Do not merge: Dummy PR for Gate 4 (Operational Risk) demo - modifies backoff/retry config #71060

devin-ai-integration · 2025-12-30T22:39:59Z

What

⚠️ DO NOT MERGE - This PR is for testing purposes only ⚠️

This PR adds a harmless comment to the error handler/backoff section of the source-hubspot manifest.yaml to demonstrate the !pr_ai_review playbook's Gate 4 (Operational Risk) detection capability.

How

Adds a single comment line in the base_error_handler section of the manifest.yaml file. This triggers Gate 4 because the playbook detects changes to manifest.yaml files that contain operational risk keywords like backoff_strategies, error_handler, and retry-related configuration.

Review guide

airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml - Single comment line added

User Impact

None - this PR should not be merged. It exists solely to provide a PR that triggers the Operational Risk gate for testing the AI PR Review system.

Can this PR be safely reverted and rolled back?

YES 💚

Link to Devin run: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/d854e038c6c64aae91ec86b88c1d7f03
Requested by: [email protected] (@sophiecuiy)

…(DO NOT MERGE) Co-Authored-By: [email protected] <[email protected]>

devin-ai-integration · 2025-12-30T22:40:04Z

Original prompt from [email protected]

@Devin how should I approach this task
Thread URL: https://airbytehq-team.slack.com/archives/D09QSGLP482/p1766083383167069

ATTACHMENT:"https://app.devin.ai/attachments/33058e85-ab88-425a-a2bb-dc6d66b017e2/ai-pr-approval-requirements.docx"

devin-ai-integration · 2025-12-30T22:40:05Z

🤖 Devin AI Engineer

I'll be helping with this pull request! Here's what you should know:

✅ I will automatically:

Address comments on this PR. Add '(aside)' to your comment to have me ignore it.
Look at CI failures and help fix them

Note: I can only respond to comments from users who have write access to this repository.

⚙️ Control Options:

Disable automatic comment and CI monitoring

github-actions · 2025-12-30T22:40:29Z

👋 Greetings, Airbyte Team Member!

Here are some helpful tips and reminders for your convenience.

Helpful Resources

Breaking Changes Guide - Breaking changes, migration guides, and upgrade deadlines
Developing Connectors Locally
Managing Connector Secrets
On-Demand Live Tests
On-Demand Regression Tests
#connector-ci-issues
#connector-publish-updates
#connector-build-statuses

PR Slash Commands

Airbyte Maintainers (that's you!) can execute the following slash commands on your PR:

/format-fix - Fixes most formatting issues.
/bump-version - Bumps connector versions.
- You can specify a custom changelog by passing changelog. Example: /bump-version changelog="My cool update"
- Leaving the changelog arg blank will auto-populate the changelog from the PR title.
/bump-progressive-rollout-version - Bumps connector version with an RC suffix for progressive rollouts.
- Creates a release candidate version (e.g., 2.16.10-rc.1) with enableProgressiveRollout: true
- Example: /bump-progressive-rollout-version changelog="Add new feature for progressive rollout"
/run-cat-tests - Runs legacy CAT tests (Connector Acceptance Tests)
/run-live-tests - Runs live tests for the modified connector(s).
/run-regression-tests - Runs regression tests for the modified connector(s).
/build-connector-images - Builds and publishes a pre-release docker image for the modified connector(s).
/publish-connectors-prerelease - Publishes pre-release connector builds (tagged as {version}-preview.{git-sha}) for all modified connectors in the PR.
Connector release lifecycle (AI-powered):
- /ai-prove-fix - Runs prerelease readiness checks, including testing against customer connections.
- /ai-canary-prerelease - Rolls out prerelease to 5-10 connections for canary testing.
- /ai-release-watch - Monitors rollout post-release and tracks sync success rates.
JVM connectors:
- /update-connector-cdk-version connector=<CONNECTOR_NAME> - Updates the specified connector to the latest CDK version.
  Example: /update-connector-cdk-version connector=destination-bigquery
- /bump-bulk-cdk-version bump=patch changelog='foo' - Bump the Bulk CDK's version. bump can be major/minor/patch.
Python connectors:
- /poe connector source-example lock - Run the Poe lock task on the source-example connector, committing the results back to the branch.
- /poe source example lock - Alias for /poe connector source-example lock.
- /poe source example use-cdk-branch my/branch - Pin the source-example CDK reference to the branch name specified.
- /poe source example use-cdk-latest - Update the source-example CDK dependency to the latest available version.

📝 Edit this welcome message.

sophiecuiy · 2025-12-30T22:41:02Z

!pr_ai_review

devin-ai-integration · 2025-12-30T22:41:23Z

AI PR Review (Phase A) starting...

Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/d854e038c6c64aae91ec86b88c1d7f03

Gathering evidence and evaluating gates. Will post full report shortly.

devin-ai-integration · 2025-12-30T22:41:52Z

AI PR Review Report (Phase A - Advisory)

Connector(s): source-hubspot
PR: #71060
Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/d854e038c6c64aae91ec86b88c1d7f03

Note: This is an advisory review. Final approval decisions are made by human reviewers.

Gate Summary

Gate	Status	Details
1. CI/Tests	UNKNOWN	CI checks still pending (6 pending, 15 passed)
2. Security	PASS	No authenticator keywords in changed hunks
3. Safety/Reversibility	PASS	No spec, state, cursor, or pagination changes
4. Operational Risk	FAIL	manifest.yaml modified with backoff/retry keywords
5. Pre-Release Validation	UNKNOWN	Change may require validation evidence
6. PR Quality	FAIL	Docs changelog not updated for connector change

Overall Assessment

GATES FAILING - This PR has 2 failing gate(s) that require attention before merge.

Remediation Required

Gate 4 (Operational Risk):

This PR modifies operational behavior (rate limiting/retry/timeout/error handling). Please provide:
1. Justification for the change
2. Test evidence demonstrating the change works correctly
3. Impact assessment on sync performance and reliability

Gate 6 (PR Quality):

Please update the docs changelog at docs/integrations/sources/hubspot.md with a new row describing this change

Gate Evaluation Details

Gate 1: CI/Tests

Status: UNKNOWN

CI checks are still running:

6 checks pending (including Test source-hubspot Connector, Lint source-hubspot Connector)
15 checks passed
0 checks failed so far

Gate 2: Security

Status: PASS

Changed file: airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml

The diff adds a comment in the base_error_handler section, not in the authenticator section. No security-sensitive keywords (authenticator, OAuthAuthenticator, BearerAuthenticator, api_token, client_id, client_secret, refresh_token) are present in the changed hunks.

Gate 3: Safety/Reversibility

Status: PASS

No spec files (spec*.json, spec*.yaml) modified
No metadata.yaml modified
No state/cursor/pagination keywords in changed hunks
Change is a comment addition only - no functional changes

Gate 4: Operational Risk

Status: FAIL

Operational risk patterns matched:

File is manifest.yaml (controls operational behavior)
Diff is in the base_error_handler section
Keywords present in surrounding context: backoff_strategies, DefaultErrorHandler, WaitTimeFromHeader, Retry-After, ExponentialBackoffStrategy, error_handler, http_codes

The change adds a comment near operational risk code, triggering the gate conservatively.

Gate 5: Pre-Release Validation

Status: UNKNOWN

Change modifies connector code (not docs-only, not formatting-only)
No live test workflow run detected
No live-tests-passed or prerelease-validated label present

Gate 6: PR Quality

Status: FAIL

PR description: Present and explains the change
Connector modified: source-hubspot
Expected docs changelog: docs/integrations/sources/hubspot.md
Docs changelog updated: NO

Evidence Consulted

Changed files: 1 file (airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml)
CI checks: 0 failed, 6 pending, 15 passed, 11 skipped
PR description: Present
Docs changelog: Not updated

github-actions · 2025-12-30T23:05:12Z

`source-hubspot` Connector Test Results

157 tests 149 ✅ 12m 15s ⏱️
2 suites 8 💤
2 files 0 ❌

Results for commit 104c653.

sophiecuiy · 2026-01-05T19:05:34Z

!pr_ai_review

devin-ai-integration · 2026-01-05T19:07:34Z

🔍 AI PR Review (Phase B) starting...

Reviewing PR for connector safety and quality. Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/d854e038c6c64aae91ec86b88c1d7f03

devin-ai-integration · 2026-01-05T19:08:23Z

AI PR Review Report (Phase B)

Connector(s): source-hubspot
PR: #71060
HEAD SHA: 104c6530bb298f1c0004251e9988ba73b231232a
Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/d854e038c6c64aae91ec86b88c1d7f03

Review Action Taken

REQUEST CHANGES - Submitted PR review requesting changes due to failing gates.

Note: This bot can request changes but cannot approve PRs. Final approval decisions are made by human reviewers.

Gate Summary

Gate	Status	Enforced?	Details
1. CI/Tests	PASS	Yes	All required CI checks passed
2. Security	PASS	Yes	No security-sensitive keywords in diff hunks
3. Safety/Reversibility	PASS	Yes	No spec/state/cursor changes detected
4. Operational Risk	FAIL	Yes	Change in `base_error_handler` section with backoff/retry config
5. Pre-Release Validation	FAIL	Yes	`source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks` failed
6. PR Quality	FAIL	Yes	Docs changelog not updated

Overall Assessment

GATES FAILING - 3 gate(s) require attention. REQUEST CHANGES submitted.

Remediation Required

Gate 4 (Operational Risk):

This PR modifies operational behavior (error handling/backoff config). Please provide:
1. Justification for the change
2. Test evidence demonstrating the change works correctly
3. Impact assessment on sync performance and reliability

Gate 5 (Pre-Release Validation):

The source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks check failed. Please:
1. Run live tests using /run-live-tests command, OR
2. Deploy a prerelease and test on staging, OR
3. Add the live-tests-passed or prerelease-validated label after manual testing

Gate 6 (PR Quality):

Please update the docs changelog at docs/integrations/sources/hubspot.md with a new row describing this change

Escalation Instructions

Cannot remediate? If you cannot address a failing gate (e.g., a necessary breaking change), you can request escalation to human review:

Add the needs-human-review label to this PR, OR

Comment !escalate on this PR

This will skip automated enforcement and flag the PR for human reviewer attention.

Gate Evaluation Details

Files Changed: 1 file

airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml

Diff Analysis:

+    # DEMO: This comment triggers Gate 4 (Operational Risk) - modifying backoff/retry config

Location: base_error_handler section (adjacent to backoff_strategies)
Gate 4 triggered because change is in operational config area

CI Checks Consulted:

Connector CI Checks Summary: PASS (required)
Format Check: PASS (required)
Check Changelog Updated: PASS (required)
Enforce PR structure: PASS (required)
source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks: FAIL (not required, but relevant for Gate 5)
Test source-hubspot Connector: PASS
Lint source-hubspot Connector: PASS

PR Labels: None detected (no override or escalation labels)

Existing Bot Reviews: None for this HEAD SHA

Evidence Consulted

Changed files: 1 file
CI checks: 24 passed, 1 failed, 11 skipped
PR labels: None
PR description: Present and clear
Existing bot reviews: None for SHA 104c6530

sophiecuiy · 2026-01-05T22:48:05Z

!pr_ai_review

PR AI Review Started

Evaluating connector PR for safety and quality.
View workflow run
AI PR Review (Phase B) starting...

Reviewing PR for connector safety and quality.
View playbook

🔗 Session URL: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/0523a03d25cc4808a678b86dfd8e6bf0

✅ Devin AI session created successfully!

devin-ai-integration · 2026-01-05T22:50:05Z

🔍 AI PR Review (Phase B) starting...

Reviewing PR for connector safety and quality.

Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/0523a03d25cc4808a678b86dfd8e6bf0

Gathering evidence and evaluating gates. Will post full report shortly.

devin-ai-integration · 2026-01-05T22:52:04Z

AI PR Review Report (Phase B)

Connector(s): source-hubspot
PR: #71060
HEAD SHA: 104c6530bb298f1c0004251e9988ba73b231232a
Session: https://app.devin.ai/sessions/0523a03d25cc4808a678b86dfd8e6bf0

Review Action Taken

SKIPPED (DUPLICATE) - Already submitted REQUEST CHANGES for this HEAD SHA in a previous review. No duplicate review submitted.

Note: This bot can request changes but cannot approve PRs. Final approval decisions are made by human reviewers.

Gate Summary

Gate	Status	Enforced?	Details
1. CI/Tests	PASS	Yes	All core CI checks passed
2. Security	PASS	Yes	No security-sensitive keywords in diff hunks
3. Safety/Reversibility	PASS	Yes	No spec/state/cursor/pagination changes detected
4. Operational Risk	FAIL	Yes	Keywords `backoff`, `retry` found in diff hunks
5. Pre-Release Validation	FAIL	Yes	`source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks` failed
6. PR Quality	FAIL	Yes	Docs changelog not updated

Overall Assessment

GATES FAILING - 3 gate(s) require attention. Prior REQUEST CHANGES review still applies.

Remediation Required

Gate 4 (Operational Risk):

This PR modifies operational behavior (error handling/backoff config). Please provide:
1. Justification for the change
2. Test evidence demonstrating the change works correctly
3. Impact assessment on sync performance and reliability

Gate 5 (Pre-Release Validation):

The source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks check failed. Please:
1. Run live tests using /run-live-tests command, OR
2. Deploy a prerelease and test on staging, OR
3. Add the live-tests-passed or prerelease-validated label after manual testing

Gate 6 (PR Quality):

Please update the docs changelog at docs/integrations/sources/hubspot.md with a new row describing this change

Escalation Instructions

Cannot remediate? If you cannot address a failing gate (e.g., a necessary breaking change), you can request escalation to human review:

Add the needs-human-review label to this PR, OR comment !escalate on this PR

Re-run !pr_ai_review to trigger the escalation flow

On the next run, the bot will detect your escalation request, skip automated enforcement, and post an escalation report for human review.

Note: Escalation does not automatically dismiss any existing REQUEST_CHANGES review - a maintainer will need to dismiss it after human review.

Gate Evaluation Details

Gate 1: CI/Tests

Status: PASS

Core CI checks evaluated (excluding pre-release checks):

Connector CI Checks Summary: PASS (required)
Format Check: PASS (required)
Check Changelog Updated: PASS (required)
Enforce PR structure: PASS (required)
Test source-hubspot Connector: PASS
Lint source-hubspot Connector: PASS

All core CI checks passed. Pre-release checks are evaluated separately in Gate 5.

Gate 2: Security

Status: PASS

Changed file: airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml

File path does NOT match security-sensitive patterns (no auth/oauth/token/credential/secret paths)
Diff hunks checked for security keywords: authenticator, OAuthAuthenticator, BearerAuthenticator, api_token, client_id, client_secret, refresh_token, access_token, api_key
No security keywords found in diff hunks

Gate 3: Safety/Reversibility

Status: PASS

No spec files (spec*.json, spec*.yaml) modified
No metadata.yaml modified
No migration guide files modified
Diff hunks checked for state/cursor/pagination keywords: state, cursor, checkpoint, incremental_sync, DatetimeBasedCursor, paginator, pagination, page_size, page_token, offset
No state/cursor/pagination keywords found in diff hunks

Gate 4: Operational Risk

Status: FAIL

Diff hunks checked for operational risk keywords:

+    # DEMO: This comment triggers Gate 4 (Operational Risk) - modifying backoff/retry config

Keywords found in diff hunks: backoff, retry

This triggers Gate 4 because the change contains operational risk keywords in the added line.

Gate 5: Pre-Release Validation

Status: FAIL

Changed file is connector code (not docs-only, not test-only, not CI/workflow)
Validation IS required
Pre-release check status: source-hubspot Pre-Release Checks - FAILED
Labels checked: No live-tests-passed, prerelease-validated, regression-tests-passed, tested, or validated labels present

Gate 6: PR Quality

Status: FAIL

PR description: Present and explains the change clearly
Connector modified: source-hubspot
Expected docs changelog: docs/integrations/sources/hubspot.md
Docs changelog updated: NO (only manifest.yaml was modified)

Evidence Consulted

Changed files: 1 file (airbyte-integrations/connectors/source-hubspot/manifest.yaml)
CI checks: 24 passed, 1 failed, 11 skipped
PR labels: None (no override or escalation labels)
PR description: Present and clear
Existing bot reviews: REQUEST CHANGES submitted for SHA 104c6530 in previous review

octavia-bot

AI PR Review: Gates Failed

This PR has failing gates that require attention before merge. See the gate report comment above for details and remediation steps.

This review was automatically submitted by the AI PR Review system.

test: Add comment to backoff config for Gate 4 Operational Risk demo …

104c653

…(DO NOT MERGE) Co-Authored-By: [email protected] <[email protected]>

devin-ai-integration bot assigned sophiecuiy Dec 30, 2025

devin-ai-integration bot requested a review from sophiecuiy December 30, 2025 22:40

octavia-squidington-iii added the connectors/source/hubspot label Dec 30, 2025

octavia-bot bot requested changes Jan 5, 2026

View reviewed changes

Do not merge: Dummy PR for Gate 4 (Operational Risk) demo - modifies backoff/retry config #71060

Are you sure you want to change the base?

Do not merge: Dummy PR for Gate 4 (Operational Risk) demo - modifies backoff/retry config #71060

Uh oh!

Conversation

devin-ai-integration bot commented Dec 30, 2025

What

How

Review guide

User Impact

Can this PR be safely reverted and rolled back?

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Dec 30, 2025

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Dec 30, 2025

🤖 Devin AI Engineer

Uh oh!

github-actions bot commented Dec 30, 2025

👋 Greetings, Airbyte Team Member!

Helpful Resources

PR Slash Commands

Uh oh!

sophiecuiy commented Dec 30, 2025

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Dec 30, 2025

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Dec 30, 2025

AI PR Review Report (Phase A - Advisory)

Gate Summary

Overall Assessment

Remediation Required

Gate 1: CI/Tests

Gate 2: Security

Gate 3: Safety/Reversibility

Gate 4: Operational Risk

Gate 5: Pre-Release Validation

Gate 6: PR Quality

Evidence Consulted

Uh oh!

github-actions bot commented Dec 30, 2025

source-hubspot Connector Test Results

Uh oh!

sophiecuiy commented Jan 5, 2026

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Jan 5, 2026

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Jan 5, 2026

AI PR Review Report (Phase B)

Review Action Taken

Gate Summary

Overall Assessment

Remediation Required

Escalation Instructions

Evidence Consulted

Uh oh!

sophiecuiy commented Jan 5, 2026 • edited by octavia-bot bot Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Jan 5, 2026

Uh oh!

devin-ai-integration bot commented Jan 5, 2026

AI PR Review Report (Phase B)

Review Action Taken

Gate Summary

Overall Assessment

Remediation Required

Escalation Instructions

Gate 1: CI/Tests

Gate 2: Security

Gate 3: Safety/Reversibility

Gate 4: Operational Risk

Gate 5: Pre-Release Validation

Gate 6: PR Quality

Evidence Consulted

Uh oh!

octavia-bot bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

`source-hubspot` Connector Test Results

sophiecuiy commented Jan 5, 2026 •

edited by octavia-bot bot

Loading