Impact
The fix introduced in version 8.1.0 for GHSA-rh2x-ccvw-q7r3 (CVE-2024-21527) can be bypassed using mixed-case or uppercase URL schemes.
The default --chromium-deny-list value is ^file:(?!//\/tmp/).*. This regex is anchored to lowercase file: at the start. However, per RFC 3986 Section 3.1, URI schemes are case-insensitive. Chromium normalizes the scheme to lowercase before navigation, so a URL like FILE:///etc/passwd or File:///etc/passwd bypasses the deny-list check but still gets resolved by Chromium as file:///etc/passwd.
The root cause is in pkg/gotenberg/filter.go — the FilterDeadline function compiles the deny-list regex with regexp2.MustCompile(denied.String(), 0), where 0 means no flags (case-sensitive). Since the regex pattern itself doesn't include a (?i) flag, matching is strictly case-sensitive.
This affects both the URL endpoint and HTML conversion (via iframes, link tags, etc.).
Steps to Reproduce
- Start Gotenberg with default settings:
docker run --rm -p 3000:3000 gotenberg/gotenberg:8.26.0 gotenberg
- Read
/etc/passwd via the URL endpoint using an uppercase scheme:
curl -X POST 'http://localhost:3000/forms/chromium/convert/url' \
--form 'url=FILE:///etc/passwd' -o output.pdf
-
Open output.pdf — it contains the contents of /etc/passwd.
-
Alternatively, create an index.html:
<iframe src="FILE:///etc/passwd" width="100%" height="100%"></iframe>
Then convert it:
curl -X POST 'http://localhost:3000/forms/chromium/convert/html' \
-F 'files=@index.html' -o output.pdf
- The resulting PDF contains
/etc/passwd contents.
Mixed-case variants like File:, fILE:, fiLE: etc. all work as well.
Root Cause
pkg/modules/chromium/chromium.go defines the default deny-list as ^file:(?!//\/tmp/).*
pkg/gotenberg/filter.go compiles this with regexp2.MustCompile(denied.String(), 0) — flag 0 means case-sensitive
pkg/modules/chromium/events.go uses FilterDeadline to check intercepted request URLs against the deny-list
- Chromium normalizes URL schemes to lowercase, so
FILE:///etc/passwd becomes file:///etc/passwd after the deny-list check has already passed
Suggested Fix
Change the default deny-list regex to use a case-insensitive flag:
(?i)^file:(?!//\/tmp/).*
Or apply case-insensitive matching in FilterDeadline when compiling the regex.
Severity
This is effectively the same impact as CVE-2024-21527 — unauthenticated arbitrary file read from the Gotenberg container. An attacker can leak environment variables, configuration, credentials, and other sensitive data.
References
Impact
The fix introduced in version 8.1.0 for GHSA-rh2x-ccvw-q7r3 (CVE-2024-21527) can be bypassed using mixed-case or uppercase URL schemes.
The default
--chromium-deny-listvalue is^file:(?!//\/tmp/).*. This regex is anchored to lowercasefile:at the start. However, per RFC 3986 Section 3.1, URI schemes are case-insensitive. Chromium normalizes the scheme to lowercase before navigation, so a URL likeFILE:///etc/passwdorFile:///etc/passwdbypasses the deny-list check but still gets resolved by Chromium asfile:///etc/passwd.The root cause is in
pkg/gotenberg/filter.go— theFilterDeadlinefunction compiles the deny-list regex withregexp2.MustCompile(denied.String(), 0), where0means no flags (case-sensitive). Since the regex pattern itself doesn't include a(?i)flag, matching is strictly case-sensitive.This affects both the URL endpoint and HTML conversion (via iframes, link tags, etc.).
Steps to Reproduce
/etc/passwdvia the URL endpoint using an uppercase scheme:Open
output.pdf— it contains the contents of/etc/passwd.Alternatively, create an
index.html:Then convert it:
/etc/passwdcontents.Mixed-case variants like
File:,fILE:,fiLE:etc. all work as well.Root Cause
pkg/modules/chromium/chromium.godefines the default deny-list as^file:(?!//\/tmp/).*pkg/gotenberg/filter.gocompiles this withregexp2.MustCompile(denied.String(), 0)— flag0means case-sensitivepkg/modules/chromium/events.gousesFilterDeadlineto check intercepted request URLs against the deny-listFILE:///etc/passwdbecomesfile:///etc/passwdafter the deny-list check has already passedSuggested Fix
Change the default deny-list regex to use a case-insensitive flag:
Or apply case-insensitive matching in
FilterDeadlinewhen compiling the regex.Severity
This is effectively the same impact as CVE-2024-21527 — unauthenticated arbitrary file read from the Gotenberg container. An attacker can leak environment variables, configuration, credentials, and other sensitive data.
References