Photon probes: initial updates on existing techniques#315
Photon probes: initial updates on existing techniques#315kara-mela wants to merge 2 commits intoExPaNDS-eu:masterfrom
Conversation
Motivation Currently, there is hardly any information given on photon probes, e.g. definition and links. Modification Added definitions and wikipedia links to the photon probes. Complemented altlabels and relationships. Result Information on photon probes further completed. Contributes to ExPaNDS-eu#312
terencetan-c
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Would it be better to define PaNET01005 - PaNET01015 as 'technique defined by a probe using.....'? Since these terms are techniques and not the probes themselves. Or is the distinction between the two meaningless?
Similarly for PaNET00100, it might be better to emphasise that it is referring to the technique that uses photons rather than the photons themselves. In contrast, the specifier classes would represent the actual probes like x-ray and photon, and the definitions might be more suited for the specifiers.
Also, would it be accurate to say THz photon is a subclass of IR photon? The Wikipedia link states that THz lies within the transition region between microwave and far infrared. Although I suppose PaN facilities don't operate at the microwave level as far as I know, so it might be correct in our context.
|
Good question. When we are touching these topics, I would like to do it properly. Therefore, I see two options
The source that I found for THz probes (might also be wikipedia) included THz into IR. It seems that I forgot to add this relationship. |
|
Yes, I agree. This ambiguity with the labels was actually one of the motivations for the new structure; the fact that the technique class labels implied the existence of the specifier classes, but the latter wasn't actually defined in PaNET. I think option 2 makes more sense since that makes clear the distinction between techniques and specifiers (like probes). |
Motivation Currently, the labels of (photon) probes and techniques are ambiguous. For instance, the term "IR photon probe" actually refers to the group of IR photon techniques (PaNET01005). The probe itself is represented by the specifier "IR photon" (PaNET2020002). This leads to confusion, especially when trying to provide proper definitions. Modification The photon probes have been renamed, e.g. to "IR photon probe technique". The definition now describes the technique and not the probe. Result Disambiguity resolved.
Motivation
Currently, there is hardly any information given on photon probes, e.g. definition and links.
Modification
Added definitions and wikipedia links to the photon probes. Complemented altlabels and relationships.
Result
Information on photon probes further completed.
Contributes to #312