Replies: 10 comments 88 replies
-
The following could be done:
This will technically work but I am not sure about the performance. Also, since the two halves form two different displays, they sync separately which will form a visible tearing on fast moving scenes in the middle of the screen (just like it was the case with early 4K displays). BetterDummy does not do this out of the box (the current public version has no streaming, the development version cannot stream to two view layers a single virtual display, as the need did not come up, but this can obviously be changed, it is a matter of coding only). |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
Anyway, I added a feature request for this: #200 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
macOS 12.3 has a new .mtdd override file ( /System/Library/Displays/Contents/Resources/Overrides/DisplayVendorID-10ac/DisplayProductID-4147.mtdd ) for the UP3218K. Does it work? You may need to remove any existing overrides you've created. It has two tiled modes. One for 48Hz and another for 60Hz. I suppose the 48Hz might be needed for 10bpc? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
Dell UP3218K might work 6K60 on MacPro7,1 running Ventura (brinlyau found some code in displaypolicyd that specifically mentions this display and the MacPro7,1). We don't know if it works yet. Currently working on a patch to remove the MacPro7,1 check. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
Got it working at 8k60 :) on Ventura with a patch to remove the check! I'll try clean up the hacky code we have and ideally not require OpenCore (maybe we can do a lldb based patch)! |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
https://www.startech.com/en-au/display-video-adapters/tb32dp14
Is this the cable that you think will make the Dell UP3218k work? (I highly
doubt it)
…On Mon, 20 Feb 2023 at 19:43, eledtech1234 ***@***.***> wrote:
@HansBouwmeester <https://github.com/HansBouwmeester> interesting, so in
theory the M2 Max can support Tiled Display Topology Data Block with
different video output port!? In the past separate video output ports on
Mac are not sync properly, there is always screen tearing after sometime
Can you try if it is sync properly without any tearing? e.g.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hIRq5HTh5s Would be great if you loop
something longer than 15 minutes (this is the usual out sync time on Intel
Macs)
in short: yes m2/m1 pro and max.
long version:
its not possible with 2 cables from 2 thunderbolt ports. you need a
thunderbold dual display port adapter which support 8k. for now only
startech works. we are on testing more adapters.
i am trying to make a list until end of the week which adapters work.
—
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#199 (reply in thread)>,
or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABECH2KQKUIKN4TQHSJKAT3WYMVE3ANCNFSM5JSHYVSA>
.
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID:
***@***.***>
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
My new Macbook Pro M4, Sequoia 15.2, did recognize the Dell UP3218K at 8K 60hz with two USB-c to DP 1.4 cables out of the box. So sharp, pure bliss! However, after two days it suddenly doesn't do so anymore. I woke it up from sleep and it was a mess at some resolution too low to remember. I fiddled, re-started, uninstalled SwitchResX, installed BetterMonitor instead, but to no avail. It does now run at 2160 x 3840 and I'm thoroughly frustrated. The cables I use are new, but not especially high quality. OTOH I don't know which cables would be high quality, and they didn't suffer any mechanical abuse. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
@rat10 - Intel Macs with AMD can go way higher in terms of framebuffer resolution than Apple Silicon Macs. Generally non-pro Apple Silicon Macs can go up to 3072px HiDPI (6144px) and pro Apple Silicon Macs up to 3840px HiDPI (7680px) horizontally. Neither of them will however go beyond the max native resolution for HiDPI (contrary to Intel Macs). With the latest M4 and M4 Pro the situation is more awkward however - they provide support for more external displays in certain configurations but this comes at a price of a much more stringent resource management. The system (based on the native resolution of the display) tries to figure out the probably max framebuffer size (both horizontally and now with M4 vertically) the user might need and allocate a limit based on that (in a very limiting manner) so if subsequent displays are connected, those should have the resources needed. Because of this M4 Macs (even Pro/Max variants) generally underperform in terms of any headroom available for higher HiDPI resolutions. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
All the modes you are looking at are scaled modes with active pixels 3840x2160 and pixel clock 533MHz (4K60). SwitchResX shows you which modes are scaled and you can view their timing info by double clicking the mode in the Current Resolutions list. There may be an EDID patch in the overrides file that removes the second extension block from the EDID. The second extension block contains the 8K30 single tile mode and also the Tiled Display Topology Data Block for the 8K60 dual tile mode. But the biggest problem is that there's only one DisplayPort connection for the Dell UP3218K display and it might not be a good connection:
(1) is the built in display of the Macbook Pro (16 inch, 2019) (Intel 8-Core i9, AMD Radeon Pro 5500M 8 GB). Sink OUI:000-016-250 is Apple, Inc. You have bad DisplayPort cables, or the display is broken. Do you have a different Mac to test? Different cables? You need DisplayPort 1.4 (HBR3) cables at least. Both DisplayPort cables need to be connected to separate Thunderbolt ports of the Mac. They cannot be connected to the same Thunderbolt adapter or hub or dock. The MacBook Pro has four Thunderbolt ports try each of them. I don't think the goal is to get 8K60 on your Intel Mac so I'm not going to ask you to install OCLP with my Lilu/WhateverGreen forks. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
The Dell UP3218K is the only 8k computer monitor on the market at the moment. Unfortunately, the only connectivity it offers is 2xDisplayPort 1.4 without DSC, with each cable comprising half of the screen (as a tiled display). Since MacOS doesn't properly support MST, that means the only option for connecting this monitor to MacOS is to use a single cable, which only allows for 8k@30hz, unless you were cool with running each half of the screen in mirrored mode (which is what you get when connecting both cables).
Does BetterDummy offer some way to work around this? There are numerous threads on MacRumors regarding this, but nobody seems to have a real solution to it.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions