environment/tests/ci/phase10-untraced-probe.js failed closed with E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING; post-push CI hotfix: node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js covers the two T10.0.1 CI validators |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-07T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.1 tracking scaffold before functional runtime; what: Phase 10 ledgers, surface index, dependency checker, fail-closed trace reconciliation, and the post-push validate-counts CI-count alignment; verification: phase10 scaffold 8/8, Phase 9 496 pass/5 skip/0 fail, fail-closed probe verified, validate-counts ciValidators 17; reviewer: claude-code HAT 1 ACCEPT and HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-08; anti-dup verified: extends Phase 9 tracking/surface-index pattern; tier-C: yes-with-pages concepts/dual-ledger-discipline.md and entities/phase10-tracking-scaffold.md; non-blocking follow-up: FU-T10.0.1-TRACE-PER-PATCH-001 |
| 002 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.2 | W10-SCHEMA-FOUNDATION | Phase 10 v1 schema contract foundation | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/schemas/phase10-knowledge-domain.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-source-bundle.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-raw-document.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-provenance-link.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-computed-artifact.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-inbox-entry.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-query-record.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-presentation.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-export-recipe.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-marp-template.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-compile-policy.schema.json, environment/schemas/phase10-role-envelope.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-schema-test-helper.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-knowledge-domain.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-source-bundle.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-raw-document.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-provenance-link.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-computed-artifact.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-inbox-entry.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-query-record.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-presentation.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-export-recipe.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-marp-template.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-compile-policy.schema.test.js, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-role-envelope.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-runtime-contracts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/10-hat3-t10-0-2-closure-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md |
no functional runtime; schema contracts and schema tests only | RED: node --test environment/tests/schemas/phase10-*.schema.test.js failed 40/41 before schema files existed; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed schemaTests 54 vs 67 before count update. GREEN: Phase 10 schema tests 41/41, validate-counts, validate-runtime-contracts, Phase 10 checker/surface tests 9/9, check-phase10-ledger, check-phase9-ledger, surface index regenerated to 31 surfaces, and aggregate node environment/tests/ci/run-all.js PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.2 implements the reviewed 13-contract schema foundation after non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and operator GO HAT 2; what: new Phase 10 schema contracts, RED-first schema tests, count guard update schemas/schemaTests 54 -> 67, runtime-contract registration, Phase 10 surface-index extension, schema-test trace coverage in check-phase10-ledger.js, WIKI schema-contract page, and private ledgers/gate state; verification: targeted GREEN listed in tests column, build-registries --rebuild, audit-schema-fields --fix --json, run-all.js PASS; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09; anti-dup verified: no phase10-domain, phase10-claim-edge, phase10-serendipity-finding, or phase10-steering-event schema files; role-envelope implemented as a new schema contract only, not runtime role migration; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md |
| 003 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.2 | W10-SCHEMA-FOUNDATION-WIKI-SYNC | Phase 10 schema foundation WIKI lint and mirror sync | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-exported-symbols.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/closures/scheduled-gate-health-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md |
no functional runtime; WIKI mirror only | GREEN: node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/wiki-lint.mjs --json PASS issueCount 0; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/sync-mirror.mjs --json wrote 4 mirror updates; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/sync-mirror.mjs --check --json PASS changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.2 HAT 2 WIKI obligations require lint and mirror sync after adding the schema-contract page and registry/log updates; what: WIKI mirror files for the schema-contract page, registry, log, and pre-existing scheduled gate-health closure; verification: wiki-lint PASS and mirror check PASS; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09; tier-C: WIKI sync only |
| 004 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.3 | W10-LAW13-LINT-FOUNDATION | Phase 10 LAW 13 lint foundation | package.json, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/law13-lint.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-law13-lint.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/11-hat1-stop-t10-0-3-law13-lint-foundation-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md |
no workflow runtime; lint/check foundation only | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/law13-lint.js existed. GREEN: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js 15/15 pass; node environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.js PASS; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS with ciValidators: 18; node environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js wrote 33 surfaces; node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js 9/9 pass; aggregate node environment/tests/ci/run-all.js PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.3 implements the reviewed LAW 13 lint foundation after non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing operator GO HAT 2; what: 11-check LAW 13 lint catalog, fail-closed tests for 15 RED cases, CI entrypoint wired into run-all.js, count guard ciValidators 17 -> 18, package script, and surface-index extension; verification: targeted and aggregate GREEN listed in tests column; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09 via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.3-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no workflow runtime, no query adapter, no compile/publish pipeline, no curator role migration, no claim-edge mutation; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-law13-lint.md |
| 005 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.4 | W10-CLAIM-EDGE-PROJECTION | Phase 10 read-only claim-edge projection surface | package.json, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/claim-edge-projection.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-claim-edge-projection.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-claim-edge-projection.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-claim-edge-projection.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/13-hat1-stop-t10-0-4-claim-edge-projection-surface-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/14-hat3-t10-0-4-closure-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md |
read-only projection helper only; no claim-edge writes | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-claim-edge-projection.test.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/claim-edge-projection.js existed. GREEN: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-claim-edge-projection.test.js 15/15 pass; node environment/tests/ci/phase10-claim-edge-projection.js PASS; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS with ciValidators: 19; node environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js wrote 35 surfaces; node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js 10/10 pass; aggregate node environment/tests/ci/run-all.js PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.4 implements the reviewed read-only claim-edge projection surface after non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing operator GO HAT 2; what: metadata-only projection helper, fail-closed tests for 15 RED cases, CI entrypoint wired into run-all.js, count guard ciValidators 18 -> 19, package script, and surface-index/checker extension; verification: targeted and aggregate GREEN listed in tests column; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09 via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.4-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no phase10-claim-edge schema/store, no createClaimEdge, no edges.jsonl write, no claim-ledger mutation, no query/export/curator/domain runtime; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-claim-edge-projection.md |
| 006 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.4 | W10-CLAIM-EDGE-PROJECTION-WIKI-SYNC | Phase 10 claim-edge projection WIKI lint and mirror sync | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-claim-edge-projection.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-claim-edge-projection.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
no functional runtime; WIKI mirror only | GREEN: node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/build-registries.mjs --rebuild PASS with 0 changed; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/audit-schema-fields.mjs --fix --json PASS issueCount 0; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/wiki-lint.mjs --json PASS issueCount 0; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/sync-mirror.mjs --json wrote 2 mirror updates. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.4 HAT 2 WIKI obligations require lint and mirror sync after adding the projection page and log updates; what: WIKI mirror files for the projection page and log; verification: registry, schema-field audit, wiki-lint, and mirror sync PASS; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09; tier-C: WIKI sync only |
| 007 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.5 | W10-CURATOR-ROLE-MIGRATION | Phase 10 curator-agent role migration foundation | package.json, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/orchestrator/agent-orchestration.js, environment/orchestrator/task-registry/phase10-wiki-lint.json, environment/orchestrator/task-registry/phase10-wiki-compile.json, environment/phase10/curator-role.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-curator-role.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-curator-role.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, environment/tests/control/agent-orchestration.test.js, environment/tests/lib/task-registry.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-curator-role.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/agent-orchestration-js.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/15-hat1-stop-t10-0-5-curator-agent-role-migration-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/16-hat3-t10-0-5-closure-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json |
dual-envelope curator dispatch planning only; no reviewed-runner transport migration | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-curator-role.test.js failed 15/15 before curator-agent existed. GREEN: curator tests 15/15, validator PASS, agent-orchestration 65/65, task-registry/schema 28/28, surface/checker 12/12, check-phase9-ledger, check-phase10-ledger, and aggregate run-all.js PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.5 implements the reviewed curator-agent role migration after Claude Code non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing operator GO HAT 2; what: eighth runtime role, Phase 9 transport plus Phase 10 governance envelope, bounded wiki-lint/wiki-compile task registry entries, fail-closed authority guards, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 19 -> 20, package script, and surface-index/checker coverage; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate GREEN recorded; reviewer: claude-code HAT 1 ACCEPT and HAT 3 ACCEPT via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.5-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no reviewed-runner transport swap, no createClaimEdge, no edges.jsonl writer, no full inbox/skill-cache reads, no supposition promotion, no serendipity seed capture; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-curator-role.md |
| 008 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.6 | W10-DOMAIN-LIFECYCLE-CLI | Phase 10 knowledge-domain lifecycle CLI foundation | package.json, bin/vre, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js, environment/schemas/phase9-objective.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase9-objective.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-domain-lifecycle-cli.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/vre-environment-schemas.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-domain-lifecycle-cli.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/vre-environment-schemas.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/17-hat1-stop-t10-0-6-knowledge-domain-lifecycle-cli-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/18-hat3-t10-0-6-closure-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json |
one-active-domain lifecycle CLI only; runtime domain records remain gitignored under .vibe-science-environment/ |
RED: node --test environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js failed 10/11 before vre domain existed; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed cliTests 10 vs 11 before count update. GREEN: domain CLI tests 11/11, Phase 9/10/domain-config schema tests 16/16, validate-counts PASS with cliTests: 11, surface/checker tests 13/13, surface index regenerated to 39 surfaces, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI lint issueCount 0, and mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.6 implements the reviewed one-active knowledge-domain lifecycle CLI after Claude Code non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing operator GO HAT 2; what: vre domain create/link/unlink/status/archive, gitignored domain state path, objective domainId bridge, schema-defined domain objectiveLinks[] symmetry, archive write-blocking, workspace-escape guard, count guard cliTests 10 -> 11, package script, and surface-index/checker coverage; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN recorded, plus Claude Code HAT 3 attack-point verification and fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING; reviewer: claude-code HAT 1 ACCEPT and HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09 via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.6-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no cross-domain merge/synthesis/query, no export/publish/MARP/presentation adapter, no claim-edge writer, no claim-ledger mutation, no supposition or serendipity authority, no tracked domain-data file; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-domain-lifecycle-cli.md |
| 009 | 2026-06-09 | 10.0 | T10.0.7 | W10-PHASE12-LAW13-BRIDGE | Phase 12 LAW 13 bridge binding validator | package.json, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/law13-bridge.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-bridge.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-bridge.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-law13-bridge.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/19-hat1-stop-t10-0-7-phase12-law13-bridge-binding-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/20-hat3-t10-0-7-closure-2026-06-09.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json |
validator-only bridge/check surface; no new schema file, query, export, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, or Phase 12 runtime | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-bridge.test.js and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-bridge.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/law13-bridge.js; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed ciValidators 20 vs 21 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: bridge tests 12/12, bridge validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 21, surface/checker tests 14/14, surface index regenerated to 41 surfaces, check-phase9-ledger PASS, check-phase10-ledger PASS, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI lint issueCount 0, and mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-09T00:00:00Z; why: T10.0.7 implements the reviewed validator-only Phase 12 LAW 13 bridge binding after Claude Code non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing operator GO HAT 2; what: existing phase12.phase10-law13-review-extension six-boolean contract enforcement, relay-verdict/query metadata not LAW 13 provenance, claimed-transition R2 path guard, supposition-isolation guard, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 20 -> 21, package script, run-all wiring, and surface-index/checker coverage; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN recorded plus Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT rerunning run-all.js; reviewer: claude-code HAT 1 ACCEPT and HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-09 via relays C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat1-t10.0.7-verdict.md and C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.7-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: separate from T10.0.3 phase10-law13-lint, no schema file, no query/export/compile/publish/MARP/presentation/provenance-writer/claim-ledger-writer/createClaimEdge/Phase12 runtime/cross-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-law13-bridge.md |
| 010 | 2026-06-10 | 10.0 | T10.0.8 | W10-DOMAIN-LINK-LINT-FIELD-FIX | LAW 13 domain-link lint field alignment | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/law13-lint.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-law13-lint.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/21-hat1-stop-t10-0-8-domain-link-lint-field-fix-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
lint/test/validator field fix only; no schema migration, domain-lifecycle rewrite, new schema file, writer, or workflow runtime | RED: after migrating tests/validator to real objectiveLinks, node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js failed 3/17 because correct links false-positive; node environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.js failed the valid fixture. GREEN: law13 lint tests 17/17, validator PASS, no linkedObjectiveIds remains in lint/test/validator, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 21, check-phase10-ledger PASS, and aggregate run-all.js PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: Claude Code holistic audit proved T10.0.3 domain-link lint read phantom linkedObjectiveIds while real Phase 10 domains use objectiveLinks; what: law13-lint.js now reads domain.objectiveLinks and resolves (link?.objectiveId ?? link), with string and object-shaped regression coverage; verification: targeted RED/GREEN, aggregate run-all.js, and Claude Code independent HAT 3 re-execution all pass; reviewer: claude-code HAT 1 ACCEPT and HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.0.8-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no schema/domain-lifecycle/runtime/query/export/claim-edge/provenance writer change; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-law13-lint.md |
| 011 | 2026-06-10 | 10.1 | T10.1.0 | W10.1-RAW-ZONE-STORAGE-SCAFFOLD | Active-domain raw-zone storage scaffold | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/raw-zone.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-raw-zone.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-raw-zone.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-raw-zone.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-raw-zone.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/31-hat1-stop-t10-1-0-raw-zone-storage-scaffold-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/32-hat3-t10-1-0-raw-zone-storage-scaffold-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
active-domain raw storage only; no source-bundle approval, inbox workflow, scientific-skill intake, KB migration, query, compile, export, MARP, presentation, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge writer, or multi-domain behavior | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-raw-zone.test.js and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-raw-zone.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/raw-zone.js; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed ciValidators 21 vs 22 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: raw-zone tests 9/9, raw-zone validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 22, surface index regenerated to 43 surfaces, surface/checker tests 15/15, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI lint issueCount 0, and mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.1.0 implements the reviewed raw-zone storage scaffold after Claude Code non-author HAT 1 ACCEPT and standing Phase 10 GO; what: active-domain raw metadata/payload storage, path safety, archived-domain write blocking, duplicate/idempotency guards, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 21 -> 22, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN recorded; reviewer: claude-code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via relay C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-t10.1.0-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: raw storage is not provenance and no source-bundle/inbox/query/export/claim-edge/multi-domain behavior is opened; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-raw-zone.md |
| 012 | 2026-06-10 | 10.1 | T10.1.1 | W10.1-SOURCE-BUNDLE-REGISTRATION | Schema-first source-bundle registration | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/source-bundles.js, environment/schemas/phase10-source-bundle.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-source-bundle.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-source-bundles.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-source-bundles.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-source-bundles.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-source-bundles.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/33-hat1-stop-t10-1-1-source-bundle-registration-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/34-hat3-t10-1-1-source-bundle-registration-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
curated source-bundle registration only; no inbox workflow, scientific-skill intake, KB migration, wiki compile, query, export, MARP, presentation, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge writer, raw-zone mutation, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: source-bundle schema test failed 7/9 before the existing schema accepted the five amended fields; source-bundles task test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/source-bundles.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 22 vs 23 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: source-bundle schema tests 10/10, task tests 9/9, source-bundles validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 23, surface index regenerated to 45 surfaces, and surface/checker tests 16/16. Full ledger/WIKI/aggregate verification is recorded in the HAT 3 report before relay. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.1.1 implements Claude Code's accepted schema-first REDIRECT amendment after T10.1.0 raw-zone commit/CI green; what: existing phase10.source-bundle.v1 schema now carries bundleVersion, license, allowTrackPayload, scopeOfUse, and rawDocumentRefs, plus runtime registration from real raw-zone records, curated-only approval policy, corrigendum versioning, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 22 -> 23, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and targeted GREEN recorded, with aggregate/WIKI checks required before HAT 3 relay; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.1.1-verdict.md; commit/push and CI confirmation pending; anti-dup verified: source bundles remain approval records and do not write provenance, inbox, query, wiki pages, claim ledger, claim edges, exports, or multi-domain state; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-source-bundles.md |
| 013 | 2026-06-10 | 10.1 | T10.1.2 | W10.1-INBOX-REVIEW-PROMOTION | Schema-first inbox review and promotion | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/inbox.js, environment/schemas/phase10-inbox-entry.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-inbox-entry.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-inbox.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-inbox.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-inbox-workflow.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/35-hat1-stop-t10-1-2-inbox-review-promotion-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/36-hat3-t10-1-2-inbox-review-promotion-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
inbox review/promotion only; no scientific-skill intake, Obsidian import compatibility, KB migration, wiki compile, query, export, MARP, presentation, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge writer, curator role expansion, role transport migration, automatic promotion, bulk approval, or multi-domain behavior | RED: inbox schema tests failed 6/9 before candidateStatus and design-required fields replaced reviewStatus; inbox task test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/inbox.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 23 vs 24 before count update; the added approval-atomicity regression failed 10/11 before inbox approval validation moved before promotion writes. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: inbox schema tests 9/9, inbox tests 11/11, inbox validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 24, surface index regenerated to 47 surfaces, surface/checker tests 17/17, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI lint issueCount 0, and mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.1.2 implements Claude Code's accepted schema-first inbox STOP after T10.1.1 commit/CI green; what: existing phase10.inbox-entry.v1 now uses canonical candidateStatus with no reviewStatus alias, plus inbox submission, operator/curator views, dedupe/task-cap guards, one-entry review, tombstones, stale resurfacing, approval promotion through existing raw-zone/source-bundle helpers, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 23 -> 24, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.1.2-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: inbox candidates are not provenance and no claim-ledger/claim-edge/query/export/compile/presentation/multi-domain/skill adapter behavior is opened; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-inbox-workflow.md; non-blocking follow-up: FU-T10.1.2-PROMOTION-ATOMICITY |
| 014 | 2026-06-10 | 10.1 | T10.1.3 | W10.1-KNOWLEDGE-BASE-MIGRATION | Knowledge-base migration bridge | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/knowledge-base-import.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-knowledge-base-import.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-knowledge-base-import.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-knowledge-base-migration.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/concepts/knowledge-base-runtime.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/37-hat1-stop-t10-1-3-knowledge-base-migration-bridge-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/38-hat3-t10-1-3-knowledge-base-migration-bridge-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
snapshot-to-inbox migration bridge only; no Obsidian compatibility, scientific-skill adapter, direct wiki writer, raw/source-bundle writer, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge writer, schema file, CLI, query, compile, export, presentation, or multi-domain behavior | RED: task test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before knowledge-base-import.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 24 vs 25 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: knowledge-base import tests 5/5, validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 25, surface index regenerated to 49 surfaces, and surface/checker tests 18/18. Full ledger/WIKI/aggregate verification is recorded in the HAT 3 report before relay. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.1.3 implements Claude Code's accepted knowledge-base migration bridge plus cap amendment after T10.1.2 commit/CI green; what: legacy KNOWLEDGE snapshot parser, Phase 10 migration manifest/freeze marker, existing-inbox candidate submission, deterministic <=10 candidate task batches, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 24 -> 25, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first, targeted GREEN, aggregate/WIKI checks, fail-closed probe, and Claude Code cap-not-weakened execution recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.1.3-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: migrated records are not provenance or active claims and no raw/source-bundle/wiki/provenance/claim/query/export/multi-domain surface is opened; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-knowledge-base-migration.md; non-blocking: internal import manifest schemaVersion has no schema file and cross-submission import writes are not fully transactional |
| 015 | 2026-06-10 | 10.1 | T10.1.4 | W10.1-SCIENTIFIC-SKILL-INTAKE | Scientific-skill discovery intake bridge | .gitignore, package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/scientific-skill-intake.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-scientific-skill-intake.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-scientific-skill-intake.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-scientific-skill-intake.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-inbox-workflow.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/39-hat1-stop-t10-1-4-scientific-skills-discovery-integration-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/40-hat3-t10-1-4-scientific-skills-discovery-integration-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
already-reviewed scientific-skill output intake only; no network clients, direct raw/source-bundle/provenance/wiki/claim writer, automatic promotion, CLI, schema file, query, compile, export, presentation, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: task test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before scientific-skill-intake.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 25 vs 26 before count update; cache writes failed with E_PHASE10_SKILL_CACHE_NOT_GITIGNORED before .gitignore amendment. GREEN: scientific-skill intake tests 8/8, validator PASS, git check-ignore PASS for root and nested .vre-local/skill-cache/, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators: 26, surface index regenerated to 51 surfaces, surface/checker tests 19/19, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI lint issueCount 0, and mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.1.4 implements Claude Code's accepted cache-path-amended scientific-skill discovery intake after T10.1.3 commit/CI green; what: deterministic PubMed/DOI/GEO/AlphaFold/OpenAlex source mapping, inbox submission through existing T10.1.2 helper, deterministic <=10 candidate task batches, TTL-bound non-provenance skill cache, .gitignore protection, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 25 -> 26, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN plus Claude Code HAT 3 execution of gitignore and cap-not-weakened probes; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.1.4-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no network clients, no raw/source-bundle/provenance/wiki/claim/query/export/runtime promotion path, no schema file, no CLI, no role change, and no multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-scientific-skill-intake.md |
| 016 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.0 | W10.2-WIKI-COMPILE-SCAFFOLD | Schema-first wiki compile scaffold | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/wiki-compile.js, environment/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.test.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/43-hat1-stop-t10-2-0-wiki-compile-scaffold-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/44-hat3-t10-2-0-wiki-compile-scaffold-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
deterministic wiki-page scaffold only; no synthesis/R2, declared-kind routing, source discovery, inbox/raw/source-bundle/provenance/claim/query/export/presentation writer, curator role change, task-registry migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: schema test failed until phase10.wiki-page.v1 persisted page type, LAW 13 assertion status, and hypothesis nexusStatus; task test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/wiki-compile.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 26 vs 27 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: wiki-page schema tests 7/7, wiki compile tests 9/9, wiki compile validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:27, surface index regenerated to 53 surfaces, surface/checker tests 19/19, aggregate run-all.js PASS. Full ledger/WIKI/dependency/fail-closed verification is recorded in the HAT 3 report before relay. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.0 implements Claude Code's accepted schema-first wiki compile scaffold after Wave 10.1 operator closeout; what: existing wiki-page schema repair, deterministic compileWikiPages, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 26 -> 27, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first targeted/aggregate GREEN recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 1 re-ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat1-t10.2.0-reaccept-verdict.md and HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.0-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: compile consumes existing active-domain/source-bundle/provenance-link contracts and does not create provenance, claims, queries, exports, role changes, or multi-domain state; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md |
| 017 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.0 | W10.2-WIKI-COMPILE-WIKI-SYNC | Phase 10 wiki compile WIKI lint and mirror sync | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
no functional runtime; WIKI mirror only | GREEN: node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/wiki-lint.mjs --json PASS issueCount 0; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/build-registries.mjs --check --json PASS changed 0; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/sync-mirror.mjs --json wrote entity/log mirror updates. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.0 HAT 2 WIKI obligations require lint and mirror sync after adding the wiki compile entity; what: WIKI mirror files for the wiki compile entity and log; verification: wiki-lint, build-registries check, and mirror sync PASS; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.0-verdict.md; tier-C: WIKI sync only |
| 018 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.1 | W10.2-R2-AUDITED-SYNTHESIS | R2-audited synthesis compile policy | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/wiki-r2-audit.js, environment/phase10/wiki-compile.js, environment/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-r2-audit.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-r2-audit.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-r2-audited-synthesis.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-law13-bridge.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/45-hat1-stop-t10-2-1-r2-audited-synthesis-policy-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/46-hat3-t10-2-1-r2-audited-synthesis-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
synthesis publish path only; no source discovery, raw/source-bundle/inbox/provenance/query/export/presentation/claim writer, dynamic auto-upgrade, risk routing, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: positive audited synthesis probe failed on T10.2.0 with E_PHASE10_WIKI_COMPILE_POLICY_FORBIDDEN; phase10-wiki-r2-audit.test.js failed before wiki-r2-audit.js; validate-counts would fail ciValidators 27 -> 28 before count update. GREEN: wiki-page schema tests 10/10, wiki compile + R2 tests 16/16, checker tests 18/18, R2 validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:28, surface index regenerated to 55 surfaces, check-phase10-ledger, dependency check, check-phase9-ledger, fail-closed trace probe, aggregate run-all.js, WIKI lint, registry check, and mirror check all PASS before HAT 3 ACCEPT. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.1 implements Claude Code's accepted positive-case amendment after T10.2.0 commit/CI green; what: new wiki-r2-audit helper, mandatory compileWikiPages integration for three-pass-r2-audited synthesis, existing wiki-page schema R2 audit extension, fail-closed repair/provenance/bridge tests, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 27 -> 28, package script, run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first, targeted GREEN, aggregate/checker/WIKI GREEN, and Claude Code executed positive compile/schema/lint proof; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.1-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no provenance writer, query writer, export path, MARP/presentation surface, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, role migration, source discovery, raw/source-bundle/inbox mutation, dynamic auto-upgrade, risk scanner, or multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-r2-audited-synthesis.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js |
| 019 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.1 | W10.2-R2-AUDITED-SYNTHESIS-WIKI-SYNC | Phase 10 R2 audited synthesis WIKI lint and mirror sync | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-r2-audited-synthesis.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-law13-bridge.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md |
no functional runtime; WIKI mirror only | GREEN: node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/build-registries.mjs --rebuild --json PASS with 0 changed; node blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/sync-mirror.mjs --json added/updated 5 mirror files; final WIKI lint issueCount 0, registry check changed [], mirror check changed 0. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.1 WIKI obligations require mirror sync after adding the R2 audited synthesis entity and updating related pages; what: WIKI mirror files for the new R2 audited synthesis page, bridge/schema/compile pages, and log; verification: mirror sync and final mirror check PASS; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.1-verdict.md; tier-C: WIKI sync only |
| 020 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.2 | W10.2-ASSERTION-GRAPH-RISK-SCANNER | Assertion graph materialization and deterministic risk scanner | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/assertion-graph.js, environment/phase10/risk-scanner.js, environment/phase10/wiki-compile.js, environment/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-r2-audit.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-assertion-graph.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-assertion-graph.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-risk-scanner.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-risk-scanner.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-assertion-graph.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-risk-scanner.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/47-hat1-stop-t10-2-2-assertion-graph-risk-scanner-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/48-hat3-t10-2-2-assertion-graph-risk-scanner-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
assertion routing metadata only; no synthesis auto-publication, general dynamic auto-upgrade heuristic table, source discovery, raw/source-bundle/inbox/provenance/query/export/presentation writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: targeted task tests failed before assertion-graph.js and risk-scanner.js existed; wiki-page schema rejected routing fields before extension; validate-counts failed ciValidators 28 -> 30 before count update; check-phase10-ledger failed closed until T10.2.2 paths were traced. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: assertion graph/risk scanner/wiki compile/schema tests 34/34 PASS, all affected validators PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:30, surface index regenerated to 59 surfaces, checker fixture tests PASS, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI registry/lint/mirror checks PASS. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.2 implements Claude Code's accepted assertion graph/risk scanner HAT 1 after T10.2.1 commit/CI green; what: materialized assertion graph helper, deterministic risk scanner, compileWikiPages routing integration, existing wiki-page schema/test extension for declaredKind/riskFlags/finalRouting/pageRouting, validator fixture alignment for declaredKind, two CI validators, count guard ciValidators 28 -> 30, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, WIKI entities, and HAT 3 handoff; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/checker/WIKI GREEN recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.2-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: concept causal routing is metadata-only and creates no synthesis page, source/entity causal risk rejects, hypothesis-review routing stays isolated, query/relay/presentation/export are not provenance cites, and T10.2.3 dynamic heuristics remain deferred; tier-C: yes-with-pages entities/phase10-assertion-graph.md and entities/phase10-risk-scanner.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js |
| 021 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | T10.2.3 | W10.2-DYNAMIC-AUTO-UPGRADE-HEURISTICS | Dynamic compile-policy auto-upgrade heuristics | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/compile-policy.js, environment/phase10/wiki-compile.js, environment/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-wiki-page.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-compile-policy.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-compile-policy.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-compile.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-compile-policy.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-compile.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-schema-contracts.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/49-hat1-stop-t10-2-3-dynamic-auto-upgrade-heuristics-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/50-hat3-t10-2-3-dynamic-auto-upgrade-heuristics-closure-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-lint-check-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-role-budget-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
compile-policy resolution only; no CLI override, interactive ask, synthesis auto-publication, source discovery, raw/source-bundle/inbox/provenance/query/export/presentation writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-compile-policy.test.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before compile-policy.js; validate-counts would fail ciValidators 30 -> 31 before count update; checker fail-closed probe is required before HAT 3. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: compile-policy helper tests 5/5, wiki compile integration tests 15/15, wiki-page schema tests 13/13, compile-policy validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:31, surface index regenerated to 61 surfaces, checker fixture tests 20/20, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI registry/lint/mirror PASS, and full node --test PASS once locally with 1206/1197/0/9. Claude Code repeated full Windows runs and found an unrelated intermittent connectors.test.js EPERM lockfile flake tracked as FU-CONNECTOR-LOCK-EPERM. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.3 implements Claude Code's accepted REDIRECT-amended dynamic auto-upgrade heuristic scope after T10.2.2 hotfix CI green; what: deterministic resolveCompilePolicy helper, compileWikiPages page-level compilePolicyRationale, fail-closed non-synthesis review-required handling, schema/test extension, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 30 -> 31, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, WIKI entity, and HAT 3 handoff; verification: RED-first, targeted/aggregate/checker/WIKI GREEN, and reviewer direct proofs recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT on 2026-06-10 via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.2.3-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no --policy CLI override, no interactive ask, no automatic synthesis page creation, no source/provenance/claim/query/export/presentation writer, and no multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-compile-policy.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js; non-blocking follow-up: FU-CONNECTOR-LOCK-EPERM |
| 022 | 2026-06-10 | 10.2 | FU-CONNECTOR-LOCK-EPERM | W10.2-CONNECTOR-LOCK-EPERM-HARDENING | Windows lock EPERM hardening follow-up from T10.2.3 review | environment/control/_io.js, environment/orchestrator/_io.js, environment/tests/control/io-locks.test.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/closures/phase10-wave10-2-closeout-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/closures/phase10-wave10-2-closeout-evidence-2026-06-10.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/52-hat3-wave10-2-closeout-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md |
control/orchestrator lock acquisition hardening only; no Phase 10 query, compile, export, provenance, claim, role, or multi-domain behavior | RED: validate-counts failed controlTests 29 -> 30 after the new lock test appeared. GREEN before relay: node --test environment/tests/control/io-locks.test.js 7/7 and node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS with controlTests:30. Full aggregate and ledger checks PASS: Phase 9/10 ledgers PASS, npm run check PASS, and Claude Code repeated full node --test twice at 1213 tests, 1204 pass, 0 fail, 9 skipped. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.2.3 reviewer found a Windows connector-lock EPERM flake; what: classify Windows EPERM from lock open as transient contention, retry without stale-removing live locks, reuse the classifier in orchestrator locking, add a focused control test, and update count guard; verification: targeted test and count guard pass before non-author review; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-fu-connector-lock-eperm-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no connector API redesign, no query/export/provenance/claim writer, no role migration, and no Phase 10 runtime scope expansion; tier-C: noop, lock handling hardening follow-up |
| 023 | 2026-06-10 | 10.3 | T10.3.0 | W10.3-WIKI-QUERY-READ-PATH | Bounded single-domain wiki query read path | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/wiki-query.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-wiki-query.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/54-hat1-stop-t10-3-0-wiki-query-read-path-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
bounded read path only; query outputs are metadata, never LAW 13 provenance; no decision-use matrix, contradiction/staleness lint expansion, promotion, export, presentation, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, role migration, source discovery, or multi-domain behavior | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before wiki-query.js; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed ciValidators 31 -> 32 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: wiki-query tests 8/8, validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:32, surface index regenerated to 63 surfaces, checker fixture tests 21/21 PASS, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI registry/lint/mirror checks PASS, and full node --test PASS. Claude Code independently re-ran the anti-bypass decisionUse, freshness, path/traversal, cross-domain, no-forbidden-writer, count, probe, and full node --test checks before ACCEPT. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.3.0 implements Claude Code's accepted §16.1-amended wiki-query read path after Wave 10.2 closeout; what: deterministic runWikiQuery, codebase-owned code-only estimation table, compiled-manifest freshness guard, bounded path/budget guards, computed conservative decisionUse, query-record schema validation, metadata markdown under wiki/queries/<query-id>.md, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 31 -> 32, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and GREEN evidence listed in tests column; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.3.0-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no query-as-provenance path, no R2 decision-grade output, no schema edit, no export/presentation/multi-domain/promotion behavior, and no claim/provenance writer; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-wiki-query.md |
| 024 | 2026-06-10 | 10.3 | T10.3.1 | W10.3-QUERY-DECISION-USE | Schema-first query decision-use matrix and LAW 13 guard foundation | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/query-decision-use.js, environment/phase10/wiki-query.js, environment/phase10/law13-lint.js, environment/schemas/phase10-query-record.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-query-record.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-decision-use.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-decision-use.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-query-decision-use.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/56-hat1-stop-t10-3-1-query-decision-use-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md |
query decision-use metadata only; no contradiction/staleness expansion, query promotion, export, presentation, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, source discovery, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: phase10-query-decision-use.test.js and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before helper existed; query-record schema tests failed because formal queryClass, status, outputPath, and report-generation scope were not enforced; LAW 13 lint tests failed because the three accepted checks were absent; wiki-query tests failed because T10.3.0 still treated queryClass as an estimation profile. GREEN before HAT 3 handoff: query-decision-use tests 7/7, query-record schema tests 7/7, LAW 13 lint tests 20/20, wiki-query tests 10/10, query-decision-use/wiki-query/law13 validators PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:33, surface index regenerated to 65 surfaces, checker fixture tests 22/22 PASS, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, dependency check PASS, fail-closed trace probe E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING, aggregate run-all.js PASS, WIKI registry/lint/mirror checks PASS, and full node --test PASS before Claude Code review. |
verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.3.1 implements Claude Code's accepted query decision-use STOP and required clean-replace amendment; what: pure decision-use helper, schema-first query-record repair, wiki-query formal queryClass/local estimationProfile split, R2/full-enumeration gates, LAW 13 computed/report-scope/R2 lint additions, count guard ciValidators 32 -> 33, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and targeted GREEN recorded, aggregate/HAT3 verification completed by Claude Code with 13-case matrix and full node --test; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 1 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat1-t10.3.1-verdict.md and HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.3.1-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: query outputs remain metadata and existing query-not-provenance, synthesis-not-cites-query, domain-link-bidirectional-integrity, and transitive-isolation regressions stay covered; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-query-decision-use.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js |
| 025 | 2026-06-10 | 10.3 | T10.3.2 | W10.3-QUERY-LINTS-CONTRADICTION-FRESHNESS | Query lint foundation for visible warnings, contradiction completeness, freshness caveats, promotion metadata, and stale/refuted evidence markers | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/query-lints.js, environment/phase10/wiki-query.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-lints.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-lints.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-query-lints.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/phase10-query-lints.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/58-hat1-stop-t10-3-2-query-lints-contradiction-freshness-2026-06-10.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | query-lint helper/validator only; query outputs remain metadata, not LAW 13 provenance; no schema edit, source discovery, query promotion writer, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, export/presentation, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED observed: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-lints.test.js and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-query-lints.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before query-lints.js; node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js failed ciValidators 33 -> 34 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3 review: query-lints tests 8/8, query-lints validator PASS, wiki-query tests 10/10, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:34, surface index regenerated to 67 surfaces, checker fixture tests 23/23 PASS, aggregate run-all.js PASS, and full node --test PASS 1248/1239/0/9. Full ledger/WIKI/HAT 3 verification is complete; Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT recorded. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-10T00:00:00Z; why: T10.3.2 implements Claude Code's accepted query-lints STOP after T10.3.1 commit/CI green; what: pure query-lints helper, visible metadata warning in wiki-query, RED-first lint tests, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 33 -> 34, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, WIKI entity, and mirror sync; verification: RED-first and targeted GREEN recorded, complete HAT 3 verification and Claude Code ACCEPT recorded via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.3.2-verdict.md; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 1 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat1-t10.3.2-verdict.md and HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.3.2-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no query-as-provenance path, no promotion writer, no schema change, no export/presentation/multi-domain behavior, and no claim/provenance writer; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-query-lints.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js |
| 026 | 2026-06-16 | 10.3 | FU-QUERY-MANIFEST-EXPIRY-BOUNDARY | W10.3-WIKI-QUERY-FRESHNESS-BOUNDARY | Wiki query compiled-manifest expiry boundary hardening | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/wiki-query.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/62-hat1-stop-fu-query-manifest-expiry-boundary-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/63-hat3-fu-query-manifest-expiry-boundary-closure-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | freshness-boundary hardening only; no schema/count/surface-index/export/presentation/provenance/claim/multi-domain behavior | RED expectation: pre-fix expiresAt < nowMs allows a manifest whose expiresAt equals query now; GREEN: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-query.test.js rejects expiresAt: TIMESTAMP through production runWikiQuery with E_PHASE10_QUERY_MANIFEST_STALE; phase10-wiki-query, validate-counts, check-phase10-ledger, run-all, WIKI audits, registry, lint, and mirror checks pass. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-16T00:00:00Z; why: close the half-open freshness boundary before Wave 10.4 export/presentation work builds on query freshness semantics; what: wiki-query now treats expiresAt <= now as stale and the regression test covers equality; verification: wiki-query test 10/10 PASS, validator/count/ledger/run-all PASS, WIKI checks PASS; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-fu-followups-verdict-2026-06-16.md; fallback subagent verdict C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\non-author-agent-hat3-fu-followups-verdict-2026-06-16.md is superseded; anti-dup verified: no query writer expansion, no export/presentation/multi-domain behavior, and no count change; tier-C: noop, off-by-one freshness hardening follow-up |
| 027 | 2026-06-16 | 10.3 | FU-WIKI-COVERAGE-LOCAL-ARTIFACT-SCOPE | W10.3-WIKI-COVERAGE-LOCAL-ARTIFACT-SCOPE | WIKI coverage local artifact exclusion repair | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/tools/generate-vre-coverage.mjs, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/coverage/*.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/coverage/*.jsonl, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/*.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/*.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/64-hat1-stop-fu-wiki-coverage-local-artifact-scope-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/65-hat3-fu-wiki-coverage-local-artifact-scope-closure-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | WIKI coverage tooling and generated private WIKI outputs only; no VRE runtime/export/MARP/presentation/provenance/claim/query/multi-domain behavior | RED: Claude Code HAT 3 found analysis/scripts/hgsoc_cd8_subset.py and root audit.config.yaml leaking into generated coverage/high-risk inventories after the first scope patch. GREEN: generate-vre-coverage.mjs excludes .tmp-vre-*, .tmp/, .vibe-science-environment/, analysis/, root audit.config.yaml, top-level audit/, and nested VRE vibe-science/ for directories and files; direct leak probe reports zero entries across file/api/callable/dependency/ownership/high-risk inventories; WIKI coverage/entity/schema/registry/lint/mirror checks pass. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-16T00:00:00Z; why: prevent WIKI audits from baking volatile local artifacts into live-source coverage before Wave 10.4 opens; what: private WIKI coverage generator and generated coverage outputs are repaired locally, and this VRE ledger row provides the pushed public trace because vibe-science/blueprints/private/ is intentionally gitignored in its host repo; verification: direct leak probe PASS, generate-vre-coverage --check PASS, entity export audit issueCount 0, schema field audit issueCount 0, registry check PASS, wiki-lint issueCount 0, mirror check changed 0; reviewer: Claude Code REDIRECT via C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-fu-followups-verdict-2026-06-16.md and Claude Code re-review ACCEPT via C:\Users\Test-User\.codex\relay\nuove_skill_phase10\turns\claude-hat3-fu-wiki-coverage-rereview-verdict-2026-06-16.md; anti-dup verified: no temp deletion, no runtime/export/MARP/presentation/multi-domain behavior, and live environment/audit/query.js, environment/phase10/wiki-query.js, and vibe-science/plugin/lib/ remain covered; tier-C: noop, WIKI audit hygiene follow-up |
| 028 | 2026-06-16 | 10.4 | T10.4.0 | W10.4-EXPORT-RECIPE-GUARD | Export recipe guard foundation | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/export-guard.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-export-guard.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-export-guard.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-export-guard.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/66-hat1-stop-t10-4-0-export-recipe-guard-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/67-hat3-t10-4-0-export-recipe-guard-closure-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | pre-render/pre-export guard helper and validator only; no vre domain export CLI, MARP renderer, presentation adapter, staleness checker, git-hook install, network publishing, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, schema edit, or multi-domain behavior | RED: export-guard test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before export-guard.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 34 -> 35 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3: export-guard tests 9/9 PASS, validator PASS, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:35, surface index regenerated to 69 surfaces, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, fail-closed trace probe PASS, run-all.js PASS, full node --test PASS, and WIKI checks PASS. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-16T00:00:00Z; why: T10.4.0 implements Claude Code's accepted export recipe guard STOP after pre-Wave-10.4 follow-ups landed with green CI; what: pure guard helper over export attempts, CI validator, count/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, export-guard ledger and WIKI trace; verification: RED-first and targeted/aggregate/WIKI GREEN recorded before HAT 3; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 1 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat1-t10.4.0-verdict.md and HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.4.0-verdict.md; carry-forward: operation:"export" equals public export is accepted as fail-closed for T10.4.0 and private-team/local-export semantics must be re-opened in T10.4.1 HAT 1 before adapters inherit the assumption; anti-dup verified: no CLI export, no MARP/presentation/staleness files, no signature infrastructure, no public artifact writer, no schema edit, no provenance/claim writer, and no multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-export-guard.md |
| 029 | 2026-06-16 | 10.4 | T10.4.1 | W10.4-MARP-PRESENTATION-ADAPTER | Local in-memory MARP presentation adapter | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/marp-export.js, environment/templates/marp/morning-digest.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/r2-verdict.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/synthesis-conference.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/synthesis-preprint.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/decision-support-query.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/contradiction-audit-query.marp.template.md, environment/templates/marp/hypothesis-discussion.marp.template.md, environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-export-guard.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-marp-export.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/68-hat1-stop-t10-4-1-marp-presentation-adapter-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/69-hat3-t10-4-1-marp-presentation-adapter-closure-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | in-memory MARP markdown/metadata only; no CLI, filesystem writer, MARP binary, PDF/HTML render, public/private/local export package, schema edit, presentation persistence, provenance writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, staleness checker, or multi-domain behavior | RED: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.test.js and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.js failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before environment/phase10/marp-export.js; validate-counts failed ciValidators 35 -> 36 before count update; aggregate RED found the T10.4.0 validator still forbidding marp-export.js, which is now an authorized T10.4.1 surface. GREEN: MARP adapter tests 10/10 PASS, validator PASS, export-guard validator PASS after minimal forbidden-path relaxation, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:36, surface index regenerated to 71 surfaces, checker fixture tests 25/25 PASS, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, fail-closed trace probe PASS, run-all.js PASS, full node --test PASS 1269/1260/0/9, WIKI checks PASS. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-16T00:00:00Z; why: T10.4.1 implements Claude Code's accepted in-memory MARP adapter STOP after T10.4.0 commit/CI green; what: pure helper, seven reviewed local template files with actual SHA-derived templateVersion, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 35 -> 36, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, export-guard ledger and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first, targeted, aggregate, full-test, WIKI, and fail-closed evidence recorded; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t1041-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no domain-export CLI, no presentation-staleness.js, no output writer, no MARP binary/PDF/HTML renderer, no schema edit, no provenance/claim writer, and no multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-marp-export.md; carry-forward: T10.4.1-OPEN-001 export packaging semantics deferred, T10.4.1-OPEN-002 presentation schema gap before persisted records |
| 030 | 2026-06-16 | 10.4 | T10.4.2 | W10.4-PRESENTATION-STALENESS-CHECKER | Read-only presentation staleness checker and D-006 schema alignment | package.json, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase10-vre-surface-index.json, environment/phase10/presentation-staleness.js, environment/schemas/phase10-presentation.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-presentation.schema.test.js, environment/schemas/phase10-marp-template.schema.json, environment/tests/schemas/phase10-marp-template.schema.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-presentation-staleness.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-presentation-staleness.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-export-guard.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-marp-export.test.js, environment/tests/ci/run-all.js, environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.js, environment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase10-presentation-staleness.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/70-hat1-stop-t10-4-2-presentation-staleness-checker-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/71-hat3-t10-4-2-presentation-staleness-checker-closure-2026-06-16.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-export-guard-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-schema-registry.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-implementation-log.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-file-change-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-change-trace-ledger.md, vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/phase10-maintenance-notes.md | read-only staleness validation over supplied record/current-state objects; existing presentation/template schemas extended in place for D-006 dependency SHA metadata; no writer, persistence, CLI export, export package, MARP binary/PDF/HTML render, provenance writer, claim writer, query execution, R2 authority, role migration, or multi-domain behavior | RED: staleness test and validator failed with ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND before presentation-staleness.js; schema tests failed with additional-property errors before D-006 schema extension; validate-counts failed ciValidators 36 -> 37 before count update. GREEN before HAT 3: targeted staleness tests 7/7, validator PASS, presentation/template schema tests 9/9, export-guard and MARP validators PASS after minimal forbidden-path narrowing, validate-counts PASS with ciValidators:37, surface index regenerated to 73 surfaces, Phase 9/10 ledger checks PASS, fail-closed trace probe PASS, run-all.js PASS, full node --test PASS 1280/1271/0/9, and WIKI checks PASS. | verified | who: codex; when: 2026-06-16T00:00:00Z; why: T10.4.2 implements Claude Code's accepted presentation-staleness STOP after T10.4.1 commit/CI green; what: pure read-only staleness helper, D-006 schema/test alignment, CI validator, count guard ciValidators 36 -> 37, package/run-all wiring, surface-index/checker coverage, export-guard ledger and WIKI entity; verification: RED-first and targeted GREEN recorded before HAT 3; reviewer: Claude Code HAT 1 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat1-t1042-verdict.md, HAT 3 ACCEPT via C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t1042-verdict.md; anti-dup verified: no presentation writer/persistence/export/renderer/provenance/claim/query/multi-domain behavior; tier-C: yes-with-page entities/phase10-presentation-staleness.md; out-of-scope pre-existing diffs: environment/phase10/domain-lifecycle.js, environment/tests/cli/domain-cli.test.js |
| 031 | 2026-06-24 | L4 | FU-TL4.3-PHASE10-LAW13-ADVERSARIAL-VERDICT-REFS | W10-LAW13-ADVERSARIAL-VERDICT-REF-GUARD | Phase10 LAW13 review-metadata typed-ref guard follow-up | phase10-vre-feature-ledger.md, phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md, environment/phase10/law13-bridge.js, environment/phase10/wiki-r2-audit.js, environment/phase10/law13-lint.js, environment/phase10/multi-domain-gate.js, environment/phase10/cross-domain-query.js, environment/phase10/cross-domain-merge.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-bridge.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-law13-lint.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-wiki-r2-audit.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-multi-domain-gate.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-query.test.js, environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.test.js, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase14-world-class-vre/202-hat1-stop-fu-tl4-3-phase10-law13-adversarial-verdict-refs-2026-06-24.md, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase14-world-class-vre/phase14-world-class-status-ledger.md, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase14-world-class-vre/phase14-world-class-changelog.md, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/current-status.md, ../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.json, C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase14/turns/claude-hat1-fu-tl4.3-phase10-law13-adversarial-verdict-refs-amended-verdict-2026-06-24.md | guard-only metadata-provenance rejection hardening; no producer, no new files, no schema/count movement, no provider/OBDK/reviewed-api/real-data/claim-export/Graphify/L5/CLI/unattended runtime | RED: six target regressions failed before the guard update: law13-bridge, law13-lint, wiki-r2-audit, multi-domain-gate, cross-domain-query, and cross-domain-merge accepted adversarial-verdict typed refs where existing relay/review metadata refs were already rejected. GREEN so far: target six-file suite PASS 83/83 after adding adversarial-verdict to existing relay/review metadata vocabularies. Full aggregate, ledger probes, WIKI checks, and HAT3 remain required before closure. | implemented | who: codex; when: 2026-06-24T00:00:00Z; why: closes Claude Code's TL4.3 HAT3 forward finding before any adversarial-verdict provenance-ref producer can exist; what: guard-only addition of adversarial-verdict to the six Phase10 LAW13 relay/review-metadata rejection chokepoints, with RED-first regressions in existing tests and local error semantics preserved; verification: target RED/GREEN recorded, aggregate pending; reviewer: Claude Code amended HAT1 ACCEPT via relay; anti-dup verified: no new producer, no TL4.3 helper change, no L2/L4/provider/OBDK/reviewed-api/real-data/claim-export/Graphify/L5/CLI/unattended runtime, no schema or count movement; tier-C: noop because this is provenance-safety hardening, not new scientific cognition. |
vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/59-hat3-t10-3-2-query-lints-closure-2026-06-10.md
vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-db-writers.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-schema-graph.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-gate-triggers.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-protocol-invariants.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-cli-verbs.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-db-writers.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-exported-symbols.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-schema-graph.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-gate-triggers.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-protocol-invariants.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-cli-verbs.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/log.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/closures/scheduled-gate-health-2026-06-15.md
vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/vre-control-io-js.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/vre-environment-orchestrator.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/registry-exported-symbols.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/vre-control-io-js.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/vre_wiki/entities/vre-environment-orchestrator.md
The same T10.0.1 patch also records HAT 2 completion and HAT 3 pending-review state in:
vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/00-index.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/phase10-implementation-plan/08-hat3-t10-0-1-closure-2026-06-07.mdvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/state/decision-gates.jsonvibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md
T10.5.0 adds a read-only multi-domain gate classifier. The positive result is only future HAT-task eligibility; it never grants authorization and never performs merge, synthesis, query, export, provenance, claim, lifecycle, CLI, or schema behavior.
Changed Phase 10 VRE paths:
package.jsonphase9-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-surface-index.jsonenvironment/phase10/multi-domain-gate.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-multi-domain-gate.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-multi-domain-gate.test.jsenvironment/tests/ci/run-all.jsenvironment/tests/ci/validate-counts.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js
Verification so far: RED-first module-missing failures and ciValidators
37 -> 38 mismatch were captured before production code/count update.
Target GREEN: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-multi-domain-gate.test.js
12/12 PASS, node environment/tests/ci/phase10-multi-domain-gate.js PASS,
node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS, checker fixture tests
27/27 PASS, and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js
regenerated 75 surfaces. Aggregate, fail-closed probe, WIKI checks, full
node --test, and Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT are complete via
C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.5.0-verdict.md.
T10.5.1 adds a read-only in-memory cross-domain merge/synthesis planner. The positive result is a local non-authoritative plan only: it is not persisted, not authoritative, grants no authorization, performs no operation, and writes nothing. The helper consumes the real T10.5.0 gate and cannot infer permission from schema presence, closeout documents, or multiple domain IDs.
Changed Phase 10 VRE paths:
package.jsonphase9-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-surface-index.jsonenvironment/phase10/cross-domain-merge.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.test.jsenvironment/tests/ci/run-all.jsenvironment/tests/ci/validate-counts.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js
Verification so far: RED-first module-missing failures and ciValidators
38 -> 39 mismatch were captured before production helper/count update.
Target GREEN: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.test.js
15/15 PASS, node environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.js PASS,
node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS, checker fixture tests
28/28 PASS, and node environment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.js
regenerated 77 surfaces. Aggregate, fail-closed probe, WIKI checks, full
node --test, and Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT are complete via
C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.5.1-verdict.md.
Anti-dup verified: no cross-domain query execution, query CLI, export packaging, MARP/presentation behavior, filesystem writers, schema edits, provenance-link writers, claim-ledger writers, claim-edge mutation, domain lifecycle mutation, Phase 12 runtime, role migration, source discovery, publication/network behavior, or automatic T10.5.2 opening.
T10.5.2 adds a read-only in-memory cross-domain query boundary/evaluator. The
positive result is local-only and non-authoritative: it is not persisted, does
not authorize a query, performs no operation, and writes nothing. The helper
consumes the T10.5.0 query gate and T10.5.1 merge/synthesis policy evidence;
it does not replace the single-domain wiki-query.js runner.
Changed Phase 10 VRE paths:
package.jsonphase9-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-feature-ledger.mdphase10-vre-surface-index.jsonenvironment/phase10/cross-domain-query.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.test.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-query.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-query.test.jsenvironment/tests/ci/run-all.jsenvironment/tests/ci/validate-counts.jsenvironment/tests/ci/phase10-surface-index.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.jsenvironment/tests/ci/check-phase10-ledger.test.js
Verification: RED-first module-missing failures and ciValidators
39 -> 40 mismatch were captured before production helper/count update.
GREEN handoff evidence: node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-query.test.js 15/15 PASS,
node environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-query.js PASS,
node --test environment/tests/ci/phase10-cross-domain-merge.test.js
15/15 PASS, node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js PASS, checker
fixture tests 29/29 PASS, check-phase10-ledger and check-phase9-ledger
PASS, fail-closed probe returns expected E_PHASE10_TRACE_MISSING,
node environment/tests/ci/run-all.js PASS, full node --test PASS
1325 total / 1316 pass / 0 fail / 9 skipped, WIKI checks PASS, and
decision-gates.json parses. Claude Code HAT 3 ACCEPT recorded via
C:/Users/Test-User/.codex/relay/nuove_skill_phase10/turns/claude-hat3-t10.5.2-verdict.md.
Self-found aggregate hardening: full node --test exposed the obsolete
T10.5.1 regression that required T10.5.2 files to remain absent. The test now
asserts the enduring boundary instead: T10.5.1 still rejects
operation: "query" and remains non-operational/non-authoritative after
T10.5.2 opens.
Anti-dup verified: no query runner, query-record writer, query markdown writer, cross-domain CLI, export profile/package, MARP/presentation behavior, filesystem writer, schema edit, provenance-link writer, claim-ledger writer, claim-edge mutation, domain lifecycle mutation, role migration, publication, or Wave 10.5 closeout behavior is opened by this task.