Duplicate state 'OSH' (state_id: 1003) removed from the geojson, jso…

[fullmetalldev]

…n, csv files for the country - Kyrgyzstan.

[dr5hn]

Weekly data-quality review (2026-05-11)

Verdict: needs-fix

Checks

• Schema: ❌ This PR edits auto-generated files (json/states.json, json/countries+states.json, json/countries+states+cities.json). Per repo conventions, only contributions/ files are the source of truth; json/ is regenerated automatically and must not be edited directly.
• FK integrity: ✅ / N/A — No contributions/ files were changed; the canonical data is unaffected by this PR.
• Coordinates: ✅ No coordinate changes.
• Wikidata: N/A — Wikidata endpoints returned 403 (persistent network failure during review).
• Naming convention: ✅ No name changes.

Specific concerns

1. Wrong files edited. All three changed files live under json/, which is an auto-generated export directory. Changes here are silently overwritten on every export run. The correct target is contributions/states/states.json.

2. Potentially incorrect removal. The two "Osh" entries in contributions/states/states.json are distinct administrative entities:

   • id=1003, iso2=GO, iso3166_2=KG-GO — Osh City (a first-level administrative unit, analogous to KG-GB = Bishkek)
   • id=1005, iso2=O, iso3166_2=KG-O — Osh Oblast/Region

   Both KG-GO and KG-O are valid, distinct subdivisions under ISO 3166-2:KG. Removing KG-GO (Osh City) may be incorrect. Please confirm against the current ISO 3166-2:KG standard before proceeding. If the removal is confirmed correct, the change must be made in contributions/states/states.json and re-exported through the normal pipeline.

🤖 Automated weekly review — Claude (sonnet-4-6).

---

Generated by Claude Code