[Feature Request]: Changing the logic of the Quit Game

[MaderatorCreator]

Feature Type

Quality of Life

Describe

Quit Game on Android opens the menu, which is very convenient, but on Windows it closes the program, which is why you have to use New Game during the game to open the menu.

You can simply change the logic of the Quit Game from exiting the program to exiting the program menu, but it's not a fact that everyone will like it, so I see the best option for adding settings to the logic of the button - either it closes the DevX, or it exits into its menu. You can also add a transition option to the list of characters in a single-player or online game, depending on which one the player leaves.

[julealgon]

...but it's not a fact that everyone will like it, so I see the best option for adding settings to the logic of the button

I strongly dislike this reasoning for adding a setting.

The project cannot please everyone at the same time. Adding settings in an attempt to do that incurs maintainability costs to the project along with other issues.

I think proposing a new flow for the menu options is fine (this has been discussed already):

• [PROPOSAL] Come back on main menu on "Quit Game" click, instead of exit #4181

But making it conditional based on settings.... I hope that does not get implemented.

[kphoenix137]

Feature Type

Quality of Life

Describe

Quit Game on Android opens the menu, which is very convenient, but on Windows it closes the program, which is why you have to use New Game during the game to open the menu.

You can simply change the logic of the Quit Game from exiting the program to exiting the program menu, but it's not a fact that everyone will like it, so I see the best option for adding settings to the logic of the button - either it closes the DevX, or it exits into its menu. You can also add a transition option to the list of characters in a single-player or online game, depending on which one the player leaves.

I disagree with this suggestion entirely. Returning to the main menu means that "New Game" and "Quit Game" are effectively the same thing. It's probably the way it is on Android because the in game button isn't able to close the app.

[AJenbo]

This is more realistic, but needs to be finished so it's ready for merging: #3902