Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull Request Overview
This pull request adds comprehensive test coverage for the messaging connector components, specifically targeting edge cases, error handling scenarios, and improving code coverage for connector registration, descriptor functionality, and channel registry operations.
- Adds extensive unit tests for
ServiceCollectionExtensions,ConnectorDescriptor,ChannelRegistry, andChannelRegistryBuilderclasses - Introduces comprehensive error handling and edge case testing scenarios including disposal, concurrent operations, and validation
- Includes tests for authentication provider functionality and various connector initialization scenarios
Reviewed Changes
Copilot reviewed 12 out of 12 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ServiceCollectionExtensionsTests.cs | New comprehensive test file covering service collection extension methods with edge cases and error validation |
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ConnectorDescriptorExtendedTests.cs | New test file providing extensive coverage of ConnectorDescriptor functionality including equality, validation, and property handling |
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ChannelRegistryErrorHandlingTests.cs | New test file focused on error handling scenarios in ChannelRegistry operations |
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ChannelRegistryBuilderExtendedTests.cs | New test file covering ChannelRegistryBuilder edge cases and hosted service registration |
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ChannelRegistryAdvancedTests.cs | New test file for advanced scenarios including disposal patterns and concurrent operations |
| test/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors.XUnit/Messaging/ChannelDescriptorExtendedTests.cs | New test file covering ChannelDescriptor edge cases and comprehensive validation scenarios |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors/Messaging/ConnectorDescriptor.cs | Fix for display name logic to handle whitespace properly |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors/Messaging/ChannelRegistryBuilder.cs | Enhancement to validate schema attributes during registration and consolidate registration logic |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Firebase/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs | Renamed class and added Firebase-specific authentication logging methods |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Firebase/Messaging/FirebaseServiceAccountAuthenticationProvider.cs | Updated to use new structured logging methods |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Abstractions/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs | Renamed class and improved authentication logging with strongly-typed enums |
| src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Abstractions/Messaging/ChannelConnectorBase.cs | Updated to use improved logging methods with typed authentication parameters |
Tip: Customize your code reviews with copilot-instructions.md. Create the file or learn how to get started.
| } | ||
|
|
||
| [Fact] | ||
| public void AddChannelRegistry_RegistersChannelRegistryAssingleton() |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Method name contains a typo: 'Assingleton' should be 'AsSingleton'.
| public void AddChannelRegistry_RegistersChannelRegistryAssingleton() | |
| public void AddChannelRegistry_RegistersChannelRegistryAsSingleton() |
| protected override async Task ShutdownConnectorAsync(CancellationToken cancellationToken) | ||
| { | ||
| // Simulate slow shutdown but still complete within reasonable time for sync disposal | ||
| await Task.Delay(3000, cancellationToken); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The 3-second delay in ShutdownConnectorAsync could cause test performance issues. Consider reducing this delay or using a configurable timeout for testing.
| await Task.Delay(3000, cancellationToken); | |
| // Simulate slow shutdown but allow configurable delay for testing | |
| await Task.Delay(_shutdownDelayMs, cancellationToken); |
This pull request refactors and enhances logging across the messaging connector components, streamlining logger extension classes and improving the clarity and consistency of authentication-related logs. It also tightens validation when registering channel connectors and makes a minor fix to connector display name logic.
Logging Refactoring and Improvements
LoggerExtensionsname in bothDeveel.Messaging.Connector.AbstractionsandDeveel.Messaging.Connector.Firebasenamespaces for consistency and maintainability. (src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Abstractions/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs,src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Firebase/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs) [1] [2]AuthenticationTypeenum instead of raw strings, improving type safety and log clarity. (src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Abstractions/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs, usages inChannelConnectorBase.cs) [1] [2] [3]src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Abstractions/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs, usages inChannelConnectorBase.cs) [1] [2]Firebase Connector Logging Enhancements
FirebaseServiceAccountAuthenticationProviderto use these methods for clearer, more structured logs. (src/Deveel.Messaging.Connector.Firebase/Messaging/LoggerExtensions.cs, usages inFirebaseServiceAccountAuthenticationProvider.cs) [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]Channel Connector Registration and Descriptor Improvements
ChannelRegistryBuilderby enforcing that registered connector types must be decorated with theChannelSchemaAttribute, ensuring proper schema association. (src/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors/Messaging/ChannelRegistryBuilder.cs)src/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors/Messaging/ChannelRegistryBuilder.cs)src/Deveel.Messaging.Connectors/Messaging/ConnectorDescriptor.cs)