Skip to content

Commit b629483

Browse files
th3vib3coderclaude
th3vib3coder
and
claude
committed
phase9-wave5-t54-b1-seq114: append handshake events feature ledger row
Append seq 114 row for Wave 5 T5.4 sub-task B.1 (plugin-side handshake governance event emission). The companion vibe-science commit lands the actual event emission code (handshake_injected/handshake_degraded through logPhase9GovernanceEvent); this VRE-side row tracks the cross-repo evidence for the closure gate (22/22 phase9-handshake- injection, 43/43 test:phase9, 173 e2e + 342 phase8 + 43 phase9). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent dada5ba commit b629483

1 file changed

Lines changed: 1 addition & 0 deletions

File tree

‎phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -176,3 +176,4 @@ Companion files:
176176
| 111 | 2026-04-29 | 5 | W5-CLAIM-EDGE-SCHEMA | T5.2 sub-task A.1: `phase9.claim-edge.v1` schema lands with six frozen relations (`supports`, `contradicts`, `supersedes`, `depends_on`, `evolved_into`, `related_to`), required `{schemaVersion, edgeId, fromId, toId, relation, createdAt}`, optional `{confidence, sourceR2EventId, objectiveId}`. Plugin `CLAIM-*` namespace per D2.1. Confidence optional-only-if-producer per D2.2. Self-loop guard split: schema deliberately accepts self-loops (CF1 fix); A.2 consumer rejects with `E_CLAIM_EDGE_SELF_LOOP`. File 14 schemas-and-fixtures-index gains `phase9.claim-edge.v1` row this same patch, avoiding a phantom schema. Mantras VERBATIM: "il mantra del ledger aggiornato ogni passaggio però deve rimanere" + "non si inizia phase 10 senza aver terminato phase 9". | `environment/schemas/phase9-claim-edge.schema.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/valid-supports.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/valid-contradicts.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/valid-self-loop.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/invalid-unknown-relation.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/invalid-missing-from-id.json`, `environment/tests/fixtures/phase9/claim-edge/invalid-missing-to-id.json`, `environment/tests/schemas/phase9-claim-edge.schema.test.js`, `environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js`, `package.json`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase9-vre-autonomous-research-loop/14-schemas-and-fixtures-index.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase9-vre-autonomous-research-loop/16-implementation-status-ledger.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/phase9-claim-edge-schema.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/concepts/typed-edge-substrate.md` | none | RED verified before implementation: `node --test environment/tests/schemas/phase9-claim-edge.schema.test.js` failed 8/8 with `ENOENT ... environment\\schemas\\phase9-claim-edge.schema.json`. GREEN: `node --test environment/tests/schemas/phase9-claim-edge.schema.test.js` (8/8 pass); `npm run test:phase9` (380 pass, 0 fail, 5 skipped); `npm run validate` (13/13 validators OK). Pending pre-commit review evidence: `/lint-wiki` umbrella and explicit ledger checks after wiki sync. | verified | anti-dup verified: 6 inverse-index registries, WIKI entity pages, and VRE codebase searched for `createClaimEdge`, `claim-edge`, `EDGE-`, `phase9.claim-edge`, and `edges.jsonl`; no existing implementation found. Two wiki mentions were forward-looking Phase 10 notes, not an existing surface. R2 inline OK: schema is additive, no existing schema modified, no consumer code added. Confounder harness: N/A, non-quantitative. tier-C: yes-with-page `concepts/typed-edge-substrate.md`. Honest residual: A.1 alone does not enable edge writes; A.2 store landing is required before any runtime can append typed edges. |
177177
| 112 | 2026-04-29 | 5 | W5-CLAIM-EDGE-STORE | T5.2 sub-task A.2 lands the VRE-owned claim-edge store consumer. `environment/claims/edges.js` writes `.vibe-science-environment/claims/edges.jsonl` under the reviewed control-plane lock `claims-edges.jsonl`, validates `phase9.claim-edge.v1`, rejects self-loops with `E_CLAIM_EDGE_SELF_LOOP`, rejects unknown relations with `E_CLAIM_EDGE_RELATION_UNKNOWN`, defaults endpoint checks to fail-closed via `claimResolver`, returns duplicate identical payloads as `duplicate-no-op`, and fails conflicting tuple duplicates with the exact CL1 code `E_CLAIM_EDGE_DUPLICATE_CONFLICT`. The store is additive and has no downstream production emitter until D.1 seq 121. Mantras VERBATIM: "il mantra del ledger aggiornato ogni passaggio però deve rimanere" + "non si inizia phase 10 senza aver terminato phase 9". | `environment/claims/edges.js`, `environment/tests/control/claim-edges.test.js`, `environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-write-sandbox-allowlist.json`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-write-sandbox.js`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-surface-index.js`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-surface-index.test.js`, `phase9-vre-surface-index.json`, `package.json`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase9-vre-autonomous-research-loop/16-implementation-status-ledger.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/claims-edges-js.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/concepts/edge-store-idempotency.md` | none | RED verified before implementation: `node --test environment/tests/control/claim-edges.test.js` failed with `ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND` for `environment\\claims\\edges.js`. GREEN: `node --test environment/tests/control/claim-edges.test.js` (8/8 pass); targeted `node --test environment/tests/ci/phase9-write-sandbox.test.js environment/tests/ci/phase9-surface-index.test.js` (7/7 pass after `environment/claims/` became a reviewed write-sandbox prefix); `node environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js` (OK); `npm run test:phase9` (388 pass, 0 fail, 5 skipped); `npm run validate` (13/13 validators OK); `/lint-wiki` umbrella 10/10 PASS. | verified | anti-dup verified: HAT 1 searched the 6 inverse-index registries plus VRE codebase for `createClaimEdge`, `readClaimEdges`, `environment/claims/`, `edges.jsonl`, and `claims-edges.jsonl`; no existing consumer/store existed. R2 inline OK: store is lock-protected, additive, schema-backed, and does not touch kernel or existing production call-sites. Confounder harness: N/A, non-quantitative. tier-C: yes-with-page `concepts/edge-store-idempotency.md`. Honest residual: A.2 still does not emit production edges; D.1 seq 121 wires reviewer-2 `REJECT + claimId + contradictedClaimId` verdicts into this store. |
178178
| 113 | 2026-04-29 | 5 | W5-GOVERNANCE-BRIDGE | T5.3 sub-task B.0 (NEW per CF2) lands the VRE-to-plugin governance logger bridge. Plugin CLI `vibe-science/plugin/scripts/governance-log.js` reads stdin JSON, validates and writes through plugin-owned governance DB helpers, and emits `{ok,eventId,code}` with exit codes 0/1/2/3. VRE wrapper `environment/orchestrator/governance-logger.js` spawns `process.execPath` with the CLI path, defaults to a 5s timeout, resolves CLI path via `VIBE_SCIENCE_PLUGIN_CLI`, `VIBE_SCIENCE_PLUGIN_ROOT`, or sibling-repo fallback, and fails closed on timeout, nonzero exit, bad stdout, or missing CLI. Adds slash-form bridge source components to `KNOWN_GOVERNANCE_SOURCE_COMPONENTS`. Answers file 06 line 254-255 open question: plugin-owned CLI, not direct cross-repo DB write. Mantras VERBATIM: "il mantra del ledger aggiornato ogni passaggio però deve rimanere" + "non si inizia phase 10 senza aver terminato phase 9". | `../vibe-science/plugin/scripts/governance-log.js`, `../vibe-science/plugin/lib/phase9-governance-events.js`, `../vibe-science/tests/phase9-governance-log-cli.test.mjs`, `environment/orchestrator/governance-logger.js`, `environment/tests/orchestrator/governance-logger.test.js`, `environment/tests/ci/validate-counts.js`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-write-sandbox-allowlist.json`, `phase9-vre-surface-index.json`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-surface-index.js`, `environment/tests/ci/phase9-surface-index.test.js`, `../vibe-science/package.json`, `package.json`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase9-vre-autonomous-research-loop/16-implementation-status-ledger.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/governance-log-cli-js.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/governance-logger-js.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/concepts/cross-repo-governance-bridge.md` | none | RED verified before implementation per HAT 2 transcript: plugin test file failed 6/6 with CLI/vocabulary absent; VRE wrapper tests failed with missing `environment/orchestrator/governance-logger.js`. GREEN after HAT 3: `node --test tests/phase9-governance-log-cli.test.mjs` (6/6 pass); `node --test environment/tests/orchestrator/governance-logger.test.js` (5/5 pass); `npm run test:phase9` in `vibe-science` (36/36 pass); `npm run test:phase9` in `vibe-research-environment` (393 pass, 0 fail, 5 skipped); `npm run validate` in VRE (13 validators OK, including `check-phase9-ledger`); `npm test` in `vibe-science` (173 e2e + 342 phase8 + 36 phase9 pass); `/lint-wiki` umbrella 10/10 PASS after coverage, export inventories, registries, verified-at dashboard, and mirror sync. | verified | anti-dup verified via HAT 1 STOP: no existing VRE-to-plugin governance logger bridge; existing plugin validator and DB writer are reused. R2 inline accepted corrections baked in: existing subprocess pattern reuse, plugin `openAndInit` plus migrations, and six plugin-side tests including source-component vocabulary. Confounder harness: N/A, non-quantitative. tier-C: yes-with-page `concepts/cross-repo-governance-bridge.md`. Honest residual: B.0 alone does not emit production events; T5.5 must adopt this bridge at VRE-side governance call sites. |
179+
| 114 | 2026-04-29 | 5 | W5-GOVERNANCE-CAPABILITY-LOGGING | T5.4 sub-task B.1 lands plugin-side handshake governance event emission. `plugin/scripts/handshake-inject.js` now writes `handshake_injected` for full handshake injection and `handshake_degraded` for missing/degraded fallback paths through `logPhase9GovernanceEvent` directly, not through the T5.3 bridge. REDIRECT closure: `session-start.js` and `prompt-submit.js` pass their already-open DB handles into the handshake helper, `prompt-submit.js` applies migrations before threading its fresh DB handle so Phase 9 governance columns exist, and the telemetry-owned DB close path is wrapped fail-soft so close failures cannot affect handshake injection. Telemetry is fail-soft: DB/migration/validator/write/close failures are caught and reported to stderr without changing the original handshake digest or degraded fallback flow. Event details are sanitized (`handshake_id`, `capabilities_count`, or enum `reason`) and do not include env secrets or raw sensitive paths. Mantras VERBATIM: "il mantra del ledger aggiornato ogni passaggio però deve rimanere" + "non si inizia phase 10 senza aver terminato phase 9". | `../vibe-science/plugin/scripts/handshake-inject.js`, `../vibe-science/plugin/scripts/session-start.js`, `../vibe-science/plugin/scripts/prompt-submit.js`, `../vibe-science/tests/phase9-handshake-injection.test.mjs`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/phase9-vre-autonomous-research-loop/16-implementation-status-ledger.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/log.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/handshake-inject-js.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/prompt-submit-js.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/hook-prompt-submit.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-exported-symbols.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-protocol-invariants.md`, `../vibe-science/blueprints/private/WIKI_VRE/entities/registry-db-writers.md` | none | RED verified before implementation: `node --test tests/phase9-handshake-injection.test.mjs` failed only the two new emission assertions (`handshake_injected`, `handshake_degraded`), while the Phase 8 `claim_without_harness` regression already passed. REDIRECT RED verified: the same test file failed exactly two additional P1 regressions for missing existing-DB threading and non-fail-soft owned-DB close, then a second-pass RED failed exactly one `prompt-submit.js` DB-threading/order regression, and a third-pass RED failed exactly one fresh prompt-hook DB telemetry assertion with `0 !== 1` before migrations were applied. GREEN: `node --test tests/phase9-handshake-injection.test.mjs` (22/22 pass, including the three B.1 assertions plus four REDIRECT regressions); `npm run test:phase9` in `vibe-science` (43/43 pass); `npm test` in `vibe-science` (173 e2e + 342 phase8 + 43 phase9 pass); `/lint-wiki` umbrella 10/10 PASS; `node environment/tests/ci/check-phase9-ledger.js --changed-file=phase9-vre-feature-ledger.md` OK. | verified | anti-dup verified via HAT 1 STOP: no existing `handshake_injected` / `handshake_degraded` event emissions; existing `plugin/scripts/governance-log.js` from seq 113 is a generic bridge CLI, not a duplicate handshake call site. R2 inline accepted HAT 1; REDIRECT P1/P2s fixed surgically without touching `pre-tool-use.js` or the T5.1 event/source allowlists. Confounder harness: N/A, non-quantitative. tier-C: noop, event-emission wiring only; no new concept/synthesis page. Honest residual: B.2 seq 115 must handle nuclear-bash deny events and the pre-existing raw Phase 8 fork-event debt separately. |

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)