Add `attemptOption` to Alternative

[LukaJCB]

def attemptOption[A](fa: F[A]): F[Option[A]] =
  fa.map(_.some) <+> Option.empty[A].pure[F]

[ybasket]

@LukaJCB What use case(s) do you have in mind for that? Tried to find a good example for a doctest, but I can't come up with something "useful" - in fact, it has rather weird behaviour for some Alternative instances, for example List:

Alternative[List].attemptOption(Nil) // returns List(None)
Alternative[List].attemptOption(List(2)) // returns List(Some(2), None)

So it's pretty much fs2's noneTerminate on a List. Option itself seems also not very handy:

Alternative[Option].attemptOption(None) // returns Some(None)
Alternative[Option].attemptOption(Some(2)) // returns Some(Some(2))

I would see a use case for IO (equivalent to .attempt.map(_.toOption)), but as it has no Alternative instance, it doesn't matter here.

[LukaJCB]

If you're using mtl and have OptionT somewhere in your stack, this would allow you to materialize the option :)

E.g. something like ReaderT[OptionT[IO, ?], R, A]

[ybasket]

Maybe my head is a bit slow today - still can't figure out how you would use it. ReaderT[F, _, _] has an instance of Alternative iff F has and OptionT doesn't seem have any Alternative instance (only MonoidK). Can you maybe share a short code snippet that illustrates the use case?

[LukaJCB]

Oh that'd odd, I was sure OptionT had an Alternative instance 🤔

[rmehri01]

Hi, I can try to help with this. Does an Alternative instance need to be added for OptionT then?

[mehmeteking]

Is this issue still relevant?