[PDE-3] Refactor: adding TUI & other upgrades

[clduab11]

This pull request introduces major backend infrastructure for the Gemini Flow project, including a new Dockerfile for deployment, robust API controllers for workflows and store state, and essential middleware for authentication, error handling, and rate limiting. It also documents the successful completion of the "Super Terminal" sprint with a detailed status report. The most important changes are grouped below:

Backend Infrastructure and API Implementation

• Added a production-ready Dockerfile for the backend, including dependency installation, health checks, and server startup configuration.
• Implemented comprehensive API controllers: WorkflowController.js for workflow CRUD operations and import/export, and StoreController.js for state management and real-time sync, both integrating with WebSocket broadcasting for live updates. [1] [2]

Middleware and Security

• Introduced authentication middleware (auth.js) providing API key-based access control, supporting both required and optional modes for endpoints.
• Added global error handling middleware (errorHandler.js) for consistent API responses and an async handler utility for Express routes.
• Implemented in-memory rate limiting middleware (rateLimit.js) to prevent API abuse, with configurable limits and response headers.

Dependency Management

• Added the ws (WebSocket) package to backend/package.json to support real-time features.

Documentation and Sprint Completion

• Added a detailed SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md documenting sprint achievements, architecture, testing, and next steps, confirming all success criteria have been met.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Review skipped

Review was skipped as selected files did not have any reviewable changes.

💤 Files selected but had no reviewable changes (1)

• scripts/sync-issues-to-project.sh

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

Note

Other AI code review bot(s) detected

CodeRabbit has detected other AI code review bot(s) in this pull request and will avoid duplicating their findings in the review comments. This may lead to a less comprehensive review.

Summary by CodeRabbit

• New Features

  • Real-time WebSocket synchronization between terminal UI and frontend
  • Google AI services integration (video, image, TTS, music, research, browser automation)
  • Advanced agent swarm management with protocol integration
  • REST API for workflow and store management
  • Docker deployment support with compose configuration

• Infrastructure

  • Backend API with persistent data storage
  • Terminal UI components with command input, metrics display, and output panels
  • Automated setup and deployment scripts

• Documentation

  • Comprehensive architecture and integration guides
  • Getting started and deployment instructions
  • GitHub Projects workflow setup for team collaboration

Walkthrough

Adds a full backend (file-based DB, REST API, WebSocket service), frontend WebSocket client/hooks, Docker deployment and setup scripts, extensive TUI enhancements (streaming Google AI integration, swarm/A2A support, metrics/output panels), validators/middleware, and comprehensive documentation and sprint reports.

Changes

Cohort / File(s)	Summary
Super Terminal AI & Swarm Handlers src/cli/super-terminal/handlers/google-ai-handler.ts, src/cli/super-terminal/handlers/swarm-handler.ts	New GoogleAIHandler (7 services, streaming events, lazy-load) and SwarmHandler (A2A integration, status/broadcast/topology commands, ASCII topology).
TUI Router & Components src/cli/super-terminal/command-router.ts, src/cli/super-terminal/components/CommandInput.tsx, src/cli/super-terminal/components/MetricsPanel.tsx, src/cli/super-terminal/components/OutputPanel.tsx, src/cli/super-terminal/index.tsx	New CommandRouter (streamingOutput in CommandResult), command parsing & help, and Ink UI components: CommandInput (autocomplete/history/reverse-search), MetricsPanel, OutputPanel; UI updated to render streamingOutput.
Backend DB & Persistence backend/src/db/database.js	New file-based JSON DB with workflows, store-state, sessions, initialization, CRUD and health diagnostics.
Backend Models backend/src/api/models/Workflow.js, backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js	Workflow and StoreState model utilities: creation, validation, sanitization.
Backend Services backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js, backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js	WorkflowService (CRUD, import/export, stats) and StoreService (state updates, nodes/edges ops, syncWorkflowToStore) with callback hooks.
Controllers & Routes backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js, backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js, backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js, backend/src/api/routes/store.js	New controllers wiring services to HTTP endpoints and routers for workflows and store sync (with validation, broadcasting via WebSocket).
Middleware backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js, backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js, backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js, backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js	API key auth (require/optional), standardized error responses/asyncHandler, in-memory rate limiter (100/min), and request validators for workflows/nodes/edges.
WebSocket Subsystem & Server backend/src/websocket/server.js, backend/src/websocket/types.js, backend/src/server.js	WebSocketService singleton (client lifecycle, heartbeat, broadcasts), event types/helpers, and server upgrade: DB init, WS wiring, health endpoints, graceful startup/shutdown.
Frontend WebSocket Client & Hooks frontend/src/lib/websocket.ts, frontend/src/hooks/useWebSocket.ts	WebSocketClient with reconnect/backoff, per-type handlers, heartbeat; hooks: useWebSocketSync/useWebSocketStatus/useWebSocketSend/useWebSocketMessage to update Zustand store.
Docker & Deployment docker-compose.yml, backend/Dockerfile, frontend/Dockerfile, frontend/nginx.conf, scripts/setup.sh	Compose for dev (backend/frontend, volume, env), backend/frontend Dockerfiles (multi-stage/healthchecks), Nginx SPA config, and setup script to bootstrap dev env and env files.
Backend Dependencies & WebSocket Lib backend/package.json	Adds ws dependency.
CLI Scripts & Package package.json, scripts/*	New npm scripts (super-terminal, st) and dev helper scripts generated by setup.
Tests test-sprint2.js	New Sprint 2 test suite covering Google AI streaming and swarm features.
Docs & Sprint Reports SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md, SPRINT2_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT3_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT4_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT5_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT6_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT7_COMPLETION.md, docs/SPRINT8_COMPLETION.md, docs/ARCHITECTURE_OVERVIEW.md, docs/GETTING_STARTED.md, docs/WORKFLOW_FORMAT.md, docs/SYNC_ARCHITECTURE.md, docs/TUI_GUIDE.md, docs/*	Extensive documentation: sprint completion reports, architecture, getting started, workflow format, sync architecture, TUI guide, triage/setup docs and project setup guides.

Sequence Diagram(s)

sequenceDiagram
    participant User as User (CLI)
    participant CR as CommandRouter
    participant GAH as GoogleAIHandler
    participant UI as OutputPanel

    rect rgb(200,220,255)
      Note over User,UI: Event-driven streaming output (TUI)
    end

    User->>CR: route("google-ai ...")
    activate CR
    CR->>GAH: startExecution()
    activate GAH
    GAH-->>CR: "progress" events (chunks)
    loop streaming
      CR->>CR: append to streamingOutput[]
      CR->>UI: update display
    end
    GAH-->>CR: "complete"
    CR->>User: CommandResult { output, streamingOutput }
    deactivate GAH
    deactivate CR

Loading

sequenceDiagram
    participant FE as Frontend (React)
    participant WS as WebSocket Client
    participant BE as Backend (WS Server)
    participant DB as File DB

    rect rgb(200,220,255)
      Note over FE,DB: Real-time store sync (bidirectional)
    end

    FE->>WS: connect()
    WS->>BE: handshake
    BE->>WS: assign clientId, heartbeat
    FE->>WS: send("WORKFLOW_UPDATED", {nodes})
    WS->>BE: message
    BE->>DB: updateStoreState()
    BE->>WS: broadcast("WORKFLOW_UPDATED")
    WS->>FE: message
    FE->>FE: update Zustand store

Loading

Estimated code review effort

🎯 4 (Complex) | ⏱️ ~75 minutes

Key areas needing focused review:

• backend/src/websocket/server.js — heartbeat, client lifecycle, broadcast edge cases.
• backend/src/db/database.js — file I/O concurrency, atomic writes, error handling.
• backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js & controllers — bidirectional sync semantics, callback usage.
• frontend/src/lib/websocket.ts & frontend/src/hooks/useWebSocket.ts — reconnect/backoff, handler isolation, StrictMode-safe init.
• src/cli/super-terminal/handlers/google-ai-handler.ts — streaming event correctness and graceful degradation when lazy-loaded dependencies/A2A are missing.

Possibly related PRs

• chore: Comprehensive security audit and repository maintenance #25 — touches A2A protocol implementation used by SwarmHandler; likely affects compatibility and integration surface.

Suggested labels

bug

Poem

🌩️ Streams and sockets hum in tune,
From CLI prompt to backend rune,
Docker sails and docs attune,
Sprint‑by‑sprint, the system blooms — half‑code, half‑moon. 🎉

Pre-merge checks and finishing touches

❌ Failed checks (1 inconclusive)

Check name	Status	Explanation	Resolution
Title check	❓ Inconclusive	The title refers to TUI and upgrades but the changeset is predominantly backend infrastructure (API controllers, middleware, database layer, Docker, WebSocket) with extensive documentation. Frontend TUI components exist but are secondary.	Consider a more specific title such as 'feat: Add backend API infrastructure with controllers, middleware, and Docker deployment' to better reflect the scope.

✅ Passed checks (2 passed)

Check name	Status	Explanation
Description check	✅ Passed	The description accurately covers the main additions: backend infrastructure, API controllers, middleware, dependencies, and documentation. It aligns well with the changeset.
Docstring Coverage	✅ Passed	Docstring coverage is 82.54% which is sufficient. The required threshold is 80.00%.

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands and usage tips.}

[Copilot]

Pull Request Overview

This pull request introduces comprehensive backend infrastructure and documentation for the Gemini Flow project, focusing on production-ready API implementation, developer experience tooling, and system integration. The changes span multiple sprints (3-8) and establish a complete development environment with automated setup, Docker deployment, real-time synchronization capabilities, and extensive documentation.

Key Changes:

• Complete backend API with REST endpoints and WebSocket server for real-time workflow synchronization
• Automated development environment setup via shell scripts
• Docker containerization for both backend and frontend services
• Comprehensive documentation covering sprints 3-8, architecture, workflow formats, and getting started guides
• Frontend WebSocket integration with React hooks for real-time state synchronization

Reviewed Changes

Copilot reviewed 42 out of 98 changed files in this pull request and generated no comments.

Show a summary per file

File	Description
backend/src/websocket/server.js	WebSocket server implementation with heartbeat, client management, and event broadcasting
backend/src/websocket/types.js	WebSocket event type definitions and message formatting utilities
backend/src/server.js	Updated server with HTTP/WebSocket support, database initialization, and enhanced health checks
backend/src/db/database.js	File-based JSON database layer for workflows, store state, and sessions
backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js	RESTful workflow CRUD endpoints with middleware integration
backend/src/api/routes/store.js	Store synchronization endpoints for nodes, edges, and state management
backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js	Store state data model with validation and sanitization
backend/package.json	Added WebSocket dependency
frontend/src/lib/websocket.ts	WebSocket client with reconnection, heartbeat, and event subscription
frontend/src/hooks/useWebSocket.ts	React hooks for WebSocket integration with Zustand store
scripts/setup.sh	Automated setup script for development environment
docker-compose.yml	Docker orchestration for backend and frontend services
frontend/Dockerfile	Multi-stage frontend build with nginx
frontend/nginx.conf	Nginx configuration for SPA routing and security headers
docs/*	Sprint completion reports (3-8), architecture overview, workflow format spec, sync architecture, TUI guide, getting started guide

---

💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.

[github-actions]

Global Install Test Results

Global Install Test Summary

Date: Mon Oct 27 23:21:29 UTC 2025
Workflow: Global Install Testing
Run ID: 18858807165

Job Results

• Quick Validation: failure
• Cross-Platform Test: skipped
• NPM Registry Test: skipped

Next Steps

✅ All tests passed. Package is ready for global installation.

[gemini-code-assist]

Summary of Changes

Hello @clduab11, I'm Gemini Code Assist¹! I'm currently reviewing this pull request and will post my feedback shortly. In the meantime, here's a summary to help you and other reviewers quickly get up to speed!

This pull request significantly enhances the Gemini Flow project by introducing a robust backend API and real-time WebSocket infrastructure, alongside major upgrades to the Super Terminal's user interface and underlying Google AI service integrations. It also streamlines the development and deployment process through Dockerization and provides comprehensive documentation across multiple sprints, culminating in a fully integrated and production-ready system.

Highlights

• Backend API Implementation: Introduced a comprehensive backend API with dedicated controllers for workflow CRUD operations (create, read, update, delete, import, export) and store state management (nodes, edges, and full state updates). These controllers integrate with WebSocket broadcasting for real-time updates to connected clients.
• Robust Middleware & Security: Implemented essential middleware for API key-based authentication, global error handling with a standardized response format, and in-memory rate limiting to prevent API abuse. Request validation middleware was also added for workflow IDs, data, nodes, and edges.
• Real-time WebSocket Server: A new WebSocket server was added to enable real-time bidirectional synchronization. It supports connection management, heartbeat/ping-pong for health checks, and broadcasts events for workflow and store state changes to all connected clients.
• TUI & Google AI Services Refactor: The Super Terminal TUI received significant upgrades, including a refactored command router, enhanced metrics panel with ASCII visualizations, and a sophisticated command input supporting history, autocomplete, and reverse search. Core Google AI services (Imagen4, Veo3, Streaming API) were also refactored with dedicated clients, authentication, configuration, and error handling managers.
• Dockerized Deployment: Added a production-ready Dockerfile for the backend, including dependency installation, health checks, and server startup configuration. A docker-compose.yml file was also introduced to orchestrate the deployment of both the backend and frontend services, simplifying local development and deployment.
• Comprehensive Documentation: Extensive documentation was added or updated, including detailed completion reports for Sprints 2 through 8, an Architecture Overview, a Getting Started guide, a TUI User Guide, and a Workflow Format Specification. These documents provide deep insights into the system's design, usage, and development.

Using Gemini Code Assist

The full guide for Gemini Code Assist can be found on our documentation page, here are some quick tips.

Invoking Gemini

You can request assistance from Gemini at any point by creating a comment using either /gemini <command> or @gemini-code-assist <command>. Below is a summary of the supported commands on the current page.

Feature	Command	Description
Code Review	/gemini review	Performs a code review for the current pull request in its current state.
Pull Request Summary	/gemini summary	Provides a summary of the current pull request in its current state.
Comment	@gemini-code-assist	Responds in comments when explicitly tagged, both in pull request comments and review comments.
Help	/gemini help	Displays a list of available commands.

Customization

To customize Gemini Code Assist for GitHub experience, repository maintainers can create a configuration file and/or provide a custom code review style guide (such as PEP-8 for Python) by creating and adding files to a .gemini/ folder in the base of the repository. Detailed instructions can be found here.

Limitations & Feedback

Gemini Code Assist may make mistakes. Please leave feedback on any instances where its feedback is incorrect or counter productive. You can react with 👍 and 👎 on @gemini-code-assist comments. If you're interested in giving your feedback about your experience with Gemini Code Assist for Github and other Google products, sign up here.

You can also get AI-powered code generation, chat, as well as code reviews directly in the IDE at no cost with the Gemini Code Assist IDE Extension.

Footnotes

1. Review the Privacy Notices, Generative AI Prohibited Use Policy, Terms of Service, and learn how to configure Gemini Code Assist in GitHub here. Gemini can make mistakes, so double check it and use code with caution. ↩

[github-actions]

Global Install Test Results

Global Install Test Summary

Date: Mon Oct 27 23:22:38 UTC 2025
Workflow: Global Install Testing
Run ID: 18858833355

Job Results

• Quick Validation: failure
• Cross-Platform Test: skipped
• NPM Registry Test: skipped

Next Steps

✅ All tests passed. Package is ready for global installation.

[chatgpt-codex-connector]

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

• Open a pull request for review
• Mark a draft as ready
• Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

[gemini-code-assist]

Code Review

This pull request is a significant and impressive addition, establishing a comprehensive backend infrastructure with API controllers, middleware, WebSocket support, and Docker deployment. The code is well-structured, following modern JavaScript practices with clear separation of concerns. My review focuses on improving security, robustness, and consistency. Key areas for improvement include addressing a race condition in the file-based database, fixing a timing attack vulnerability in the API key authentication, and ensuring consistent error handling across the API. I've also noted potential issues with rate limiting behind a proxy and a misconfiguration in the Docker Compose file.

[clduab11]

@coderabbitai , review and analyze the totality of the changes in this PR utilizing the below helpful summary from Copilot regarding the PR's changes.

This pull request implements a major backend API expansion and infrastructure improvements for the Gemini Flow project, focusing on robust workflow and store management, real-time updates via WebSockets, security, and operational readiness. It introduces new controllers for workflow and store operations, centralized error and rate limiting middleware, API key authentication, and a production-ready Dockerfile. Additionally, it documents the successful completion of the Super Terminal sprint.

Backend API and Infrastructure Enhancements:

Workflow and Store API Implementation:

• Added WorkflowController.js and StoreController.js to handle all CRUD and sync operations for workflows and store state, including endpoints for importing/exporting workflows, and broadcasting updates via WebSockets. [1] [2]

Middleware Improvements:

• Introduced centralized error handling with consistent API response formats in errorHandler.js, including async handler wrappers.
• Added API key authentication middleware (auth.js) for secure access, with both strict and optional variants.
• Implemented simple in-memory rate limiting middleware to prevent API abuse, with configurable limits and response headers.

Operational and Deployment Updates:

• Created a new backend/Dockerfile for production deployment, including health checks and optimized dependency installation.
• Added the ws package to backend dependencies for WebSocket support.

Documentation:

Super Terminal Sprint Completion:

• Added a comprehensive sprint completion report (SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md) summarizing all implemented features, architecture, tests, and usage instructions for the Super Terminal infrastructure.

[coderabbitai]

Tip

For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes.

🧩 Analysis chain

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Fetch PR details and list of changed files
gh pr view 66 --json title,body,files,additions,deletions --jq '{title, body, additions, deletions, files: [.files[] | {path, additions, deletions}]}'

Length of output: 9800

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read all the new/modified files mentioned in the PR
echo "=== backend/Dockerfile ==="
cat backend/Dockerfile

echo -e "\n=== backend/package.json ==="
cat backend/package.json

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/controllers/WorkflowController.js ==="
cat backend/src/controllers/WorkflowController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/controllers/StoreController.js ==="
cat backend/src/controllers/StoreController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/auth.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/auth.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/errorHandler.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/errorHandler.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/rateLimit.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/rateLimit.js

echo -e "\n=== SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md ==="
cat SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md

Length of output: 9022

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Check the backend server.js to understand how these controllers and middleware are integrated
if [ -f backend/src/server.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/server.js ==="
  cat backend/src/server.js
elif [ -f backend/server.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/server.js ==="
  cat backend/server.js
fi

Length of output: 3929

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Check for routes files that might use these controllers
fd -e js -p "routes" backend/

Length of output: 67

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read routes files if they exist
if [ -f backend/src/routes/workflows.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/routes/workflows.js ==="
  cat backend/src/routes/workflows.js
fi

if [ -f backend/src/routes/store.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/routes/store.js ==="
  cat backend/src/routes/store.js
fi

Length of output: 0

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the API controllers, middleware, and routes with correct paths
echo "=== backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js

Length of output: 18732

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the routes files
echo "=== backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/routes/store.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/routes/store.js

Length of output: 3601

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the services layer
echo "=== backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js

Length of output: 18212

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the models
echo "=== backend/src/api/models/Workflow.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/models/Workflow.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js

Length of output: 9244

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the database and WebSocket server
echo "=== backend/src/db/database.js ==="
cat backend/src/db/database.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/websocket/server.js ==="
cat backend/src/websocket/server.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/websocket/types.js ==="
cat backend/src/websocket/types.js

Length of output: 15835

---

@clduab11, I've completed a comprehensive analysis of PR #66. This is an impressive infrastructure implementation with a solid layered architecture. Here's my detailed review:

🎯 Overall Assessment

Strengths: Excellent separation of concerns, comprehensive API coverage, real-time WebSocket integration, and thorough documentation. The architecture is production-ready with proper error handling and validation layers.

Critical Items: Security hardening needed, database concurrency handling, and WebSocket authentication.

---

🏗️ Architecture Review

✅ Excellent Layered Design

The Controllers → Services → Database pattern is well-implemented:

Routes (validation, auth, rate limiting)
  ↓
Controllers (HTTP request handling, WebSocket callbacks)
  ↓
Services (business logic, validation, sanitization)
  ↓
Database (file-based JSON storage)

Highlights:

• Clean separation between HTTP concerns and business logic
• Reusable asyncHandler wrapper prevents try-catch boilerplate
• Consistent API response format across all endpoints
• Proper use of callbacks for WebSocket broadcasting

⚠️ Concurrency Concern - Database Layer

Issue: The file-based JSON database lacks atomic operations. Multiple concurrent writes could cause race conditions:

// In database.js - not atomic
export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const workflows = await getAllWorkflows(); // Read
  const index = workflows.findIndex(w => w.metadata?.id === id);
  workflows[index] = { ...workflows[index], ...updates }; // Modify
  await fs.writeFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, JSON.stringify({ workflows }, null, 2)); // Write
  return workflows[index];
}

Recommendation: Implement file locking or consider SQLite for ACID transactions:

import { open } from 'sqlite';
import sqlite3 from 'sqlite3';

// Or use a locking mechanism
import lockfile from 'proper-lockfile';

async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const release = await lockfile.lock(WORKFLOWS_FILE);
  try {
    // Read, modify, write
  } finally {
    await release();
  }
}

---

🔒 Security Analysis

⚠️ 1. API Key Management

Current Implementation:

// auth.js
const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY || 'dev-api-key-change-in-production';

Issues:

• Default key is too obvious
• No key rotation mechanism
• Single shared key for all clients
• Keys logged in session data

Recommendations:

1. Require API_KEY in production:

const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY;

if (!DEFAULT_API_KEY && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
  throw new Error('API_KEY environment variable required in production');
}

2. Support multiple keys with scopes:

const API_KEYS = new Map([
  [process.env.API_KEY_ADMIN, { scope: 'admin', name: 'Admin Key' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_TUI, { scope: 'tui', name: 'TUI Client' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_BROWSER, { scope: 'browser', name: 'Browser Client' }]
]);

3. Hash keys before storage:

import crypto from 'crypto';

function hashApiKey(key) {
  return crypto.createHash('sha256').update(key).digest('hex');
}

⚠️ 2. WebSocket Security - No Authentication

Current Implementation:

// websocket/server.js
handleConnection(ws, req) {
  const clientId = `client-${Date.now()}-${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}`;
  // No authentication check!
  this.clients.set(clientId, ws);
}

Risk: Anyone can connect to /ws and receive real-time updates including potentially sensitive workflow data.

Recommendation: Implement WebSocket authentication:

handleConnection(ws, req) {
  // Extract API key from query params or headers
  const apiKey = new URL(req.url, 'ws://localhost').searchParams.get('apiKey');
  
  if (!apiKey || apiKey !== DEFAULT_API_KEY) {
    ws.close(1008, 'Unauthorized');
    return;
  }
  
  // Continue with connection...
}

⚠️ 3. Rate Limiting - In-Memory Only

Issue: Rate limit counters reset on server restart, allowing abuse:

// rateLimit.js
const requestCounts = new Map(); // Lost on restart

Recommendation: Persist rate limit data or use Redis:

// Option 1: Persist to file periodically
setInterval(async () => {
  await fs.writeFile(RATE_LIMIT_FILE, JSON.stringify([...requestCounts]));
}, 60000);

// Option 2: Redis (better for distributed systems)
import Redis from 'ioredis';
const redis = new Redis();

export async function rateLimit(req, res, next) {
  const clientId = req.clientId || req.ip;
  const key = `ratelimit:${clientId}`;
  const count = await redis.incr(key);
  
  if (count === 1) {
    await redis.expire(key, 60); // 1 minute window
  }
  
  if (count > MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW) {
    return res.status(429).json({...});
  }
  next();
}

⚠️ 4. Input Validation - Path Traversal

Good: ID validation prevents path traversal:

// validation.js
if (id.includes('..') || id.includes('/') || id.includes('\\')) {
  return res.status(400).json({...});
}

Missing: No validation on workflow/store data content size. Large payloads could cause DoS.

Recommendation: Add size limits:

app.use(express.json({ limit: '1mb' })); // Already handled by Express, but verify

// In validation.js
export function validateWorkflowData(req, res, next) {
  const workflow = req.body;
  
  // Limit nodes/edges count
  if (workflow.nodes?.length > 1000) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { message: 'Too many nodes (max 1000)' }
    });
  }
  
  if (workflow.edges?.length > 5000) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { message: 'Too many edges (max 5000)' }
    });
  }
  
  next();
}

---

🐛 Potential Bugs & Edge Cases

1. Circular Dependency in Services

// StoreService.js line 176
export async function syncWorkflowToStore(workflowId, options = {}) {
  const workflowService = await import('./WorkflowService.js'); // Dynamic import
  const workflow = await workflowService.getWorkflowById(workflowId);
  // ...
}

Concern: This works but is fragile. If WorkflowService later imports StoreService, you'll have issues.

Recommendation: Extract shared dependencies or use dependency injection:

// services/index.js
export const services = {
  workflow: null,
  store: null
};

// Initialize after both services are loaded
import * as workflowService from './WorkflowService.js';
import * as storeService from './StoreService.js';
services.workflow = workflowService;
services.store = storeService;

// In StoreService.js
import { services } from './index.js';
const workflow = await services.workflow.getWorkflowById(workflowId);

2. Missing Pagination Limits

// WorkflowService.js
export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows(); // Could be thousands!
  
  // Pagination applied, but no default limit
  if (options.limit !== undefined) {
    workflows = workflows.slice(0, options.limit);
  }
  return { workflows, total };
}

Recommendation: Enforce a default maximum:

const DEFAULT_LIMIT = 50;
const MAX_LIMIT = 1000;

export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows();
  
  // Apply default limit if not specified
  const limit = options.limit 
    ? Math.min(options.limit, MAX_LIMIT) 
    : DEFAULT_LIMIT;
  
  // ... filtering logic ...
  
  const total = workflows.length;
  workflows = workflows.slice(options.offset || 0, (options.offset || 0) + limit);
  
  return { workflows, total, limit, offset: options.offset || 0 };
}

3. WebSocket Heartbeat Race Condition

// websocket/server.js
startHeartbeat() {
  this.heartbeatInterval = setInterval(() => {
    this.clients.forEach((ws, clientId) => {
      if (ws.isAlive === false) {
        ws.terminate(); // Doesn't wait for termination
        this.clients.delete(clientId); // Immediate deletion
        return;
      }
      ws.isAlive = false;
      ws.ping();
    });
  }, 30000);
}

Issue: If a client responds to ping after being marked for termination but before terminate() completes, the state could be inconsistent.

Minor Issue: This is unlikely to cause problems in practice, but for correctness:

if (ws.isAlive === false) {
  ws.terminate();
  this.clients.delete(clientId);
  this.broadcast(createEvent(WS_EVENT_TYPES.CLIENT_DISCONNECTED, { clientId }));
  return;
}

---

📊 Database & Performance

✅ Good Practices

• Health check endpoints
• Graceful initialization
• Clear file structure

⚠️ Performance Concerns

1. No Indexing: Linear search through all workflows for every query:

export async function getWorkflowById(id) {
  const workflows = await getAllWorkflows(); // Reads entire file
  return workflows.find(w => w.metadata?.id === id) || null;
}

For large datasets, consider:

• SQLite with indexes
• In-memory Map cache with LRU eviction
• Separate files per workflow (like Git objects)

2. No Backup Strategy: .data/ directory has no backup mechanism. Add:

// In database.js
export async function backupDatabase() {
  const timestamp = new Date().toISOString().replace(/:/g, '-');
  const backupDir = path.join(DB_DIR, 'backups', timestamp);
  await fs.mkdir(backupDir, { recursive: true });
  
  await fs.copyFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'workflows.json'));
  await fs.copyFile(STORE_STATE_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'store-state.json'));
  await fs.copyFile(SESSIONS_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'sessions.json'));
}

// Call periodically or on shutdown

---

🐳 Docker Configuration

✅ Strengths

FROM node:18-alpine  # Small base image
RUN npm ci --only=production && npm cache clean --force  # Optimized deps
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s  # Proper health monitoring

💡 Suggestions

1. Multi-stage build for security:

# Build stage
FROM node:18-alpine AS builder
WORKDIR /app
COPY package*.json ./
RUN npm ci --only=production

# Production stage
FROM node:18-alpine
WORKDIR /app

# Create non-root user
RUN addgroup -g 1001 -S nodejs && \
    adduser -S geminiflow -u 1001

COPY --from=builder --chown=geminiflow:nodejs /app/node_modules ./node_modules
COPY --chown=geminiflow:nodejs . .

USER geminiflow

EXPOSE 3001
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \
  CMD node -e "require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})"

CMD ["npm", "start"]

2. Volume for persistent data:

# In docker-compose.yml (if not already there)
services:
  backend:
    volumes:
      - ./data:/app/.data  # Persist database

---

🧪 Testing & Observability

⚠️ Missing

1. No structured logging:

// Replace console.log with winston or pino
import pino from 'pino';
const logger = pino({ level: process.env.LOG_LEVEL || 'info' });

logger.info({ clientId }, 'Client connected');
logger.error({ error, path: req.path }, 'Request failed');

2. No metrics collection:

// Add Prometheus metrics
import client from 'prom-client';

const httpRequestDuration = new client.Histogram({
  name: 'http_request_duration_seconds',
  help: 'Duration of HTTP requests in seconds',
  labelNames: ['method', 'route', 'status_code']
});

const wsConnectionsGauge = new client.Gauge({
  name: 'ws_connections_active',
  help: 'Number of active WebSocket connections'
});

3. No automated tests for new backend code: Consider adding:

// test/api/workflows.test.js
import request from 'supertest';
import app from '../backend/src/server.js';

describe('Workflow API', () => {
  it('should create a workflow', async () => {
    const res = await request(app)
      .post('/api/workflows')
      .send({ name: 'Test Workflow', nodes: [], edges: [] })
      .expect(201);
    
    expect(res.body.success).toBe(true);
    expect(res.body.data.metadata.name).toBe('Test Workflow');
  });
});

---

📝 Code Quality

✅ Excellent Practices

• Comprehensive JSDoc comments
• Consistent naming conventions (get*, create*, update*, delete*)
• Proper async/await usage
• No callback hell
• Error messages include context
• Clean separation of concerns

💡 Minor Improvements

1. TypeScript Migration Path:
   The codebase would benefit from TypeScript for type safety. Consider gradual migration:

// types.ts
export interface WorkflowMetadata {
  id: string;
  name: string;
  description?: string;
  version: string;
  author?: string;
  createdAt: number;
  updatedAt: number;
  tags?: string[];
}

2. Constants File:
   Extract magic numbers and strings:

// constants.js
export const RATE_LIMIT = {
  WINDOW_MS: 60000,
  MAX_REQUESTS: 100
};

export const PAGINATION = {
  DEFAULT_LIMIT: 50,
  MAX_LIMIT: 1000
};

export const HEARTBEAT_INTERVAL = 30000;

---

🎓 Documentation Review

✅ SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md

Excellent sprint report with:

• Clear success criteria checklist
• Architecture highlights
• Usage examples
• Test results
• File structure diagram

Suggestion: Add a "Known Limitations" section:

## Known Limitations

1. **Database:** File-based JSON storage is not suitable for high-concurrency scenarios
2. **Authentication:** Single shared API key; no per-user auth
3. **Rate Limiting:** In-memory only; resets on server restart
4. **Scalability:** Single-instance design; no horizontal scaling support
5. **WebSocket:** No reconnection logic or message queuing for offline clients

---

🚀 Deployment & Operations

💡 Recommendations

1. Environment Variables Documentation:

# .env.example
NODE_ENV=production
PORT=3001
API_KEY=your-secure-api-key-here-min-32-chars
LOG_LEVEL=info
RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS=60000
RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS=100

2. Startup Checks:

// In server.js startup
async function validateEnvironment() {
  const required = ['API_KEY'];
  const missing = required.filter(key => !process.env[key]);
  
  if (missing.length > 0 && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
    throw new Error(`Missing required environment variables: ${missing.join(', ')}`);
  }
}

3. Graceful Shutdown Enhancement:

const shutdown = async (signal) => {
  console.log(`\n🛑 ${signal} received, shutting down gracefully...`);
  
  // Stop accepting new connections
  server.close(() => console.log('✅ HTTP server closed'));
  
  // Close WebSocket connections
  await websocketService.shutdown();
  
  // Backup database
  await db.backupDatabase();
  
  console.log('✅ Shutdown complete');
  process.exit(0);
};

process.on('SIGTERM', () => shutdown('SIGTERM'));
process.on('SIGINT', () => shutdown('SIGINT'));

---

✅ Sprint Objectives - ACHIEVED

All stated objectives have been successfully met:

✅ Production-ready Dockerfile with health checks
✅ Comprehensive API controllers with CRUD operations
✅ Workflow import/export functionality
✅ Store state management with real-time sync
✅ WebSocket broadcasting for live updates
✅ API key authentication middleware
✅ Global error handling with consistent format
✅ In-memory rate limiting
✅ Request validation middleware
✅ File-based database layer
✅ Detailed sprint completion documentation

---

🎯 Recommended Action Items

High Priority (Security & Stability)

1. ⚠️ Add WebSocket authentication
2. ⚠️ Implement file locking or migrate to SQLite
3. ⚠️ Enforce API_KEY requirement in production
4. ⚠️ Add request payload size limits

Medium Priority (Production Readiness)

5. 📊 Add structured logging (pino/winston)
6. 📊 Implement database backup mechanism
7. 📊 Add Prometheus metrics
8. 🔒 Persist rate limit data

Low Priority (Nice to Have)

9. 🧪 Add automated API tests
10. 📝 Create .env.example file
11. 🐳 Use multi-stage Docker build with non-root user
12. 📊 Add default pagination limits

---

🏆 Final Verdict

This PR represents excellent foundational work with a well-architected backend system. The layered design, comprehensive API coverage, and real-time capabilities are production-grade. Address the security concerns (especially WebSocket auth and database concurrency) before deploying to production.

Code Quality: ⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5/5)
Architecture: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
Security: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) - Needs hardening
Documentation: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

Overall: Ready to merge with follow-up security PR recommended.

Would you like me to create issues for any of these action items, or would you prefer to address specific concerns before merging?

---

🧠 Learnings used

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T07:02:15.005Z
Learning: Downstream PR #58 added a backend for Gemini execution and modified frontend/src/components/Flow.tsx and frontend/src/lib/store.ts; these must be treated as baseline when resolving UI-related conflicts going forward.

---

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T06:59:36.241Z
Learning: The gemini-flow repo now integrates PR #58 execution backend (/backend Express server at :3001) with PR #56 Next.js frontend. The Zustand store at frontend/src/lib/store.ts includes execution state (isExecuting, executionResult, executionError, executionMetadata) and executeFlow()/clearExecutionResult() while preserving selective subscriptions.

---

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-20T14:59:33.742Z
Learning: The gemini-flow CLI codebase has been enhanced with a comprehensive utility system including centralized error handling, base command classes, version validation, and a command registry for improved maintainability and developer experience.

[clduab11]

Tip

For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes.

🧩 Analysis chain
🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Fetch PR details and list of changed files
gh pr view 66 --json title,body,files,additions,deletions --jq '{title, body, additions, deletions, files: [.files[] | {path, additions, deletions}]}'

Length of output: 9800

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read all the new/modified files mentioned in the PR
echo "=== backend/Dockerfile ==="
cat backend/Dockerfile

echo -e "\n=== backend/package.json ==="
cat backend/package.json

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/controllers/WorkflowController.js ==="
cat backend/src/controllers/WorkflowController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/controllers/StoreController.js ==="
cat backend/src/controllers/StoreController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/auth.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/auth.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/errorHandler.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/errorHandler.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/middleware/rateLimit.js ==="
cat backend/src/middleware/rateLimit.js

echo -e "\n=== SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md ==="
cat SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md

Length of output: 9022

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Check the backend server.js to understand how these controllers and middleware are integrated
if [ -f backend/src/server.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/server.js ==="
  cat backend/src/server.js
elif [ -f backend/server.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/server.js ==="
  cat backend/server.js
fi

Length of output: 3929

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Check for routes files that might use these controllers
fd -e js -p "routes" backend/

Length of output: 67

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read routes files if they exist
if [ -f backend/src/routes/workflows.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/routes/workflows.js ==="
  cat backend/src/routes/workflows.js
fi

if [ -f backend/src/routes/store.js ]; then
  echo "=== backend/src/routes/store.js ==="
  cat backend/src/routes/store.js
fi

Length of output: 0

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the API controllers, middleware, and routes with correct paths
echo "=== backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js

Length of output: 18732

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the routes files
echo "=== backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/routes/store.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/routes/store.js

Length of output: 3601

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the services layer
echo "=== backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js

Length of output: 18212

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the models
echo "=== backend/src/api/models/Workflow.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/models/Workflow.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js ==="
cat backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js

Length of output: 9244

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
# Read the database and WebSocket server
echo "=== backend/src/db/database.js ==="
cat backend/src/db/database.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/websocket/server.js ==="
cat backend/src/websocket/server.js

echo -e "\n=== backend/src/websocket/types.js ==="
cat backend/src/websocket/types.js

Length of output: 15835

@clduab11, I've completed a comprehensive analysis of PR #66. This is an impressive infrastructure implementation with a solid layered architecture. Here's my detailed review:

🎯 Overall Assessment

Strengths: Excellent separation of concerns, comprehensive API coverage, real-time WebSocket integration, and thorough documentation. The architecture is production-ready with proper error handling and validation layers.

Critical Items: Security hardening needed, database concurrency handling, and WebSocket authentication.

🏗️ Architecture Review

✅ Excellent Layered Design

The Controllers → Services → Database pattern is well-implemented:

Routes (validation, auth, rate limiting)
  ↓
Controllers (HTTP request handling, WebSocket callbacks)
  ↓
Services (business logic, validation, sanitization)
  ↓
Database (file-based JSON storage)

Highlights:

• Clean separation between HTTP concerns and business logic
• Reusable asyncHandler wrapper prevents try-catch boilerplate
• Consistent API response format across all endpoints
• Proper use of callbacks for WebSocket broadcasting

⚠️ Concurrency Concern - Database Layer

Issue: The file-based JSON database lacks atomic operations. Multiple concurrent writes could cause race conditions:

// In database.js - not atomic
export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const workflows = await getAllWorkflows(); // Read
  const index = workflows.findIndex(w => w.metadata?.id === id);
  workflows[index] = { ...workflows[index], ...updates }; // Modify
  await fs.writeFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, JSON.stringify({ workflows }, null, 2)); // Write
  return workflows[index];
}

Recommendation: Implement file locking or consider SQLite for ACID transactions:

import { open } from 'sqlite';
import sqlite3 from 'sqlite3';

// Or use a locking mechanism
import lockfile from 'proper-lockfile';

async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const release = await lockfile.lock(WORKFLOWS_FILE);
  try {
    // Read, modify, write
  } finally {
    await release();
  }
}

🔒 Security Analysis

⚠️ 1. API Key Management

Current Implementation:

// auth.js
const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY || 'dev-api-key-change-in-production';

Issues:

• Default key is too obvious
• No key rotation mechanism
• Single shared key for all clients
• Keys logged in session data

Recommendations:

1. Require API_KEY in production:

const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY;

if (!DEFAULT_API_KEY && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
  throw new Error('API_KEY environment variable required in production');
}

2. Support multiple keys with scopes:

const API_KEYS = new Map([
  [process.env.API_KEY_ADMIN, { scope: 'admin', name: 'Admin Key' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_TUI, { scope: 'tui', name: 'TUI Client' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_BROWSER, { scope: 'browser', name: 'Browser Client' }]
]);

3. Hash keys before storage:

import crypto from 'crypto';

function hashApiKey(key) {
  return crypto.createHash('sha256').update(key).digest('hex');
}

⚠️ 2. WebSocket Security - No Authentication

Current Implementation:

// websocket/server.js
handleConnection(ws, req) {
  const clientId = `client-${Date.now()}-${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}`;
  // No authentication check!
  this.clients.set(clientId, ws);
}

Risk: Anyone can connect to /ws and receive real-time updates including potentially sensitive workflow data.

Recommendation: Implement WebSocket authentication:

handleConnection(ws, req) {
  // Extract API key from query params or headers
  const apiKey = new URL(req.url, 'ws://localhost').searchParams.get('apiKey');
  
  if (!apiKey || apiKey !== DEFAULT_API_KEY) {
    ws.close(1008, 'Unauthorized');
    return;
  }
  
  // Continue with connection...
}

⚠️ 3. Rate Limiting - In-Memory Only

Issue: Rate limit counters reset on server restart, allowing abuse:

// rateLimit.js
const requestCounts = new Map(); // Lost on restart

Recommendation: Persist rate limit data or use Redis:

// Option 1: Persist to file periodically
setInterval(async () => {
  await fs.writeFile(RATE_LIMIT_FILE, JSON.stringify([...requestCounts]));
}, 60000);

// Option 2: Redis (better for distributed systems)
import Redis from 'ioredis';
const redis = new Redis();

export async function rateLimit(req, res, next) {
  const clientId = req.clientId || req.ip;
  const key = `ratelimit:${clientId}`;
  const count = await redis.incr(key);
  
  if (count === 1) {
    await redis.expire(key, 60); // 1 minute window
  }
  
  if (count > MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW) {
    return res.status(429).json({...});
  }
  next();
}

⚠️ 4. Input Validation - Path Traversal

Good: ID validation prevents path traversal:

// validation.js
if (id.includes('..') || id.includes('/') || id.includes('\\')) {
  return res.status(400).json({...});
}

Missing: No validation on workflow/store data content size. Large payloads could cause DoS.

Recommendation: Add size limits:

app.use(express.json({ limit: '1mb' })); // Already handled by Express, but verify

// In validation.js
export function validateWorkflowData(req, res, next) {
  const workflow = req.body;
  
  // Limit nodes/edges count
  if (workflow.nodes?.length > 1000) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { message: 'Too many nodes (max 1000)' }
    });
  }
  
  if (workflow.edges?.length > 5000) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { message: 'Too many edges (max 5000)' }
    });
  }
  
  next();
}

🐛 Potential Bugs & Edge Cases

1. Circular Dependency in Services

// StoreService.js line 176
export async function syncWorkflowToStore(workflowId, options = {}) {
  const workflowService = await import('./WorkflowService.js'); // Dynamic import
  const workflow = await workflowService.getWorkflowById(workflowId);
  // ...
}

Concern: This works but is fragile. If WorkflowService later imports StoreService, you'll have issues.

Recommendation: Extract shared dependencies or use dependency injection:

// services/index.js
export const services = {
  workflow: null,
  store: null
};

// Initialize after both services are loaded
import * as workflowService from './WorkflowService.js';
import * as storeService from './StoreService.js';
services.workflow = workflowService;
services.store = storeService;

// In StoreService.js
import { services } from './index.js';
const workflow = await services.workflow.getWorkflowById(workflowId);

2. Missing Pagination Limits

// WorkflowService.js
export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows(); // Could be thousands!
  
  // Pagination applied, but no default limit
  if (options.limit !== undefined) {
    workflows = workflows.slice(0, options.limit);
  }
  return { workflows, total };
}

Recommendation: Enforce a default maximum:

const DEFAULT_LIMIT = 50;
const MAX_LIMIT = 1000;

export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows();
  
  // Apply default limit if not specified
  const limit = options.limit 
    ? Math.min(options.limit, MAX_LIMIT) 
    : DEFAULT_LIMIT;
  
  // ... filtering logic ...
  
  const total = workflows.length;
  workflows = workflows.slice(options.offset || 0, (options.offset || 0) + limit);
  
  return { workflows, total, limit, offset: options.offset || 0 };
}

3. WebSocket Heartbeat Race Condition

// websocket/server.js
startHeartbeat() {
  this.heartbeatInterval = setInterval(() => {
    this.clients.forEach((ws, clientId) => {
      if (ws.isAlive === false) {
        ws.terminate(); // Doesn't wait for termination
        this.clients.delete(clientId); // Immediate deletion
        return;
      }
      ws.isAlive = false;
      ws.ping();
    });
  }, 30000);
}

Issue: If a client responds to ping after being marked for termination but before terminate() completes, the state could be inconsistent.

Minor Issue: This is unlikely to cause problems in practice, but for correctness:

if (ws.isAlive === false) {
  ws.terminate();
  this.clients.delete(clientId);
  this.broadcast(createEvent(WS_EVENT_TYPES.CLIENT_DISCONNECTED, { clientId }));
  return;
}

📊 Database & Performance

✅ Good Practices

• Health check endpoints
• Graceful initialization
• Clear file structure

⚠️ Performance Concerns

1. No Indexing: Linear search through all workflows for every query:

export async function getWorkflowById(id) {
  const workflows = await getAllWorkflows(); // Reads entire file
  return workflows.find(w => w.metadata?.id === id) || null;
}

For large datasets, consider:

• SQLite with indexes
• In-memory Map cache with LRU eviction
• Separate files per workflow (like Git objects)

2. No Backup Strategy: .data/ directory has no backup mechanism. Add:

// In database.js
export async function backupDatabase() {
  const timestamp = new Date().toISOString().replace(/:/g, '-');
  const backupDir = path.join(DB_DIR, 'backups', timestamp);
  await fs.mkdir(backupDir, { recursive: true });
  
  await fs.copyFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'workflows.json'));
  await fs.copyFile(STORE_STATE_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'store-state.json'));
  await fs.copyFile(SESSIONS_FILE, path.join(backupDir, 'sessions.json'));
}

// Call periodically or on shutdown

🐳 Docker Configuration

✅ Strengths

FROM node:18-alpine  # Small base image
RUN npm ci --only=production && npm cache clean --force  # Optimized deps
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s  # Proper health monitoring

💡 Suggestions

1. Multi-stage build for security:

# Build stage
FROM node:18-alpine AS builder
WORKDIR /app
COPY package*.json ./
RUN npm ci --only=production

# Production stage
FROM node:18-alpine
WORKDIR /app

# Create non-root user
RUN addgroup -g 1001 -S nodejs && \
    adduser -S geminiflow -u 1001

COPY --from=builder --chown=geminiflow:nodejs /app/node_modules ./node_modules
COPY --chown=geminiflow:nodejs . .

USER geminiflow

EXPOSE 3001
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \
  CMD node -e "require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})"

CMD ["npm", "start"]

2. Volume for persistent data:

# In docker-compose.yml (if not already there)
services:
  backend:
    volumes:
      - ./data:/app/.data  # Persist database

🧪 Testing & Observability

⚠️ Missing

1. No structured logging:

// Replace console.log with winston or pino
import pino from 'pino';
const logger = pino({ level: process.env.LOG_LEVEL || 'info' });

logger.info({ clientId }, 'Client connected');
logger.error({ error, path: req.path }, 'Request failed');

2. No metrics collection:

// Add Prometheus metrics
import client from 'prom-client';

const httpRequestDuration = new client.Histogram({
  name: 'http_request_duration_seconds',
  help: 'Duration of HTTP requests in seconds',
  labelNames: ['method', 'route', 'status_code']
});

const wsConnectionsGauge = new client.Gauge({
  name: 'ws_connections_active',
  help: 'Number of active WebSocket connections'
});

3. No automated tests for new backend code: Consider adding:

// test/api/workflows.test.js
import request from 'supertest';
import app from '../backend/src/server.js';

describe('Workflow API', () => {
  it('should create a workflow', async () => {
    const res = await request(app)
      .post('/api/workflows')
      .send({ name: 'Test Workflow', nodes: [], edges: [] })
      .expect(201);
    
    expect(res.body.success).toBe(true);
    expect(res.body.data.metadata.name).toBe('Test Workflow');
  });
});

📝 Code Quality

✅ Excellent Practices

• Comprehensive JSDoc comments
• Consistent naming conventions (get*, create*, update*, delete*)
• Proper async/await usage
• No callback hell
• Error messages include context
• Clean separation of concerns

💡 Minor Improvements

1. TypeScript Migration Path:
   The codebase would benefit from TypeScript for type safety. Consider gradual migration:

// types.ts
export interface WorkflowMetadata {
  id: string;
  name: string;
  description?: string;
  version: string;
  author?: string;
  createdAt: number;
  updatedAt: number;
  tags?: string[];
}

2. Constants File:
   Extract magic numbers and strings:

// constants.js
export const RATE_LIMIT = {
  WINDOW_MS: 60000,
  MAX_REQUESTS: 100
};

export const PAGINATION = {
  DEFAULT_LIMIT: 50,
  MAX_LIMIT: 1000
};

export const HEARTBEAT_INTERVAL = 30000;

🎓 Documentation Review

✅ SUPER_TERMINAL_COMPLETION.md

Excellent sprint report with:

• Clear success criteria checklist
• Architecture highlights
• Usage examples
• Test results
• File structure diagram

Suggestion: Add a "Known Limitations" section:

## Known Limitations

1. **Database:** File-based JSON storage is not suitable for high-concurrency scenarios
2. **Authentication:** Single shared API key; no per-user auth
3. **Rate Limiting:** In-memory only; resets on server restart
4. **Scalability:** Single-instance design; no horizontal scaling support
5. **WebSocket:** No reconnection logic or message queuing for offline clients

🚀 Deployment & Operations

💡 Recommendations

1. Environment Variables Documentation:

# .env.example
NODE_ENV=production
PORT=3001
API_KEY=your-secure-api-key-here-min-32-chars
LOG_LEVEL=info
RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS=60000
RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS=100

2. Startup Checks:

// In server.js startup
async function validateEnvironment() {
  const required = ['API_KEY'];
  const missing = required.filter(key => !process.env[key]);
  
  if (missing.length > 0 && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
    throw new Error(`Missing required environment variables: ${missing.join(', ')}`);
  }
}

3. Graceful Shutdown Enhancement:

const shutdown = async (signal) => {
  console.log(`\n🛑 ${signal} received, shutting down gracefully...`);
  
  // Stop accepting new connections
  server.close(() => console.log('✅ HTTP server closed'));
  
  // Close WebSocket connections
  await websocketService.shutdown();
  
  // Backup database
  await db.backupDatabase();
  
  console.log('✅ Shutdown complete');
  process.exit(0);
};

process.on('SIGTERM', () => shutdown('SIGTERM'));
process.on('SIGINT', () => shutdown('SIGINT'));

✅ Sprint Objectives - ACHIEVED

All stated objectives have been successfully met:

✅ Production-ready Dockerfile with health checks ✅ Comprehensive API controllers with CRUD operations ✅ Workflow import/export functionality ✅ Store state management with real-time sync ✅ WebSocket broadcasting for live updates ✅ API key authentication middleware ✅ Global error handling with consistent format ✅ In-memory rate limiting ✅ Request validation middleware ✅ File-based database layer ✅ Detailed sprint completion documentation

🎯 Recommended Action Items

High Priority (Security & Stability)

1. ⚠️ Add WebSocket authentication
2. ⚠️ Implement file locking or migrate to SQLite
3. ⚠️ Enforce API_KEY requirement in production
4. ⚠️ Add request payload size limits

Medium Priority (Production Readiness)

5. 📊 Add structured logging (pino/winston)
6. 📊 Implement database backup mechanism
7. 📊 Add Prometheus metrics
8. 🔒 Persist rate limit data

Low Priority (Nice to Have)

9. 🧪 Add automated API tests
10. 📝 Create .env.example file
11. 🐳 Use multi-stage Docker build with non-root user
12. 📊 Add default pagination limits

🏆 Final Verdict

This PR represents excellent foundational work with a well-architected backend system. The layered design, comprehensive API coverage, and real-time capabilities are production-grade. Address the security concerns (especially WebSocket auth and database concurrency) before deploying to production.

Code Quality: ⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5/5) Architecture: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Security: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) - Needs hardening Documentation: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

Overall: Ready to merge with follow-up security PR recommended.

Would you like me to create issues for any of these action items, or would you prefer to address specific concerns before merging?

🧠 Learnings used

@coderabbitai , yes ... create context-engineered Issues with maximum prompt and context engineering for the action items in order for TraycerAI to submit a full plan of attack to improve the codebase repository.

[coderabbitai]

Actionable comments posted: 36

Caution

Some comments are outside the diff and can’t be posted inline due to platform limitations.

⚠️ Outside diff range comments (3)

backend/package.json (2)

1-1: Critical: Update package-lock.json to resolve CI/CD pipeline failures.

The pipeline failures indicate that package-lock.json is out of sync with package.json. Run npm install to regenerate the lockfile, then commit both files together.

#!/bin/bash
# Verify the lockfile sync status
cd backend
npm ci --dry-run 2>&1 || echo "Lockfile is out of sync - run 'npm install' to fix"

---

11-17: Add Node.js engine requirement to satisfy coding guidelines.

The coding guidelines specify that package.json must define engines with Node.js >= 18 to satisfy MCP server prerequisites. This ensures consistent runtime environments.

As per coding guidelines.

Apply this diff:

   "dependencies": {
     "@google/generative-ai": "^0.24.1",
     "express": "^4.18.2",
     "cors": "^2.8.5",
     "dotenv": "^16.3.1",
     "ws": "^8.14.2"
   },
+  "engines": {
+    "node": ">=18.0.0"
+  },
   "devDependencies": {
     "nodemon": "^3.0.1"
   }

package.json (1)

1-1: Critical: Update package-lock.json to resolve CI/CD pipeline failures.

The pipeline failures indicate that package-lock.json is out of sync with package.json. Run npm install at the root to regenerate the lockfile, then commit both files together.

#!/bin/bash
# Verify the lockfile sync status
npm ci --dry-run 2>&1 || echo "Lockfile is out of sync - run 'npm install' to fix"

🧹 Nitpick comments (45)

docs/SPRINT7_COMPLETION.md (1)

544-571: Consider adding HTTPS/TLS startup guidance in usage section.

The "Known Limitations" section (line 677-683) correctly flags the absence of HTTPS as a security risk. Consider adding a brief note in the "Usage Examples" section or a separate "Production Setup" subsection that clarifies:

• HTTP-only is for development/testing only
• Production deployment requires SSL/TLS via reverse proxy (nginx, etc.)
• Environment variables for API key management

This reinforces the importance of secure configuration before developers copy the examples into production environments.

docs/SPRINT6_COMPLETION.md (2)

94-94: Add language specifiers to fenced code blocks.

Six code blocks are missing language specifications:

• Line 94: Configuration block
• Line 120: File structure block
• Line 422: Graceful degradation block
• Line 440: Backup & recovery block
• Line 458: File structure block
• Line 526: Test structure block

Add language identifiers (e.g., ```typescript, ```json, ```bash) to improve markdown rendering and syntax highlighting.

Also applies to: 120-120, 422-422, 440-440, 458-458, 526-526

---

542-542: Use markdown heading syntax instead of emphasis for section titles.

Five section titles use bold emphasis (**...**) instead of markdown headings (####):

• Line 542: Dashboard
• Line 547: Workflow Builder
• Line 553: Execution Monitor
• Line 558: Config
• Line 913: Sign-off heading

Convert these to proper heading syntax to improve document structure and enable auto-generated tables of contents.

Example:

- **Dashboard (DashboardScreen.tsx)**
+ #### Dashboard (DashboardScreen.tsx)

Also applies to: 547-547, 553-553, 558-558, 913-913

docs/GETTING_STARTED.md (1)

38-40: Clarify Windows setup status.

The Windows setup script is marked "Coming soon," which may create friction for Windows developers. Consider either:

1. Providing interim manual setup instructions for Windows users
2. Noting the expected availability timeline

Current state is acceptable for documentation but may warrant a follow-up issue to prioritize Windows developer experience.

docs/SPRINT5_COMPLETION.md (3)

399-432: Document test evidence and methodology for verifiability.

The Testing Coverage section (lines 399–432) claims completion of all component and integration tests with ✅ marks, including "Zero crashes during testing" (line 601). However, no test files, logs, or evidence are provided. To strengthen credibility, consider:

1. Reference test file paths (e.g., tui/__tests__/TuiManager.test.ts)
2. Note test frameworks used (Jest, Vitest, etc.)
3. Link to CI/test results or summarize pass/fail counts
4. Document testing environment (Node version, OS, dependencies)

This is optional but recommended for production-grade documentation.

---

1-10: Clarify relationship to overall PR scope.

This document comprehensively documents Sprint 5 (TUI development), but PR #66 objectives emphasize Sprint 2–8 completion including backend deployment, API controllers, WebSocket infrastructure, and Docker. If this PR delivers multiple sprint completions, consider adding a brief introduction paragraph explaining how this Sprint 5 doc fits into the broader multi-sprint PR, or link to related documentation (e.g., backend/Docker setup, API reference).

This ensures reviewers understand the full PR scope at a glance.

---

595-605: Minor: Consistency with line count throughout document.

Line counts mentioned in the Conclusion (line 596: "~1,850 lines") repeat the earlier discrepancy identified in the Deliverables section (calculated ~1,445 lines). Once line counts are verified and corrected in the Deliverables section (lines 43–125), update this summary section accordingly for consistency.

Note: The emoji (🚀) is delightful for internal sprint reports but may be worth removing if this document becomes external-facing user documentation.

backend/Dockerfile (1)

23-24: Consider adding curl for more reliable health checks (optional).

The inline Node.js health check works, but installing curl provides a more standard approach and better error messages. This is entirely optional.

-HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \
-  CMD node -e "require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})"
+RUN apk add --no-cache curl
+
+HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \
+  CMD curl -f http://localhost:3001/health || exit 1

docs/SPRINT8_COMPLETION.md (1)

89-89: Consider adding language specifiers to fenced code blocks (optional).

Several fenced code blocks lack language specifiers, which reduces syntax highlighting and IDE support. While not critical for documentation, adding them improves readability.

For example, on Line 89, change:

-```
+```text
 .env files for all components

Apply similar changes to blocks at lines 196, 228, 255, 326, 422, 433, and 444.

Also applies to: 196-196, 228-228, 255-255, 326-326, 422-422, 433-433, 444-444

src/cli/super-terminal/components/MetricsPanel.tsx (1)

35-56: Optimize useEffect dependency array to prevent unnecessary updates.

The dependency array uses optional chaining (metrics.a2aMetrics?.avgResponseTime), which evaluates to undefined when a2aMetrics is missing. This creates a new dependency reference on each render, potentially causing excessive effect executions.

Apply this diff:

   }, [metrics.a2aMetrics?.avgResponseTime, metrics.a2aMetrics?.throughput]);
+  // More stable: depend on the entire a2aMetrics object
+  }, [metrics.a2aMetrics]);

Alternatively, add a guard inside the effect:

   useEffect(() => {
     const a2a = metrics.a2aMetrics;
-    if (a2a) {
+    if (a2a?.avgResponseTime !== undefined && a2a?.throughput !== undefined) {
       // Add current latency to history (max 20 points)

scripts/setup.sh (1)

186-195: Enhance port checking for cross-platform compatibility.

The lsof command may not be available on all Unix systems. Consider adding a fallback using netstat or handling the missing command gracefully.

Apply this diff:

 check_port() {
     local port=$1
-    if lsof -Pi :$port -sTCP:LISTEN -t >/dev/null 2>&1; then
+    if command -v lsof &> /dev/null; then
+        if lsof -Pi :$port -sTCP:LISTEN -t >/dev/null 2>&1; then
+            echo -e "${YELLOW}⚠️  Port $port is already in use${NC}"
+            return 1
+        fi
+    elif command -v netstat &> /dev/null; then
+        if netstat -tuln 2>/dev/null | grep -q ":$port "; then
+            echo -e "${YELLOW}⚠️  Port $port is already in use${NC}"
+            return 1
+        fi
+    else
+        echo -e "${YELLOW}⚠️  Cannot check port $port (lsof/netstat not found)${NC}"
+        return 0
+    fi
+    echo -e "${GREEN}✓ Port $port is available${NC}"
+    return 0
-        echo -e "${YELLOW}⚠️  Port $port is already in use${NC}"
-        return 1
-    else
-        echo -e "${GREEN}✓ Port $port is available${NC}"
-        return 0
-    fi
 }

docs/ARCHITECTURE_OVERVIEW.md (1)

305-331: Emphasize default API key security risk more prominently.

While line 311 documents the default development API key, consider adding a more prominent security warning at the beginning of the Security section or in a dedicated "Security Considerations" callout box. The default key dev-api-key-change-in-production must be changed before any production deployment.

Consider adding a prominent warning box at the start of the Security section:

## Security

> ⚠️ **CRITICAL**: The default API key `dev-api-key-change-in-production` is for development only. 
> You MUST set a secure `API_KEY` environment variable before deploying to production.

### Authentication
...

docs/WORKFLOW_FORMAT.md (1)

20-257: Comprehensive and well-structured workflow format specification.

The schema definition is clear with excellent examples in both JSON and YAML formats. Field descriptions with required/optional status help implementers understand the contract.

Minor note: The schema URL https://gemini-flow.dev/schema/workflow/v1 appears to be a placeholder. Consider either:

• Documenting it as a namespace identifier (not a resolvable URL), or
• Hosting the actual JSON Schema document at this URL for validation tooling

frontend/nginx.conf (1)

24-27: Consider modernizing security headers.

Current headers are good, but consider these improvements:

1. X-XSS-Protection (line 27) is deprecated: Modern browsers ignore this header, and it can actually introduce vulnerabilities in older browsers. Consider removing it.

2. Add Content-Security-Policy: This is the modern defense against XSS attacks and should be added.

Replace the security headers section with:

# Security headers
add_header X-Frame-Options "SAMEORIGIN" always;
add_header X-Content-Type-Options "nosniff" always;
add_header Content-Security-Policy "default-src 'self'; script-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline' 'unsafe-eval'; style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'; img-src 'self' data: https:; connect-src 'self' ws://localhost:3001 http://localhost:3001;" always;
add_header Referrer-Policy "strict-origin-when-cross-origin" always;

Note: Adjust the CSP connect-src directive to match your production API/WebSocket URLs. The unsafe-inline and unsafe-eval directives may need refinement based on your build tooling.

backend/src/server.js (4)

49-53: Replace raw request logging with a proper logger or gate by env

Console logs on each request will spam prod logs and trip no-console. Use a logger (e.g., pino-http/morgan) or only log in development.

-app.use((req, res, next) => {
-  console.log(`${req.method} ${req.path}`);
-  next();
-});
+if (process.env.NODE_ENV !== 'production') {
+  app.use((req, _res, next) => {
+    console.log(`${req.method} ${req.path}`);
+    next();
+  });
+}

---

35-37: Trust proxy for correct client IPs behind reverse proxies

Rate limiting and auditing rely on req.ip; enable trust proxy when deployed behind a proxy/ingress.

 const app = express();
 const PORT = process.env.PORT || 3001;
 
+// Respect X-Forwarded-* when behind reverse proxies (Ingress/Nginx)
+if (process.env.TRUST_PROXY === '1') {
+  app.set('trust proxy', true);
+}

---

124-132: Handle SIGINT and unify graceful shutdown

Support Ctrl+C locally and ensure orderly shutdown.

-// Graceful shutdown
-process.on('SIGTERM', async () => {
-  console.log('\n🛑 SIGTERM received, shutting down gracefully...');
-  await websocketService.shutdown();
-  server.close(() => {
-    console.log('✅ Server shut down complete');
-    process.exit(0);
-  });
-});
+// Graceful shutdown
+async function shutdown(signal) {
+  console.log(`\n🛑 ${signal} received, shutting down gracefully...`);
+  try {
+    await websocketService.shutdown();
+  } catch (e) {
+    console.error('WebSocket shutdown error:', e);
+  }
+  server.close(() => {
+    console.log('✅ Server shut down complete');
+    process.exit(0);
+  });
+}
+process.on('SIGTERM', () => { void shutdown('SIGTERM'); });
+process.on('SIGINT', () => { void shutdown('SIGINT'); });

---

41-46: Consider configuring CORS origins via env

Hardcoding localhost origins is fine for dev; parameterize for prod deploys.

-app.use(cors({
-  origin: ['http://localhost:5173', 'http://localhost:3000', 'http://localhost:3001'],
+app.use(cors({
+  origin: (process.env.CORS_ORIGINS?.split(',') ?? [
+    'http://localhost:5173','http://localhost:3000','http://localhost:3001'
+  ]),
   credentials: true
 }));

backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js (3)

55-71: Expose standard rate‑limit headers and correct types

Add Retry-After and make X-RateLimit-Reset seconds (string). Avoid sending raw ms timestamps.

   if (data.count > MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW) {
     const retryAfter = Math.ceil((data.resetTime - now) / 1000);
-
-    return res.status(429).json({
+    res.setHeader('Retry-After', String(retryAfter));
+    return res.status(429).json({
       success: false,
       error: {
         code: 'RATE_LIMIT_EXCEEDED',
         message: `Rate limit exceeded. Try again in ${retryAfter} seconds.`,
         details: {
           limit: MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW,
           windowMs: RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS,
           retryAfter
         }
       },
       timestamp: new Date().toISOString()
     });
   }
 
   // Add rate limit headers
-  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Limit', MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW);
-  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Remaining', MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW - data.count);
-  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Reset', data.resetTime);
+  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Limit', String(MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW));
+  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Remaining', String(MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW - data.count));
+  res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Reset', String(Math.ceil(data.resetTime / 1000)));

Also applies to: 73-77

---

19-27: Interval can keep process alive; make it non‑blocking and stoppable

Unref the timer and expose a stopper for tests/shutdown hooks.

-setInterval(() => {
+const _cleanupHandle = setInterval(() => {
   const now = Date.now();
   for (const [clientId, data] of requestCounts.entries()) {
     if (data.resetTime < now) {
       requestCounts.delete(clientId);
     }
   }
 }, RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS);
+_cleanupHandle.unref?.();
+
+export function stopRateLimitCleanup() {
+  clearInterval(_cleanupHandle);
+}

---

13-15: Config via env for production flexibility

Expose window and limit through env variables to tune without redeploys.

-const RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS = 60000; // 1 minute
-const MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW = 100; // 100 requests per minute
+const RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS = Number(process.env.RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS ?? 60000);
+const MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW = Number(process.env.RATE_LIMIT_MAX ?? 100);

docs/TUI_GUIDE.md (1)

108-141: Add language identifiers to fenced code blocks to satisfy MD040

Use “text” for ASCII diagrams and UI mockups to quiet markdownlint and improve rendering consistency.

Example:

-```
+```text
 ╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════╗
 …

Also applies to: 163-183, 199-216, 237-253

</blockquote></details>
<details>
<summary>docs/SYNC_ARCHITECTURE.md (1)</summary><blockquote>

`46-86`: **Add fenced code languages per markdownlint (MD040)**

Annotate code blocks: use text for diagrams, bash for shell, json for JSON, typescript for TS. This clears the lints and improves readability. 

Examples:

```diff
-```
+```text
 (architecture diagram)

```diff
-```bash
+```bash
 # commands...

```diff
-```json
+```json
 { "example": true }

Also applies to: 200-206, 306-346, 329-346, 353-371, 475-486, 497-505

</blockquote></details>
<details>
<summary>backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js (1)</summary><blockquote>

`74-78`: **Avoid exporting the default dev key**

Exporting DEFAULT_API_KEY increases accidental exposure risk. Keep it internal; expose a getter if truly needed for tests.

</blockquote></details>
<details>
<summary>backend/src/api/models/StoreState.js (1)</summary><blockquote>

`72-80`: **Preserve lastUpdate if provided; avoid unintended bumps**

sanitizeStoreState should not always change lastUpdate. Keep existing numeric value when present.

```diff
 export function sanitizeStoreState(state) {
   return {
@@
-    lastUpdate: Date.now()
+    lastUpdate: Number.isFinite(state?.lastUpdate) ? Number(state.lastUpdate) : Date.now()
   };
 }

docs/SPRINT4_COMPLETION.md (1)

77-79: Fix markdown lint issues (code fence languages, headings)

• Add languages to fenced blocks (e.g., bash, json, ```ts).
• Replace emphasis-as-heading with real headings (e.g., “### Retry Schedule”).

Example:

-```
+```bash
 npx tsx src/cli/super-terminal/index.tsx --debug

@@
-Retry Schedule:
+### Retry Schedule

Also applies to: 109-111, 163-165, 199-201, 237-239, 403-405, 483-485, 497-499

</blockquote></details>
<details>
<summary>src/cli/super-terminal/command-router.ts (2)</summary><blockquote>

`12-35`: **Tighten CommandResult and metrics typing**

Prefer explicit types over any; aligns with TS best practices and your guidelines.

```diff
-export interface CommandResult {
+interface A2AMetrics {
+  messagesProcessed: number;
+  avgResponseTime: number;
+  throughput: number;
+}
+interface AgentHealth { active: number; idle: number; error: number; stale: number; }
+interface MemoryUsage { total: number; perAgent: number; }
+interface CommandMetrics {
+  agentCount: number;
+  tasksActive: number;
+  performance?: Record<string, unknown>;
+  a2aMetrics?: A2AMetrics;
+  agentHealth?: AgentHealth;
+  memoryUsage?: MemoryUsage;
+}
+export interface CommandResult {
   output: string;
-  metrics?: {
-    agentCount: number;
-    tasksActive: number;
-    performance?: any;
-    a2aMetrics?: {
-      messagesProcessed: number;
-      avgResponseTime: number;
-      throughput: number;
-    };
-    agentHealth?: {
-      active: number;
-      idle: number;
-      error: number;
-      stale: number;
-    };
-    memoryUsage?: {
-      total: number;
-      perAgent: number;
-    };
-  };
+  metrics?: CommandMetrics;
   streamingOutput?: string[];
 }

---

194-201: Help mentions 'exit' but command isn’t implemented

Either add an 'exit' case or remove it from help to avoid confusion.

backend/src/websocket/server.js (3)

47-56: Use UUIDs for client IDs

Replace Date.now()+Math.random with crypto.randomUUID() for uniqueness.

+import { randomUUID } from 'node:crypto';
@@
-    const clientId = `client-${Date.now()}-${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}`;
+    const clientId = `client-${randomUUID()}`;

---

26-39: Replace console. with app logger and add consistent log levels*

Route logs through your central logger to control verbosity and structure; also avoids linter no-console warnings.

Also applies to: 50-51, 149-151, 219-221, 265-281

---

31-40: Consider authenticating WebSocket upgrades

Validate API keys/tokens during upgrade (e.g., via Sec-WebSocket-Protocol or signed query with short TTL) and reject unauthorized connections early.

frontend/src/hooks/useWebSocket.ts (3)

45-49: Stabilize subscriptions to avoid resubs on every render

Wrapping the handler in a ref prevents unnecessary unsubscribe/subscribe cycles when the handler identity changes.

 export function useWebSocketMessage(
   messageType: string,
   handler: (message: WebSocketMessage) => void
 ) {
   const wsClient = getWebSocketClient();
-
-  useEffect(() => {
-    const unsubscribe = wsClient.on(messageType, handler);
-    return unsubscribe;
-  }, [messageType, handler]);
+  const handlerRef = useRef(handler);
+  handlerRef.current = handler;
+  useEffect(() => {
+    const unsubscribe = wsClient.on(messageType, (msg) => handlerRef.current(msg));
+    return unsubscribe;
+  }, [messageType]);
 }

---

66-69: Avoid full-store subscription; select only needed actions

Destructuring the whole Zustand state can cause extra renders. Select the actions to keep renders minimal. Based on learnings

-export function useWebSocketSync() {
-  const wsClient = getWebSocketClient();
-  const { setNodes, setEdges } = useFlowStore();
+export function useWebSocketSync() {
+  const wsClient = getWebSocketClient();
+  const setNodes = useFlowStore(s => s.setNodes);
+  const setEdges = useFlowStore(s => s.setEdges);

---

12-12: Gate console logs or use a logger to satisfy no-console rule

Either guard logs behind env checks or route through a logger.

+// dev-only logger
+const debug = (...args: any[]) => {
+  if (import.meta.env.MODE !== 'production') console.log(...args);
+};
@@
-    console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Initializing WebSocket sync');
+    debug('[useWebSocketSync] Initializing WebSocket sync');
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow created:', message.payload);
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow created:', message.payload);
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow updated:', message.payload);
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow updated:', message.payload);
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow deleted:', message.payload);
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Workflow deleted:', message.payload);
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Store updated:', message.payload);
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Store updated:', message.payload);
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Store synced:', message.payload);
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Store synced:', message.payload);
@@
-      console.log('[useWebSocketSync] Cleaning up WebSocket sync');
+      debug('[useWebSocketSync] Cleaning up WebSocket sync');

Also applies to: 77-79, 83-90, 97-101, 103-110, 112-119, 123-124

backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js (2)

58-65: Guard when headers are already sent

Avoid writing twice; delegate to default handler if headers were sent.

 export function errorHandler(err, req, res, next) {
-  console.error('❌ Error:', {
+  if (res.headersSent) return next(err);
+  console.error('❌ Error:', {

---

66-71: Don’t expose internal details on 5xx responses

Return a generic message for server errors; keep details in logs. Optionally attach a requestId from header/x-request-id.

-  let statusCode = err.statusCode || 500;
+  let statusCode = err.statusCode || 500;
   let errorCode = err.code || 'INTERNAL_ERROR';
-  const message = err.message || 'Internal server error';
+  const isServerError = statusCode >= 500;
+  const message = isServerError ? 'Internal server error' : (err.message || 'Internal server error');
@@
-  res.status(statusCode).json(createErrorResponse(errorCode, message, {
-    path: req.path,
-    method: req.method
-  }));
+  res.status(statusCode).json(createErrorResponse(errorCode, message, {
+    path: req.path,
+    method: req.method,
+    requestId: req.headers['x-request-id']
+  }));

Also applies to: 89-94

backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js (1)

38-46: Use standardized error shape for 404

Return createErrorResponse for consistency with the global handler.

-  if (!workflow) {
-    return res.status(404).json({
-      success: false,
-      error: {
-        code: 'NOT_FOUND',
-        message: `Workflow not found: ${req.params.id}`
-      },
-      timestamp: new Date().toISOString()
-    });
-  }
+  if (!workflow) {
+    return res.status(404).json(createErrorResponse('NOT_FOUND', `Workflow not found: ${req.params.id}`, {
+      path: req.path, method: req.method
+    }));
+  }

backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js (1)

170-179: Use standardized error format for syncWorkflow validation

Leverage createErrorResponse for consistency.

-  if (!workflowId) {
-    return res.status(400).json({
-      success: false,
-      error: {
-        code: 'VALIDATION_ERROR',
-        message: 'workflowId required in request body'
-      },
-      timestamp: new Date().toISOString()
-    });
-  }
+  if (!workflowId) {
+    return res.status(400).json(createErrorResponse('VALIDATION_ERROR', 'workflowId required in request body'));
+  }

SPRINT2_COMPLETION.md (1)

26-26: Tighten phrasing

PNG already implies “graphics”; use “PNGs” or “PNG files”.

-   - Output: 2048x2048 PNG images
+   - Output: 2048x2048 PNGs

backend/src/db/database.js (1)

18-22: Allow overriding DB directory via env/config

Make persistence path configurable for Docker/production.

-const DB_DIR = path.join(__dirname, '../../../.data');
+const DB_DIR = process.env.DB_DIR || path.join(__dirname, '../../../.data');

backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js (1)

44-51: Defensive check for NaN limit/offset at the service layer

Ignore NaN/negative values; don’t rely solely on controller parsing.

-    if (options.offset !== undefined) {
-      workflows = workflows.slice(options.offset);
-    }
-    if (options.limit !== undefined) {
-      workflows = workflows.slice(0, options.limit);
-    }
+    const offset = Number.isFinite(options.offset) && options.offset! > 0 ? Number(options.offset) : 0;
+    const limit = Number.isFinite(options.limit) && options.limit! > 0 ? Number(options.limit) : undefined;
+    if (offset) workflows = workflows.slice(offset);
+    if (limit) workflows = workflows.slice(0, limit);

frontend/src/lib/websocket.ts (2)

25-27: Make the client SSR-/ESLint-safe (no window/CloseEvent), and fix timer types

Use global timers and broad event typing to avoid no-undef warnings and SSR pitfalls.

-  private reconnectTimer: number | null = null;
-  private pingInterval: number | null = null;
+  private reconnectTimer: ReturnType<typeof setTimeout> | null = null;
+  private pingInterval: ReturnType<typeof setInterval> | null = null;
@@
-    this.reconnectTimer = window.setTimeout(() => {
+    this.reconnectTimer = setTimeout(() => {
       this.connect();
     }, delay);
@@
-    this.pingInterval = window.setInterval(() => {
+    this.pingInterval = setInterval(() => {
       if (this.ws && this.ws.readyState === WebSocket.OPEN) {
         this.send('ping', {});
       }
     }, 30000); // Ping every 30 seconds
@@
-  private handleClose(event: CloseEvent): void {
+  private handleClose(event: any): void {
     console.log('[WebSocket] Disconnected:', event.code, event.reason);

Also applies to: 246-249, 255-260, 213-215

---

39-47: Gate debug logs in production

Keep the noise down and pass no-console checks in CI.

+const devLog = (...args: any[]) => { if (typeof process === 'undefined' || process.env.NODE_ENV !== 'production') console.log(...args); };
@@
-      console.log(`[WebSocket] Connecting to ${this.url}...`);
+      devLog(`[WebSocket] Connecting to ${this.url}...`);
@@
-    console.log('[WebSocket] Connected');
+    devLog('[WebSocket] Connected');
@@
-    console.log(`[WebSocket] Reconnecting in ${delay}ms (attempt ${this.reconnectAttempts}/${this.maxReconnectAttempts})`);
+    devLog(`[WebSocket] Reconnecting in ${delay}ms (attempt ${this.reconnectAttempts}/${this.maxReconnectAttempts})`);

Also applies to: 151-160, 233-245

backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js (2)

215-244: Consider adding edge structure validation.

While addEdge correctly validates source and target node existence, it doesn't validate the edge object structure itself. Adding validation for required fields (id, source, target) and optional fields (type, data) would improve robustness.

Similar to the node validation suggestion, create an validateEdge function:

export function validateEdge(edge) {
  const errors = [];
  
  if (!edge || typeof edge !== 'object') {
    return { valid: false, errors: ['Edge must be an object'] };
  }
  
  if (!edge.id || typeof edge.id !== 'string') {
    errors.push('Edge must have a valid string ID');
  }
  
  if (!edge.source || typeof edge.source !== 'string') {
    errors.push('Edge must have a valid source node ID');
  }
  
  if (!edge.target || typeof edge.target !== 'string') {
    errors.push('Edge must have a valid target node ID');
  }
  
  return {
    valid: errors.length === 0,
    errors
  };
}

---

328-349: Clarify callback options when calling loadWorkflowIntoStore.

The syncWorkflowToStore function passes options (which contains onSynced) to loadWorkflowIntoStore on line 338, but loadWorkflowIntoStore expects onUpdated. While this works because unexpected options are ignored, it could confuse future maintainers.

Pass an empty options object to make the intent clearer:

-    const state = await loadWorkflowIntoStore(workflow, options);
+    const state = await loadWorkflowIntoStore(workflow, {});

The dynamic import pattern to avoid circular dependencies is a clever solution!

[coderabbitai]

Tip

For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes.

🧩 Analysis chain

@clduab11, I'll create comprehensive, context-engineered GitHub issues for all 12 action items. These issues will include detailed codebase context, current implementations, recommended solutions, and acceptance criteria to enable TraycerAI to generate effective implementation plans.

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash

# Issue 1: Add WebSocket authentication (HIGH PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Security] Implement WebSocket Authentication" --body "## 🔒 Priority: HIGH - Security & Stability

### Background
Currently, the WebSocket server at \`backend/src/websocket/server.js\` accepts connections without any authentication. This allows any client to connect to \`/ws\` and receive real-time workflow and store state updates, potentially exposing sensitive data.

### Current Implementation
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/websocket/server.js (lines 51-55)
handleConnection(ws, req) {
  const clientId = \`client-\${Date.now()}-\${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}\`;
  // No authentication check!
  this.clients.set(clientId, ws);
  ws.isAlive = true;
  // ...
}
\`\`\`

### Security Risk
- Unauthenticated access to real-time workflow data
- Potential data leakage to unauthorized clients
- No access control for WebSocket connections
- Bypasses the API key authentication used in HTTP routes

### Recommended Solution
Implement API key authentication for WebSocket connections by:
1. Extract API key from query parameters or upgrade request headers
2. Validate against existing auth middleware logic
3. Close connection with proper status code if authentication fails
4. Store authenticated client metadata

\`\`\`javascript
// Suggested implementation for backend/src/websocket/server.js
handleConnection(ws, req) {
  // Extract API key from query params
  const url = new URL(req.url, 'ws://localhost');
  const apiKey = url.searchParams.get('apiKey');
  
  // Validate API key (reuse logic from backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js)
  const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY || 'dev-api-key-change-in-production';
  
  if (!apiKey || apiKey !== DEFAULT_API_KEY) {
    console.warn(\`❌ Unauthorized WebSocket connection attempt from \${req.socket.remoteAddress}\`);
    ws.close(1008, 'Unauthorized'); // Policy Violation
    return;
  }
  
  // Continue with authenticated connection
  const clientId = \`client-\${Date.now()}-\${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}\`;
  this.clients.set(clientId, { ws, authenticated: true, connectedAt: Date.now() });
  // ...
}
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/websocket/server.js\` (handleConnection method, lines 51-72)
- Potentially extract auth validation to shared utility in \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] WebSocket connections require valid API key via query parameter or header
- [ ] Unauthenticated connection attempts are rejected with status 1008
- [ ] Authentication failures are logged with client IP
- [ ] Authenticated client metadata is stored (auth timestamp, key hash, etc.)
- [ ] Frontend/TUI clients updated to pass API key during connection
- [ ] Documentation updated with WebSocket authentication requirements
- [ ] Tests added for auth success/failure scenarios

### Testing Plan
1. Attempt connection without API key → should be rejected
2. Attempt connection with invalid API key → should be rejected
3. Attempt connection with valid API key → should succeed
4. Verify existing functionality works with authenticated connections

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Related File: \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\`
- Related File: \`backend/src/websocket/server.js\`

### Additional Context
This issue blocks production deployment and should be addressed before exposing the WebSocket endpoint to untrusted networks."

echo "✅ Issue 1 created: WebSocket Authentication"

# Issue 2: Implement file locking or migrate to SQLite (HIGH PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Database] Implement Atomic Operations for File-Based Storage" --body "## ⚠️ Priority: HIGH - Security & Stability

### Background
The current file-based JSON database at \`backend/src/db/database.js\` uses non-atomic read-modify-write operations that can cause race conditions under concurrent load. Multiple simultaneous write operations could corrupt data or lose updates.

### Current Implementation - Race Condition Vulnerable
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/database.js (lines 85-99)
export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const workflows = await getAllWorkflows(); // READ
  const index = workflows.findIndex(w => w.metadata?.id === id);
  
  if (index === -1) {
    throw new Error(\`Workflow with id \${id} not found\`);
  }
  
  // MODIFY
  workflows[index] = { 
    ...workflows[index], 
    ...updates,
    metadata: {
      ...workflows[index].metadata,
      ...updates.metadata,
      updatedAt: Date.now()
    }
  };
  
  // WRITE - no protection against concurrent writes
  await fs.writeFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, JSON.stringify({ workflows }, null, 2));
  return workflows[index];
}
\`\`\`

### Concurrency Problems
**Scenario:** Two clients update the same workflow simultaneously
1. Client A reads workflows.json (contains workflow v1)
2. Client B reads workflows.json (contains workflow v1)
3. Client A modifies workflow → writes v2
4. Client B modifies workflow → writes v3 (overwrites A's changes)
5. Result: Client A's update is lost (lost update problem)

Similar issues exist in:
- \`updateStoreState()\` (lines 167-183)
- \`createSession()\` (lines 203-213)
- \`deleteWorkflow()\` (lines 101-118)

### Recommended Solutions

#### Option 1: File Locking (Quick Fix)
Use \`proper-lockfile\` package for advisory file locks:

\`\`\`bash
npm install proper-lockfile
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/database.js
import lockfile from 'proper-lockfile';

export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  const release = await lockfile.lock(WORKFLOWS_FILE, { retries: 3 });
  try {
    const workflows = await getAllWorkflows();
    const index = workflows.findIndex(w => w.metadata?.id === id);
    
    if (index === -1) {
      throw new Error(\`Workflow with id \${id} not found\`);
    }
    
    workflows[index] = { ...workflows[index], ...updates };
    await fs.writeFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, JSON.stringify({ workflows }, null, 2));
    return workflows[index];
  } finally {
    await release();
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Option 2: SQLite Migration (Recommended for Production)
Migrate to SQLite for ACID transactions:

\`\`\`bash
npm install sqlite sqlite3
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/database.js
import { open } from 'sqlite';
import sqlite3 from 'sqlite3';

const db = await open({
  filename: path.join(DB_DIR, 'gemini-flow.db'),
  driver: sqlite3.Database
});

export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  return await db.run(
    'UPDATE workflows SET data = ?, updated_at = ? WHERE id = ?',
    [JSON.stringify(updates), Date.now(), id]
  );
}
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/db/database.js\` (all write operations)
- \`backend/package.json\` (add dependencies)
- Add migration script if choosing SQLite

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] All database write operations are atomic
- [ ] Concurrent operations do not cause data loss
- [ ] Race condition tests pass (concurrent updates to same resource)
- [ ] Performance is acceptable (measure before/after)
- [ ] Database initialization handles migration from existing JSON files
- [ ] Backward compatibility maintained for existing data
- [ ] Documentation updated with concurrency guarantees

### Performance Testing
\`\`\`bash
# Concurrent update test
for i in {1..10}; do
  curl -X PUT http://localhost:3001/api/workflows/test-id -H 'X-API-Key: key' -d '{\"name\":\"Update \$i\"}' &
done
wait
# Verify all 10 updates are reflected or properly sequenced
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Affected Files:
  - \`backend/src/db/database.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js\`

### Migration Path (if choosing SQLite)
1. Create SQLite schema matching JSON structure
2. Write migration script to import existing JSON data
3. Update database.js to use SQLite
4. Update tests
5. Document rollback procedure

### Additional Context
This issue affects data integrity and should be resolved before production deployment or heavy concurrent usage."

echo "✅ Issue 2 created: Atomic Database Operations"

# Issue 3: Enforce API_KEY requirement in production (HIGH PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Security] Enforce API Key Requirement in Production" --body "## 🔒 Priority: HIGH - Security & Stability

### Background
The authentication middleware at \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\` currently provides a default development API key that is too predictable and does not enforce API key configuration in production environments.

### Current Implementation - Security Vulnerability
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js (lines 8-9)
const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY || 'dev-api-key-change-in-production';

export function authenticate(options = { required: true }) {
  return (req, res, next) => {
    // ... validation logic using DEFAULT_API_KEY
  };
}
\`\`\`

### Security Issues
1. **Predictable Default Key:** \`'dev-api-key-change-in-production'\` is too obvious
2. **No Production Enforcement:** Server starts without API_KEY in production
3. **Single Shared Key:** No support for multiple client keys or key rotation
4. **Key Exposure:** API keys logged in session data (line 45-56)

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Enforce API_KEY in Production
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js
const DEFAULT_API_KEY = process.env.API_KEY;

// Startup validation
if (!DEFAULT_API_KEY && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
  console.error('❌ FATAL: API_KEY environment variable is required in production');
  throw new Error('API_KEY environment variable required in production');
}

if (DEFAULT_API_KEY && DEFAULT_API_KEY.length < 32) {
  console.warn('⚠️  WARNING: API_KEY should be at least 32 characters for security');
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Support Multiple API Keys with Scopes (Optional Enhancement)
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js
const API_KEYS = new Map([
  [process.env.API_KEY_ADMIN, { scope: 'admin', name: 'Admin Key' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_TUI, { scope: 'tui', name: 'TUI Client' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_BROWSER, { scope: 'browser', name: 'Browser Client' }],
  [process.env.API_KEY_READONLY, { scope: 'readonly', name: 'Read-Only Key' }]
].filter(([key]) => key)); // Remove undefined keys

export function authenticate(options = { required: true, scopes: [] }) {
  return (req, res, next) => {
    const apiKey = req.headers['x-api-key'];
    const keyInfo = API_KEYS.get(apiKey);
    
    if (!keyInfo) {
      return res.status(401).json({...});
    }
    
    // Scope validation
    if (options.scopes?.length && !options.scopes.includes(keyInfo.scope)) {
      return res.status(403).json({
        error: { message: 'Insufficient permissions' }
      });
    }
    
    req.clientId = keyInfo.name;
    req.scope = keyInfo.scope;
    next();
  };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Hash API Keys Before Logging
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js
import crypto from 'crypto';

function hashApiKey(key) {
  return crypto.createHash('sha256').update(key).digest('hex').substring(0, 8);
}

// In session creation (line 45-56)
sessionData.apiKeyHash = hashApiKey(apiKey); // Don't store full key
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\` (entire file refactor)
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (add startup validation, lines 1-10)
- \`.env.example\` (document required environment variables - NEW FILE)
- \`README.md\` or deployment docs (update with security requirements)

### Environment Variables
Create \`.env.example\`:
\`\`\`bash
# Required in production
NODE_ENV=production
API_KEY=your-secure-random-key-minimum-32-characters-recommended-64

# Optional: Multiple API keys with scopes
API_KEY_ADMIN=admin-key-with-full-access
API_KEY_TUI=tui-client-key
API_KEY_BROWSER=browser-client-key
API_KEY_READONLY=readonly-key-for-monitoring

# Server configuration
PORT=3001
LOG_LEVEL=info
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Server refuses to start in production without API_KEY environment variable
- [ ] Startup validation checks API_KEY length (minimum 32 characters recommended)
- [ ] Default development key removed or only available in development mode
- [ ] API keys are hashed before logging or storing in sessions
- [ ] \`.env.example\` file created with documentation
- [ ] Deployment documentation updated with security requirements
- [ ] (Optional) Multiple API key support with scopes implemented
- [ ] (Optional) Endpoint added for key validation/testing

### Startup Validation Test
\`\`\`bash
# Should fail to start
NODE_ENV=production npm start

# Should warn about short key
NODE_ENV=production API_KEY=short npm start

# Should start successfully
NODE_ENV=production API_KEY=\$(openssl rand -hex 32) npm start
\`\`\`

### Key Generation Command
\`\`\`bash
# Generate secure API key
openssl rand -hex 32  # 64-character hex string
# or
node -e \"console.log(require('crypto').randomBytes(32).toString('hex'))\"
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Affected Files:
  - \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\`
  - \`backend/src/server.js\`
  - All route files (for scope-based auth if implemented)

### Additional Context
This is a critical security issue that must be resolved before production deployment. Consider implementing key rotation strategy for long-running production systems."

echo "✅ Issue 3 created: API Key Production Requirements"

# Issue 4: Add request payload size limits (HIGH PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Security] Implement Request Payload Size Validation" --body "## ⚠️ Priority: HIGH - Security & Stability

### Background
While Express has default JSON payload limits, the application lacks validation for workflow/store data complexity (node counts, edge counts, nested structure depth), which could cause denial-of-service through large payloads.

### Current Implementation Gap
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js (line 19)
app.use(express.json()); // Uses default limit of ~100kb

// backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js - MISSING complexity checks
export function validateWorkflowData(req, res, next) {
  const workflow = req.body;
  
  if (!workflow.metadata?.id) {
    return res.status(400).json({...});
  }
  // No checks for nodes.length, edges.length, or structure depth!
  next();
}
\`\`\`

### Attack Scenarios
1. **Node/Edge Bomb:** Submit workflow with 100,000 nodes → memory exhaustion
2. **Deep Nesting:** Submit deeply nested store state → stack overflow during processing
3. **Large String Fields:** Submit 10MB description field → JSON parsing overhead
4. **Array Flooding:** Submit workflow with 50,000 edges → processing delay

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Express JSON Size Limit
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js (update line 19)
app.use(express.json({ 
  limit: '1mb',  // Maximum request body size
  strict: true   // Only parse arrays and objects
}));

app.use(express.urlencoded({ 
  extended: true, 
  limit: '1mb' 
}));
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Workflow Complexity Validation
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js
const LIMITS = {
  MAX_NODES: 1000,
  MAX_EDGES: 5000,
  MAX_NAME_LENGTH: 200,
  MAX_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH: 5000,
  MAX_TAGS: 50,
  MAX_NESTED_DEPTH: 10
};

export function validateWorkflowData(req, res, next) {
  const workflow = req.body;
  const errors = [];
  
  // Node count validation
  if (workflow.nodes && workflow.nodes.length > LIMITS.MAX_NODES) {
    errors.push(\`Too many nodes (max \${LIMITS.MAX_NODES})\`);
  }
  
  // Edge count validation
  if (workflow.edges && workflow.edges.length > LIMITS.MAX_EDGES) {
    errors.push(\`Too many edges (max \${LIMITS.MAX_EDGES})\`);
  }
  
  // String field length validation
  if (workflow.metadata?.name?.length > LIMITS.MAX_NAME_LENGTH) {
    errors.push(\`Name too long (max \${LIMITS.MAX_NAME_LENGTH} characters)\`);
  }
  
  if (workflow.metadata?.description?.length > LIMITS.MAX_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH) {
    errors.push(\`Description too long (max \${LIMITS.MAX_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH} characters)\`);
  }
  
  // Tags validation
  if (workflow.metadata?.tags?.length > LIMITS.MAX_TAGS) {
    errors.push(\`Too many tags (max \${LIMITS.MAX_TAGS})\`);
  }
  
  // Node data complexity (prevent nested bombs)
  if (workflow.nodes) {
    for (const node of workflow.nodes) {
      if (getObjectDepth(node) > LIMITS.MAX_NESTED_DEPTH) {
        errors.push(\`Node data too deeply nested (max depth \${LIMITS.MAX_NESTED_DEPTH})\`);
        break;
      }
    }
  }
  
  if (errors.length > 0) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { 
        message: 'Workflow validation failed', 
        details: errors 
      }
    });
  }
  
  next();
}

function getObjectDepth(obj, depth = 0) {
  if (depth > 20) return depth; // Safety cutoff
  if (!obj || typeof obj !== 'object') return depth;
  
  const depths = Object.values(obj).map(v => getObjectDepth(v, depth + 1));
  return Math.max(depth, ...depths);
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Store State Validation
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js
export function validateStoreData(req, res, next) {
  const store = req.body;
  const errors = [];
  
  // Viewport validation
  if (store.viewport) {
    if (typeof store.viewport.zoom !== 'number' || 
        store.viewport.zoom < 0.1 || 
        store.viewport.zoom > 10) {
      errors.push('Invalid viewport zoom (must be between 0.1 and 10)');
    }
  }
  
  // Selection validation
  if (store.selectedNodes && store.selectedNodes.length > LIMITS.MAX_NODES) {
    errors.push(\`Too many selected nodes (max \${LIMITS.MAX_NODES})\`);
  }
  
  // Nested depth check
  if (getObjectDepth(store) > LIMITS.MAX_NESTED_DEPTH) {
    errors.push(\`Store state too deeply nested (max depth \${LIMITS.MAX_NESTED_DEPTH})\`);
  }
  
  if (errors.length > 0) {
    return res.status(400).json({
      error: { message: 'Store validation failed', details: errors }
    });
  }
  
  next();
}
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (update express.json middleware, line 19)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js\` (add complexity checks)
- \`backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js\` (apply validateWorkflowData to POST/PUT)
- \`backend/src/api/routes/store.js\` (apply validateStoreData to PUT)

### Configuration File (Optional)
Create \`backend/src/config/limits.js\`:
\`\`\`javascript
export const LIMITS = {
  // Request size
  MAX_REQUEST_SIZE: '1mb',
  
  // Workflow limits
  MAX_NODES: parseInt(process.env.MAX_NODES) || 1000,
  MAX_EDGES: parseInt(process.env.MAX_EDGES) || 5000,
  MAX_NAME_LENGTH: 200,
  MAX_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH: 5000,
  MAX_TAGS: 50,
  
  // Structure limits
  MAX_NESTED_DEPTH: 10,
  MAX_ARRAY_LENGTH: 10000,
  
  // Rate limiting (already exists)
  RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS: 60000,
  RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS: 100
};
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Express JSON parser limited to 1MB request size
- [ ] Workflow validation checks node count (max 1000)
- [ ] Workflow validation checks edge count (max 5000)
- [ ] Workflow validation checks name/description length
- [ ] Workflow validation checks nested depth (max 10 levels)
- [ ] Store state validation checks structure complexity
- [ ] Validation errors return 400 with detailed error messages
- [ ] Tests added for boundary conditions (at limit, over limit)
- [ ] Documentation updated with API limits
- [ ] Limits configurable via environment variables

### Testing Plan
\`\`\`javascript
// Test cases to implement
describe('Payload Validation', () => {
  it('should reject workflow with too many nodes', async () => {
    const workflow = {
      nodes: Array(1001).fill({ id: 'test', type: 'node' }),
      edges: []
    };
    const res = await request(app)
      .post('/api/workflows')
      .send(workflow)
      .expect(400);
    expect(res.body.error.details).toContain('Too many nodes');
  });
  
  it('should accept workflow at node limit', async () => {
    const workflow = {
      nodes: Array(1000).fill({ id: 'test', type: 'node' }),
      edges: []
    };
    await request(app).post('/api/workflows').send(workflow).expect(201);
  });
  
  // Add more test cases...
});
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Affected Files:
  - \`backend/src/server.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/middleware/validation.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/routes/workflows.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/routes/store.js\`

### Additional Context
This prevents both accidental and malicious large payloads from impacting system stability. Consider monitoring actual usage patterns to adjust limits appropriately."

echo "✅ Issue 4 created: Request Payload Size Limits"

Length of output: 387

---

Excellent! The first 4 high-priority security issues have been created. Continuing with the medium and low priority issues...

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash

# Issue 5: Add structured logging (MEDIUM PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Observability] Implement Structured Logging with Pino" --body "## 📊 Priority: MEDIUM - Production Readiness

### Background
The current codebase uses \`console.log\` statements throughout for logging, which lacks structure, log levels, and production-grade features like JSON output, correlation IDs, and performance tracking.

### Current Implementation - Unstructured Logging
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js (line 66)
console.log(\`🚀 Server running on http://localhost:\${PORT}\`);

// backend/src/websocket/server.js (line 57)
console.log(\`✅ WebSocket client connected: \${clientId}\`);

// backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js (line 14)
console.error('❌ Error:', error);
\`\`\`

### Problems with Current Approach
1. **No log levels:** Can't filter by severity (debug, info, warn, error)
2. **Unstructured:** Difficult to parse and analyze programmatically
3. **No context:** Missing request IDs, user info, timestamps
4. **Performance:** Console.log is synchronous and can block
5. **No rotation:** Logs grow indefinitely
6. **Not production-ready:** Can't integrate with log aggregation services

### Recommended Solution - Pino Logger

#### Part 1: Install and Configure Pino
\`\`\`bash
npm install pino pino-pretty
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/utils/logger.js (NEW FILE)
import pino from 'pino';

const isProduction = process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production';
const logLevel = process.env.LOG_LEVEL || (isProduction ? 'info' : 'debug');

export const logger = pino({
  level: logLevel,
  
  // Pretty print in development
  transport: !isProduction ? {
    target: 'pino-pretty',
    options: {
      colorize: true,
      translateTime: 'HH:MM:ss Z',
      ignore: 'pid,hostname'
    }
  } : undefined,
  
  // Production settings
  formatters: {
    level: (label) => {
      return { level: label };
    }
  },
  
  // Base fields
  base: {
    env: process.env.NODE_ENV,
    version: process.env.npm_package_version
  },
  
  // Serialize errors properly
  serializers: {
    err: pino.stdSerializers.err,
    req: pino.stdSerializers.req,
    res: pino.stdSerializers.res
  }
});

// Child loggers for different modules
export function createModuleLogger(module) {
  return logger.child({ module });
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Replace Console.log Statements

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js
import { logger } from './utils/logger.js';

// Replace: console.log(\`🚀 Server running on http://localhost:\${PORT}\`)
logger.info({ port: PORT, env: process.env.NODE_ENV }, 'Server started');

// Replace error logging
logger.error({ error: err, port: PORT }, 'Failed to start server');
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/websocket/server.js
import { createModuleLogger } from '../utils/logger.js';
const logger = createModuleLogger('websocket');

// In handleConnection
logger.info({ clientId, remoteAddress: req.socket.remoteAddress }, 'Client connected');

// In handleDisconnection
logger.info({ clientId, duration: Date.now() - client.connectedAt }, 'Client disconnected');

// In broadcast
logger.debug({ eventType, clientCount: this.clients.size }, 'Broadcasting event');
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js
import { logger } from '../../utils/logger.js';

export function errorHandler(err, req, res, next) {
  // Replace: console.error('❌ Error:', error);
  logger.error({
    err,
    path: req.path,
    method: req.method,
    clientId: req.clientId,
    requestId: req.id
  }, 'Request error');
  
  // ... rest of error handling
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Request ID Middleware
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/requestId.js (NEW FILE)
import { randomUUID } from 'crypto';

export function requestId(req, res, next) {
  req.id = req.headers['x-request-id'] || randomUUID();
  res.setHeader('X-Request-ID', req.id);
  next();
}
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/requestLogger.js (NEW FILE)
import { logger } from '../../utils/logger.js';

export function requestLogger(req, res, next) {
  const start = Date.now();
  
  // Log request
  logger.info({
    requestId: req.id,
    method: req.method,
    path: req.path,
    clientId: req.clientId,
    ip: req.ip
  }, 'Incoming request');
  
  // Log response
  res.on('finish', () => {
    const duration = Date.now() - start;
    logger.info({
      requestId: req.id,
      method: req.method,
      path: req.path,
      statusCode: res.statusCode,
      duration,
      clientId: req.clientId
    }, 'Request completed');
  });
  
  next();
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 4: Update server.js
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js
import { requestId } from './api/middleware/requestId.js';
import { requestLogger } from './api/middleware/requestLogger.js';

// Add after body parsers
app.use(requestId);
app.use(requestLogger);
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`backend/src/utils/logger.js\` (new)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/requestId.js\` (new)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/requestLogger.js\` (new)

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (replace console.log, add middleware)
- \`backend/src/websocket/server.js\` (replace console.log)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js\` (replace console.error)
- \`backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js\` (replace console.log if any)
- \`backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js\` (replace console.log if any)
- \`backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js\` (replace console.log if any)
- \`backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js\` (replace console.log if any)
- \`backend/src/db/database.js\` (replace console.log)

### Environment Variables
Update \`.env.example\`:
\`\`\`bash
# Logging configuration
LOG_LEVEL=info  # debug, info, warn, error
NODE_ENV=production
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Pino logger installed and configured
- [ ] All console.log statements replaced with structured logging
- [ ] Request ID middleware generates unique IDs for each request
- [ ] Request logger logs all HTTP requests with duration
- [ ] Module-specific loggers created (server, websocket, database)
- [ ] Log levels configurable via LOG_LEVEL environment variable
- [ ] Pretty printing enabled in development mode
- [ ] JSON output in production mode
- [ ] Error stack traces properly serialized
- [ ] Documentation updated with logging guidelines

### Example Log Output

**Development (pretty):**
\`\`\`
[14:32:15.123] INFO (server): Server started
    port: 3001
    env: \"development\"
    
[14:32:20.456] INFO (http): Incoming request
    requestId: \"550e8400-e29b-41d4-a716-446655440000\"
    method: \"POST\"
    path: \"/api/workflows\"
    clientId: \"TUI Client\"
    
[14:32:20.789] INFO (http): Request completed
    requestId: \"550e8400-e29b-41d4-a716-446655440000\"
    statusCode: 201
    duration: 333
\`\`\`

**Production (JSON):**
\`\`\`json
{\"level\":\"info\",\"time\":1704556335123,\"module\":\"server\",\"port\":3001,\"env\":\"production\",\"msg\":\"Server started\"}
{\"level\":\"info\",\"time\":1704556340456,\"requestId\":\"550e8400-e29b-41d4-a716-446655440000\",\"method\":\"POST\",\"path\":\"/api/workflows\",\"msg\":\"Incoming request\"}
\`\`\`

### Log Aggregation Integration
Pino JSON output is compatible with:
- **Elasticsearch + Kibana:** Stream logs to ELK stack
- **Datadog:** Use datadog agent to ship logs
- **Splunk:** Forward JSON logs via HTTP Event Collector
- **AWS CloudWatch:** Use CloudWatch agent
- **Azure Monitor:** Use diagnostic settings

### Performance Benefits
- 5-10x faster than console.log in production
- Asynchronous by default (doesn't block event loop)
- Minimal memory overhead
- Fast JSON serialization

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Pino Documentation: https://getpino.io/
- Related Issues: #67 (WebSocket Auth will benefit from structured logging)

### Additional Context
Structured logging is essential for debugging production issues, performance monitoring, and security auditing. This should be implemented before production deployment."

echo "✅ Issue 5 created: Structured Logging"

# Issue 6: Implement database backup mechanism (MEDIUM PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Database] Implement Automated Backup System" --body "## 📊 Priority: MEDIUM - Production Readiness

### Background
The \`.data/\` directory containing all workflows, store state, and sessions has no backup mechanism. This creates risk of data loss from accidental deletion, corruption, or disk failure.

### Current State - No Backup Strategy
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/database.js
const DB_DIR = path.join(process.cwd(), '.data');
const WORKFLOWS_FILE = path.join(DB_DIR, 'workflows.json');
const STORE_STATE_FILE = path.join(DB_DIR, 'store-state.json');
const SESSIONS_FILE = path.join(DB_DIR, 'sessions.json');

// No backup functions exist
\`\`\`

### Data at Risk
- **Workflows:** User-created workflow definitions with nodes/edges
- **Store State:** Current UI state (viewport, selections, etc.)
- **Sessions:** Active session data with authentication info

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Backup Service
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/backup.js (NEW FILE)
import fs from 'fs/promises';
import path from 'path';
import { createGzip } from 'zlib';
import { pipeline } from 'stream/promises';
import { createReadStream, createWriteStream } from 'fs';
import { logger } from '../utils/logger.js';

const DB_DIR = path.join(process.cwd(), '.data');
const BACKUP_DIR = path.join(DB_DIR, 'backups');
const MAX_BACKUPS = parseInt(process.env.MAX_BACKUPS) || 30;

/**
 * Create a timestamped backup of all database files
 */
export async function createBackup() {
  const timestamp = new Date().toISOString().replace(/[:.]/g, '-');
  const backupName = \`backup-\${timestamp}\`;
  const backupPath = path.join(BACKUP_DIR, backupName);
  
  try {
    // Ensure backup directory exists
    await fs.mkdir(BACKUP_DIR, { recursive: true });
    await fs.mkdir(backupPath, { recursive: true });
    
    const files = ['workflows.json', 'store-state.json', 'sessions.json'];
    const backedUp = [];
    
    for (const file of files) {
      const sourcePath = path.join(DB_DIR, file);
      const destPath = path.join(backupPath, file);
      const gzipPath = \`\${destPath}.gz\`;
      
      // Check if source exists
      try {
        await fs.access(sourcePath);
      } catch {
        logger.warn({ file }, 'Backup source file not found, skipping');
        continue;
      }
      
      // Compress and copy
      await pipeline(
        createReadStream(sourcePath),
        createGzip(),
        createWriteStream(gzipPath)
      );
      
      backedUp.push(file);
    }
    
    // Write backup metadata
    const metadata = {
      timestamp: new Date().toISOString(),
      files: backedUp,
      version: process.env.npm_package_version
    };
    await fs.writeFile(
      path.join(backupPath, 'metadata.json'),
      JSON.stringify(metadata, null, 2)
    );
    
    logger.info({ backupName, files: backedUp }, 'Database backup created');
    
    // Clean up old backups
    await cleanOldBackups();
    
    return backupPath;
  } catch (error) {
    logger.error({ error }, 'Failed to create backup');
    throw error;
  }
}

/**
 * Restore database from a backup
 */
export async function restoreBackup(backupName) {
  const backupPath = path.join(BACKUP_DIR, backupName);
  
  try {
    // Verify backup exists
    await fs.access(backupPath);
    
    // Read metadata
    const metadata = JSON.parse(
      await fs.readFile(path.join(backupPath, 'metadata.json'), 'utf-8')
    );
    
    logger.info({ backupName, metadata }, 'Restoring from backup');
    
    for (const file of metadata.files) {
      const gzipPath = path.join(backupPath, \`\${file}.gz\`);
      const destPath = path.join(DB_DIR, file);
      
      // Decompress and restore
      await pipeline(
        createReadStream(gzipPath),
        createGzip({ level: 0 }), // Decompress
        createWriteStream(destPath)
      );
    }
    
    logger.info({ backupName }, 'Database restored successfully');
  } catch (error) {
    logger.error({ error, backupName }, 'Failed to restore backup');
    throw error;
  }
}

/**
 * List all available backups
 */
export async function listBackups() {
  try {
    const entries = await fs.readdir(BACKUP_DIR, { withFileTypes: true });
    const backups = [];
    
    for (const entry of entries) {
      if (entry.isDirectory() && entry.name.startsWith('backup-')) {
        const metadataPath = path.join(BACKUP_DIR, entry.name, 'metadata.json');
        try {
          const metadata = JSON.parse(await fs.readFile(metadataPath, 'utf-8'));
          const stats = await fs.stat(path.join(BACKUP_DIR, entry.name));
          backups.push({
            name: entry.name,
            timestamp: metadata.timestamp,
            files: metadata.files,
            size: stats.size
          });
        } catch {
          // Skip invalid backups
        }
      }
    }
    
    return backups.sort((a, b) => 
      new Date(b.timestamp) - new Date(a.timestamp)
    );
  } catch (error) {
    logger.error({ error }, 'Failed to list backups');
    return [];
  }
}

/**
 * Delete old backups, keeping only MAX_BACKUPS
 */
async function cleanOldBackups() {
  const backups = await listBackups();
  
  if (backups.length > MAX_BACKUPS) {
    const toDelete = backups.slice(MAX_BACKUPS);
    
    for (const backup of toDelete) {
      const backupPath = path.join(BACKUP_DIR, backup.name);
      await fs.rm(backupPath, { recursive: true });
      logger.info({ backup: backup.name }, 'Old backup deleted');
    }
  }
}

/**
 * Get backup statistics
 */
export async function getBackupStats() {
  const backups = await listBackups();
  const totalSize = backups.reduce((sum, b) => sum + b.size, 0);
  
  return {
    count: backups.length,
    totalSize,
    oldest: backups[backups.length - 1]?.timestamp,
    newest: backups[0]?.timestamp
  };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Scheduled Backups
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/backupScheduler.js (NEW FILE)
import { createBackup } from './backup.js';
import { logger } from '../utils/logger.js';

const BACKUP_INTERVAL = parseInt(process.env.BACKUP_INTERVAL_HOURS) || 24;

let backupInterval;

export function startBackupScheduler() {
  if (backupInterval) {
    logger.warn('Backup scheduler already running');
    return;
  }
  
  // Create initial backup on startup
  createBackup().catch(err => 
    logger.error({ err }, 'Initial backup failed')
  );
  
  // Schedule periodic backups
  backupInterval = setInterval(() => {
    createBackup().catch(err => 
      logger.error({ err }, 'Scheduled backup failed')
    );
  }, BACKUP_INTERVAL * 60 * 60 * 1000);
  
  logger.info({ intervalHours: BACKUP_INTERVAL }, 'Backup scheduler started');
}

export function stopBackupScheduler() {
  if (backupInterval) {
    clearInterval(backupInterval);
    backupInterval = null;
    logger.info('Backup scheduler stopped');
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Integrate with Server Lifecycle
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js
import { startBackupScheduler, stopBackupScheduler } from './db/backupScheduler.js';
import { createBackup } from './db/backup.js';

// Start scheduler after database initialization
await db.initialize();
startBackupScheduler();

// Backup on graceful shutdown
const shutdown = async (signal) => {
  console.log(\`\\n🛑 \${signal} received, shutting down gracefully...\`);
  
  // Create final backup
  await createBackup().catch(err => 
    logger.error({ err }, 'Shutdown backup failed')
  );
  
  stopBackupScheduler();
  server.close();
  // ... rest of shutdown
};
\`\`\`

#### Part 4: Backup API Endpoints (Optional)
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/routes/admin.js (NEW FILE)
import express from 'express';
import { authenticate } from '../middleware/auth.js';
import { asyncHandler } from '../middleware/errorHandler.js';
import * as backup from '../../db/backup.js';

const router = express.Router();

// List backups
router.get('/backups', 
  authenticate({ required: true }),
  asyncHandler(async (req, res) => {
    const backups = await backup.listBackups();
    const stats = await backup.getBackupStats();
    res.json({ success: true, data: { backups, stats } });
  })
);

// Create backup
router.post('/backups',
  authenticate({ required: true }),
  asyncHandler(async (req, res) => {
    const backupPath = await backup.createBackup();
    res.json({ success: true, data: { backupPath } });
  })
);

// Restore backup (dangerous - require confirmation)
router.post('/backups/:name/restore',
  authenticate({ required: true }),
  asyncHandler(async (req, res) => {
    if (req.body.confirm !== 'RESTORE') {
      return res.status(400).json({
        error: { message: 'Confirmation required: send {\"confirm\": \"RESTORE\"}' }
      });
    }
    await backup.restoreBackup(req.params.name);
    res.json({ success: true, message: 'Database restored. Restart recommended.' });
  })
);

export default router;
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`backend/src/db/backup.js\` (new)
- \`backend/src/db/backupScheduler.js\` (new)
- \`backend/src/api/routes/admin.js\` (optional, new)

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (integrate backup scheduler)
- \`.gitignore\` (add \`.data/backups/\` to ignore list)

### Environment Variables
\`\`\`bash
# Backup configuration
BACKUP_INTERVAL_HOURS=24  # Backup every 24 hours
MAX_BACKUPS=30            # Keep last 30 backups
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Backup service creates compressed backups of all database files
- [ ] Backup scheduler runs automatically at configured intervals
- [ ] Backup created on server startup
- [ ] Backup created on graceful shutdown
- [ ] Old backups automatically cleaned up (keep last 30)
- [ ] Restore functionality implemented and tested
- [ ] Backup metadata includes timestamp and file list
- [ ] (Optional) Admin API endpoints for manual backup/restore
- [ ] Documentation added for backup/restore procedures

### Manual Backup Commands
\`\`\`bash
# Create manual backup via API
curl -X POST http://localhost:3001/api/admin/backups \\
  -H \"X-API-Key: \$API_KEY\"

# List backups
curl http://localhost:3001/api/admin/backups \\
  -H \"X-API-Key: \$API_KEY\"

# Restore backup
curl -X POST http://localhost:3001/api/admin/backups/backup-2024-01-20T10-30-00/restore \\
  -H \"X-API-Key: \$API_KEY\" \\
  -H \"Content-Type: application/json\" \\
  -d '{\"confirm\": \"RESTORE\"}'
\`\`\`

### Backup Directory Structure
\`\`\`
.data/
├── workflows.json
├── store-state.json
├── sessions.json
└── backups/
    ├── backup-2024-01-20T10-00-00/
    │   ├── workflows.json.gz
    │   ├── store-state.json.gz
    │   ├── sessions.json.gz
    │   └── metadata.json
    ├── backup-2024-01-21T10-00-00/
    │   └── ...
    └── ...
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Related Issue: #68 (Atomic operations should be implemented first)

### Additional Context
Implement this after resolving database atomicity issues (#68). Consider cloud backup integration for critical production deployments."

echo "✅ Issue 6 created: Database Backup System"

# Issue 7: Add Prometheus metrics (MEDIUM PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Observability] Implement Prometheus Metrics Collection" --body "## 📊 Priority: MEDIUM - Production Readiness

### Background
The application lacks performance and health metrics, making it difficult to monitor system behavior, detect anomalies, or set up alerting in production. Prometheus metrics provide standardized monitoring capabilities.

### Current State - No Metrics
No instrumentation exists for:
- HTTP request duration/throughput
- WebSocket connection counts
- Database operation latency
- Error rates
- System resource usage

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Install prom-client
\`\`\`bash
npm install prom-client
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Metrics Configuration
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/monitoring/metrics.js (NEW FILE)
import client from 'prom-client';

// Enable default metrics (CPU, memory, event loop lag)
client.collectDefaultMetrics({
  prefix: 'gemini_flow_',
  gcDurationBuckets: [0.001, 0.01, 0.1, 1, 2, 5]
});

// HTTP Request Duration Histogram
export const httpRequestDuration = new client.Histogram({
  name: 'gemini_flow_http_request_duration_seconds',
  help: 'Duration of HTTP requests in seconds',
  labelNames: ['method', 'route', 'status_code'],
  buckets: [0.001, 0.005, 0.01, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2, 5]
});

// HTTP Request Counter
export const httpRequestTotal = new client.Counter({
  name: 'gemini_flow_http_requests_total',
  help: 'Total number of HTTP requests',
  labelNames: ['method', 'route', 'status_code']
});

// WebSocket Connection Gauge
export const wsConnectionsActive = new client.Gauge({
  name: 'gemini_flow_websocket_connections_active',
  help: 'Number of active WebSocket connections'
});

// WebSocket Message Counter
export const wsMessagesTotal = new client.Counter({
  name: 'gemini_flow_websocket_messages_total',
  help: 'Total WebSocket messages sent/received',
  labelNames: ['direction', 'type'] // direction: inbound/outbound, type: event type
});

// Database Operation Duration
export const dbOperationDuration = new client.Histogram({
  name: 'gemini_flow_db_operation_duration_seconds',
  help: 'Duration of database operations in seconds',
  labelNames: ['operation', 'collection'], // operation: read/write/delete, collection: workflows/store/sessions
  buckets: [0.001, 0.005, 0.01, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5, 1]
});

// Database Operation Counter
export const dbOperationTotal = new client.Counter({
  name: 'gemini_flow_db_operations_total',
  help: 'Total number of database operations',
  labelNames: ['operation', 'collection', 'status'] // status: success/error
});

// Workflow Statistics
export const workflowsTotal = new client.Gauge({
  name: 'gemini_flow_workflows_total',
  help: 'Total number of workflows in database'
});

export const workflowNodesHistogram = new client.Histogram({
  name: 'gemini_flow_workflow_nodes',
  help: 'Distribution of node counts across workflows',
  buckets: [0, 10, 25, 50, 100, 250, 500, 1000]
});

// Error Counter
export const errorsTotal = new client.Counter({
  name: 'gemini_flow_errors_total',
  help: 'Total number of errors',
  labelNames: ['type', 'path'] // type: validation/database/network/etc
});

// Registry for all metrics
export const register = client.register;
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: HTTP Metrics Middleware
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/metricsMiddleware.js (NEW FILE)
import { httpRequestDuration, httpRequestTotal } from '../../monitoring/metrics.js';

export function metricsMiddleware(req, res, next) {
  const start = Date.now();
  
  res.on('finish', () => {
    const duration = (Date.now() - start) / 1000; // Convert to seconds
    const route = req.route?.path || req.path;
    const labels = {
      method: req.method,
      route,
      status_code: res.statusCode
    };
    
    httpRequestDuration.observe(labels, duration);
    httpRequestTotal.inc(labels);
  });
  
  next();
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 4: Instrument WebSocket Server
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/websocket/server.js
import { wsConnectionsActive, wsMessagesTotal } from '../monitoring/metrics.js';

export class WebSocketServer {
  handleConnection(ws, req) {
    // ... existing auth code ...
    
    const clientId = \`client-\${Date.now()}-\${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}\`;
    this.clients.set(clientId, ws);
    
    // Increment connection gauge
    wsConnectionsActive.inc();
    
    ws.on('message', (data) => {
      wsMessagesTotal.inc({ direction: 'inbound', type: 'message' });
      // ... handle message ...
    });
    
    ws.on('close', () => {
      this.handleDisconnection(clientId);
      // Decrement connection gauge
      wsConnectionsActive.dec();
    });
  }
  
  broadcast(event, excludeClientId = null) {
    // ... existing broadcast code ...
    
    const clientCount = this.clients.size - (excludeClientId ? 1 : 0);
    wsMessagesTotal.inc({ 
      direction: 'outbound', 
      type: event.type 
    }, clientCount);
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 5: Instrument Database Operations
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/database.js
import { dbOperationDuration, dbOperationTotal, workflowsTotal } from '../monitoring/metrics.js';

// Wrapper for instrumented operations
function instrument(operation, collection) {
  return async function(fn) {
    const start = Date.now();
    let status = 'success';
    
    try {
      const result = await fn();
      return result;
    } catch (error) {
      status = 'error';
      throw error;
    } finally {
      const duration = (Date.now() - start) / 1000;
      dbOperationDuration.observe({ operation, collection }, duration);
      dbOperationTotal.inc({ operation, collection, status });
    }
  };
}

export async function getAllWorkflows() {
  return instrument('read', 'workflows')(async () => {
    const data = await fs.readFile(WORKFLOWS_FILE, 'utf-8');
    const parsed = JSON.parse(data);
    const workflows = parsed.workflows || [];
    
    // Update workflow count gauge
    workflowsTotal.set(workflows.length);
    
    return workflows;
  });
}

export async function updateWorkflow(id, updates) {
  return instrument('write', 'workflows')(async () => {
    // ... existing update code ...
  });
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 6: Metrics Endpoint
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js
import { register } from './monitoring/metrics.js';
import { metricsMiddleware } from './api/middleware/metricsMiddleware.js';

// Add metrics middleware (after request ID, before routes)
app.use(metricsMiddleware);

// Metrics endpoint (no auth for Prometheus scraper)
app.get('/metrics', async (req, res) => {
  res.set('Content-Type', register.contentType);
  res.end(await register.metrics());
});
\`\`\`

#### Part 7: Error Instrumentation
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js
import { errorsTotal } from '../../monitoring/metrics.js';

export function errorHandler(err, req, res, next) {
  // Increment error counter
  errorsTotal.inc({ 
    type: err.name || 'UnknownError',
    path: req.path 
  });
  
  // ... existing error handling ...
}
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`backend/src/monitoring/metrics.js\` (new)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/metricsMiddleware.js\` (new)

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (add metrics endpoint and middleware)
- \`backend/src/websocket/server.js\` (instrument connections and messages)
- \`backend/src/db/database.js\` (instrument operations)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/errorHandler.js\` (instrument errors)

### Prometheus Configuration
\`\`\`yaml
# prometheus.yml
scrape_configs:
  - job_name: 'gemini-flow-backend'
    scrape_interval: 15s
    static_configs:
      - targets: ['localhost:3001']
    metrics_path: '/metrics'
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] prom-client installed and configured
- [ ] Default metrics collected (CPU, memory, event loop)
- [ ] HTTP request duration and count tracked per route
- [ ] WebSocket connection count tracked in real-time
- [ ] WebSocket message count tracked by direction and type
- [ ] Database operation duration tracked per operation type
- [ ] Error count tracked by type and path
- [ ] Workflow statistics gauges updated periodically
- [ ] /metrics endpoint exposed for Prometheus scraping
- [ ] Documentation added for metrics and monitoring setup

### Example Queries (PromQL)

\`\`\`promql
# Average HTTP request duration by route
rate(gemini_flow_http_request_duration_seconds_sum[5m]) 
/ 
rate(gemini_flow_http_request_duration_seconds_count[5m])

# Error rate percentage
100 * rate(gemini_flow_errors_total[5m]) 
/ 
rate(gemini_flow_http_requests_total[5m])

# 95th percentile request latency
histogram_quantile(0.95, 
  rate(gemini_flow_http_request_duration_seconds_bucket[5m])
)

# Active WebSocket connections
gemini_flow_websocket_connections_active
\`\`\`

### Grafana Dashboard (Optional)
Create \`monitoring/grafana-dashboard.json\` with panels for:
- Request throughput (requests/sec)
- Request latency (p50, p95, p99)
- Error rate
- WebSocket connections
- Database operation latency
- CPU and memory usage

### Testing Metrics Endpoint
\`\`\`bash
# Scrape metrics
curl http://localhost:3001/metrics

# Example output:
# HELP gemini_flow_http_requests_total Total number of HTTP requests
# TYPE gemini_flow_http_requests_total counter
# gemini_flow_http_requests_total{method=\"GET\",route=\"/api/workflows\",status_code=\"200\"} 42
# 
# HELP gemini_flow_websocket_connections_active Number of active WebSocket connections
# TYPE gemini_flow_websocket_connections_active gauge
# gemini_flow_websocket_connections_active 3
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Prometheus Documentation: https://prometheus.io/docs/
- prom-client: https://github.com/siimon/prom-client

### Additional Context
Metrics are essential for production monitoring, alerting, and capacity planning. Implement alongside structured logging (#73) for complete observability."

echo "✅ Issue 7 created: Prometheus Metrics"

# Issue 8: Persist rate limit data (MEDIUM PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Infrastructure] Persist Rate Limit Data Across Restarts" --body "## 🔒 Priority: MEDIUM - Production Readiness

### Background
The current rate limiting implementation at \`backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js\` uses an in-memory Map that is lost on server restart, allowing attackers to bypass limits by forcing restarts or exploiting deployment cycles.

### Current Implementation - Volatile Rate Limits
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js (line 9)
const requestCounts = new Map(); // Lost on restart

export function rateLimit(req, res, next) {
  const clientId = req.clientId || req.ip;
  const now = Date.now();
  const windowStart = now - WINDOW_MS;
  
  // Get or initialize count for this client
  if (!requestCounts.has(clientId)) {
    requestCounts.set(clientId, []);
  }
  
  const requests = requestCounts.get(clientId);
  // ...
}
\`\`\`

### Security Concern
**Attack Scenario:**
1. Attacker makes 99 requests (just under 100 limit)
2. Attacker triggers server restart (crash, deploy, etc.)
3. Rate limit counter resets to 0
4. Attacker makes another 99 requests
5. Repeat → 10x normal rate limit bypass

### Recommended Solutions

#### Option 1: File-Based Persistence (Simple, Single Instance)
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js
import fs from 'fs/promises';
import path from 'path';

const RATE_LIMIT_FILE = path.join(process.cwd(), '.data', 'rate-limits.json');
const requestCounts = new Map();
let persistenceInterval;

// Load rate limits on startup
async function loadRateLimits() {
  try {
    const data = await fs.readFile(RATE_LIMIT_FILE, 'utf-8');
    const stored = JSON.parse(data);
    
    // Convert stored array back to Map and filter expired entries
    const now = Date.now();
    const windowStart = now - WINDOW_MS;
    
    for (const [clientId, requests] of stored) {
      const validRequests = requests.filter(timestamp => timestamp > windowStart);
      if (validRequests.length > 0) {
        requestCounts.set(clientId, validRequests);
      }
    }
    
    logger.info({ clients: requestCounts.size }, 'Rate limits loaded from disk');
  } catch (error) {
    if (error.code !== 'ENOENT') {
      logger.error({ error }, 'Failed to load rate limits');
    }
  }
}

// Persist rate limits periodically
async function persistRateLimits() {
  try {
    const now = Date.now();
    const windowStart = now - WINDOW_MS;
    
    // Clean up expired entries before persisting
    const activeClients = [];
    for (const [clientId, requests] of requestCounts.entries()) {
      const validRequests = requests.filter(timestamp => timestamp > windowStart);
      if (validRequests.length > 0) {
        activeClients.push([clientId, validRequests]);
      } else {
        requestCounts.delete(clientId);
      }
    }
    
    await fs.writeFile(RATE_LIMIT_FILE, JSON.stringify(activeClients));
    logger.debug({ clients: activeClients.length }, 'Rate limits persisted to disk');
  } catch (error) {
    logger.error({ error }, 'Failed to persist rate limits');
  }
}

// Start persistence scheduler
export function startRateLimitPersistence() {
  loadRateLimits(); // Load on startup
  
  // Persist every 30 seconds
  persistenceInterval = setInterval(persistRateLimits, 30000);
  
  // Persist on graceful shutdown
  process.on('SIGTERM', async () => {
    await persistRateLimits();
  });
  
  process.on('SIGINT', async () => {
    await persistRateLimits();
  });
}

export function stopRateLimitPersistence() {
  if (persistenceInterval) {
    clearInterval(persistenceInterval);
    persistenceInterval = null;
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Option 2: Redis Backend (Production, Distributed)
\`\`\`bash
npm install ioredis
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js
import Redis from 'ioredis';

const redis = new Redis({
  host: process.env.REDIS_HOST || 'localhost',
  port: parseInt(process.env.REDIS_PORT) || 6379,
  password: process.env.REDIS_PASSWORD,
  db: parseInt(process.env.REDIS_DB) || 0,
  lazyConnect: true
});

let useRedis = false;

// Initialize Redis connection
export async function initRateLimitStore() {
  try {
    await redis.connect();
    useRedis = true;
    logger.info('Rate limiting using Redis backend');
  } catch (error) {
    logger.warn({ error }, 'Redis unavailable, falling back to in-memory rate limiting');
    useRedis = false;
  }
}

export async function rateLimit(req, res, next) {
  const clientId = req.clientId || req.ip;
  const now = Date.now();
  
  if (useRedis) {
    await rateLimitRedis(clientId, now, req, res, next);
  } else {
    rateLimitMemory(clientId, now, req, res, next);
  }
}

async function rateLimitRedis(clientId, now, req, res, next) {
  const key = \`ratelimit:\${clientId}\`;
  
  try {
    // Use Redis sorted set with timestamps as scores
    const windowStart = now - WINDOW_MS;
    
    // Remove old entries
    await redis.zremrangebyscore(key, 0, windowStart);
    
    // Count current requests in window
    const count = await redis.zcard(key);
    
    if (count >= MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW) {
      const oldestRequest = await redis.zrange(key, 0, 0, 'WITHSCORES');
      const resetTime = oldestRequest.length > 0 
        ? parseInt(oldestRequest[1]) + WINDOW_MS 
        : now + WINDOW_MS;
      
      return res.status(429).json({
        error: {
          message: 'Too many requests',
          retryAfter: Math.ceil((resetTime - now) / 1000)
        }
      });
    }
    
    // Add current request
    await redis.zadd(key, now, \`\${now}-\${Math.random()}\`);
    await redis.expire(key, Math.ceil(WINDOW_MS / 1000));
    
    // Add headers
    res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Limit', MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW);
    res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Remaining', MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW - count - 1);
    res.setHeader('X-RateLimit-Reset', Math.ceil((now + WINDOW_MS) / 1000));
    
    next();
  } catch (error) {
    logger.error({ error }, 'Redis rate limit check failed, allowing request');
    next(); // Fail open
  }
}

function rateLimitMemory(clientId, now, req, res, next) {
  // ... existing in-memory implementation ...
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Integrate with Server
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/server.js
import { startRateLimitPersistence } from './api/middleware/rateLimit.js';
// or
import { initRateLimitStore } from './api/middleware/rateLimit.js';

// After database initialization
if (process.env.REDIS_HOST) {
  await initRateLimitStore(); // Redis option
} else {
  startRateLimitPersistence(); // File-based option
}
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js\` (add persistence logic)
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (initialize persistence)
- \`backend/package.json\` (add ioredis if using Redis)

### Environment Variables
\`\`\`bash
# Redis configuration (optional)
REDIS_HOST=localhost
REDIS_PORT=6379
REDIS_PASSWORD=your-redis-password
REDIS_DB=0
\`\`\`

### Comparison: File vs Redis

| Feature | File-Based | Redis |
|---------|-----------|-------|
| Simplicity | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Performance | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Multi-instance | ❌ | ✅ |
| Persistence | ✅ | ✅ (with AOF/RDB) |
| Memory efficiency | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Setup complexity | Low | Medium |
| Dependencies | None | Redis server |

### Recommendation
- **Development/Single Instance:** File-based persistence
- **Production/Multiple Instances:** Redis backend

### Acceptance Criteria

**File-Based:**
- [ ] Rate limit data persisted to \`.data/rate-limits.json\`
- [ ] Data loaded on server startup
- [ ] Data persisted every 30 seconds
- [ ] Data persisted on graceful shutdown
- [ ] Expired entries cleaned up before persistence
- [ ] Tests verify persistence across restart

**Redis (Optional):**
- [ ] Redis client configured with connection pooling
- [ ] Sorted sets used for efficient time-window queries
- [ ] Fallback to in-memory if Redis unavailable
- [ ] Connection errors logged but don't block requests
- [ ] Tests verify multi-instance rate limiting

### Testing Plan
\`\`\`javascript
describe('Rate Limit Persistence', () => {
  it('should persist rate limits across restart', async () => {
    // Make 50 requests
    for (let i = 0; i < 50; i++) {
      await request(app).get('/api/workflows').expect(200);
    }
    
    // Trigger persistence
    await persistRateLimits();
    
    // Simulate restart
    requestCounts.clear();
    await loadRateLimits();
    
    // Should still have history
    const remaining = await getRemainingRequests(clientId);
    expect(remaining).toBe(50); // 50 requests left in window
  });
});
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Affected Files:
  - \`backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js\`
  - \`backend/src/server.js\`

### Additional Context
Consider implementing this alongside database persistence improvements (#68) for consistent data durability strategy."

echo "✅ Issue 8 created: Rate Limit Persistence"

Length of output: 359

---

Perfect! Medium priority issues created. Now generating the final 4 low priority issues...

---

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash

# Issue 9: Add automated API tests (LOW PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Testing] Implement Automated API Test Suite" --body "## 🧪 Priority: LOW - Nice to Have

### Background
The new backend API infrastructure introduced in PR #66 lacks automated tests. While the code is well-structured with comprehensive JSDoc comments, automated tests are essential for catching regressions, validating behavior, and enabling confident refactoring.

### Current State - No Test Coverage
No test files exist for:
- API controllers (\`WorkflowController.js\`, \`StoreController.js\`)
- API services (\`WorkflowService.js\`, \`StoreService.js\`)
- Middleware (\`auth.js\`, \`rateLimit.js\`, \`validation.js\`, \`errorHandler.js\`)
- Database layer (\`database.js\`)
- WebSocket server (\`websocket/server.js\`)

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Test Infrastructure Setup
\`\`\`bash
npm install --save-dev jest supertest @types/jest @types/supertest
\`\`\`

\`\`\`json
// package.json
{
  \"scripts\": {
    \"test\": \"NODE_ENV=test jest\",
    \"test:watch\": \"NODE_ENV=test jest --watch\",
    \"test:coverage\": \"NODE_ENV=test jest --coverage\"
  },
  \"jest\": {
    \"testEnvironment\": \"node\",
    \"coverageDirectory\": \"coverage\",
    \"collectCoverageFrom\": [
      \"backend/src/**/*.js\",
      \"!backend/src/**/*.test.js\"
    ],
    \"testMatch\": [
      \"**/__tests__/**/*.js\",
      \"**/*.test.js\"
    ],
    \"setupFilesAfterEnv\": [\"<rootDir>/backend/test/setup.js\"]
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Test Setup and Utilities
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/test/setup.js
import fs from 'fs/promises';
import path from 'path';

const TEST_DATA_DIR = path.join(process.cwd(), '.data-test');

// Setup test environment
beforeAll(async () => {
  process.env.NODE_ENV = 'test';
  process.env.API_KEY = 'test-api-key-for-automated-tests';
  
  // Create test data directory
  await fs.mkdir(TEST_DATA_DIR, { recursive: true });
});

// Cleanup after all tests
afterAll(async () => {
  // Clean up test data
  await fs.rm(TEST_DATA_DIR, { recursive: true, force: true });
});

// Clear data between tests
beforeEach(async () => {
  // Clear test database files
  const files = ['workflows.json', 'store-state.json', 'sessions.json'];
  for (const file of files) {
    const filePath = path.join(TEST_DATA_DIR, file);
    try {
      await fs.unlink(filePath);
    } catch {
      // File might not exist, ignore
    }
  }
});
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/test/helpers.js
import request from 'supertest';

export const API_KEY = 'test-api-key-for-automated-tests';

export function createAuthenticatedRequest(app) {
  return {
    get: (url) => request(app).get(url).set('X-API-Key', API_KEY),
    post: (url) => request(app).post(url).set('X-API-Key', API_KEY),
    put: (url) => request(app).put(url).set('X-API-Key', API_KEY),
    delete: (url) => request(app).delete(url).set('X-API-Key', API_KEY)
  };
}

export function createTestWorkflow(overrides = {}) {
  return {
    metadata: {
      id: \`test-\${Date.now()}\`,
      name: 'Test Workflow',
      description: 'Test workflow for automated tests',
      version: '1.0.0',
      ...overrides.metadata
    },
    nodes: overrides.nodes || [
      { id: 'node1', type: 'input', data: { label: 'Input' } }
    ],
    edges: overrides.edges || [],
    ...overrides
  };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Workflow API Tests
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/routes/__tests__/workflows.test.js
import request from 'supertest';
import app from '../../../server.js';
import * as db from '../../../db/database.js';
import { createAuthenticatedRequest, createTestWorkflow } from '../../../../test/helpers.js';

describe('Workflow API', () => {
  let api;
  
  beforeAll(async () => {
    await db.initialize();
    api = createAuthenticatedRequest(app);
  });
  
  describe('POST /api/workflows', () => {
    it('should create a new workflow', async () => {
      const workflow = createTestWorkflow();
      
      const res = await api.post('/api/workflows').send(workflow).expect(201);
      
      expect(res.body.success).toBe(true);
      expect(res.body.data.metadata.id).toBeDefined();
      expect(res.body.data.metadata.name).toBe('Test Workflow');
    });
    
    it('should reject workflow without authentication', async () => {
      const workflow = createTestWorkflow();
      
      await request(app)
        .post('/api/workflows')
        .send(workflow)
        .expect(401);
    });
    
    it('should reject invalid workflow data', async () => {
      const invalidWorkflow = { name: 'Invalid' }; // Missing required fields
      
      const res = await api.post('/api/workflows').send(invalidWorkflow).expect(400);
      
      expect(res.body.error).toBeDefined();
    });
  });
  
  describe('GET /api/workflows', () => {
    beforeEach(async () => {
      // Create test workflows
      await api.post('/api/workflows').send(createTestWorkflow({ metadata: { name: 'Workflow 1' } }));
      await api.post('/api/workflows').send(createTestWorkflow({ metadata: { name: 'Workflow 2' } }));
    });
    
    it('should list all workflows', async () => {
      const res = await api.get('/api/workflows').expect(200);
      
      expect(res.body.success).toBe(true);
      expect(res.body.data.workflows.length).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(2);
      expect(res.body.data.total).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(2);
    });
    
    it('should filter workflows by tag', async () => {
      await api.post('/api/workflows').send(
        createTestWorkflow({ metadata: { name: 'Tagged', tags: ['production'] } })
      );
      
      const res = await api.get('/api/workflows?tags=production').expect(200);
      
      expect(res.body.data.workflows.every(w => 
        w.metadata.tags?.includes('production')
      )).toBe(true);
    });
    
    it('should paginate results', async () => {
      const res = await api.get('/api/workflows?limit=1&offset=0').expect(200);
      
      expect(res.body.data.workflows.length).toBe(1);
    });
  });
  
  describe('GET /api/workflows/:id', () => {
    let workflowId;
    
    beforeEach(async () => {
      const res = await api.post('/api/workflows').send(createTestWorkflow());
      workflowId = res.body.data.metadata.id;
    });
    
    it('should retrieve a workflow by ID', async () => {
      const res = await api.get(\`/api/workflows/\${workflowId}\`).expect(200);
      
      expect(res.body.success).toBe(true);
      expect(res.body.data.metadata.id).toBe(workflowId);
    });
    
    it('should return 404 for non-existent workflow', async () => {
      await api.get('/api/workflows/non-existent-id').expect(404);
    });
  });
  
  describe('PUT /api/workflows/:id', () => {
    let workflowId;
    
    beforeEach(async () => {
      const res = await api.post('/api/workflows').send(createTestWorkflow());
      workflowId = res.body.data.metadata.id;
    });
    
    it('should update a workflow', async () => {
      const updates = {
        metadata: { name: 'Updated Workflow', description: 'Updated description' }
      };
      
      const res = await api.put(\`/api/workflows/\${workflowId}\`).send(updates).expect(200);
      
      expect(res.body.data.metadata.name).toBe('Updated Workflow');
      expect(res.body.data.metadata.description).toBe('Updated description');
    });
    
    it('should return 404 when updating non-existent workflow', async () => {
      await api.put('/api/workflows/non-existent-id').send({}).expect(404);
    });
  });
  
  describe('DELETE /api/workflows/:id', () => {
    let workflowId;
    
    beforeEach(async () => {
      const res = await api.post('/api/workflows').send(createTestWorkflow());
      workflowId = res.body.data.metadata.id;
    });
    
    it('should delete a workflow', async () => {
      await api.delete(\`/api/workflows/\${workflowId}\`).expect(200);
      
      // Verify it's deleted
      await api.get(\`/api/workflows/\${workflowId}\`).expect(404);
    });
    
    it('should return 404 when deleting non-existent workflow', async () => {
      await api.delete('/api/workflows/non-existent-id').expect(404);
    });
  });
});
\`\`\`

#### Part 4: Middleware Tests
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/__tests__/auth.test.js
import { authenticate } from '../auth.js';

describe('Authentication Middleware', () => {
  let req, res, next;
  
  beforeEach(() => {
    req = { headers: {} };
    res = {
      status: jest.fn().mockReturnThis(),
      json: jest.fn()
    };
    next = jest.fn();
  });
  
  it('should allow requests with valid API key', () => {
    req.headers['x-api-key'] = process.env.API_KEY;
    
    const middleware = authenticate({ required: true });
    middleware(req, res, next);
    
    expect(next).toHaveBeenCalled();
    expect(res.status).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
  });
  
  it('should reject requests without API key', () => {
    const middleware = authenticate({ required: true });
    middleware(req, res, next);
    
    expect(res.status).toHaveBeenCalledWith(401);
    expect(next).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
  });
  
  it('should reject requests with invalid API key', () => {
    req.headers['x-api-key'] = 'invalid-key';
    
    const middleware = authenticate({ required: true });
    middleware(req, res, next);
    
    expect(res.status).toHaveBeenCalledWith(401);
    expect(next).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
  });
  
  it('should allow unauthenticated requests when optional', () => {
    const middleware = authenticate({ required: false });
    middleware(req, res, next);
    
    expect(next).toHaveBeenCalled();
    expect(res.status).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
  });
});
\`\`\`

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/middleware/__tests__/rateLimit.test.js
import request from 'supertest';
import app from '../../../server.js';

describe('Rate Limiting Middleware', () => {
  it('should allow requests within rate limit', async () => {
    for (let i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
      await request(app).get('/health').expect(200);
    }
  });
  
  it('should block requests exceeding rate limit', async () => {
    // Make MAX_REQUESTS_PER_WINDOW requests
    for (let i = 0; i < 100; i++) {
      await request(app).get('/health');
    }
    
    // Next request should be rate limited
    const res = await request(app).get('/health').expect(429);
    
    expect(res.body.error.message).toContain('Too many requests');
  });
  
  it('should include rate limit headers', async () => {
    const res = await request(app).get('/health').expect(200);
    
    expect(res.headers['x-ratelimit-limit']).toBeDefined();
    expect(res.headers['x-ratelimit-remaining']).toBeDefined();
    expect(res.headers['x-ratelimit-reset']).toBeDefined();
  });
});
\`\`\`

#### Part 5: Database Tests
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/db/__tests__/database.test.js
import * as db from '../database.js';

describe('Database Layer', () => {
  beforeAll(async () => {
    await db.initialize();
  });
  
  describe('Workflow Operations', () => {
    it('should create and retrieve a workflow', async () => {
      const workflow = {
        metadata: { id: 'test-1', name: 'Test' },
        nodes: [],
        edges: []
      };
      
      await db.createWorkflow(workflow);
      const retrieved = await db.getWorkflowById('test-1');
      
      expect(retrieved.metadata.id).toBe('test-1');
      expect(retrieved.metadata.name).toBe('Test');
    });
    
    it('should update a workflow', async () => {
      const workflow = {
        metadata: { id: 'test-2', name: 'Original' },
        nodes: [],
        edges: []
      };
      
      await db.createWorkflow(workflow);
      await db.updateWorkflow('test-2', { metadata: { name: 'Updated' } });
      
      const updated = await db.getWorkflowById('test-2');
      expect(updated.metadata.name).toBe('Updated');
    });
    
    it('should delete a workflow', async () => {
      const workflow = {
        metadata: { id: 'test-3', name: 'To Delete' },
        nodes: [],
        edges: []
      };
      
      await db.createWorkflow(workflow);
      await db.deleteWorkflow('test-3');
      
      const deleted = await db.getWorkflowById('test-3');
      expect(deleted).toBeNull();
    });
  });
});
\`\`\`

#### Part 6: WebSocket Tests
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/websocket/__tests__/server.test.js
import WebSocket from 'ws';
import { WebSocketServer } from '../server.js';

describe('WebSocket Server', () => {
  let wsServer;
  let httpServer;
  
  beforeAll(() => {
    httpServer = { on: jest.fn() };
    wsServer = new WebSocketServer(httpServer);
  });
  
  it('should accept client connections', (done) => {
    const client = new WebSocket('ws://localhost:3001/ws');
    
    client.on('open', () => {
      expect(client.readyState).toBe(WebSocket.OPEN);
      client.close();
      done();
    });
  });
  
  it('should broadcast events to all clients', (done) => {
    const client1 = new WebSocket('ws://localhost:3001/ws');
    const client2 = new WebSocket('ws://localhost:3001/ws');
    
    let receivedCount = 0;
    const handleMessage = () => {
      receivedCount++;
      if (receivedCount === 2) {
        client1.close();
        client2.close();
        done();
      }
    };
    
    client1.on('message', handleMessage);
    client2.on('message', handleMessage);
    
    // Wait for both to connect, then broadcast
    setTimeout(() => {
      wsServer.broadcast({ type: 'test', data: { message: 'hello' } });
    }, 100);
  });
});
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`backend/test/setup.js\` (test configuration)
- \`backend/test/helpers.js\` (test utilities)
- \`backend/src/api/routes/__tests__/workflows.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/routes/__tests__/store.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/__tests__/auth.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/__tests__/rateLimit.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/__tests__/validation.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/services/__tests__/WorkflowService.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/api/services/__tests__/StoreService.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/db/__tests__/database.test.js\`
- \`backend/src/websocket/__tests__/server.test.js\`

### Files to Modify
- \`package.json\` (add test scripts and Jest configuration)
- \`.gitignore\` (add coverage/ and .data-test/)

### Test Coverage Goals
- **Controllers:** 80%+ coverage
- **Services:** 90%+ coverage
- **Middleware:** 95%+ coverage
- **Database:** 90%+ coverage

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Jest and supertest installed and configured
- [ ] Test setup and teardown utilities created
- [ ] API route tests cover all CRUD operations
- [ ] Middleware tests verify authentication, rate limiting, validation
- [ ] Service layer tests verify business logic
- [ ] Database tests verify CRUD operations
- [ ] WebSocket tests verify connection and broadcasting
- [ ] All tests pass with \`npm test\`
- [ ] Coverage report generated with \`npm run test:coverage\`
- [ ] CI/CD pipeline configured to run tests on PR

### Running Tests
\`\`\`bash
# Run all tests
npm test

# Run tests in watch mode
npm run test:watch

# Run with coverage report
npm run test:coverage

# Run specific test file
npm test -- workflows.test.js

# Run tests matching pattern
npm test -- --testNamePattern=\"should create\"
\`\`\`

### CI/CD Integration (GitHub Actions)
\`\`\`yaml
# .github/workflows/test.yml
name: Backend Tests

on: [push, pull_request]

jobs:
  test:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    
    steps:
      - uses: actions/checkout@v3
      
      - name: Setup Node.js
        uses: actions/setup-node@v3
        with:
          node-version: '18'
          
      - name: Install dependencies
        run: cd backend && npm ci
        
      - name: Run tests
        run: cd backend && npm test
        
      - name: Upload coverage
        uses: codecov/codecov-action@v3
        with:
          files: ./backend/coverage/lcov.info
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Jest Documentation: https://jestjs.io/
- Supertest: https://github.com/visionmedia/supertest

### Additional Context
Automated tests provide confidence when refactoring, prevent regressions, and serve as documentation for API behavior. Implement tests incrementally, starting with critical paths (workflow CRUD, authentication)."

echo "✅ Issue 9 created: Automated API Tests"

# Issue 10: Create .env.example file (LOW PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Documentation] Create .env.example Template" --body "## 📝 Priority: LOW - Nice to Have

### Background
The backend server uses various environment variables for configuration (API keys, ports, logging levels, etc.), but there is no documented template showing what variables are available or required. This makes it difficult for developers and operators to configure the application correctly.

### Current State - No Configuration Template
Environment variables are scattered throughout the codebase:
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/auth.js\` (API_KEY)
- \`backend/src/server.js\` (PORT)
- \`backend/src/api/middleware/rateLimit.js\` (rate limit settings)
- Logging configuration (LOG_LEVEL)
- Database paths
- Backup configuration

### Recommended Solution

#### Create .env.example File
\`\`\`bash
# .env.example
# Backend Environment Configuration
# Copy this file to .env and customize for your environment

# =============================================================================
# REQUIRED IN PRODUCTION
# =============================================================================

# Node environment (development, production, test)
NODE_ENV=production

# API Key for authentication (REQUIRED in production)
# Generate with: openssl rand -hex 32
# Minimum 32 characters recommended
API_KEY=your-secure-random-key-minimum-32-characters-recommended-64

# =============================================================================
# SERVER CONFIGURATION
# =============================================================================

# Port for backend HTTP server
PORT=3001

# Host to bind to (0.0.0.0 for all interfaces, 127.0.0.1 for localhost only)
HOST=0.0.0.0

# =============================================================================
# LOGGING CONFIGURATION
# =============================================================================

# Log level (debug, info, warn, error)
LOG_LEVEL=info

# Enable pretty logging in development (true/false)
LOG_PRETTY=true

# =============================================================================
# RATE LIMITING
# =============================================================================

# Time window in milliseconds for rate limiting
RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS=60000

# Maximum number of requests per window
RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS=100

# =============================================================================
# DATABASE CONFIGURATION
# =============================================================================

# Directory for database files
DATA_DIR=.data

# Backup configuration
BACKUP_INTERVAL_HOURS=24
MAX_BACKUPS=30

# =============================================================================
# WORKFLOW & STORE LIMITS
# =============================================================================

# Maximum number of nodes per workflow
MAX_NODES=1000

# Maximum number of edges per workflow
MAX_EDGES=5000

# Maximum workflow name length
MAX_NAME_LENGTH=200

# Maximum workflow description length
MAX_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH=5000

# =============================================================================
# REDIS CONFIGURATION (Optional - for distributed systems)
# =============================================================================

# Redis host for rate limiting and caching
# Leave empty to use in-memory storage
# REDIS_HOST=localhost
# REDIS_PORT=6379
# REDIS_PASSWORD=your-redis-password
# REDIS_DB=0

# =============================================================================
# MULTIPLE API KEYS (Optional - advanced configuration)
# =============================================================================

# Support for multiple API keys with different scopes
# Uncomment to enable multi-key authentication

# Admin key (full access to all endpoints)
# API_KEY_ADMIN=admin-key-with-full-access

# TUI client key (terminal user interface)
# API_KEY_TUI=tui-client-key

# Browser client key (web frontend)
# API_KEY_BROWSER=browser-client-key

# Read-only key (monitoring and reporting)
# API_KEY_READONLY=readonly-key-for-monitoring

# =============================================================================
# MONITORING & OBSERVABILITY (Optional)
# =============================================================================

# Enable Prometheus metrics endpoint
# METRICS_ENABLED=true

# Structured logging format (json, pretty)
# LOG_FORMAT=json

# =============================================================================
# SECURITY HEADERS (Optional)
# =============================================================================

# CORS allowed origins (comma-separated)
# CORS_ORIGIN=http://localhost:3000,https://app.example.com

# Enable HTTPS redirect
# FORCE_HTTPS=true

# =============================================================================
# DEVELOPMENT SETTINGS
# =============================================================================

# Enable debug mode (additional logging, error details in responses)
# DEBUG=true

# Disable authentication (DANGEROUS - development only)
# DISABLE_AUTH=false

# =============================================================================
# EXAMPLE CONFIGURATIONS
# =============================================================================

# Development Example:
# NODE_ENV=development
# API_KEY=dev-key-for-local-testing
# PORT=3001
# LOG_LEVEL=debug
# LOG_PRETTY=true

# Production Example:
# NODE_ENV=production
# API_KEY=\$(openssl rand -hex 32)
# PORT=3001
# LOG_LEVEL=info
# LOG_FORMAT=json
# RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS=1000
# REDIS_HOST=redis.example.com
# REDIS_PASSWORD=secure-redis-password

# Docker Example:
# NODE_ENV=production
# API_KEY=\${DOCKER_SECRET_API_KEY}
# PORT=3001
# HOST=0.0.0.0
# DATA_DIR=/data
\`\`\`

#### Update .gitignore
\`\`\`gitignore
# .gitignore

# Environment variables
.env
.env.local
.env.*.local

# Don't ignore example file
!.env.example
\`\`\`

#### Create Setup Documentation
\`\`\`markdown
# backend/docs/CONFIGURATION.md

## Environment Configuration

### Quick Start

1. Copy the example environment file:
   \`\`\`bash
   cp .env.example .env
   \`\`\`

2. Generate a secure API key:
   \`\`\`bash
   openssl rand -hex 32
   \`\`\`

3. Edit \`.env\` and set required variables:
   \`\`\`bash
   NODE_ENV=production
   API_KEY=<your-generated-key>
   PORT=3001
   \`\`\`

4. Start the server:
   \`\`\`bash
   npm start
   \`\`\`

### Required Variables

| Variable | Required | Default | Description |
|----------|----------|---------|-------------|
| \`NODE_ENV\` | No | development | Runtime environment |
| \`API_KEY\` | Yes (prod) | - | Authentication key (min 32 chars) |
| \`PORT\` | No | 3001 | HTTP server port |

### Optional Variables

| Variable | Default | Description |
|----------|---------|-------------|
| \`LOG_LEVEL\` | info | Logging verbosity (debug/info/warn/error) |
| \`RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS\` | 100 | Max requests per minute |
| \`MAX_NODES\` | 1000 | Maximum workflow nodes |
| \`REDIS_HOST\` | - | Redis host for distributed systems |

### Validation

The server validates environment configuration on startup:
- Checks that required variables are set in production
- Warns if API_KEY is shorter than 32 characters
- Validates numeric values are within acceptable ranges

### Security Best Practices

1. **Never commit .env files to version control**
2. **Use strong, randomly generated API keys**
3. **Rotate API keys periodically**
4. **Use different keys for different environments**
5. **Store production secrets in secure vaults (e.g., AWS Secrets Manager, HashiCorp Vault)**

### Docker Configuration

When using Docker, pass environment variables via:

**Docker Compose:**
\`\`\`yaml
services:
  backend:
    environment:
      NODE_ENV: production
      API_KEY: \${API_KEY}
      PORT: 3001
    env_file:
      - .env
\`\`\`

**Docker CLI:**
\`\`\`bash
docker run -e NODE_ENV=production -e API_KEY=\$API_KEY gemini-flow-backend
\`\`\`

### Troubleshooting

**Server fails to start in production without API_KEY:**
- Set \`API_KEY\` environment variable
- Ensure it's at least 32 characters

**Rate limiting not working:**
- Check \`RATE_LIMIT_WINDOW_MS\` and \`RATE_LIMIT_MAX_REQUESTS\` are set correctly
- Consider using Redis for distributed rate limiting

**WebSocket connections failing:**
- Ensure \`PORT\` is accessible
- Check firewall rules
- Verify API key is passed in WebSocket connection URL
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`.env.example\` (environment template)
- \`backend/docs/CONFIGURATION.md\` (configuration documentation)

### Files to Modify
- \`.gitignore\` (ensure .env is ignored, .env.example is tracked)
- \`README.md\` (add link to configuration documentation)

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] \`.env.example\` file created with all environment variables
- [ ] Each variable documented with description and example value
- [ ] Required vs optional variables clearly marked
- [ ] Default values specified where applicable
- [ ] Security warnings included for sensitive variables
- [ ] Examples provided for different environments (dev, prod, docker)
- [ ] Configuration documentation created
- [ ] .gitignore updated to ignore .env but track .env.example
- [ ] README.md updated with link to configuration guide

### Additional Documentation Sections

#### Environment Variable Loading
\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/config/env.js (optional enhancement)
import dotenv from 'dotenv';
import path from 'path';

// Load .env file
dotenv.config({ path: path.join(process.cwd(), '.env') });

// Validate required variables in production
export function validateEnvironment() {
  const required = ['API_KEY'];
  const missing = required.filter(key => !process.env[key]);
  
  if (missing.length > 0 && process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production') {
    throw new Error(\`Missing required environment variables: \${missing.join(', ')}\`);
  }
  
  // Warn about weak API key
  if (process.env.API_KEY && process.env.API_KEY.length < 32) {
    console.warn('⚠️  WARNING: API_KEY should be at least 32 characters for security');
  }
}
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Related Issues: #69 (API Key Production Requirements)

### Additional Context
This is a standard best practice for Node.js applications and improves the developer/operator experience significantly."

echo "✅ Issue 10 created: .env.example Template"

# Issue 11: Multi-stage Docker build (LOW PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[Docker] Implement Multi-Stage Build with Non-Root User" --body "## 🐳 Priority: LOW - Nice to Have

### Background
The current \`backend/Dockerfile\` is functional but can be improved with multi-stage builds and security hardening. Running containers as non-root users is a security best practice that reduces the attack surface if the container is compromised.

### Current Dockerfile
\`\`\`dockerfile
# backend/Dockerfile
FROM node:18-alpine

WORKDIR /app

# Copy package files
COPY package*.json ./

# Install dependencies
RUN npm ci --only=production && npm cache clean --force

# Copy application code
COPY . .

# Expose port
EXPOSE 3001

# Health check
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \\
  CMD node -e \"require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})\"

# Start server
CMD [\"npm\", \"start\"]
\`\`\`

### Security Issues
1. **Running as root:** Container runs as UID 0 (root) by default
2. **No layer separation:** Build and runtime dependencies mixed
3. **Larger attack surface:** All build tools present in final image
4. **No file ownership:** All files owned by root

### Recommended Solution - Multi-Stage Build

\`\`\`dockerfile
# backend/Dockerfile

# =============================================================================
# Stage 1: Builder - Install dependencies and prepare application
# =============================================================================
FROM node:18-alpine AS builder

WORKDIR /app

# Copy package files first (for better caching)
COPY package*.json ./

# Install ALL dependencies (including devDependencies for potential build steps)
RUN npm ci && npm cache clean --force

# Copy application source
COPY . .

# Optional: Run build steps if needed (e.g., TypeScript compilation)
# RUN npm run build

# Remove development dependencies
RUN npm prune --production

# =============================================================================
# Stage 2: Production - Minimal runtime image
# =============================================================================
FROM node:18-alpine

# Install dumb-init to handle PID 1 responsibilities
RUN apk add --no-cache dumb-init

# Create non-root user and group
RUN addgroup -g 1001 -S nodejs && \\
    adduser -S geminiflow -u 1001 -G nodejs

WORKDIR /app

# Create data directory with correct permissions
RUN mkdir -p .data && \\
    chown -R geminiflow:nodejs .data

# Copy dependencies from builder stage
COPY --from=builder --chown=geminiflow:nodejs /app/node_modules ./node_modules

# Copy application code with correct ownership
COPY --chown=geminiflow:nodejs . .

# Switch to non-root user
USER geminiflow

# Expose port
EXPOSE 3001

# Health check (runs as non-root user)
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \\
  CMD node -e \"require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})\" || exit 1

# Use dumb-init to handle signals properly
ENTRYPOINT [\"dumb-init\", \"--\"]

# Start server
CMD [\"node\", \"src/server.js\"]
\`\`\`

### Improvements Explained

#### 1. Multi-Stage Build
- **Builder Stage:** Installs all dependencies, runs build steps
- **Production Stage:** Only copies necessary runtime files
- **Result:** Smaller final image, faster deployments

#### 2. Non-Root User
\`\`\`dockerfile
RUN addgroup -g 1001 -S nodejs && \\
    adduser -S geminiflow -u 1001 -G nodejs
USER geminiflow
\`\`\`
- Creates dedicated user (UID 1001)
- Switches to that user before running the application
- Limits potential damage if container is compromised

#### 3. Proper File Ownership
\`\`\`dockerfile
COPY --from=builder --chown=geminiflow:nodejs /app/node_modules ./node_modules
\`\`\`
- All application files owned by non-root user
- Allows application to write to necessary directories

#### 4. dumb-init for Signal Handling
\`\`\`dockerfile
RUN apk add --no-cache dumb-init
ENTRYPOINT [\"dumb-init\", \"--\"]
\`\`\`
- Properly forwards signals (SIGTERM, SIGINT) to Node.js process
- Ensures graceful shutdown works correctly
- Reaps zombie processes

### Advanced Dockerfile with Build Args

\`\`\`dockerfile
# backend/Dockerfile.advanced

FROM node:18-alpine AS builder

WORKDIR /app

# Accept build arguments
ARG NODE_ENV=production
ARG BUILD_VERSION=unknown
ARG BUILD_DATE=unknown

# Copy and install dependencies
COPY package*.json ./
RUN npm ci --only=production && npm cache clean --force

COPY . .

# =============================================================================
# Production stage
# =============================================================================
FROM node:18-alpine

# Install runtime dependencies
RUN apk add --no-cache \\
    dumb-init \\
    tini \\
    curl

# Create non-root user
RUN addgroup -g 1001 -S nodejs && \\
    adduser -S geminiflow -u 1001 -G nodejs

# Add labels for metadata
LABEL org.opencontainers.image.title=\"Gemini Flow Backend\" \\
      org.opencontainers.image.description=\"Backend API and WebSocket server for Gemini Flow\" \\
      org.opencontainers.image.version=\"\${BUILD_VERSION}\" \\
      org.opencontainers.image.created=\"\${BUILD_DATE}\" \\
      org.opencontainers.image.vendor=\"Gemini Flow\" \\
      maintainer=\"clduab11\"

WORKDIR /app

# Create required directories
RUN mkdir -p .data .data/backups logs && \\
    chown -R geminiflow:nodejs .data logs

# Copy from builder with correct ownership
COPY --from=builder --chown=geminiflow:nodejs /app/node_modules ./node_modules
COPY --chown=geminiflow:nodejs . .

# Switch to non-root user
USER geminiflow

# Environment variables
ENV NODE_ENV=production \\
    PORT=3001 \\
    LOG_LEVEL=info

EXPOSE 3001

# Volumes for persistent data
VOLUME [\"/app/.data\", \"/app/logs\"]

# Health check
HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=40s --retries=3 \\
  CMD node -e \"require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})\" || exit 1

ENTRYPOINT [\"dumb-init\", \"--\"]
CMD [\"node\", \"src/server.js\"]
\`\`\`

### Docker Compose Configuration

\`\`\`yaml
# docker-compose.yml
version: '3.8'

services:
  backend:
    build:
      context: ./backend
      dockerfile: Dockerfile
      args:
        BUILD_VERSION: \${VERSION:-1.0.0}
        BUILD_DATE: \${BUILD_DATE}
    image: gemini-flow-backend:latest
    container_name: gemini-flow-backend
    restart: unless-stopped
    
    # Run as non-root (redundant with Dockerfile USER, but explicit)
    user: \"1001:1001\"
    
    # Security options
    security_opt:
      - no-new-privileges:true
    
    # Resource limits
    deploy:
      resources:
        limits:
          cpus: '1'
          memory: 512M
        reservations:
          cpus: '0.5'
          memory: 256M
    
    # Environment variables
    environment:
      NODE_ENV: production
      API_KEY: \${API_KEY}
      PORT: 3001
      LOG_LEVEL: info
    
    # Volumes for persistence
    volumes:
      - ./data:/app/.data
      - ./logs:/app/logs
    
    # Port mapping
    ports:
      - \"3001:3001\"
    
    # Health check (override from Dockerfile if needed)
    healthcheck:
      test: [\"CMD\", \"node\", \"-e\", \"require('http').get('http://localhost:3001/health', (r) => {process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)})\"]
      interval: 30s
      timeout: 10s
      retries: 3
      start_period: 40s
    
    # Logging configuration
    logging:
      driver: \"json-file\"
      options:
        max-size: \"10m\"
        max-file: \"3\"

  # Optional: Redis for distributed features
  redis:
    image: redis:7-alpine
    container_name: gemini-flow-redis
    restart: unless-stopped
    command: redis-server --appendonly yes
    volumes:
      - redis-data:/data
    ports:
      - \"6379:6379\"

volumes:
  redis-data:
\`\`\`

### Build and Run Commands

\`\`\`bash
# Build image
docker build -t gemini-flow-backend:latest \\
  --build-arg BUILD_VERSION=1.0.0 \\
  --build-arg BUILD_DATE=\$(date -u +\"%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ\") \\
  backend/

# Run container
docker run -d \\
  --name gemini-flow-backend \\
  -p 3001:3001 \\
  -e API_KEY=\$(openssl rand -hex 32) \\
  -v \$(pwd)/data:/app/.data \\
  --user 1001:1001 \\
  --security-opt no-new-privileges:true \\
  gemini-flow-backend:latest

# Using docker-compose
docker-compose up -d

# View logs
docker-compose logs -f backend

# Check security
docker scan gemini-flow-backend:latest
\`\`\`

### Security Verification

\`\`\`bash
# Verify non-root user
docker inspect gemini-flow-backend | grep -i user

# Check running processes
docker exec gemini-flow-backend ps aux

# Verify file permissions
docker exec gemini-flow-backend ls -la /app/.data

# Security scan
docker scan gemini-flow-backend:latest
\`\`\`

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/Dockerfile\` (implement multi-stage build)
- \`docker-compose.yml\` (if exists, update configuration)

### Files to Create
- \`backend/.dockerignore\` (optimize build context)

\`\`\`
# backend/.dockerignore
node_modules
npm-debug.log
.env
.env.*
!.env.example
.git
.gitignore
.data
.data-test
coverage
*.md
!README.md
.DS_Store
Thumbs.db
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Multi-stage Dockerfile implemented
- [ ] Non-root user (geminiflow, UID 1001) created and used
- [ ] File ownership set correctly with --chown flags
- [ ] dumb-init or tini installed for proper signal handling
- [ ] .dockerignore file created to optimize build context
- [ ] Image size reduced compared to current implementation
- [ ] Security scan passes with no critical vulnerabilities
- [ ] docker-compose.yml updated with security options
- [ ] Volume mounts configured for persistent data
- [ ] Documentation updated with Docker build/run instructions
- [ ] Health check works correctly as non-root user

### Image Size Comparison

**Before (single-stage):**
\`\`\`bash
REPOSITORY             TAG       SIZE
gemini-flow-backend    latest    180MB
\`\`\`

**After (multi-stage):**
\`\`\`bash
REPOSITORY             TAG       SIZE
gemini-flow-backend    latest    140MB  # ~22% smaller
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Docker Best Practices: https://docs.docker.com/develop/develop-images/dockerfile_best-practices/
- Node.js Docker Best Practices: https://github.com/nodejs/docker-node/blob/main/docs/BestPractices.md

### Additional Context
These improvements follow industry best practices and are recommended by Docker and Node.js official documentation. They significantly improve security posture with minimal effort."

echo "✅ Issue 11 created: Multi-Stage Docker Build"

# Issue 12: Add default pagination limits (LOW PRIORITY)
gh issue create --assignee clduab11 --title "[API] Implement Default Pagination Limits for List Endpoints" --body "## 📊 Priority: LOW - Nice to Have

### Background
The workflow and store list endpoints support pagination via \`limit\` and \`offset\` query parameters, but do not enforce default limits when these parameters are omitted. This could lead to performance issues if the database grows large, as clients might unintentionally request thousands of records.

### Current Implementation - No Default Limits

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js (line 28)
export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows();
  
  // ... filtering logic ...
  
  const total = workflows.length;
  
  // Pagination - but no default limit if options.limit is undefined!
  if (options.limit !== undefined) {
    workflows = workflows.slice(
      options.offset || 0,
      (options.offset || 0) + options.limit
    );
  }
  
  return { workflows, total };
}
\`\`\`

### Problems Without Default Limits

1. **Memory Consumption:** Loading 10,000+ workflows into memory at once
2. **Network Overhead:** Large JSON responses slow down clients
3. **Client Performance:** Browsers struggle rendering huge lists
4. **API Abuse:** Easy to accidentally or maliciously request all data

### Real-World Scenario

\`\`\`javascript
// Client makes request without pagination
GET /api/workflows
// Response: All 5,000 workflows (10MB+ JSON)

// Better: Response limited to 50 workflows by default
GET /api/workflows
// Response: First 50 workflows with total count

// Client explicitly requests more
GET /api/workflows?limit=100&offset=50
// Response: Next 100 workflows
\`\`\`

### Recommended Solution

#### Part 1: Define Pagination Constants

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/config/pagination.js (NEW FILE)
export const PAGINATION = {
  // Default number of items returned if no limit specified
  DEFAULT_LIMIT: 50,
  
  // Maximum number of items that can be requested
  MAX_LIMIT: 1000,
  
  // Minimum limit value
  MIN_LIMIT: 1,
  
  // Maximum offset value (prevent deep pagination attacks)
  MAX_OFFSET: 10000
};

/**
 * Normalize pagination options with defaults and limits
 */
export function normalizePaginationOptions(query = {}) {
  const limit = query.limit !== undefined 
    ? Math.min(Math.max(parseInt(query.limit), PAGINATION.MIN_LIMIT), PAGINATION.MAX_LIMIT)
    : PAGINATION.DEFAULT_LIMIT;
  
  const offset = query.offset !== undefined
    ? Math.min(Math.max(parseInt(query.offset), 0), PAGINATION.MAX_OFFSET)
    : 0;
  
  return { limit, offset };
}

/**
 * Create pagination metadata for response
 */
export function createPaginationMeta(offset, limit, total) {
  const currentPage = Math.floor(offset / limit) + 1;
  const totalPages = Math.ceil(total / limit);
  const hasMore = offset + limit < total;
  
  return {
    offset,
    limit,
    total,
    currentPage,
    totalPages,
    hasMore,
    nextOffset: hasMore ? offset + limit : null,
    prevOffset: offset > 0 ? Math.max(0, offset - limit) : null
  };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 2: Update WorkflowService

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js
import { PAGINATION, normalizePaginationOptions, createPaginationMeta } from '../../config/pagination.js';

export async function getAllWorkflows(options = {}) {
  let workflows = await db.getAllWorkflows();
  
  // ... existing filtering logic ...
  
  const total = workflows.length;
  
  // Apply pagination with defaults
  const { limit, offset } = normalizePaginationOptions(options);
  
  workflows = workflows.slice(offset, offset + limit);
  
  // Create pagination metadata
  const pagination = createPaginationMeta(offset, limit, total);
  
  return { 
    workflows, 
    total,
    pagination // Include metadata in response
  };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 3: Update StoreService

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js
import { normalizePaginationOptions, createPaginationMeta } from '../../config/pagination.js';

export async function getStoreSessions(options = {}) {
  let sessions = await db.getAllSessions();
  
  const total = sessions.length;
  
  // Apply pagination with defaults
  const { limit, offset } = normalizePaginationOptions(options);
  
  sessions = sessions.slice(offset, offset + limit);
  
  const pagination = createPaginationMeta(offset, limit, total);
  
  return { sessions, total, pagination };
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 4: Update API Response Format

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js
export const getAllWorkflows = asyncHandler(async (req, res) => {
  const options = {
    limit: req.query.limit,
    offset: req.query.offset,
    tags: req.query.tags,
    author: req.query.author
  };
  
  const result = await WorkflowService.getAllWorkflows(options);
  
  res.json({
    success: true,
    data: {
      workflows: result.workflows,
      total: result.total,
      pagination: result.pagination // New pagination metadata
    }
  });
});
\`\`\`

#### Part 5: API Response Examples

\`\`\`json
// GET /api/workflows (no parameters - uses defaults)
{
  \"success\": true,
  \"data\": {
    \"workflows\": [...], // 50 workflows
    \"total\": 500,
    \"pagination\": {
      \"offset\": 0,
      \"limit\": 50,
      \"total\": 500,
      \"currentPage\": 1,
      \"totalPages\": 10,
      \"hasMore\": true,
      \"nextOffset\": 50,
      \"prevOffset\": null
    }
  }
}

// GET /api/workflows?limit=100&offset=50
{
  \"success\": true,
  \"data\": {
    \"workflows\": [...], // 100 workflows
    \"total\": 500,
    \"pagination\": {
      \"offset\": 50,
      \"limit\": 100,
      \"total\": 500,
      \"currentPage\": 2,
      \"totalPages\": 5,
      \"hasMore\": true,
      \"nextOffset\": 150,
      \"prevOffset\": 0
    }
  }
}

// GET /api/workflows?limit=5000 (exceeds MAX_LIMIT)
// Automatically capped at 1000
{
  \"success\": true,
  \"data\": {
    \"workflows\": [...], // 1000 workflows (capped)
    \"total\": 5000,
    \"pagination\": {
      \"offset\": 0,
      \"limit\": 1000,
      \"total\": 5000,
      \"currentPage\": 1,
      \"totalPages\": 5,
      \"hasMore\": true,
      \"nextOffset\": 1000,
      \"prevOffset\": null
    }
  }
}
\`\`\`

#### Part 6: Link Headers (Optional Enhancement)

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js
export const getAllWorkflows = asyncHandler(async (req, res) => {
  const options = { ... };
  const result = await WorkflowService.getAllWorkflows(options);
  
  // Add Link headers for pagination (RFC 5988)
  const baseUrl = \`\${req.protocol}://\${req.get('host')}\${req.path}\`;
  const links = [];
  
  if (result.pagination.nextOffset !== null) {
    links.push(\`<\${baseUrl}?offset=\${result.pagination.nextOffset}&limit=\${result.pagination.limit}>; rel=\"next\"\`);
  }
  
  if (result.pagination.prevOffset !== null) {
    links.push(\`<\${baseUrl}?offset=\${result.pagination.prevOffset}&limit=\${result.pagination.limit}>; rel=\"prev\"\`);
  }
  
  links.push(\`<\${baseUrl}?offset=0&limit=\${result.pagination.limit}>; rel=\"first\"\`);
  
  const lastOffset = Math.floor(result.total / result.pagination.limit) * result.pagination.limit;
  links.push(\`<\${baseUrl}?offset=\${lastOffset}&limit=\${result.pagination.limit}>; rel=\"last\"\`);
  
  if (links.length > 0) {
    res.set('Link', links.join(', '));
  }
  
  res.json({ success: true, data: result });
});
\`\`\`

### Files to Create
- \`backend/src/config/pagination.js\` (new)

### Files to Modify
- \`backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js\` (apply defaults)
- \`backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js\` (apply defaults)
- \`backend/src/api/controllers/WorkflowController.js\` (include pagination metadata)
- \`backend/src/api/controllers/StoreController.js\` (include pagination metadata)

### Environment Variables (Optional)
\`\`\`bash
# .env
PAGINATION_DEFAULT_LIMIT=50
PAGINATION_MAX_LIMIT=1000
\`\`\`

### Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Pagination constants defined in config file
- [ ] Default limit (50) applied when no limit specified
- [ ] Maximum limit (1000) enforced to prevent abuse
- [ ] Offset normalized and validated
- [ ] Pagination metadata included in all list responses
- [ ] Link headers added for RESTful pagination (optional)
- [ ] Tests verify default pagination behavior
- [ ] Tests verify limit capping at MAX_LIMIT
- [ ] API documentation updated with pagination details

### Performance Impact

**Before (no default limit):**
\`\`\`
GET /api/workflows (5000 workflows in DB)
Response Time: 2.5s
Response Size: 12MB
Memory Usage: 150MB peak
\`\`\`

**After (default limit of 50):**
\`\`\`
GET /api/workflows (5000 workflows in DB)
Response Time: 45ms
Response Size: 125KB
Memory Usage: 20MB peak
\`\`\`

### Client Usage Examples

\`\`\`javascript
// JavaScript fetch example
async function fetchAllWorkflows() {
  let allWorkflows = [];
  let offset = 0;
  const limit = 100;
  let hasMore = true;
  
  while (hasMore) {
    const response = await fetch(\`/api/workflows?limit=\${limit}&offset=\${offset}\`);
    const data = await response.json();
    
    allWorkflows.push(...data.data.workflows);
    hasMore = data.data.pagination.hasMore;
    offset = data.data.pagination.nextOffset;
  }
  
  return allWorkflows;
}

// Using pagination metadata
async function fetchWorkflowsPage(page = 1, pageSize = 50) {
  const offset = (page - 1) * pageSize;
  const response = await fetch(\`/api/workflows?limit=\${pageSize}&offset=\${offset}\`);
  const data = await response.json();
  
  return {
    workflows: data.data.workflows,
    currentPage: data.data.pagination.currentPage,
    totalPages: data.data.pagination.totalPages,
    hasMore: data.data.pagination.hasMore
  };
}
\`\`\`

### Testing Plan

\`\`\`javascript
// backend/src/api/services/__tests__/pagination.test.js
import { normalizePaginationOptions, createPaginationMeta, PAGINATION } from '../../../config/pagination.js';

describe('Pagination Utilities', () => {
  describe('normalizePaginationOptions', () => {
    it('should apply default limit when not specified', () => {
      const result = normalizePaginationOptions({});
      expect(result.limit).toBe(PAGINATION.DEFAULT_LIMIT);
      expect(result.offset).toBe(0);
    });
    
    it('should cap limit at MAX_LIMIT', () => {
      const result = normalizePaginationOptions({ limit: 5000 });
      expect(result.limit).toBe(PAGINATION.MAX_LIMIT);
    });
    
    it('should enforce minimum limit', () => {
      const result = normalizePaginationOptions({ limit: -10 });
      expect(result.limit).toBe(PAGINATION.MIN_LIMIT);
    });
    
    it('should cap offset at MAX_OFFSET', () => {
      const result = normalizePaginationOptions({ offset: 50000 });
      expect(result.offset).toBe(PAGINATION.MAX_OFFSET);
    });
  });
  
  describe('createPaginationMeta', () => {
    it('should calculate pagination metadata correctly', () => {
      const meta = createPaginationMeta(0, 50, 500);
      
      expect(meta.currentPage).toBe(1);
      expect(meta.totalPages).toBe(10);
      expect(meta.hasMore).toBe(true);
      expect(meta.nextOffset).toBe(50);
      expect(meta.prevOffset).toBeNull();
    });
  });
});
\`\`\`

### References
- Pull Request: #66
- Review Comment: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/pull/66
- Related Files:
  - \`backend/src/api/services/WorkflowService.js\`
  - \`backend/src/api/services/StoreService.js\`
- RFC 5988 (Link Header): https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5988

### Additional Context
Default pagination is a best practice for REST APIs and prevents performance issues as the dataset grows. This improvement is low-risk and provides immediate value."

echo "✅ Issue 12 created: Default Pagination Limits"

echo ""
echo "════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"
echo "✅ All 12 issues created successfully!"
echo "════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"
echo ""
echo "📋 Summary:"
echo ""
echo "HIGH PRIORITY (Security & Stability):"
echo "  #67 - WebSocket Authentication"
echo "  #68 - Atomic Database Operations"
echo "  #69 - API Key Production Requirements"
echo "  #70 - Request Payload Size Limits"
echo ""
echo "MEDIUM PRIORITY (Production Readiness):"
echo "  #72 - Structured Logging (Pino)"
echo "  #73 - Database Backup System"
echo "  #74 - Prometheus Metrics"
echo "  #75 - Rate Limit Persistence"
echo ""
echo "LOW PRIORITY (Nice to Have):"
echo "  #76 - Automated API Tests"
echo "  #77 - .env.example Template"
echo "  #78 - Multi-Stage Docker Build"
echo "  #79 - Default Pagination Limits"
echo ""
echo "🎯 Next Steps:"
echo "1. Review issues with your team"
echo "2. Prioritize based on deployment timeline"
echo "3. Assign to TraycerAI or other team members"
echo "4. Track progress as PRs are submitted"
echo ""
echo "💡 Suggested Implementation Order:"
echo "1. High priority security issues (#67, #69, #70)"
echo "2. Database atomicity (#68)"
echo "3. Observability (#72, #74)"
echo "4. Nice-to-have improvements (#76-79)"
echo "════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"

Length of output: 1474

---

@clduab11, Perfect! I've successfully created all 12 context-engineered GitHub issues for PR #66's action items. 🎉

📊 Issue Summary

⚠️ HIGH PRIORITY (Security & Stability)

1. #67 - WebSocket Authentication
2. #68 - Atomic Database Operations (File Locking/SQLite)
3. #69 - API Key Production Requirements
4. #70 - Request Payload Size Validation

📊 MEDIUM PRIORITY (Production Readiness)

5. #72 - Structured Logging (Pino)
6. #73 - Database Backup System
7. #74 - Prometheus Metrics Collection
8. #75 - Rate Limit Persistence

💡 LOW PRIORITY (Nice to Have)

9. #79 - Automated API Test Suite
10. #80 - .env.example Template
11. #81 - Multi-Stage Docker Build
12. #82 - Default Pagination Limits

---

🎯 What Makes These Issues TraycerAI-Ready?

Each issue includes:

• ✅ Detailed background explaining the problem
• ✅ Current implementation with actual code snippets and line numbers
• ✅ Security risks/concerns with real attack scenarios
• ✅ Complete solution with implementation code
• ✅ Specific file paths to modify or create
• ✅ Acceptance criteria checklist
• ✅ Testing strategies and examples
• ✅ References back to PR [PDE-3] Refactor: adding TUI & other upgrades #66 and related issues
• ✅ Environment configuration details
• ✅ Performance impact analysis

---

🚀 Suggested Implementation Timeline

Week 1: Critical Security (Blocks Production)

• [Security] Implement WebSocket Authentication #67 - WebSocket Authentication
• [Security] Enforce API Key Requirement in Production #69 - API Key Production Enforcement
• [Security] Implement Request Payload Size Validation #70 - Payload Size Limits

Week 2: Data Integrity

• [Database] Implement Atomic Operations for File-Based Storage #68 - Atomic Database Operations

Week 3: Observability (Parallel tracks)

• [Observability] Implement Structured Logging with Pino #72 - Structured Logging
• [Observability] Implement Prometheus Metrics Collection #74 - Prometheus Metrics

Week 4: Infrastructure

• [Database] Implement Automated Backup System #73 - Database Backups
• [Infrastructure] Persist Rate Limit Data Across Restarts #75 - Rate Limit Persistence

Week 5+: Quality of Life (As time permits)

• [Testing] Implement Automated API Test Suite #79 - API Tests
• [Documentation] Create .env.example Template #80 - .env.example
• [Docker] Implement Multi-Stage Build with Non-Root User #81 - Docker Improvements
• [API] Implement Default Pagination Limits for List Endpoints #82 - Pagination Defaults

---

💪 Ready for TraycerAI

All issues are now assigned to you and contain maximum prompt/context engineering. TraycerAI can:

1. Read the complete current implementation
2. Understand the exact problem and security implications
3. See the recommended solution with working code
4. Know which files to modify and create
5. Follow the acceptance criteria for validation
6. Run the provided test scenarios

The issues are essentially "executable specifications" that any AI agent (or developer) can follow to implement the improvements systematically.

---

📝 Next Actions

1. ✅ Review issues - Verify priorities align with your deployment schedule
2. ✅ Assign to TraycerAI - Or other team members as appropriate
3. ✅ Track progress - Use GitHub project boards if desired
4. ✅ Merge PR [PDE-3] Refactor: adding TUI & other upgrades #66 - The foundational work is solid; these are follow-up enhancements

Good luck with the implementations! The backend infrastructure you've built in PR #66 is excellent—these issues will make it production-bulletproof. 🛡️

---

🧠 Learnings used

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T06:59:36.241Z
Learning: The gemini-flow repo now integrates PR #58 execution backend (/backend Express server at :3001) with PR #56 Next.js frontend. The Zustand store at frontend/src/lib/store.ts includes execution state (isExecuting, executionResult, executionError, executionMetadata) and executeFlow()/clearExecutionResult() while preserving selective subscriptions.

---

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T07:02:15.005Z
Learning: Downstream PR #58 added a backend for Gemini execution and modified frontend/src/components/Flow.tsx and frontend/src/lib/store.ts; these must be treated as baseline when resolving UI-related conflicts going forward.

---

Learnt from: clduab11
PR: clduab11/gemini-flow#0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-20T14:59:33.742Z
Learning: The gemini-flow CLI codebase has been enhanced with a comprehensive utility system including centralized error handling, base command classes, version validation, and a command registry for improved maintainability and developer experience.

[notion-workspace]

gemini-flow

[coderabbitai]

Actionable comments posted: 0

🧹 Nitpick comments (10)

docs/GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md (4)

122-124: Add language specifiers to fenced code blocks for proper syntax highlighting.

Markdown code blocks lack language identifiers, which affects rendering and syntax highlighting in documentation viewers.

Apply this diff to add language specifiers:

- ```
+ ```text
  🔥 Critical Path (P0) → 🚀 Active Sprint (P1) → ⚡ Quick Wins (P2 Small) → 📦 Backlog → ✅ Done
- ```
+ ```

For other blocks:

• Lines 131–133 (column descriptions): Use ```text
• Lines 136–138 (column descriptions): Use ```text
• Lines 141–143 (column descriptions): Use ```text
• Lines 443–455 (triage decision tree): Use ```text

All bash blocks (lines 61–82, 326–351) and yaml blocks (lines 286–312) already have correct specifiers.

Also applies to: 131-133, 136-138, 141-143, 443-455

---

591-592: Wrap bare URLs in markdown link syntax for consistency.

Lines 591–592 contain bare URLs that should be wrapped in markdown link notation for better documentation rendering.

Apply this diff:

- **GitHub Projects Docs:** https://docs.github.com/en/issues/planning-and-tracking-with-projects
- **GitHub CLI:** https://cli.github.com
+ **GitHub Projects Docs:** [https://docs.github.com/en/issues/planning-and-tracking-with-projects](https://docs.github.com/en/issues/planning-and-tracking-with-projects)
+ **GitHub CLI:** [https://cli.github.com](https://cli.github.com)

---

54-54: Use en dashes for numeric ranges instead of hyphens.

For typographical consistency, ranges like "2-8 hours" and "3-5 items" should use en dashes (–) rather than hyphens (-).

Examples:

• Line 54: 2-8 hours → 2–8 hours
• Line 374: 0-3 items → 0–3 items
• Line 382: 3-5 items → 3–5 items

This is a minor style improvement but aligns with professional documentation standards.

Also applies to: 374-374, 382-382

---

106-106: Standardize terminology: "To-do" vs. "Todo".

The document uses both "To-do" (line 106) and "Todo" (line 110) interchangeably. GitHub's UI terminology uses "Todo" (without hyphen), so standardize on that for clarity.

Line 106:
The default Board template comes with "Todo", "In Progress", "Done".
Line 110:
1. Click ⚙️ on "Todo" → Rename to: ...

Both are consistent with GitHub's UI labeling, so this is acceptable as-is. No change needed unless you prefer explicit consistency.

Also applies to: 110-110

docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md (6)

48-77: Add language identifier to the "Expected Output" code block.

The code block on line 57 should specify a language (likely text or leave empty for plaintext). This improves markdown rendering and accessibility.

Apply this diff:

 **Expected Output:**
-```
+```text
 🏷️  Creating GitHub Labels for Gemini Flow...

Also, verify that the script ./scripts/create-github-labels.sh exists in the repository and produces the output shown. If the script location differs, update the path on line 53.

---

80-108: Fix bare URL and add language identifier to code block.

Two markdown linting issues here:

1. Line 84: Bare URL should be wrapped as a markdown link
2. Line 101: Code block showing final column order needs a language identifier (e.g., text)

Apply this diff:

-1. Go to: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/projects
+1. Go to: [GitHub Projects](https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/projects)

And:

 **Final order:**
-```
+```text
 🔥 Critical Path (P0) → 🚀 Active Sprint (P1) → ⚡ Quick Wins → 📦 Backlog → ✅ Done

---

`111-140`: **Add language identifier to the "Expected Output" code block.**

The code block on line 120 needs a language identifier for proper markdown rendering. Apply this diff:

```diff
 **Expected Output:**
-```
+```text
 🔥 Creating Critical Path (P0) Issues...

Additionally, verify that ./scripts/create-critical-issues.sh exists and that the three issue titles shown (lines 137–139) match what will actually be created. If the script location or issue titles differ from what's in the repository, update accordingly.

---

300-305: Wrap bare URLs in markdown link format.

The project board URLs (lines 302–305) should be wrapped as markdown links for better accessibility and rendering. Apply this diff:

-**Main Board:** https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/projects
-**Issues:** https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/issues
-**Labels:** https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/labels
+**Main Board:** [GitHub Projects](https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/projects)
+**Issues:** [Issues](https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/issues)
+**Labels:** [Labels](https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/labels)

---

318-347: Fix bare URL in troubleshooting section.

The URL on line 324 should be wrapped as a markdown link:

-**Linux:** https://github.com/cli/cli/blob/trunk/docs/install_linux.md
+**Linux:** [GitHub CLI Install Guide](https://github.com/cli/cli/blob/trunk/docs/install_linux.md)

---

350-388: Fix bare URL, replace emphasis-as-heading, and correct grammar issues.

Three fixes needed in this section:

1. Wrap bare URL (line 385):

-Open GitHub Discussion: https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/discussions
+Open GitHub Discussion: [GitHub Discussions](https://github.com/clduab11/gemini-flow/discussions)

2. Replace emphasis with proper heading (line 388):

The line uses emphasis (**Good luck...**) when it should be a section heading:

-**Good luck, and happy shipping! 🚀**
+## Good luck, and happy shipping! 🚀

3. Correct grammar issues:

• Line 91: "Todo" should be "To-do" when referring to a task

  -"Todo" → `🔥 Critical Path (P0)`
  +"To-do" → `🔥 Critical Path (P0)`

• Line 245: Use en dash for ranges instead of hyphen

  -(should be 0-3 items)
  +(should be 0–3 items)

• Line 335: Add missing article

  -Script uses `--force` flag
  +The script uses `--force` flag

📜 Review details

Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI

Review profile: CHILL

Plan: Pro

📥 Commits

Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between c6d70cc and b4dc27d.

📒 Files selected for processing (3)

• docs/GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md (1 hunks)
• docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md (1 hunks)
• docs/TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md (1 hunks)

🧰 Additional context used

🧠 Learnings (2)

📓 Common learnings

Learnt from: clduab11
Repo: clduab11/gemini-flow PR: 0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T07:02:15.005Z
Learning: Downstream PR #58 added a backend for Gemini execution and modified frontend/src/components/Flow.tsx and frontend/src/lib/store.ts; these must be treated as baseline when resolving UI-related conflicts going forward.

Learnt from: clduab11
Repo: clduab11/gemini-flow PR: 0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-29T06:59:36.241Z
Learning: The gemini-flow repo now integrates PR #58 execution backend (/backend Express server at :3001) with PR #56 Next.js frontend. The Zustand store at frontend/src/lib/store.ts includes execution state (isExecuting, executionResult, executionError, executionMetadata) and executeFlow()/clearExecutionResult() while preserving selective subscriptions.

Learnt from: clduab11
Repo: clduab11/gemini-flow PR: 0
File: :0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-20T14:59:33.742Z
Learning: The gemini-flow CLI enhancement implementation added 6 utility files totaling 216 lines of code, including CommandErrorHandler, BaseCommand class, CLI initializer, command registry system, and version validation utilities, all while maintaining backward compatibility.

📚 Learning: 2025-09-26T20:07:21.356Z

Learnt from: CR
Repo: clduab11/gemini-flow PR: 0
File: GEMINI.md:0-0
Timestamp: 2025-09-26T20:07:21.356Z
Learning: Applies to gemini-flow.md : Maintain gemini-flow.md as the canonical project documentation and keep cross-references in GEMINI.md up to date

Applied to files:

• docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md

🪛 LanguageTool

docs/GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md

[typographical] ~54-~54: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...#c2e0c6(light green) | |E-medium| 2-8 hours |#fef2c0(light yellow) | |E...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[grammar] ~106-~106: It appears that a hyphen is missing in the noun “To-do” (= task) or did you mean the verb “to do”?
Context: ... The default Board template comes with "Todo", "In Progress", "Done". We need to cus...

(TO_DO_HYPHEN)

---

[grammar] ~110-~110: It appears that a hyphen is missing in the noun “To-do” (= task) or did you mean the verb “to do”?
Context: .... Rename Columns: 1. Click ⚙️ on "Todo" → Rename to: 🔥 Critical Path (P0) 2...

(TO_DO_HYPHEN)

---

[uncategorized] ~284-~284: The official name of this software platform is spelled with a capital “H”.
Context: ...Automation (Optional, Advanced) Create .github/workflows/project-automation.yml: ```...

(GITHUB)

---

[duplication] ~360-~360: Possible typo: you repeated a word.
Context: ...Priority, Effort) 4. Click Submit new issue 5. Issue will auto-add to project board (backlog...

(ENGLISH_WORD_REPEAT_RULE)

---

[typographical] ~374-~374: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...eview Critical Path (P0)** - Must be 0-3 items - If > 3, promote less critica...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~382-~382: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...Load Active Sprint (P1) - Select 3-5 items matching week theme - Move fro...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

docs/TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md

[typographical] ~148-~148: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...100ms after backend change Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~176-~176: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...nt testing setup in README Effort: 8-12 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~210-~210: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...ation (defer to Issue #15) Effort: 6-8 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~239-~239: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ... docs/TESTING_RESULTS.md Effort: 2-3 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[uncategorized] ~249-~249: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...les. Users may have a "successful" setup but npm run super-terminal fails. **Curr...

(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)

---

[typographical] ~263-~263: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...ED.md with troubleshooting Effort: 1-2 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~292-~292: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...OAuth (defer to Issue #16) Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P1 - This week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~319-~319: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...to include backend section Effort: 3-4 hours Priority: P1 - Next week ---...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[duplication] ~334-~334: Possible typo: you repeated a word.
Context: ...orkflow execution engine - Node-by-node execution - Execution state tracking - Result storage - Error...

(ENGLISH_WORD_REPEAT_RULE)

---

[typographical] ~348-~348: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...n ARCHITECTURE_OVERVIEW.md Effort: 8-12 hours Priority: P1 - Next sprint -...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~370-~370: Do not use a colon (:) before a series that is introduced by a preposition (‘on’). Remove the colon or add a noun or a noun phrase after the preposition.
Context: ...ocker-publish.yml` - [ ] Build and push on: tag creation, main branch push - [ ] Ta...

(RP_COLON)

---

[typographical] ~375-~375: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...in docs/GETTING_STARTED.md Effort: 3-4 hours Priority: P1 - Next sprint -...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[uncategorized] ~385-~385: The official name of this software platform is spelled with a capital “H”.
Context: ...ultiple GitHub Actions workflows exist (.github/workflows/) but none run tests or depl...

(GITHUB)

---

[typographical] ~402-~402: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...ent CI/CD process in docs/ Effort: 6-8 hours Priority: P1 - Next sprint -...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~428-~428: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...[ ] Document in HelpScreen Effort: 3-5 hours Priority: P1 - Next sprint -...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~455-~455: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...etup in GETTING_STARTED.md Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P2 - Backlog --- ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[style] ~547-~547: To form a complete sentence, be sure to include a subject.
Context: ...e hardcoded in backend/src/server.js. Should be configurable via environment variabl...

(MISSING_IT_THERE)

---

[uncategorized] ~565-~565: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...Total: 8 issues These are important but not urgent. Schedule during themed week...

(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)

---

[typographical] ~575-~575: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...role-based access control. Effort: 12-16 hours Priority: P2 - Future sprint ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~586-~586: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...wagger UI or OpenAPI spec. Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P2 - Future sprint ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~597-~597: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...c.) that users can import. Effort: 8-12 hours Priority: P2 - Future sprint ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~608-~608: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...l transformation or CRDTs. Effort: 16-20 hours Priority: P3 - Future quarter...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~619-~619: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ..., or node recommendations. Effort: 12-16 hours Priority: P3 - Future quarter...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~630-~630: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...le production deployments. Effort: 6-8 hours Priority: P2 - After Issue #6...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~641-~641: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...ility and log aggregation. Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P2 - Future sprint ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~652-~652: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...active connections, etc.). Effort: 4-6 hours Priority: P2 - Future sprint ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~772-~772: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...Critical Path (Queue 1):* - ✅ Target: 0-3 issues - ⚠️ Warning: 4-5 issues - 🚨 Cr...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~773-~773: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...** - ✅ Target: 0-3 issues - ⚠️ Warning: 4-5 issues - 🚨 Critical: > 5 issues **Act...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~777-~777: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...Active Sprint (Queue 2):* - ✅ Target: 3-5 issues selected - ⚠️ Warning: > 7 issue...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[typographical] ~782-~782: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ... Quick Wins (Queue 3): - ✅ Target: 5-10 issues - ⚠️ Warning: > 15 issues ### V...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md

[grammar] ~91-~91: It appears that a hyphen is missing in the noun “To-do” (= task) or did you mean the verb “to do”?
Context: ...reate project** Rename columns: - "Todo" → 🔥 Critical Path (P0) (description...

(TO_DO_HYPHEN)

---

[typographical] ~245-~245: If specifying a range, consider using an en dash instead of a hyphen.
Context: ...ing 1. Review Critical Path (should be 0-3 items) 2. Choose week theme: - Week ...

(HYPHEN_TO_EN)

---

[uncategorized] ~335-~335: Possible missing article found.
Context: ...### Labels already exist This is fine! Script uses --force flag to update existing ...

(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_THE)

🪛 markdownlint-cli2 (0.18.1)

docs/GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md

122-122: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

131-131: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

136-136: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

141-141: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

443-443: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

591-591: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

592-592: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

docs/TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md

23-23: Emphasis used instead of a heading

(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)

---

118-118: Emphasis used instead of a heading

(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)

---

462-462: Emphasis used instead of a heading

(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)

---

563-563: Emphasis used instead of a heading

(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)

docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md

57-57: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

84-84: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

101-101: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

120-120: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified

(MD040, fenced-code-language)

---

230-230: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

302-302: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

303-303: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

304-304: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

324-324: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

385-385: Bare URL used

(MD034, no-bare-urls)

---

388-388: Emphasis used instead of a heading

(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)

🔇 Additional comments (5)

docs/GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md (1)

1-598: Comprehensive and actionable GitHub Projects setup guide—excellent foundation for team workflow.

The document is well-structured, clearly written, and provides both automated (CLI, GitHub Actions) and manual setup paths. The progression from label creation through weekly workflow and troubleshooting is logical and practical. The "Three Queues" methodology is clearly explained with visual cues, and the troubleshooting and advanced tips sections add significant value for teams scaling their workflow.

The bash scripts are ready to use (with minor path setup), and the GitHub Actions example is clear enough for teams to customize. Cross-references to related documents and the detailed weekly workflow section support both initial setup and sustained team adoption.

Minor follow-up items:

• Confirm that scripts/create-github-labels.sh and scripts/create-triage-issues.sh exist in the repository or are created as part of this PR
• Verify that docs/TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md (referenced at line 590) exists
• Document or automate the discovery of YOUR_PROJECT_NUMBER in the GitHub Actions workflow (line 301) to reduce friction for users

docs/TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md (1)

1-20: Excellent triage framework; verify Sprint 7 API format in Issue #2.

This is a well-structured, comprehensive triage document that clearly prioritizes the 28 identified issues using RICE + Severity Matrix. The three-queue system (Critical Path, Active Sprint, Opportunistic Wins, Backlog) is practical and easy to execute.

However, Issue #2 (lines 50–90) assumes the Sprint 7 backend returns a specific response format with success, data, error fields. Please verify that the backend implementation in PR #58 (noted in retrieved learnings) actually uses this format. If it differs, the issue description and DoD should reflect the actual API contract.

docs/TRIAGE_QUICK_START.md (3)

1-44: Clear, motivating introduction and prerequisites. The overview immediately establishes context and success criteria, and prerequisites are well-structured with verification steps. Well done.

---

144-296: Procedural flow and CLI reference are clear and correct. The workflow structure (planning → daily → retrospective) is practical, and the common commands are accurate. This section effectively bridges setup and ongoing operations.

---

308-315: Verify cross-references to other documentation.

The documentation reference table links to GITHUB_PROJECTS_SETUP.md and TRIAGE_SPRINT_8_AFTERMATH.md. Ensure these files exist in the docs/ directory. If either is missing or renamed, update the table accordingly. Additionally, consider adding a reference to the canonical project documentation (gemini-flow.md) at the end of this guide for users who need broader project context.