WIP Resolve GraphQL introspection issue (#69) via schema merging

docs/CONTRIBUTING.MD

@@ -197,4 +197,99 @@ go mod tidy
 
 Contributors should close conversations when complete. Reviewers may reopen if needed.
 
-For additional help, see our [FAQ](./FAQ.md) or open a GitHub issue.
+For additional help, see our [FAQ](./FAQ.md) or open a GitHub issue.
+
+# Contributing to GraphQL Schema and Resolvers
+
+## Overview
+
+Our GraphQL setup uses a **hybrid approach** to schema management. We have individual GraphQL schemas defined within each module (e.g., `modules/core/`, `modules/warehouse/`), but we also generate a **unified schema** at the top level (`graph/`) primarily to **enable correct GraphQL introspection** for development tools like Postman, Insomnia, or Apollo Sandbox.
+
+**Why this approach?**
+
+* **Introspection:** The previous method of registering module schemas only at runtime prevented standard introspection tools from seeing the complete API schema. This made development and testing difficult.
+* **Unified View:** The build-time merge creates `graph/schema.merged.graphql` and generates corresponding Go code (`graph/generated.go`, `graph/models_gen.go`) that represents the entire API surface. This allows tools to introspect correctly.
+* **Runtime Execution:** Currently, the server *still* uses the original `app.RegisterGraphSchema()` mechanism at runtime. This means the actual query execution relies on the schemas defined and registered within each module individually. *([Note: This might be refactored in the future to use the unified schema directly at runtime, which would simplify the process]).*
+
+## Current Limitations & Workflow
+
+Because we merge schemas via simple concatenation for the build-time generation step, but modules still need their *own* complete schemas for runtime registration, there's a necessary, slightly awkward workflow involving commenting/uncommenting common definitions:
+
+1.  **Duplicate Definitions:** Common scalars (like `scalar Time`, `scalar Int64`) and base types (`type Query`, `type Mutation`, `type Subscription`) should ideally be defined *only once* (e.g., in `modules/core/interfaces/graph/base.graphql`).
+2.  **Before `go generate`:** To allow the top-level `go generate ./graph/...` to succeed using the merged schema, you **MUST temporarily comment out** any re-definitions of these common scalars/types in other modules' `.graphql` files (e.g., comment out `scalar Time` in `modules/warehouse/interfaces/graph/base.graphql`).
+3.  **After `go generate`:** You **MUST uncomment** those lines back in the module `.graphql` files. This is because the runtime `app.RegisterGraphSchema()` for that module needs the complete schema definition, including those scalars, to work correctly.
+
+**Yes, this comment/uncomment step is cumbersome and error-prone.** It's a known trade-off of this hybrid approach. Adhering strictly to defining common types only once (See Solution 1 / Best Practice mentioned previously) and refactoring the runtime to use the single generated `ExecutableSchema` would eliminate this step.
+
+## Build Process Summary
+
+Running `go generate ./graph/...` from the project root performs these steps:
+
+## How Resolvers Work
+
+We have two "layers" of resolvers:
+
+1.  **Module-Specific Resolvers:**
+    * Located in `modules/<module_name>/interfaces/graph/*.resolvers.go`.
+    * These contain the **actual business logic** for fetching data, calling services, etc.
+    * They are associated with the schemas loaded individually at runtime via `app.RegisterGraphSchema`.
+    * **Example:** `modules/core/interfaces/graph/users.resolvers.go` implements the logic for the `user` and `users` queries defined in `modules/core/interfaces/graph/users.graphql`.
+
+2.  **Unified Top-Level Resolvers:**
+    * Located in `graph/resolver.go` and `graph/*.resolvers.go`.
+    * These are generated based on the *merged* schema (`schema.merged.graphql`).
+    * The main `graph/resolver.go` defines a `Resolver` struct that holds references to the *module-specific* resolvers (or the main `app` instance).
+      ```go
+      // graph/resolver.go
+      type Resolver struct {
+          app               application.Application
+          coreResolver      *coregraph.Resolver // From modules/core/interfaces/graph
+          warehouseResolver *warehousegraph.Resolver // From modules/warehouse/interfaces/graph
+          // ... other module resolvers
+      }
+
+      func NewResolver(app application.Application) *Resolver {
+          // ... instantiate module resolvers ...
+          return &Resolver{ /* ... */ }
+      }
+      ```
+    * The implementation files (e.g., `graph/schema.merged.resolvers.go`) primarily **delegate** calls to the appropriate module-specific resolver.
+      ```go
+      // graph/schema.merged.resolvers.go (Illustrative)
+      func (r *queryResolver) User(ctx context.Context, id int64) (*User, error) { // Uses graph.User model
+          // Delegate to the core module's resolver
+          coreUserResult, err := r.coreResolver.Query().User(ctx, id) // Calls core's User resolver
+          if err != nil {
+              return nil, err
+          }
+          return (*User)(coreUserResult), nil // Direct cast if structs are identical
+      }
+
+      func (r *queryResolver) WarehousePosition(ctx context.Context, id int64) (*WarehousePosition, error) { // Uses graph.WarehousePosition
+          // Delegate to the warehouse module's resolver
+          warehousePosResult, err := r.warehouseResolver.Query().WarehousePosition(ctx, id) // Calls warehouse's resolver
+          if err != nil {
+              return nil, err
+          }
+          // return warehousemappers.PositionToGraphModel(warehousePosResult), nil // Example using mapper
+          return (*WarehousePosition)(warehousePosResult), nil // Direct cast if structs are identical
+      }
+      ```
+
+## How to Add/Modify GraphQL Fields
+
+1.  **Define Schema:** Add/modify types, queries, or mutations in the relevant module's `.graphql` file(s) (e.g., `modules/warehouse/interfaces/graph/new_feature.graphql`).
+2.  **Implement Logic:** Add the corresponding resolver method implementation in the module's `*.resolvers.go` file (e.g., `modules/warehouse/interfaces/graph/new_feature.resolvers.go`). This implementation should contain the actual business logic.
+3.  **Prepare for Generation:** **Temporarily comment out** duplicate scalar/base type definitions in non-core `.graphql` files.
+4.  **Generate Unified Code:** Run `go generate ./graph/...` from the project root. This updates/creates:
+    * `graph/generated.go`
+    * `graph/models_gen.go`
+    * Stubs for new resolvers in `graph/*.resolvers.go` (e.g., `graph/schema.merged.resolvers.go`).
+5.  **Restore Source Schemas:** **Uncomment** the lines commented out in Step 3.
+6.  **Implement Delegation:** Go to the generated stub in the top-level `graph/*.resolvers.go` file. Implement the method by:
+    * Getting the correct module resolver instance (e.g., `r.warehouseResolver`).
+    * Calling the corresponding method you implemented in the module resolver (Step 2).
+    * Mapping the result to the top-level generated model type if necessary (often a simple type cast `(*graph.MyType)(result)` works if the underlying structs are the same, otherwise use a mapper).
+7.  **Commit:** Commit changes to the module's `.graphql` and `*.resolvers.go` files, the top-level `graph/*.resolvers.go` file containing the delegation, and all updated generated files in `graph/`.
+
+This workflow allows us to have working introspection while keeping the resolver logic located within the relevant module. Remember the manual comment/uncomment steps before and after generation until the runtime is potentially refactored.

go.mod

@@ -86,6 +86,7 @@ require (
 	github.com/gotd/neo v0.1.5 // indirect
 	github.com/grpc-ecosystem/grpc-gateway v1.16.0 // indirect
 	github.com/grpc-ecosystem/grpc-gateway/v2 v2.26.1 // indirect
+	github.com/hashicorp/golang-lru/v2 v2.0.7 // indirect
 	github.com/jackc/pgpassfile v1.0.0 // indirect
 	github.com/jackc/pgservicefile v0.0.0-20240606120523-5a60cdf6a761 // indirect
 	github.com/jackc/puddle/v2 v2.2.2 // indirect

graph/generate.go

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+package graph
+
+//go:generate bash ../scripts/merge_graphql_schemas.sh
+//go:generate go run github.com/99designs/gqlgen generate