Skip to content

[Issue Report]: Opening/closing speedbook closes all panels #8400

@neube3

Description

@neube3

Operating System

Windows x64

DevilutionX version

1.5.5

Describe

I've just tried to do some inventory management and Speedbook/spellbind management and discovered that opening/closing mechanic of these two windows doesn't make much sense.

Possibly inherited from vanilla, but I didn't check.

I've later re-checked and inventory can be swapped to spellbook ("B" in default original binds), meaning any right-side panel. Then I've re-checked again and it turns out quests and character (or having two panels open) is exactly the same.

To Reproduce

Four testing scenarios:

  1. Open speedbook, open any panel -> both are open
  2. Open any panel(s), open speedbook -> panel(s) get closed, speedbook is open
  3. Open speedbook, open any panel(s), close any panel(s) -> speedbook is open, any panels not closed are open
  4. Open speedbook, open any panel(s), close speedbook -> speedbook and all open panels close

I think the scenarios 2 and 4 are not what a user would expect (incongruency given scenarios 1 and 3).

I know it is possible to close speedbook without closing the panels, because that's what happens when you click any skill/spell - only the speedbook closes then.

Expected Behavior

Scenario 2: keep both inventory and speedbook open; scenario 4: keep inventory open.

Additional context

This happens only when the speedbook is opened via keybind.

Clicking on the currently selected spell to open/close the speedbook is not affected.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions