eval-transcript

Simple benchmarking service for audio transcription for the French administration.

Initial scope:

• manage benchmark audio files under data/audio/
• keep source-of-truth transcriptions under data/source_truth/
• store model outputs under data/transcriptions/
• compare transcription quality for target models:
  • Whisper via WhisperX
  • Voxtral
  • Kyutai STT (kyutai/stt-1b-en_fr)
  • Cohere Transcribe
  • Scribe v2

Getting started

This project uses uv with a Python src/ layout.

Prerequisites

• uv for dependency management and command execution.
• Git for source control and pre-commit hooks.
• The configured Gitleaks hook is installed by pre-commit in its managed environment. A standalone gitleaks binary is only needed if you want to run full repository scans or use the gitleaks CLI directly outside pre-commit.

Development setup

uv sync
uv run eval-transcript --help

Install the pre-commit hook to scan staged changes for secrets with Gitleaks:

uv run pre-commit install

You can also run the staged-changes secret scan manually:

uv run pre-commit run gitleaks

To scan the existing repository contents and history, install the standalone Gitleaks binary and run a direct repository scan:

gitleaks git --redact --verbose

The CLI loads a .env file from the current working directory before reading provider configuration. Explicit environment variables already set in the process take precedence, and --base-url / --api-key flags override both. For local development, copy .env.example to .env and fill in the secrets:

cp .env.example .env

oMLX provider

If a local oMLX server is running with its OpenAI-compatible API on http://localhost:8000/v1, set OMLX_API_KEY and list available models:

uv run eval-transcript omlx models

Transcribe one audio file through a model alias exposed by /v1/models:

uv run eval-transcript omlx transcribe data/audio/sample.wav \
  --model whisper-large-v3-asr-fp16 \
  --language fr

The transcribe command prints text only by default for quick visual comparison against source-of-truth transcripts. Use --json to print the raw response with segment metadata.

For Cohere Transcribe on Apple Silicon, use the original Cohere model with oMLX's mlx-audio STT loader:

CohereLabs/cohere-transcribe-03-2026

A smoke test on oMLX 0.3.12 loaded this model and successfully transcribed short English and French WAV files. oMLX exposes the downloaded model as:

cohere-transcribe-03-2026

The converted MLX 8-bit candidates are currently not reliable oMLX targets. The beshkenadze 8-bit conversion is discovered and loaded, but fails during transcription with a convolution shape mismatch:

beshkenadze/cohere-transcribe-03-2026-mlx-8bit

The mlx-community mirror is useful for mlx-speech, but is not currently a drop-in oMLX candidate:

mlx-community/cohere-transcribe-03-2026-mlx-8bit

It stores its runnable files under mlx-int8/, so the current oMLX discovery fails to recognize it as a downloaded model. Moving or symlinking those files to the repository root makes oMLX discover the alias, but a smoke test on oMLX 0.3.12 failed during transcription with the same convolution shape mismatch. Treat it as incompatible with oMLX until the upstream conversion or loader changes.

After downloading a candidate locally and restarting or refreshing oMLX model discovery, check the model alias exposed by the local server:

uv run eval-transcript omlx models

Then pass that exact alias to the transcription command. If oMLX exposes the repository name as the alias, the command is:

uv run eval-transcript omlx transcribe data/audio/sample.wav \
  --model cohere-transcribe-03-2026

If oMLX exposes a different alias, use the alias printed by omlx models instead. Cohere Transcribe supports French, but on oMLX 0.3.12 the --language fr option is currently broken because oMLX maps fr to french before calling the Cohere loader. Omit --language for now; the smoke test transcribed French correctly without a language hint.

To save the text output for later comparison, use --save. The file is written to data/transcriptions/<audio-stem>/omlx__<model>.txt:

uv run eval-transcript omlx transcribe data/audio/sample.wav \
  --model whisper-large-v3-asr-fp16 \
  --language fr \
  --save

Kyutai STT (local, via the oMLX provider)

Kyutai STT ships kyutai/stt-1b-en_fr (English/French, with built-in semantic VAD) and kyutai/stt-2.6b-en. It is local-only: there is no hosted or OpenAI-compatible HTTP endpoint. File transcription runs through the moshi (PyTorch) or moshi_mlx (Apple Silicon) packages, and the only server Kyutai ships is a Rust WebSocket streaming server. See kyutai-labs/delayed-streams-modeling for the inference scripts.

To benchmark Kyutai alongside the other models, run it behind a small local OpenAI-compatible server that wraps moshi/moshi_mlx and exposes GET /v1/models plus POST /v1/audio/transcriptions returning {"text": ...} on http://localhost:8000/v1, then transcribe through the generic oMLX provider:

uv run eval-transcript omlx transcribe data/audio/sample.mp3 \
  --model kyutai/stt-1b-en_fr \
  --language fr \
  --save

This reuses the existing oMLX OpenAI-compatible client, so no Kyutai-specific provider code is needed. Use kyutai/stt-1b-en_fr for French.

ElevenLabs provider

Set ELEVENLABS_API_KEY to use ElevenLabs Speech to Text with Scribe v2. The optional ELEVENLABS_BASE_URL can point to a regional ElevenLabs API base URL if needed.

List documented ElevenLabs speech-to-text models:

uv run eval-transcript elevenlabs models

Transcribe one audio or video file through Scribe v2:

uv run eval-transcript elevenlabs transcribe data/audio/sample.wav \
  --model scribe_v2 \
  --language fr

ElevenLabs accepts either ISO-639-1 or ISO-639-3 language hints, so --language fr and --language fra are both valid French hints. The transcribe command prints text only by default. Use --json to print the serialized SDK response with metadata such as words and timestamps, or --save to write data/transcriptions/<audio-stem>/elevenlabs__<model>.txt.

Optional Scribe v2 controls include --timestamps-granularity none|word|character, --diarize, --num-speakers, --temperature, --seed, --no-verbatim, and --no-tag-audio-events.

Albert API provider

Set ALBERT_API_KEY and ALBERT_BASE_URL (for example https://albert.api.etalab.gouv.fr/v1) to use Albert API's audio transcription endpoint. List available models:

uv run eval-transcript albert models

Transcribe one audio file with Albert's Whisper model:

uv run eval-transcript albert transcribe data/audio/sample.wav \
  --model openai/whisper-large-v3 \
  --language fr

The transcribe command prints text only by default. Use --json to print the raw response, or --save to write data/transcriptions/<audio-stem>/albert__<model>.txt.

Scaleway provider

Scaleway Generative APIs expose Voxtral through an OpenAI-compatible chat completions endpoint. Set SCW_SECRET_KEY and SCW_DEFAULT_PROJECT_ID; the CLI derives the project-scoped Generative APIs URL from SCW_DEFAULT_PROJECT_ID. Both scaleway models and scaleway transcribe also accept --api-key and --project-id to override these without a .env (useful in a worktree or CI).

List Voxtral models available through Scaleway Generative APIs:

uv run eval-transcript scaleway models

The models command queries the same Generative APIs endpoint used for transcription, so every listed ID can be passed directly to --model.

Transcribe one local MP3 or WAV file through Voxtral:

uv run eval-transcript scaleway transcribe data/audio/sample.mp3 \
  --model voxtral-small-24b-2507 \
  --language fr

Voxtral follows the language of its prompt, so the CLI sends a French prompt that explicitly forbids translation. Use --language to pin a different target language (it shapes the prompt), or --prompt to override the prompt entirely. The transcribe command prints text only by default. Use --json to print the raw chat completion response, or --save to write data/transcriptions/<audio-stem>/scaleway__<model>.txt.

Data layout

The repository tracks the directory structure only. Audio and generated transcript artifacts are gitignored by default.

data/
├── manifest.md        # benchmark index generated from local data files
├── audio/             # input audio files
├── source_truth/      # human/source-of-truth transcripts
└── transcriptions/    # model-generated transcripts

Generate or refresh the global benchmark manifest after adding local data files:

uv run eval-transcript manifest sync

Scoring transcripts

Score generated transcripts against source truth with the jiwer-backed scoring engine:

uv run eval-transcript score all

Score all generated outputs for one sample:

uv run eval-transcript score sample sample

The scorer matches data/source_truth/<sample-id>.md (or .txt) with data/transcriptions/<sample-id>/*.txt and reports WER, CER, substitution/deletion/insertion counts, and the reference token count. Aggregate WER is computed from total edit counts across all scored transcripts, not by averaging per-transcript WER values. Text, Markdown, and JSON outputs also include provider/model grouped WER summaries for model comparison.

Use --json for machine-readable output, or --normalization raw to score exact text after Unicode normalization only. The default standard normalization is conservative for French: it normalizes Unicode, casing, apostrophe variants, punctuation/symbols, and whitespace while preserving accents.

Use --normalization standard_numbers to additionally fold numbers to a canonical form so spelled-out and digit notations match (cinq/5, premier/1er, deux mille cinq cents/2 500). This avoids penalizing a model only for writing numbers differently than the reference; it is useful on number-heavy material (budgets, statistics).

Text output includes top substitutions, insertions, and deletions by default. Use --top-errors 0 to hide these summaries, or --align to append normalized REF / HYP / ERR alignment blocks for each scored transcript.

Use --format markdown or --format csv for report-friendly output, and --output PATH to write the rendered scoring report to a file. --json remains available as a shortcut for --format json.

data/manifest.md uses Markdown with YAML frontmatter to index samples, source-truth paths, generated outputs, and placeholder metadata such as language, duration, domain, runtime, and real-time factor.

Source-of-truth transcripts are matched to a sample by basename and may be either .txt or .md (for example data/source_truth/sample.txt for data/audio/sample.wav).