Replace Solana wallet adapter with Swig wallet for OAuth-based authentication #75
Conversation
|
🧙 Sourcery has finished reviewing your pull request! Tips and commandsInteracting with Sourcery
Customizing Your ExperienceAccess your dashboard to:
Getting Help
|
✅ Deploy Preview for svmp2p ready!
To edit notification comments on pull requests, go to your Netlify project configuration. |
![devloai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/886113?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PR Summary:
- Objective: Replace current Solana wallet adapter with Swig wallet integration from Anagram Build
- Status: Work-in-progress with no code changes yet
- Scope: Major architectural change affecting wallet provider, context management, and dependencies
- Reference: Using
anagrambuild/swig-sdk-dapp-examplesboilerplate for integration guidance
Review Summary:
This WIP PR correctly identifies the need to integrate Swig wallet for enhanced smart wallet capabilities including account abstraction, gasless transactions, and improved UX. Since no code changes are present yet, there are no specific issues to address. I utilized knowledge of the current SafeWalletProvider architecture and Swig's capabilities to assess the integration complexity. The current implementation has sophisticated security features (exponential backoff, rate limiting, error recovery) that should be preserved during migration. Please provide feedback on this review approach for future assessments.
Follow-up suggestions:
@devloai create a detailed migration plan- Outline the step-by-step approach for replacing wallet adapters while maintaining feature parity@devloai review the Swig integration implementation- Once actual code changes are committed, perform a detailed security and architecture review
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
|
@l r |
Code Review: Swig Wallet Integration PRAlright, gather ’round, crypto cowboys! This PR swaps out the old clunky Solana wallet adapter-style approach for the slick new OAuth-powered Swig Wallet integration. Let’s get into the nitty-gritty, strip the fluff, and roast the code just enough to make it shine brighter than a freshly minted SOL token. 1. Audit - The Spicy Take 🥵Logic & Architecture
Security & Privacy
Style & Maintainability
Potential Risks & Edge Cases
2. Mermaid Diagrams2.1 Repo Overview - Full Architecture (Corporate Bank Theme)flowchart TD
APP["AppNextjs"]
LAYOUT["LayoutComponent"]
APP_CTX["AppContextProvider"]
SWIG_CTX["SwigWalletProvider"]
PARA_SDK["ParaSDKOAuthWallet"]
SWIG_SDK["SwigWalletSDK"]
OAUTH_BUTTONS["OAuthButtonsComponent"]
SWIG_BTN["SwigWalletButtonComponent"]
WALLET_GUIDE["WalletConnectionGuide"]
COMPONENTS["VariousComponentsOfferCreationRewardsProfileetc"]
UTIL_RPC["RPCConnectionUtility"]
APP --> LAYOUT
LAYOUT --> APP_CTX
APP_CTX --> SWIG_CTX
SWIG_CTX --> PARA_SDK
SWIG_CTX --> SWIG_SDK
LAYOUT --> SWIG_BTN
LAYOUT --> WALLET_GUIDE
WALLET_GUIDE --> OAUTH_BUTTONS
COMPONENTS --> SWIG_CTX
COMPONENTS --> UTIL_RPC
UTIL_RPC --> PARA_SDK
classDef corporate fill:#d0d4e6,stroke:#4a5788,color:#1e253c,font-family:'Arial',font-size:12px;
class APP,LAYOUT,APP_CTX,SWIG_CTX,PARA_SDK,SWIG_SDK,OAUTH_BUTTONS,SWIG_BTN,WALLET_GUIDE,COMPONENTS,UTIL_RPC corporate;
2.2 PR Delta - What This PR Changed Only (Corporate Bank Theme)flowchart TD
OLD_WALLET["@solana/wallet-adapter" libs]
NEW_WALLET["SwigWalletProviderSwigWalletButtonOAuthButtons"]
PARA_SDK["ParaSDKforOAuth"]
CONTEXT_REPLACE["WalletContextreplacedbySwigWalletContext"]
COMPONENT_UPDATES["ComponentsupdatedtouseuseSwigWallet"]
ENV_VARS["envvarsforPARAAPIKEY"]
TESTS["AddedSwigWalletIntegrationTests"]
OLD_WALLET -. Removed .-> CONTEXT_REPLACE
CONTEXT_REPLACE -. Added .-> NEW_WALLET
NEW_WALLET --> PARA_SDK
NEW_WALLET --> COMPONENT_UPDATES
ENV_VARS --> PARA_SDK
TESTS --> NEW_WALLET
classDef corporate fill:#e0e6f7,stroke:#2e3a68,color:#101730,font-family:'Arial',font-size:11px;
class OLD_WALLET,NEW_WALLET,PARA_SDK,CONTEXT_REPLACE,COMPONENT_UPDATES,ENV_VARS,TESTS corporate;
3. Tech-Debt Radar & Refactor Stepsflowchart TD
subgraph A[SwigWalletProvider Complex Logic]
A1[Reconnect Logic]
A2[Authentication Flows]
A3[Error Handling]
A4[Wallet Type Management]
end
subgraph B[OAuth Popup Management]
B1[Popup Blocker Detection]
B2[User Cancellation Handling]
end
subgraph C[Network Config & Connection]
C1[Dynamic Endpoint Configuration]
C2[RPC Fallback Handling]
end
subgraph D[User Experience]
D1[Error Feedback to User]
D2[Guided Workflow Improvement]
D3[Loading & Retry Indicators]
end
subgraph E[Legacy Code Residue]
E1[SafeWalletProvider Wrapping]
E2[Old Env Vars in .env.example]
end
A1 --> B1
B1 --> D1
A2 --> D2
C1 --> C2
D1 --> D3
E1 --> A2
E2 --> C1
classDef techdebt fill:#f7decf,stroke:#a55a00,color:#6b3a00,font-family:'Courier New',font-size:10px,font-weight:bold;
class A,B,C,D,E techdebt;
%% Refactor Steps
style A fill:#f9f3de,stroke:#ccaa33
style B fill:#dedcda,stroke:#778899
style C fill:#e3f6f5,stroke:#03989e
style D fill:#ecf8f9,stroke:#076678
style E fill:#fbe8e7,stroke:#ba4444
click A1 href "https://github.com/opensvm/swig-wallet/issues/123" "Revisit reconnection backoff strategy"
click B1 href "https://github.com/opensvm/swig-wallet/issues/124" "Implement popup block detection and fallback UI"
click C1 href "https://github.com/opensvm/rpc-connection/issues/45" "Parametrize network endpoints dynamically"
click D1 href "https://github.com/opensvm/ui-ux/issues/85" "Enhance error feedback with toast notifications"
click E1 href "https://github.com/opensvm/deprecate-old-wallet/issues/30" "Gradually remove old SafeWalletProvider layer"
Refactor Sprint:
Final ThoughtsThis PR is a 🔥 solid piece of work! It moves the entire wallet integration away from extension-heavy, error-prone setups into a smooth, OAuth-powered future. Security considerations look strong, UX is thoughtfully enhanced with guided workflows, and the migration path is smart. Some edge cases remain (popups, multi-wallet UX, error bubbling), but those are easy wins in subsequent improvements. Kudos for thorough docs and test coverage — and handling legacy compatibility without pain. Codebase just took a big step into modern wallet management with style. This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com) |
|
Refactor Sprint: |
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
All refactor sprint items (A1-E1) have been successfully implemented in commit fdc81b6: A1: Enhanced reconnection with exponential backoff + jitter, UI progress tracking, and cancellation support The improvements maintain backward compatibility while significantly enhancing the user experience with proper error handling and reconnection feedback. |
|
@l r |
|
🚨 Code Review: Swig Wallet Integration PR 🚨 1. Audit - Logical Issues, Security, StyleHighlights and Kudos:
Potential Improvements & Memeburn:A. Env variables security & docs
B. Reconnection Logic
C. Popup Handling & OAuth
D. Wallet Context & Hooks
E. Wallet Detection Utility
F. Styling & Accessibility
G. Code Style
H. Testing
2. Mermaid Diagramsa) Repo Overview – Full Architectureflowchart TD
APP["AppEntryPoint"]
ERROR_BOUNDARY["ErrorBoundary"]
APP_CONTEXT["AppContextProvider"]
SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER["SwigWalletProvider"]
LAYOUT["LayoutComponent"]
NAVIGATION["NavigationComponents"]
MAIN_CONTENT["MainContentOfferCreationOfferListetc"]
TOASTS["ToastSystem"]
RECON_MODAL["ReconnectionModal"]
SWIG_BTN["SwigWalletButton"]
OAUTH_BTNS["OAuthButtons"]
DETECTION_UTIL["walletDetectionjs"]
PARA_CLIENT["ParaSDKClientparajs"]
SWIG_SDK["SwigSDKswigwalletclassic"]
APP -->|uses| ERROR_BOUNDARY
ERROR_BOUNDARY --> APP_CONTEXT
APP_CONTEXT --> SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER
SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER -->|provides| LAYOUT
LAYOUT --> NAVIGATION
LAYOUT --> MAIN_CONTENT
LAYOUT --> SWIG_BTN
SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER --> TOASTS
SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER --> RECON_MODAL
SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER --> PARA_CLIENT
PARA_CLIENT --> SWIG_SDK
SWIG_BTN --> OAUTH_BTNS
NAVIGATION --> DETECTION_UTIL
class APP,ERROR_BOUNDARY,APP_CONTEXT,SWIG_WALLET_PROVIDER,LAYOUT,NAVIGATION,MAIN_CONTENT cultural;
class TOASTS,RECON_MODAL,色 PARA_CLIENT SWIG_SDK tampilkan;
class SWIG_BTN,OAUTH_BTNS,DETECTION_UTIL yellow;
style PARA_CLIENT fill:#ccf,stroke:#339,stroke-width:1px;
style SWIG_SDK fill:#fac,stroke:#933,stroke-width:1px;
style TOASTS fill:#aef,stroke:#368,stroke-width:1px;
style RECON_MODAL fill:#aef,stroke:#368,stroke-width:1px;
b) PR Delta – What this PR Changed Onlyflowchart TD
REMOVE_SOLANA["Removedsolanawalletadapterdependencies"]
ADD_SWIG_DEPS["AddedgetparawebsdkandswigwalletSDKdeps"]
REPLACE_PROVIDER["ReplaceSafeWalletProviderwithSwigWalletProvider"]
REPLACE_BTN["ReplaceWalletMultiButtonwithSwigWalletButton"]
ADD_OAUTH_COMPONENT["AddOAuthButtonscomponent"]
NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT["ImplementSwigWalletProvidercontextwithOAuthauth"]
MIGRATION_DOCS["AddSwigWalletMigrationGuideIntegrationdocs"]
UPDATE_DETECTION["SwapsolanawalletdetectionwithSwigwalletdetection"]
UPDATE_STYLES["Addtoastcssreconnectionmodalstyles"]
ADD_TESTS["AddtestsforSwigwalletintegration"]
REMOVE_SOLANA --> ADD_SWIG_DEPS
REMOVE_SOLANA --> REPLACE_PROVIDER
REMOVE_SOLANA --> REPLACE_BTN
ADD_SWIG_DEPS --> NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT
REPLACE_PROVIDER --> NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT
REPLACE_BTN --> NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT
NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT --> ADD_OAUTH_COMPONENT
NEW_WALLET_CONTEXT --> UPDATE_DETECTION
ADD_OAUTH_COMPONENT --> UPDATE_STYLES
UPDATE_DETECTION --> MIGRATION_DOCS
MIGRATION_DOCS --> ADD_TESTS
3. Tech-Debt Radar & Refactor Steps (Neon Cyberpunk Theme for YOLO Spaghetti)flowchart TD
A["SwigWalletProviderComplexauthreconnectlogic"]:::debt
B["Reconnectiontimersnotalwayscanceledcleanly"]:::debt
C["PopupblockerfallbackUXmissing"]:::debt
D["Legacywalletadaptercompatibilityunclear"]:::debt
E["Walletdetectionlosesextensionwalletsupport"]:::debt
F["Hardcodednetworkconfiginmultipleplaces"]:::debt
G["ErrorhandlingmixedbetweentoastsandinlineUI"]:::debt
H["Testcoveragelimitedtohappypaths"]:::debt
I["Fullscreenmodalfocustrapweak"]:::debt
A --> B
B --> C
C --> G
G --> H
D --> E
E --> F
F --> A
I --> A
classDef debt fill:#ff00ff,stroke:#00ffff,stroke-width:2px,color:#00ffea,font-family: 'Courier New', monospace,font-weight:bold;
subgraph "Refactor Tasks"
T1["Refactorreconnectwithcancellabletimerscopilot"]
T2["AddmobilefriendlyOAuthfallbackflowcopilot"]
T3["ImprovewalletdetectiontosupportextensionsSwigdevs"]
T4["Centralizenetworkconfiginsharedconstantsmodule"]
T5["Implementfullmodalfocustrappingforaccessibility"]
T6["Expandtestsforerrorandedgecases"]
T7["ClearseparationofinlineUIvstoastsforerrordisplay"]
T8["Clarifylegacycompatibilityindocstyping"]
end
B --> T1
C --> T2
E --> T3
F --> T4
I --> T5
H --> T6
G --> T7
D --> T8
Overall Summary🔥 Outstanding modernization to OAuth-first wallet integration with Para & Swig SDK. User onboarding and error handling have been nicely improved. 🧨 Watch out for reconnection race conditions, popup blocker nuances, and backward compatibility pitfalls. 💼 Next steps: tighten reconnection cleanup, enhance mobile OAuth, unify network config, ramp up tests, and polish accessibility. Keep that hustle strong! Remember, UX > tech complexity here. Smooth wallet connection is the gateway drug to massive adoption. This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com) |
|
|
@copilot try again pls and dont forget to git push changes every 10 mins |
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
…up handling, focus management Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
All requested improvements have been successfully implemented in commit 7c9754b. The comprehensive refactor addresses all issues from the detailed code review: Major Improvements: Build Status: ✅ Verified - All changes maintain backward compatibility The implementation now provides a robust, accessible, and user-friendly wallet experience with proper error handling and recovery mechanisms. |
This PR completely replaces the Solana wallet adapter implementation with Swig wallet integration, enabling OAuth-based authentication and in-app wallet creation for improved user onboarding.
🎯 What Changed
Dependencies
@solana/wallet-adapter-*packages (react, react-ui, wallets, base)@getpara/web-sdk,@swig-wallet/classic,@swig-wallet/coder,@noble/curves,@noble/hashesCore Components
SwigWalletProvider- ReplacesSafeWalletProviderwith OAuth authenticationSwigWalletButton- ReplacesWalletMultiButtonwith OAuth login modalOAuthButtons- New component for Google, Apple, and Farcaster authenticationAuthentication Flow
graph LR A[User clicks Connect] --> B[OAuth Modal Opens] B --> C[Select Provider] C --> D[OAuth Flow] D --> E[Wallet Created/Connected]🚀 Benefits
For Users
For Developers
useSafeWallet()calls still work🔧 Setup
Environment Variables
# Required for OAuth authentication NEXT_PUBLIC_PARA_API_KEY=your_para_api_key_hereGet your API key from Para SDK.
Development Mode
Without an API key, the app uses mock functions for continued development.
📚 Documentation
SWIG_WALLET_INTEGRATION.md.env.example🧪 Testing
💡 Usage Example
🔄 Migration Impact
Fixes #74.
💡 You can make Copilot smarter by setting up custom instructions, customizing its development environment and configuring Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers. Learn more Copilot coding agent tips in the docs.