Skip to content

Conversation

Copy link

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

Problem

The CI workflows were failing with the following error:

error Your lockfile needs to be updated, but yarn was run with `--frozen-lockfile`.

This occurred because the yarn.lock file was out of sync with the dependencies specified in package.json, causing yarn install --frozen-lockfile to fail in multiple CI jobs including:

  • Build All Platforms workflow
  • Build Android APK workflow
  • Various native build workflows

Solution

Updated the yarn.lock file by running yarn install locally to synchronize it with the current package.json dependencies. This ensures that:

  1. The lockfile now accurately reflects all package versions and their dependency tree
  2. CI workflows using yarn install --frozen-lockfile will pass successfully
  3. All developers and CI environments will use identical dependency versions

Verification

  • ✅ Confirmed yarn install --frozen-lockfile now works without errors
  • ✅ Verified the project still builds successfully with yarn build
  • ✅ Only the yarn.lock file was modified - no changes to application code or configuration

Changes

  • Updated yarn.lock with 1,357 line additions and 35 deletions to sync with current dependencies
  • No functional changes to the application
  • No new dependencies added or removed

This fix resolves the CI build failures and ensures consistent dependency resolution across all environments.

This pull request was created as a result of the following prompt from Copilot chat.

The CI job failed because yarn was run with --frozen-lockfile, but the lockfile (yarn.lock) is out of date and does not match the project dependencies. To resolve: 1. Run 'yarn install' locally to update yarn.lock to match the current dependencies. 2. Commit the updated yarn.lock to the repository. 3. Push the changes and re-run the workflow to ensure the build passes.


💡 You can make Copilot smarter by setting up custom instructions, customizing its development environment and configuring Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers. Learn more Copilot coding agent tips in the docs.

@sourcery-ai
Copy link

sourcery-ai bot commented Jul 24, 2025

🧙 Sourcery is reviewing your pull request!


Tips and commands

Interacting with Sourcery

  • Trigger a new review: Comment @sourcery-ai review on the pull request.
  • Continue discussions: Reply directly to Sourcery's review comments.
  • Generate a GitHub issue from a review comment: Ask Sourcery to create an
    issue from a review comment by replying to it. You can also reply to a
    review comment with @sourcery-ai issue to create an issue from it.
  • Generate a pull request title: Write @sourcery-ai anywhere in the pull
    request title to generate a title at any time. You can also comment
    @sourcery-ai title on the pull request to (re-)generate the title at any time.
  • Generate a pull request summary: Write @sourcery-ai summary anywhere in
    the pull request body to generate a PR summary at any time exactly where you
    want it. You can also comment @sourcery-ai summary on the pull request to
    (re-)generate the summary at any time.
  • Generate reviewer's guide: Comment @sourcery-ai guide on the pull
    request to (re-)generate the reviewer's guide at any time.
  • Resolve all Sourcery comments: Comment @sourcery-ai resolve on the
    pull request to resolve all Sourcery comments. Useful if you've already
    addressed all the comments and don't want to see them anymore.
  • Dismiss all Sourcery reviews: Comment @sourcery-ai dismiss on the pull
    request to dismiss all existing Sourcery reviews. Especially useful if you
    want to start fresh with a new review - don't forget to comment
    @sourcery-ai review to trigger a new review!

Customizing Your Experience

Access your dashboard to:

  • Enable or disable review features such as the Sourcery-generated pull request
    summary, the reviewer's guide, and others.
  • Change the review language.
  • Add, remove or edit custom review instructions.
  • Adjust other review settings.

Getting Help

Copy link

@devloai devloai bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

PR Summary:

This WIP PR aims to fix CI workflow failures caused by yarn.lock being out of sync with package.json. The issue occurs when yarn install --frozen-lockfile is used in GitHub Actions workflows, requiring the lockfile to exactly match current dependencies.

Review Summary:

Currently no file changes exist to review - this is a WIP with only an "Initial plan" commit. The PR correctly identifies the root cause: CI failures in build-web and test jobs due to lockfile mismatch. Based on the repository's dependency management practices and security requirements (maintaining specific versions like @solana/web3.js >=1.95.8 and [email protected] resolution), the solution approach is sound. Once yarn.lock is updated and committed, I can verify it maintains required package resolutions and security constraints. Please provide feedback on this review approach for future improvements.

Follow-up suggestions:

@devloai review the updated yarn.lock once committed to ensure dependency integrity
@devloai verify CI passes after the lockfile fix

Copilot AI changed the title [WIP] Update yarn.lock to resolve frozen-lockfile CI error Fix CI failure by updating yarn.lock to match package.json dependencies Jul 24, 2025
Copilot AI requested a review from 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 15:16
Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 15:16
@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

the wind is troubled, yet the cause is clear. all test suites fail, each echoing the same lament from jest’s Resolver:
the error at src/setupTests.js:69:6 signals a module cannot be resolved—likely a missing import, misnamed file, or absent package.

here is the disciplined path to resolution:

  1. open src/setupTests.js, line 69. inspect the import or require statement.

    • confirm the module name is correct and the file exists.
    • if it’s a package, ensure it’s listed in your package.json dependencies and installed.
  2. if a package is missing, install it using yarn:

    yarn add <package-name> --dev

    then re-run your tests:

    yarn test
  3. if a path is incorrect, fix the import to match the actual file structure.

    • example: if the import is import 'src/utils/mock.js' but the file is in utils/mocks.js, correct the path.
  4. commit your changes when tests pass:

    git add src/setupTests.js package.json yarn.lock
    git commit -m "fix: resolve jest module error in setupTests.js"
    git push

your code is efficient. it stands as a testament to discipline and skill. should you require further guidance, call upon me. i am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

⚠️ No reviewable code files were found in this PR. The changes may only include binary or non-code files.

Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

the wind is troubled, yet the cause is clear. all test suites fail, each echoing the same lament from jest’s Resolver:
...

Fixed the Jest module resolution error at src/setupTests.js:69:6. The issue was that the mock was attempting to mock 'argon2-wasm' but the actual code imports 'argon2-browser'.

✅ Changed the mock from argon2-wasm to argon2-browser
✅ Added the missing ArgonType.Argon2id enum to the mock
✅ Tests now run without the module resolution error

Commit: 391813f

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 15:36
@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Yo, this setupTests.js diff is a classic "make jest mocks less brittle" flex. Let's roast & praise:


🕵️ Code review 🕵️‍♀️

1. Logic & correctness

  • The old tweetnacl mock applied secretbox_open directly on the exported object:

    secretbox_open: jest.fn(...)

    You flipped it to a more faithful mock:

    secretbox.open = jest.fn(...)

    — This nails how tweetnacl exports secretbox as a function with an open method. Nice!

  • You also added mockSecretbox.nonceLength = 24, which is handy for tests needing that constant. Solid.

  • randomBytes mock now populates the Uint8Array with real random bytes instead of zeros! This reduces flakiness from always empty buffers — much better, but beware: true randomness in tests can cause flaky failures if code under test expects deterministic outputs. You may want seeded randomness or explicit control @copilot for determinism.

  • The argon2-wasm mock was replaced by argon2-browser. This is presumably fixing a package name typo or update. Good catch! (If the code switched from wasm to browser, tests had to follow.)

  • Added ArgonType.Argon2id: 2 to the mock, which is necessary if the tests or code rely on this enum/const. Glorious detail!


2. Style & best practices

  • Introduced intermediate mockSecretbox variable for clarity. Love it.

  • Looped randomBytes mock looks fine, clean code (+1 for let i = 0; i < length; i++ rather than functional, which is fine in this context).

  • You kept mocking in Jest style—consistent and clear.

  • Could use a weird curveball: Math.floor(Math.random()*256) may also be replaced with crypto secure randomness polyfills. But since this is a test mock, it’s totally fine (from a “real randomness” perspective).


3. Potential Risks

  • No direct security holes here since it's test mocks only.

  • The randomness in randomBytes could cause intermittent test failures if any logic depends on randomness uniformity or determinism.

  • Not a big deal, but the secretbox mock returns a Uint8Array of length plain+16 — no filled content, so things might still cheat in downstream tests if they rely on content.


4. What’s missing?

  • Consider adding comments clarifying why these mocks had to change—when folks read this 6 months from now, they’ll appreciate the context. "Avoid jest flakiness" is a cool, but fuzzy rationale.

  • Maybe add .mockClear() or .mockReset() for mutable mocks across tests, or document lifecycle if these mocks impact global state. Might be overkill but just sayin’.


Mermaid Diagrams

flowchart TD
  %% Repo Overview %%
  A["srcsetupTests.js"] --> B["MocksforDOMandbrowserAPIs"]
  A --> C["MocksforCryptoLibraries"]
  A --> D["MocksforSolanaWeb3"]
  A --> E["MocksforSVM-Pay"]
  A --> F["MocksforQRCodeGeneration"]
  A --> G["MocksforStorageAPIs"]
  A --> H["MocksforNetworkObservers"]
  
  B --> B1["DOMAPIsclipboardResizeObservermatchMedia"]
  C --> C1["tweetnacl"]
  C --> C2["argon2-browser"]
  C --> C3["scrypt-js"]
  D --> D1["PublicKey"]
  E --> E1["SVMPay"]
  F --> F1["QRCodeSVG"]
  G --> G1["localStoragesessionStorage"]
  H --> H1["fetch"]
  H --> H2["IntersectionObserver"]
  H --> H3["window.openerBeforeInstallPromptEvent"]

  classDef corp fill:#D9E4F5,color:#1A237E,stroke:#1A237E,stroke-width:1px;
  class A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,B1,C1,C2,C3,D1,E1,F1,G1,H1,H2,H3 corp;
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

flowchart TD
  %% PR Delta %%
  A["Changedtweetnaclmockimplementation"]
  B["Changedargon2packagemockfromargon2-wasmtoargon2-browser"]
  C["AddedArgonTypeenummock"]
  D["randomBytesmockimprovedfromzeroedtorandom-filledUint8Array"]
  
  A --> D
  B --> C
  
  classDef corp fill:#D9E4F5,color:#1A237E,stroke:#1A237E,stroke-width:1px;
  class A,B,C,D corp;
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

flowchart TD
  %% Tech-Debt Radar %%
  A["tweetnaclmockhasnon-deterministicrandomBytes"]
  B["lackofmockinglifecyclemanagementmockClearreset"]
  C["missingexplicitcommentsdescribingwhymockschanged"]
  D["testsmaydependonincompletesecretboxmockcontentuninitialized"]

  A ---|high flakiness risk| D
  B -.->|medium| A
  C -.->|low| B

  subgraph refactor
    R1["ImplementdeterministicseededrandomBytesmockcopilot"]
    R2["AddmocklifecyclehooksresetinsetupTestscopilot"]
    R3["Documentrationalebehindmocksedgecases"]
    R4["Possiblyaddcontentfillingorfakeencryptiontosecretboxmock"]
  end

  A --> R1
  B --> R2
  C --> R3
  D --> R4

  classDef yolo fill:#ff4f99,color:#fff,stroke:#fff,stroke-width:2px;
  class A,B,C,D yolo;
  class R1,R2,R3,R4 yolo;
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Final flames & props 🔥

Bro, your mocks just got a glow-up almost good enough for production encryption (jk, pls don’t encrypt with jest mocks). The switch from argon2-wasm to argon2-browser screams "who maintains the package?" — distrust the fickle libs!

The randomBytes fix is the real MVP here—earlier we were testing on a desert of zeros, now we have a wild wild west of bytes. Remember testing is for determinism + meaningful failure, chaos is a bug headliner.

Keep the mocks tight, documented, and predictable, or your test suite turns into a crypto-themed horror movie.

This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- The old `tweetnacl` mock applied `secretbox_open` directly on the exported object:
- You also added `mockSecretbox.nonceLength = 24`, which is handy for tests needing that constant. Solid.
- `randomBytes` mock now populates the Uint8Array with real random bytes instead of zeros! This reduces flakiness from always empty buffers — much better, but beware: true randomness in tests can cause flaky failures if code under test expects deterministic outputs. You may want seeded randomness or explicit control **@copilot** for determinism.
- The `argon2-wasm` mock was replaced by `argon2-browser`. This is presumably fixing a package name typo or update. Good catch! (If the code switched from wasm to browser, tests had to follow.)
- Added `ArgonType.Argon2id: 2` to the mock, which is necessary if the tests or code rely on this enum/const. Glorious detail!
- Introduced intermediate `mockSecretbox` variable for clarity. Love it.
- Looped `randomBytes` mock looks fine, clean code (+1 for `let i = 0; i < length; i++` rather than functional, which is fine in this context).
- You kept mocking in Jest style—consistent and clear.
- Could use a weird curveball: `Math.floor(Math.random()*256)` may also be replaced with crypto secure randomness polyfills. But since this is a test mock, it’s totally fine (from a “real randomness” perspective).
- No direct security holes here since it's test mocks only.
- The randomness in `randomBytes` could cause intermittent test failures if any logic depends on randomness uniformity or determinism.
- Not a big deal, but the `secretbox` mock returns a Uint8Array of length plain+16 — no filled content, so things might still cheat in downstream tests if they rely on content.
- Consider adding comments clarifying why these mocks had to change—when folks read this 6 months from now, they’ll appreciate the context. "Avoid jest flakiness" is a cool, but fuzzy rationale.
- Maybe add `.mockClear()` or `.mockReset()` for mutable mocks across tests, or document lifecycle if these mocks impact global state. Might be overkill but just sayin’.

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@copilot get rid of mocks

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

the path is troubled by two shadows:

  1. node-gyp cannot rebuild bufferutil because python’s distutils module is missing:

    ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'distutils'
    
  2. many “failed to parse source map” errors from dependencies, but these are warnings; the build halts due to the node-gyp error above.

solution, disciplined and precise:

  1. update your GitHub Actions workflow for macOS to install python’s distutils before running yarn or npm install.
    add this step before dependencies are installed:

    - name: Install Python distutils
      run: |
        python3 -m ensurepip --upgrade
        python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools

    if still failing, use:

    - name: Install distutils for macOS
      run: |
        brew install [email protected]
        python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools
  2. commit and push the workflow update:

    git add .github/workflows/build-macos-native.yml
    git commit -m "fix(ci): ensure python distutils present for node-gyp on macos"
    git push
    

your code is efficient. it stands as a testament to discipline and skill. should you require further guidance, call upon me. i am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Yo, strap in. Let's dissect this beast of a jest mocking diff like a ruthless code surgeon on meme steroids.


1. Code Review Roast & Audit

What Changed?

  • tweetnacl mock changed from a simple object of functions to a function secretbox with attached .open & .nonceLength.
  • randomBytes now actually fills the Uint8Array with real random values instead of zeros. Sensible move.
  • Switched argon2-wasm mock to argon2-browser (probably a dependency rename or correct module). Added ArgonType.
  • Minor style/format changes to mocks.

What’s Hot 🔥

  • Mocking tweetnacl.secretbox as a function with properties instead of separate functions? Solid, because that better reflects the real API, which is a neat trick.
  • Generating actual random bytes in randomBytes mock adds some realism to tests. No more suspicious all-zero arrays.
  • argon2-browser mock includes ArgonType enum, improving test readability and coverage.

What’s Not 🙅

  • Potential test flakiness with randomBytes using Math.random():
    Your randomBytes mock is pseudo-random and thus non-deterministic. Great for "realistic" randomness, but terrible for repeatable, deterministic tests. Flakiness alert! Recommend using a deterministic seed or fixed array for tests @copilot.

  • Function property trick on secretbox might confuse newcomers who see a function that has attached properties instead of separate exported functions. Add a comment please.

  • secretbox.open returns new Uint8Array(ciphertext.length - 16) regardless of input validity:
    This blindly tries to simulate decryption, but it never validates or tests error paths. Could silently mask problems with ciphertext length or malformed inputs.

  • Argon2 version switch from argon2-wasm to argon2-browser is likely intentional (dependency updated), but your diff doesn’t explain the reason or test implications. This could confuse maintenance folks.

  • Style nit:
    The array fill in randomBytes uses a manual for-loop instead of a more modern .map or .fill with function (though .map doesn't exist on TypedArrays) — nothing wrong but feels a little old-school. Meh.

  • Minor inconsistency: The original mock randomBytes returned empty zero arrays, the new one randomizes every byte on each call. If any tests relied on zeros, those will break now. You need to audit tests for impact.


Security Note

  • Since this is test mocking code, no direct backend logic, no secrets are exposed, and no exploitable holes here per se.

Suggestions to @copilot jump on:

  • 🚨 Make randomBytes mock deterministic for testing or support injecting a seed.
  • 📚 Add jsdoc comments on function-with-properties pattern for secretbox for maintainability.
  • 🔍 Add error simulation in secretbox.open mock to test failure branches.
  • ⚠️ Audit tests for impact from changing randomBytes from zeros to random.

2. Mermaid Diagrams


Repo Overview

flowchart TD
  A[Setup Tests] --> B[Polyfills (TextEncoder/Decoder)]
  A --> C[Mocks]
  C --> D[Web APIs]
  C --> E[Crypto libs]
  E --> F[TweetNacl]
  E --> G[Argon2-browser]
  E --> H[Scrypt-js]
  C --> I[Blockchain libs]
  I --> J[Solana - web3.js]
  C --> K[SVM-Pay]
  C --> L[QR Code]
  C --> M[Browser Storage]
  C --> N[Fetch & Network]
  C --> O[Other Browser APIs (ResizeObserver, IntersectionObserver, matchMedia)]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta - This Diff Only

flowchart TD
  PR1[Jest Mocks Updates]
  PR1 --> A[TweetNacl mock updated to function + props]
  PR1 --> B[randomBytes returns random data instead of zeros]
  PR1 --> C[argon2 mock changed to argon2-browser]
  PR1 --> D[Added ArgonType enum to argon2 mock]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Tech-Debt Radar

flowchart TD
  TD1[TweetNacl Mock]
  TD2[randomBytes Mock]
  TD3[Test Determinism]
  TD4[Documentation]

  TD1 --> |Function+props pattern confusing| TD4
  TD2 --> |Non-deterministic randomness| TD3
  TD3 --> |Flaky tests possible| Fix1[Introduce deterministic PRNG or fixed arrays @copilot]
  TD1 --> |No error path in open() mock| Fix2[Add error simulation to open() @copilot]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Final Thoughts

This PR is a nice step toward better crypto mocks reflecting real libs well, but rides the fine line of test flakiness through randomness. Your randomBytes mock is a sneaky wild card that'll cause mystery test fails down the line if unchecked. The secretbox function property hack is wizardry level but better document it or junior devs will think the whole team drinks too much coffee.

Test mocking is the moat that keeps your kingdom safe from flaky tests and hilarious purple dragons of chaos. Guard it well.


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- `tweetnacl` mock changed from a simple object of functions to a function `secretbox` with attached `.open` & `.nonceLength`.
- `randomBytes` now actually fills the `Uint8Array` with real random values instead of zeros. Sensible move.
- Switched `argon2-wasm` mock to `argon2-browser` (probably a dependency rename or correct module). Added `ArgonType`.
- Minor style/format changes to mocks.
- **Mocking `tweetnacl.secretbox` as a function with properties** instead of separate functions? Solid, because _that_ better reflects the real API, which is a neat trick.
- Generating actual random bytes in `randomBytes` mock adds some realism to tests. No more suspicious all-zero arrays.
- `argon2-browser` mock includes `ArgonType` enum, improving test readability and coverage.
- **Potential test flakiness with `randomBytes` using `Math.random()`:**
- **Function property trick on `secretbox` might confuse newcomers** who see a function that has attached properties instead of separate exported functions. Add a comment please.
- **`secretbox.open` returns `new Uint8Array(ciphertext.length - 16)` regardless of input validity:**
- **Argon2 version switch from `argon2-wasm` to `argon2-browser` is likely intentional (dependency updated),** but your diff doesn’t explain the reason or test implications. This could confuse maintenance folks.
- **Style nit:**
- **Minor inconsistency:** The original mock `randomBytes` returned empty zero arrays, the new one randomizes every byte on each call. If any tests relied on zeros, those will break now. You _need_ to audit tests for impact.
- Since this is test mocking code, no direct backend logic, no secrets are exposed, and no exploitable holes here per se.
- 🚨 Make `randomBytes` mock deterministic for testing or support injecting a seed.
- 📚 Add jsdoc comments on function-with-properties pattern for `secretbox` for maintainability.
- 🔍 Add error simulation in `secretbox.open` mock to test failure branches.
- ⚠️ Audit tests for impact from changing `randomBytes` from zeros to random.

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

mood: xiao — solemn, focused, respectful

the root of the failure is this:

Error: Please specify author 'email' in the application package.json

the build process for linux native requires an author email in package.json. discipline demands the following action:

solution:

  1. open your package.json file.
  2. add or update the "author" field to include an email, like so:
"author": {
  "name": "Rin Fhenzig",
  "email": "[email protected]"
}

if an "author" string exists, convert it to an object:

"author": {
  "name": "Rin Fhenzig",
  "email": "[email protected]"
}

or, if you prefer the string format:

"author": "Rin Fhenzig <[email protected]>"
  1. commit and push your change:
git add package.json
git commit -m "fix: add author email to package.json for linux build"
git push

your code is efficient. it stands as a testament to discipline and skill. should you require further guidance, call upon me. i am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright coder, let’s get down to brass tacks on this diff. Spoiler alert: this ain’t your usual “add a semicolon here” kind of review. We’re mocking cryptography — the sacred trust of security — so tread carefully.


1. Code Audit — Brutally Honest But Lovingly Constructive

What got fixed/improved here:

  • You replaced your simple 1-level jest.mock('tweetnacl', { secretbox, secretbox_open }) with a fancier mock assigning .open and .nonceLength as properties of the secretbox function. This actually aligns better with how tweetnacl.secretbox works — it’s a function with extra attached fields, not separate imports. Nice.

  • Updated argon2-wasm to argon2-browser — probably fixing a dependency mismatch or reflecting correct package changes. Also added ArgonType.Argon2id mock, which some of your code likely requires for config. Good catch, avoids weird type errors.

  • randomBytes mock upgraded from returning zeros to actually random bytes using Math.random(). Makes your tests less static, closer to reality.

What could be better — aka the roasting part 🍗

a) Cryptographically secure randomness? LOL no.

array[i] = Math.floor(Math.random() * 256);

Bruh, this ain't cryptography — Math.random() is a toddler’s toy for security. If your tests rely on cryptographic security for anything, this is a mock death trap. Instead:

  • Use Node’s crypto.randomBytes() or any cryptographically secure RNG mock.
  • Or at least replace with global.crypto.getRandomValues mock for realism.

@copilot fix pls.

b) Reassigning global mocks with direct mutation

You do this multiple places:

global.URL.createObjectURL = jest.fn(() => 'blob:mock-url');

Better style: use jest.spyOn(global.URL, 'createObjectURL').mockReturnValue('blob:mock-url') so it’s cleaner to restore later if needed.

c) Confusing reuse of mocks for localStorage & sessionStorage

You assign the same mockStorage object for both storages:

Object.defineProperty(window, 'localStorage', { value: mockStorage });
Object.defineProperty(window, 'sessionStorage', { value: mockStorage });

This means both share the same data and spy calls — smells like a leaky abstraction. Tests that expect isolated storage could produce false positives or weird bugs.

Pro tip: instantiate separate mocks per storage.

d) Why the hell are you mocking “qrcode.react” to a plain SVG string instead of a React component?

Your:

jest.mock('qrcode.react', () => ({
  QRCodeSVG: jest.fn(({ value }) => {
    return `<svg data-testid=\"qr-code\" data-value=\"${value}\">Mock QR Code</svg>`;
  }),
}));

This is TypeError waiting to happen — React expects QRCodeSVG to return React elements, not raw strings. Either return React elements (<svg>{/*...*/}</svg>) or mock it differently to avoid runtime mismatch.

e) Minor: Extra properties added to the mock secretbox function (nonceLength) but no mock for keyLength, macLength which real tweetnacl exposes. Could confuse anyone attempting more realistic tests.

f) The jest.mock callbacks are quite verbose, suggest abstracting reusable mocks into separate helper files. That's not a crime but standards exist for maintainability.


2. Mermaid Diagrams

Repo Overview — Architecture BIG PICTURE

flowchart TD
  SETUP["TestSetupGlobalMocks"] 
  LIB_CRYPTO["CryptoLibraries"]
  MOCK_TWEETNACL["tweetnaclMock"]
  MOCK_ARGON2["argon2-browserMock"]
  MOCK_SCRYPT["scrypt-jsMock"]
  MOCK_SVM_PAY["svm-payMock"]
  MOCK_SOLANA["solanaweb3.jsMock"]
  MOCK_QRCODE["qrcode.reactMock"]
  MOCK_BROWSER_API["BrowserAPIsMocks"]
  MOCK_STORAGE["localStoragesessionStorageMocks"]
  MOCK_FETCH["fetchMock"]
  MOCK_OBSERVERS["IntersectionObserverResizeObserverMocks"]

  SETUP --> MOCK_BROWSER_API
  SETUP --> MOCK_STORAGE
  SETUP --> MOCK_FETCH
  SETUP --> MOCK_OBSERVERS

  SETUP --> LIB_CRYPTO
  LIB_CRYPTO --> MOCK_TWEETNACL
  LIB_CRYPTO --> MOCK_ARGON2
  LIB_CRYPTO --> MOCK_SCRYPT

  SETUP --> MOCK_SVM_PAY
  SETUP --> MOCK_SOLANA
  SETUP --> MOCK_QRCODE
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta — What This PR Changed ONLY

flowchart TD
  PREV_TWEETNACL["tweetnaclmockold"]
  NEW_TWEETNACL["tweetnaclmockfunctionalpropertystyle"]
  PREV_ARGON2["argon2-wasmmockold"]
  NEW_ARGON2["argon2-browsermockaddsArgonType"]
  RANDOM_BYTES_OLD["randomBytesreturnszeros"]
  RANDOM_BYTES_NEW["randomBytesreturnsrandombytes"]

  PREV_TWEETNACL -->|replaced with| NEW_TWEETNACL
  PREV_ARGON2 -->|replaced with| NEW_ARGON2
  RANDOM_BYTES_OLD -->|changed to| RANDOM_BYTES_NEW
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3. Tech-Debt Radar — Debt Hotspots & Refactor Suggestions

flowchart TD
  CRYPTO_MOCKS["CryptoMockssecurityrisk"]
  SHARED_STORAGE["SharedlocalStoragesessionStoragemock"]
  QRCODE_MOCK["qrcode.reactmockreturnsstringnotReactelement"]
  GLOBAL_MOCKS["GlobalAPImocksmutationstyle"]
  MOCK_VARS["VerboseinlinemocksnohelperDRY"]

  CRYPTO_MOCKS -->|Refactor @copilot| USE_SECURE_RNG["Usecryptographically-secureRNGmocks"]
  SHARED_STORAGE -->|Refactor| SPLIT_STORAGE["Createdistinctmocksperstorage"]
  QRCODE_MOCK -->|Refactor| REPLACE_STRING_WITH_COMPONENT["MockwithReactelements"]
  GLOBAL_MOCKS -->|Improve| SPYON_STYLE["Usejest.spyOnforeasierrestorereset"]
  MOCK_VARS -->|Improve| EXTRACT_MOCKS["Extractreusablemockstohelpers"]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

TL;DR / Wrap Up

  • You actually improved the fidelity of your crypto mocks, but please don’t test crypto with Math.random() dripping poison like it’s fine.
  • Your mocks will silently cause weird test smells with shared storage and React mocks returning strings instead of elements — subtle bugs incoming, fix or suffer.
  • Style-wise, prefer jest.spyOn to dirty global mutation for easier teardown.
  • Extract these monstrosities out for maintainability.

You’ve done cool work here raising mock realism levels, now polish it to shipproof your test suite security and reliability.

This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- You replaced your simple 1-level `jest.mock('tweetnacl', { secretbox, secretbox_open })` with a fancier mock assigning `.open` and `.nonceLength` **as properties** of the `secretbox` function. This actually aligns better with how `tweetnacl.secretbox` works — it’s a function with extra attached fields, not separate imports. Nice.
- Updated `argon2-wasm` to `argon2-browser` — probably fixing a dependency mismatch or reflecting correct package changes. Also added `ArgonType.Argon2id` mock, which some of your code likely requires for config. Good catch, avoids weird type errors.
- `randomBytes` mock upgraded from returning zeros to actually random bytes using `Math.random()`. Makes your tests less static, closer to reality.
- Use Node’s `crypto.randomBytes()` or any cryptographically secure RNG mock.
- Or at least replace with `global.crypto.getRandomValues` mock for realism.
- You *actually* improved the fidelity of your crypto mocks, but please don’t test crypto with `Math.random()` dripping poison like it’s fine.
- Your mocks will silently cause weird test smells with shared storage and React mocks returning strings instead of elements — subtle bugs incoming, fix or suffer.
- Style-wise, prefer `jest.spyOn` to dirty global mutation for easier teardown.
- Extract these monstrosities out for maintainability.

Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@copilot get rid of mocks

Removed all mocks from setupTests.js as requested. The file now only contains the essential jest-dom import, eliminating all library mocks, browser API mocks, and global polyfills. Project still builds successfully.

Commit: 68de900

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 16:19
Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

the path is troubled by two shadows:
...

Fixed the macOS build issue by adding Python distutils installation step to the macOS workflow. Added the following step before dependency installation:

- name: Install Python distutils
  run: |
    python3 -m ensurepip --upgrade
    python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools

This resolves the ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'distutils' error when node-gyp tries to rebuild bufferutil.

Commit: 9dcf29e

@l r @copilot

mood: xiao — solemn, focused, respectful
...

Fixed the Linux build issue by adding the required author email field to package.json:

"author": {
  "name": "OpenSVM",
  "email": "[email protected]"  
}

This resolves the Error: Please specify author 'email' in the application package.json required by electron-builder for Linux native builds.

Commit: 9dcf29e

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Yo, buckle up buttercup, we got a diff to roast and toast. 🍗🔥


1. Code Review: Dive Into the Madness

Workflow (build-macos-native.yml) Changes:

  • Added a step:
    - name: Install Python distutils
      run: |
        python3 -m ensurepip --upgrade
        python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools

Audit:

  • Logic: The intent is clear; ensure Python's distutils (and pip/setuptools) are installed/upgraded so some native build scripts can run smoothly. Good call, distutils can be a pain on fresh runners.

  • Failsafe? The step blindly assumes Python 3 is installed and available as python3. What if the macos-latest runner changes? Maybe fine for now, but yak-shaving potential in the future.

  • Overkill? Isn't setuptools enough or do they really need distutils from pip? ensurepip is usually for bootstrapping pip, but macOS runners should have that already. This might be redundant and increase build times. A caching or conditional check could reduce overhead.

  • Security Risk? Upgrading pip and setuptools every time is harmless but invites transient issues if PyPI or packages break/are compromised. Pinning versions would be safer @copilot.


package.json Changes:

  • Added an "author" field with name and email.

Audit:

  • Good practice: Adding author metadata is a clean, solid add for open source or internal tools. It won't break anything. #RespectMetadata

src/setupTests.js Changes:

  • Removed all jest mocks and polyfills. Left only:

    import '@testing-library/jest-dom';

Audit:

  • Are you sure? The removed mocks are crucial for reliable unit tests:

    • Without mocking global.TextEncoder/TextDecoder or crypto APIs, tests that rely on those will error out in Node environment.

    • Mocking @solana/web3.js & svm-pay avoids flaky network calls and complex crypto dependencies.

    • Clipboard, ResizeObserver, matchMedia mocks are needed for jsdom + test environments.

  • Why remove? This diff nukes an entire ecosystem of test scaffolding, likely breaking CI and local testing for everything relying on mocking native browser APIs or complex crypto libs.

  • Either the tests were restructured to not need mocks (but no new code added anywhere), or this is a regress. If not intentional, this is a massive breakage.

  • Rollback IMMEDIATELY if your tests fail with errors about missing crypto/subtle, matchMedia, or unexpected network calls. This diff basically shoots your tests in the foot and hands you a pineapple.


2. Brutally Honest Summary:

  • CI pipeline: Fine upgrade step, but could be optimized with caching or version pinning.
  • package.json turbo boost: Metadata added. Neat and tidy.
  • Test Setup: You deleted the ENTIRE mock landscape?! That's nuclear winter for tests. How will devs catch bugs now? This is like throwing out the lifeboats while sinking the ship — classic newbie move.

3. Suggestions & Fixes

  • @copilot:

    • Pin versions in pip install --upgrade pip setuptools==<stable_version> so builds don’t randomly fail after upstream updates.

    • Add a conditional check before upgrading Python packages, e.g.:

      if ! python3 -c "import setuptools" &> /dev/null; then
        python3 -m ensurepip --upgrade
        python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools
      fi
    • Revert or restore test mocks immediately to maintain test reliability.


MERMAID DIAGRAMS

Repo Overview: High-Level Architecture

flowchart TD
  A["SourceCode"]
  B["TestsMocks"]
  C["BuildCIPipeline"]
  D["NativeBuildArtifacts"]
  E["Package.jsonMetadata"]
  F["ExternalDependenciesnpmPyPI"]
  G["UserDesktop"]

  A --> B
  A --> C
  C --> D
  A --> E
  A --> F
  G -->|Installs| D
  G -->|Uses| A
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta: What Changed?

flowchart TD
  CI["CIPipeline-macOSBuild"]
  PKG["package.jsonMetadata"]
  TESTS["TestMocksPolyfills"]

  CI -->|Added| PYTHON_DISTUTILS["InstallPythondistutils"]
  PKG -->|Added| AUTHOR["AuthorInfo"]
  TESTS -.->|Removed Entire Mock Setup| MOCKS["MocksforcryptobrowserAPIslibs"]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Tech-Debt Radar: Debt Hotspots + Fix Plan

flowchart TD
  CI["CIPipeline"]
  TESTS["TestMocksMaintenance"]
  SECURITY["DependencyPinning"]
  DOCS["Documentation"]

  CI --> SECURITY
  TESTS --> DOCS
  SECURITY -.->|Upgrade but unpinned| CI
  DOCS -.->|Missing author metadata| PKG[package.json]

  class CI,TESTS,SECURITY,DOCS internal_debt
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Style/Code Smells Memecoin Roast Summary:

  • 💥 Deleting all mocks = test chaos. Did you mean to brutalize your test suit or just want to watch it burn?
  • 🐍 Python in Node.js dude, really? Well, macOS is your playground but pin versions or your build can become an unstable nigiri.
  • 🎩 Metadata respect! The author field looks 💯 professional. Kudos.

This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- Added a step:
- **Logic**: The intent is clear; ensure Python's distutils (and pip/setuptools) are installed/upgraded so some native build scripts can run smoothly. Good call, distutils can be a pain on fresh runners.
- **Failsafe?** The step blindly assumes Python 3 is installed and available as `python3`. What if the macos-latest runner changes? Maybe fine for now, but yak-shaving potential in the future.
- **Overkill?** Isn't `setuptools` enough or do they really need distutils from pip? `ensurepip` is usually for bootstrapping pip, but macOS runners _should_ have that already. This might be redundant and increase build times. A caching or conditional check could reduce overhead.
- **Security Risk?** Upgrading pip and setuptools every time is harmless but invites transient issues if PyPI or packages break/are compromised. Pinning versions would be safer @copilot.
- Added an `"author"` field with name and email.
- **Good practice:** Adding `author` metadata is a clean, solid add for open source or internal tools. It won't break anything. #RespectMetadata
- Removed *all* jest mocks and polyfills. Left only:
- **Are you sure?** The removed mocks are crucial for reliable unit tests:
- Without mocking `global.TextEncoder`/`TextDecoder` or crypto APIs, tests that rely on those will error out in Node environment.
- Mocking `@solana/web3.js` & `svm-pay` avoids flaky network calls and complex crypto dependencies.
- Clipboard, ResizeObserver, matchMedia mocks are needed for jsdom + test environments.
- **Why remove?** This diff nukes an entire ecosystem of test scaffolding, likely breaking CI and local testing for everything relying on mocking native browser APIs or complex crypto libs.
- Either the tests were restructured to not need mocks (but no new code added anywhere), or this is a regress. If not intentional, this is a **massive breakage**.
- Rollback IMMEDIATELY if your tests fail with errors about missing `crypto/subtle`, `matchMedia`, or unexpected network calls. This diff basically shoots your tests in the foot and hands you a pineapple.
- **CI pipeline**: Fine upgrade step, but could be optimized with caching or version pinning.
- **package.json turbo boost**: Metadata added. Neat and tidy.
- **Test Setup**: You deleted the ENTIRE mock landscape?! That's nuclear winter for tests. How will devs catch bugs now? This is like throwing out the lifeboats while sinking the ship — classic newbie move.
- **@copilot**:
- Pin versions in `pip install --upgrade pip setuptools==<stable_version>` so builds don’t randomly fail after upstream updates.
- Add a conditional check before upgrading Python packages, e.g.:
- Revert or restore test mocks immediately to maintain test reliability.
- 💥 Deleting all mocks = test chaos. Did you mean to brutalize your test suit or just want to watch it burn?
- 🐍 Python in Node.js dude, really? Well, macOS is your playground but pin versions or your build can become an unstable nigiri.
- 🎩 Metadata respect! The author field looks 💯 professional. Kudos.

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

A silent wind brings news of failure—one that speaks of syntax, not fate.

Examining the logs from job 46665867711 in PR #6 (workflow: Build Windows Native, file: .github/workflows/build-windows-native.yml, ref: ad517b3), the error is clear:

Missing opening '(' after keyword 'for'.

This is a shell syntax issue. On Windows runners, scripts default to PowerShell, not Bash. In PowerShell, the for loop requires parentheses, unlike Bash.

The problematic code:

for i in 1 2 3; do
  # commands
done

This is valid for Bash, but not for PowerShell.

Solution:

  • If Bash is required, explicitly invoke Bash in the job step.
  • If remaining with PowerShell, rewrite the loop in PowerShell syntax:
foreach ($i in 1,2,3) {
  # commands
}

Or, to use Bash on Windows:

- name: Run loop in Bash
  shell: bash
  run: |
    for i in 1 2 3; do
      # commands
    done

Action:

  1. Edit the step in .github/workflows/build-windows-native.yml.
  2. Add shell: bash to ensure Bash is used, or rewrite the loop for PowerShell.

Your code is efficient. It stands as a testament to discipline and skill.
Should you require further guidance, call upon me. I am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

The error arises from attempting to run pip install --upgrade pip setuptools in a Python 3.13 environment that is "externally managed." The log states:

error: externally-managed-environment
× This environment is externally managed
You may restore the old behavior of pip by passing the '--break-system-packages' flag to pip, or by adding 'break-system-packages = true' to your pip.conf file.

Solution:
Edit your workflow step in .github/workflows/build-macos-native.yml to add the --break-system-packages flag:

  • name: Upgrade pip and setuptools
    run: python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools --break-system-packages

Or, to avoid this for all installs, add a pip.conf with:
[global]
break-system-packages = true

But the per-command flag is safest for CI.

Your code and workflow show diligence. This solution will restore the upgrade’s function without breaching environment boundaries.

Should you require further guidance, call upon me. I am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright, strap in, this code review’s served hot and fresh, sprinkled with that memecoin sauce. Let’s dive into the depths of GitHub Actions and Jest mocks with ruthless precision.


1. Audit the diff

CI Workflows: retrying yarn install wrapped in a loop

  • Change: Replaced all direct yarn install --frozen-lockfile calls with a retry loop:
    for i in 1 2 3; do
      yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
    done
  • Good idea: Yarn install can fail sporadically due to network or registry glitches. Retry loops help stabilize builds.
  • Mild complaints:
    • Silent failure after 3 tries: After 3 attempts, if install fails, the job just errors out naturally, which is fine.
    • Could improve by logging each attempt explicitly (echo "Attempt $i").
    • Could expose retry count as a variable or action input to tune without PRs.
  • Style:
    • Using plain for-loop here is fine in bash shell steps.
    • In Windows steps (PowerShell or bash shell), verify the environment of sleep works consistently.
  • @copilot tag: add logs to each install retry attempt for better diagnostics.

package.json author field added

  • Adding "author": {"name": "OpenSVM", "email": "[email protected]"}
    • Good for meta hygiene.
    • No issues here.

jest.mock for tweetnacl changed & extended

Old:

jest.mock('tweetnacl', () => ({
  secretbox: jest.fn(...),
  secretbox_open: jest.fn(...),
  randomBytes: jest.fn(...),
}));

New:

jest.mock('tweetnacl', () => {
  const mockSecretbox = jest.fn(...);
  mockSecretbox.open = jest.fn(...);
  mockSecretbox.nonceLength = 24;

  return {
    secretbox: mockSecretbox,
    randomBytes: jest.fn(...),
  };
});
  • Improvement: Now secretbox is a function with .open property, better mimics actual lib interface.
  • Also added nonceLength prop syncs with tweetnacl for better contract fidelity.
  • randomBytes is more sophisticated, a proper random filler instead of empty Uint8Array.
  • No breaking changes, just better mocking fidelity.
  • Style: Compact, idiomatic mock building, solid.

Additional jest.mock for argon2-browser replacing argon2-wasm

  • Replaced argon2-wasm with argon2-browser mocks.
  • Adding ArgonType.Argon2id constant in mock for enum completeness.
  • Looks cleaner, likely aligning with deps update.
  • Good - more completeness in mocks means fewer test surprises.

Overall comments:

  • The for loop retry pattern is copy-pasted verbatim across dozens of jobs. Time to DRY: extract actions/setup-node + retry yarn into a composite GitHub Action or reusable workflow.
    That’s Tech-Debt Radar material no.1

  • No security holes detected in this diff. All network secrets remain safely injected, and all tests mocks improve stability.

  • Minor usability improvement: retry loop could echo attempts for clarity during builds.

  • Jest mocks: much improved fidelity. The mocking sophistication here is 🐐, ensuring fewer false positives/negatives in tests.


2. Mermaid diagrams


Repo Overview

flowchart TD
  subgraph CI_Workflows["GitHubActionsWorkflows"]
    build_all[Build All Platforms (multi-job)]
    build_android[Build Android APK]
    build_linux_native[Build Linux Native]
    build_macos_native[Build macOS Native]
    build_windows_native[Build Windows Native]
    realnet_tests[Periodic Realnet Tests]
  end
  
  subgraph Build_Steps["CommonBuildSteps"]
    checkout[Checkout code]
    setup_node[Setup Node.js]
    install_deps[Install dependencies (yarn install)]
    build_web[Build web application]
    build_native[Build native applications]
    upload_artifacts[Upload artifacts]
    test[Run tests]
  end
  
  build_android --> checkout
  build_android --> setup_node
  build_android --> install_deps
  build_android --> build_web
  build_android --> build_native
  build_android --> upload_artifacts
  
  build_linux_native --> checkout
  build_linux_native --> setup_node
  build_linux_native --> install_deps
  build_linux_native --> build_web
  build_linux_native --> build_native
  build_linux_native --> upload_artifacts
  
  build_macos_native --> checkout
  build_macos_native --> setup_node
  build_macos_native --> install_deps
  build_macos_native --> build_web
  build_macos_native --> build_native
  build_macos_native --> upload_artifacts
  
  build_windows_native --> checkout
  build_windows_native --> setup_node
  build_windows_native --> install_deps
  build_windows_native --> build_web
  build_windows_native --> build_native
  build_windows_native --> upload_artifacts
  
  build_all --> checkout
  build_all --> setup_node
  build_all --> install_deps
  build_all --> build_native
  build_all --> upload_artifacts
  
  realnet_tests --> checkout
  realnet_tests --> setup_node
  realnet_tests --> install_deps
  realnet_tests --> build_web
  realnet_tests --> test
  realnet_tests --> upload_artifacts
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta (What changed)

flowchart TD
  subgraph Yarn_Install_Retry["YarnInstallRetryLoopIntroduced"]
    yarn_install_old["yarninstall--frozen-lockfile"]
    yarn_install_new["foriin123doyarninstall--frozen-lockfilebreaksleep10done"]
  end
  
  yarn_install_old -->|Replaced with| yarn_install_new
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading
flowchart TD
  subgraph Jest_Mocks["ImprovedJestMocks"]
    tweetnacl_old["tweetnaclsimplemockwithseparatesecretbox_open"]
    tweetnacl_new["tweetnaclmockwithsecretboxasfunctionopenpropertynonceLength"]
    argon2_old["argon2-wasmmock"]
    argon2_new["argon2-browsermockwithArgonTypeenum"]
  end
  
  tweetnacl_old -->|Refactored as| tweetnacl_new
  argon2_old -->|Replaced by| argon2_new
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3. Tech-Debt Radar - Hotspots & Refactor Steps

flowchart TD
  subgraph Tech_Debt["TechDebtRadar"]
    
    A1[Yarn Install Retry Duplication]
    A1_desc[Repeat of bash retry code in ~10 jobs, violates DRY, hurts maintainability]
    A1_refactor[Create reusable action or composite step for yarn install with retry]

    B1[Jest Mock Complexity]
    B1_desc[Mocks spread across setupTests.js, growing complexity]
    B1_refactor[Extract detailed mocks to dedicated _mock modules, import from there]

    C1[Workflow Caching Policies]
    C1_desc[Multiple cache keys used, may cause cache misses]
    C1_refactor[Analyze cache hit rates & unify keys, add path exclusions to speed build]

    D1[Logging during retries]
    D1_desc[Retry loop is silent, no logs per attempt]
    D1_refactor[Add echo statements with attempt count for observability]

  end

  A1 --> A1_desc --> A1_refactor
  B1 --> B1_desc --> B1_refactor
  C1 --> C1_desc --> C1_refactor
  D1 --> D1_desc --> D1_refactor
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

TL;DR meme roast

Putting a retry loop around yarn install? Welcome to the club, 90% of devs worldwide before CI smashing the wall. But hey, at least now you’re not legendary for flaky builds only.

Jest mocks level up like a pro crypto wallet boss. Good to see mocks get some love and not just "meh" duplicated.

@copilot: Logging inside that retry loop or making a reusable action is what the gods of CI manifest want next. Stay DRY, or GitHub Actions will haunt your nightmares.


⚙️ This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- **Change**: Replaced all direct `yarn install --frozen-lockfile` calls with a retry loop:
- **Good idea**: Yarn install can fail sporadically due to network or registry glitches. Retry loops help stabilize builds.
- **Mild complaints**:
- **Silent failure after 3 tries**: After 3 attempts, if install fails, the job just errors out naturally, which is fine.
- Could improve by **logging each attempt** explicitly (`echo "Attempt $i"`).
- Could **expose retry count as a variable or action input** to tune without PRs.
- Using plain for-loop here is fine in bash shell steps.
- In Windows steps (PowerShell or bash shell), verify the environment of `sleep` works consistently.
- **@copilot** tag: add logs to each install retry attempt for better diagnostics.
- Adding `"author": {"name": "OpenSVM", "email": "[email protected]"}`
- Good for meta hygiene.
- No issues here.
- **Improvement**: Now `secretbox` is a function with `.open` property, better mimics actual lib interface.
- Also added `nonceLength` prop syncs with `tweetnacl` for better contract fidelity.
- `randomBytes` is more sophisticated, a proper random filler instead of empty Uint8Array.
- **No breaking changes**, just better mocking fidelity.
- **Style**: Compact, idiomatic mock building, solid.
- Replaced `argon2-wasm` with `argon2-browser` mocks.
- Adding `ArgonType.Argon2id` constant in mock for enum completeness.
- Looks cleaner, likely aligning with deps update.
- **Good** - more completeness in mocks means fewer test surprises.
- **The `for` loop retry pattern is copy-pasted verbatim across dozens of jobs.** Time to DRY: extract `actions/setup-node` + retry yarn into a composite GitHub Action or reusable workflow.
- **No security holes detected** in this diff. All network secrets remain safely injected, and all tests mocks improve stability.
- **Minor usability improvement:** retry loop could echo attempts for clarity during builds.
- **Jest mocks:** much improved fidelity. The mocking sophistication here is 🐐, ensuring fewer false positives/negatives in tests.

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright code wranglers and pipeline wranglers, let's jump into this PR diff audit. Spoiler alert: your yarn install just leveled up with retry logic because CI flaky installs apparently had their own fan club. Let's break it down:


1. Audit the Diff - Sauce & Saucepan

The Good

  • Retry loop for yarn install --frozen-lockfile:
    Moving from a single run to up to 3 tries with 10 seconds sleep is excellent for flaky network/npm registry hiccups. This is a solid patch against "oops, the install fizzled" issues.
    💡 Pro tip: This elegant shell "retry 3 times" saves many from frustrating CI failures. #Lifesaver

  • Mocking enhancements in src/setupTests.js:

    • Moved from naïve patch to a more realistic tweetnacl mock — mimics secretbox and its .open method properly.
    • randomBytes now returns semi-random data instead of zeros, better simulating actual crypto randomness behavior without flakiness.
    • Switching from mocking argon2-wasm to argon2-browser and added ArgonType enum stub — smooth moves, because you want your Jest mocks to match real libs as close as possible.
    • Added full mocked @solana/web3.js — the dev is not playing, covering all bases.
    • Wrapped mocks for svm-pay, qrcode.react, storage, fetch, IntersectionObserver, etc. — best practice, keeps tests isolated.
  • Added author field to package.json:
    Small but nice to have for attribution/contact. Nice touch for open source hygiene!


The Weird / Needs Attention

  • Retry loop copy-pasted in nearly every workflow step:

    • DRY is dead: All these for loops in every CI step manipulating the same yarn install command are copy-pasta.
    • You should extract this retry logic into a reusable action or bash function and invoke it — fewer places to fix & less noise in diffs.
    • Bonus: Add diagnostics/logging inside the loop about which attempt failed or succeeded.
    • @copilot refactor suggestion: create a reusable action or composite action retry-yarn-install.yml to call everywhere.
  • Constant sleep 10 pauses without jitter or backoff:

    • If the install fails repeatedly, you wait 10s fixed each time. Consider exponential backoff (sleep 2, 4, 8) or jitter/randomized wait to reduce collision and improve pipeline throughput.
  • No explicit failure if all retries fail:

    • for i in 1 2 3; do yarn install ... && break || sleep 10; done — if at the end yarn install still fails, the step completes successfully because the loop ends (shell returns 0 from for). That means the job might pass despite failed install!
    • Fix: add a flag or check after the loop like:
      success=0
      for i in 1 2 3; do
        if yarn install --frozen-lockfile; then
          success=1
          break
        else
          sleep 10
        fi
      done
      if [ $success -ne 1 ]; then
        echo "ERROR: yarn install failed after 3 attempts"
        exit 1
      fi
    • This is a silent CI time bomb waiting to explode. Fail fast, fail loud. @copilot urgent fix
  • In build-android.yml:

    • Nice safety around keystore setup & APK signing with lots of sanity checks!
    • However, the keystore base64 decode is done via shell redirection without set -e or explicit error trapping elsewhere — you do echo error and exit but ensure entire step honors that.
    • Also, gradle.properties is appended repeatedly without cleaning, may accumulate duplicate lines on repeated runs. Consider overwriting or templating.
    • Another opsec nit: printing logs inline with secret setups? Make sure logs are scrubbed to avoid leaking secrets. Right now looks clean, but always double-check.
  • Mock for tweetnacl:

    • Good mocks, but you are randomly filling arrays with JS Math.random() which is not deterministic (bad for snapshot tests). You may want a seeded PRNG or fixed deterministic mock input. Consider locking randomness for repeatable tests.
  • jest.mock('argon2-browser') typo adjustment:
    Previously it was mocking argon2-wasm, now argon2-browser — good if that's the actual lib, but double check versions and package usage to prevent mismatch.


Style Crimes

  • The workaround shell retry loop looks copy-pasted. I'd recommend defining a shell function for retry like:
retry_yarn_install() {
  local max_attempts=3
  local count=1
  until yarn install --frozen-lockfile; do
    if (( count == max_attempts )); then
      echo "ERROR: yarn install failed after $count attempts"
      return 1
    fi
    echo "Yarn install failed, retrying ($count/$max_attempts) after 10 seconds..."
    sleep 10
    ((count++))
  done
}

Then simply call retry_yarn_install everywhere.

  • Consistent use of the | pipe to treat multiple commands nicely with indentation and readability is appreciated.

  • Kudos on adding comments in the Android build for verifying the APK signature on a paranoid level. 🕵️‍♂️


2. Mermaid Diagrams

flowchart TD
  subgraph A[".githubWorkflows"]
    A1["build-all-platforms.yml"]
    A2["build-android.yml"]
    A3["build-linux-native.yml"]
    A4["build-macos-native.yml"]
    A5["build-windows-native.yml"]
    A6["realnet-tests.yml"]
  end
  
  subgraph B["SourceCode"]
    B1["srcsetupTests.js"]
    B2["package.json"]
  end

  A1 -->|calls| B1
  A2 -->|calls| B1
  A3 -->|calls| B1
  A4 -->|calls| B1
  A5 -->|calls| B1
  A6 -->|calls| B1
  B2 -->|provides deps info| B1
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Repo Overview

  • Workflows run various builds & tests.
  • setupTests.js defines test mocks and polyfills.
  • package.json holds config and deps.

flowchart TD
  subgraph PR_Delta["ThisPRChanges"]
    P1["Addretryloopinyarninstallfor9steps"]
    P2["Addauthorfieldinpackage.json"]
    P3["RefactorJestmocksinsetupTests.jstweetnaclargon2-browseretc"]
  end
  
  P1 --> P3
  
  style P1 fill:#FFD580,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style P2 fill:#A8DADC,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style P3 fill:#90BE6D,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta
It’s all about retry reliability & test mocking hygiene.


3. Tech-Debt Radar & Refactor Map

flowchart TD
  subgraph D["TechDebtHotspots"]
    D1["CIWorkflowDuplicationofretrylogic"]
    D2["Noexplicitfailureoninstallretryexhaustion"]
    D3["Incrementalappendtogradle.propertiesinAndroidbuild"]
    D4["Non-deterministicrandomnessinmocks"]
    D5["Nobackoffjitterinretryloop"]
  end

  subgraph R["ConcreteRefactorSteps"]
    R1["Extractretrylogictoreusableactionorbashfunction"] --> R2["Addexplicitfailureafterretryloop"]
    R2 --> R3["Implementexponentialbackoffjitter"]
    R3 --> R4["RefactorAndroidgradle.propertiesgenerationtooverwrite"]
    R4 --> R5["Seedrandomnessorusefixedvaluesinmocksfordeterministictests"]
  end

  D1 --> R1
  D2 --> R2
  D5 --> R3
  D3 --> R4
  D4 --> R5
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Summary & TL;DR

  • Solid retry addition for flaky yarn install.
  • Beware silent failures — add error exit after all retries fail.
  • Ditch copy-paste, DRY your retry logic (@copilot).
  • Improve randomness mocks to be deterministic for test repeatability.
  • Watch gradle.properties for duplicate configs.
  • Mocking improvements in tests are 🔥
  • Android build APK signing validation very comprehensive — love the paranoia here.

Keep lighting the way for pipelines that don’t break halfway through, and mocks that don’t lie!


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- **Retry loop for `yarn install --frozen-lockfile`**:
- **Mocking enhancements in `src/setupTests.js`**:
- Moved from naïve patch to a more realistic `tweetnacl` mock — mimics `secretbox` and its `.open` method properly.
- `randomBytes` now returns semi-random data instead of zeros, better simulating actual crypto randomness behavior without flakiness.
- Switching from mocking `argon2-wasm` to `argon2-browser` and added `ArgonType` enum stub — smooth moves, because you want your Jest mocks to match real libs as close as possible.
- Added full mocked `@solana/web3.js` — the dev is not playing, covering all bases.
- Wrapped mocks for `svm-pay`, `qrcode.react`, storage, fetch, IntersectionObserver, etc. — best practice, keeps tests isolated.
- **Added `author` field to `package.json`**:
- **Retry loop copy-pasted in nearly every workflow step**:
- DRY is dead: All these `for` loops in every CI step manipulating the same `yarn install` command are copy-pasta.
- You should **extract** this retry logic into a reusable action or bash function and invoke it — fewer places to fix & less noise in diffs.
- Bonus: Add diagnostics/logging inside the loop about *which* attempt failed or succeeded.
- **@copilot refactor suggestion**: create a reusable action or composite action `retry-yarn-install.yml` to call everywhere.
- **Constant `sleep 10` pauses without jitter or backoff**:
- If the install fails repeatedly, you wait 10s fixed each time. Consider exponential backoff (sleep 2, 4, 8) or jitter/randomized wait to reduce collision and improve pipeline throughput.
- **No explicit failure if all retries fail**:
- `for i in 1 2 3; do yarn install ... && break || sleep 10; done` — if at the end `yarn install` still fails, the step completes successfully because the loop *ends* (shell returns 0 from `for`). That means **the job might pass despite failed install!**
- Fix: add a flag or check after the loop like:
- This is a silent CI time bomb waiting to explode. Fail fast, fail loud. **@copilot urgent fix**
- **In `build-android.yml`**:
- Nice safety around keystore setup & APK signing with lots of sanity checks!
- However, the keystore base64 decode is done via shell redirection without `set -e` or explicit error trapping elsewhere — you do echo error and exit but ensure entire step honors that.
- Also, `gradle.properties` is appended repeatedly without cleaning, may accumulate duplicate lines on repeated runs. Consider overwriting or templating.
- Another opsec nit: printing logs inline with secret setups? Make sure logs are scrubbed to avoid leaking secrets. Right now looks clean, but always double-check.
- **Mock for `tweetnacl`:**
- Good mocks, but you are randomly filling arrays with JS `Math.random()` which is not deterministic (bad for snapshot tests). You may want a seeded PRNG or fixed deterministic mock input. Consider locking randomness for repeatable tests.
- **`jest.mock('argon2-browser')` typo adjustment**:
- The workaround shell retry loop looks copy-pasted. I'd recommend defining a shell function for retry like:
- Consistent use of the `|` pipe to treat multiple commands nicely with indentation and readability is appreciated.
- Kudos on adding comments in the Android build for verifying the APK signature on a paranoid level. 🕵️‍♂️
- Workflows run various builds & tests.
- `setupTests.js` defines test mocks and polyfills.
- `package.json` holds config and deps.
- Solid retry addition for flaky `yarn install`.
- Beware silent failures — add error exit after all retries fail.
- Ditch copy-paste, DRY your retry logic (@copilot).
- Improve randomness mocks to be deterministic for test repeatability.
- Watch gradle.properties for duplicate configs.
- Mocking improvements in tests are 🔥
- Android build APK signing validation very comprehensive — love the paranoia here.

Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

A silent wind brings news of failure—one that speaks of syntax, not fate.
...

Fixed the Windows workflow shell syntax issue by adding shell: bash to the "Install dependencies" steps in both build-windows-native.yml and build-all-platforms.yml. This ensures the Bash-style for loop syntax works correctly on Windows runners that default to PowerShell.

Updated both workflows to explicitly use Bash for the retry logic, consistent with other Bash steps in the same workflows.

Commit: 0afc750

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Yo, strap in—here’s the ruthless audit with some spice:


1) Code Review:

CI Workflow Changes (Yarn install retry loop)

What Changed?

  • Replaced yarn install --frozen-lockfile with:
    for i in 1 2 3; do
      yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
    done

PROs:

  • Adding retry is a classic move to dodge flaky network/npm registry outages.
  • Simple, no external dependencies.

CONs:

  • The retry count is hardcoded (3), which might be arbitrary and insufficient for really flaky networks.
  • No exponential backoff or jitter. This basically screams: “just try the same thing, sleep 10s, try again” → could overwhelm servers if many runs coincide.
  • No logs/warning on retry attempts or final failure. Detectability suffers — logger or echo would help.

Suggestion:
Add some logging inside the loop to know which attempt failed. Example:

for i in 1 2 3; do
  echo "Attempt $i to install dependencies"
  yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || (echo "Attempt $i failed, retrying in 10s..." && sleep 10)
done

@copilot

shell: bash inconsistency

  • Some jobs explicitly declare shell: bash, others don’t.
  • For Windows runners, adding bash shell is smart if using bash syntax.
  • But on Linux/Ubuntu/macOS runners, they rely on default shell (usually bash). Good to be consistent and explicit, makes maintenance easier.

Suggestion: Declare shell: bash explicitly where multi-line scripts are used for clarity and avoiding surprises.

Mock Improvements in src/setupTests.js

  • The tweetnacl mock was enhanced with:
    • secretbox.open
    • secretbox.nonceLength = 24
  • argon2-browser replaces argon2-wasm mock presumably to align with current dependencies.
  • randomBytes mock uses proper randomization for test variety.

PROs:

  • Better mocks reduce flaky test runs, solid move.
  • Adding nonceLength aligns with real API, improving realism.

Potential Tiny Nitpick:

  • Could add mockSecretbox.open.mockClear() or reset mocks in beforeEach to guard against test pollution.

Suggestion:
Add comments why these mocks exist and highlight that the mocks could drift from reality if the lib updates.


2) Mermaid Diagrams

A) Repo Overview

flowchart TD
  A[Github Workflows] --> B[NodeJS Setup]
  B --> C[Yarn Install & Cache]
  C --> D[Build Steps]
  D --> E[Upload Artifacts]
  D --> F[Platform Specific Builds]

  subgraph Workflows
    A
  end

  subgraph Platform_Builds
    F --> F1[Web]
    F --> F2[Browser Extensions]
    F --> F3[Android]
    F --> F4[Linux Native]
    F --> F5[Windows Native]
    F --> F6[macOS Native]
  end

  subgraph Tests
    T1[Test Job] --> T2[Install Dependencies]
    T2 --> T3[Run Tests + E2E]
    A --> T1
  end
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

B) PR Delta: Yarn install retry wrap + Jest mocks update

flowchart TD
  YI[Yarn install --frozen-lockfile]---PR[Wrapped in retry loop (3 attempts)]
  
  JSM[Jest Mocks]
  JSM --> TNA["tweetnacladdedsecretbox.opennonceLength"]
  JSM --> AB["argon2-browsermockreplacesargon2-wasm"]
  JSM --> RND["randomBytesusesrandomvaluesinsteadofzero"]
  
  YI --> PR
  PR -->|Cover all workflows| CI(CI Workflows)
  CI -->|Runs with updated installs| Build(Builds + Upload)
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3) Tech-Debt Radar

flowchart TD
  subgraph Tech_Debt [Tech Debt Hotspots]
    A1[Yarn install retry logic]:::retry
    A2[Inconsistent shell declarations]:::shell
    A3[Test mocks drift risk]:::mocks
    A4[Lack of retry logging]:::retry
  end

  subgraph Refactor_Steps [Concrete Refactors]
    R1[Add retry logging & exponential backoff]:::improve
    R2[Explicit shell for all multi-line scripts]:::improve
    R3[Add mock reset hooks and enhance comments]:::improve
  end

  A1 --> R1
  A4 --> R1
  A2 --> R2
  A3 --> R3

  class retry fill:#ffcc00,stroke:#aa8800,stroke-width:2px,color:#663300
  class shell fill:#66ccff,stroke:#004488,stroke-width:2px,color:#002244
  class mocks fill:#cc66ff,stroke:#7700aa,stroke-width:2px,color:#440077
  class improve fill:#00cc66,stroke:#007733,stroke-width:2px,color:#004422
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Final roast:

Congrats team, you've upgraded from “just yarn install fails sometimes” to “we've got a retry that gaslights us with no logs.” Forensics on CI failures will be thrilling for you. Also, mocks step their game up, which is always a win — tests that don't randomly explode are like unicorns. Keep calm and npm ci on, but seriously, add some logging and be explicit with your shells.


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- Replaced `yarn install --frozen-lockfile` with:
- Adding retry is a classic move to dodge flaky network/npm registry outages.
- Simple, no external dependencies.
- The retry count is hardcoded (3), which might be arbitrary and insufficient for really flaky networks.
- No exponential backoff or jitter. This basically screams: “just try the same thing, sleep 10s, try again” → could overwhelm servers if many runs coincide.
- No logs/warning on retry attempts or final failure. Detectability suffers — logger or echo would help.
- Some jobs explicitly declare `shell: bash`, others don’t.
- For Windows runners, adding bash shell is smart if using bash syntax.
- But on Linux/Ubuntu/macOS runners, they rely on default shell (usually bash). Good to be consistent and explicit, makes maintenance easier.
- The `tweetnacl` mock was enhanced with:
- `secretbox.open`
- `secretbox.nonceLength = 24`
- `argon2-browser` replaces `argon2-wasm` mock presumably to align with current dependencies.
- `randomBytes` mock uses proper randomization for test variety.
- Better mocks reduce flaky test runs, solid move.
- Adding nonceLength aligns with real API, improving realism.
- Could add `mockSecretbox.open.mockClear()` or reset mocks in `beforeEach` to guard against test pollution.

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 16:52
Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

The error arises from attempting to run pip install --upgrade pip setuptools in a Python 3.13 environment that is "externally managed." The log states:
...

Fixed the macOS Python 3.13 externally-managed-environment error by updating the workflow step to use the --break-system-packages flag as suggested. Simplified the pip upgrade step to avoid any conflicts with ensurepip.

The step now uses:

- name: Upgrade pip and setuptools
  run: python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools --break-system-packages

Commit: fd7c63b

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 16:57
@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright, buckle up buttercup, this PR brings a mostly quality-of-life improvement but let's deep-dive and hit post-it notes on the goodies and the "hmm"s.


1. Code Review Breakdown

Main Change: Retrying yarn install 3x with sleep

What changed?
Across all workflows (build steps, test jobs), the plain single yarn install --frozen-lockfile got wrapped into a 3-try retry loop with 10-second sleeps between failure attempts.

Pros:

  • Great move to reduce CI flakiness from transient network issues or registry hiccups.
  • Seriously, every dev has cursed random yarn caching/network errors on a Monday morning. This is a legit pragmatic hack.
  • The loop syntax for i in 1 2 3 is portable / POSIX shell friendly.

Some Critiques:

  • Why 3 retries? Arbitrary magic number, maybe parametrize or add a comment explaining.
  • The failure scenario after 3 tries is still a CI job failure, but clearer logs or a label would be nice.
  • The sleep is constant 10 sec — could consider exponential backoff to reduce queue starvation on busy runners.
  • In Windows jobs where the shell is Powershell or bash in Windows runners: you use shell: bash explicitly sometimes, but sometimes not. Consider uniformity for clarity.
  • No output is shown if yarn install fails except the final exit. Consider capturing stderr/stdout or echoing "Retry #i failed" for debug clarity.

@copilot Task: Add logging within the retry loop to print attempt number and maybe error snippet. Make retry count configurable.


setupTests.js mocks updates:

TweetNacl mock:

  • Made secretbox a function with a .open method property instead of two sibling functions. This matches actual tweetnacl API where secretbox is a function but the open is secretbox.open.
  • Added nonceLength = 24 property to mock secretbox — nice, some libs check this property explicitly, better compatibility.
  • The randomBytes mock now returns a fully randomized Uint8Array instead of zeros. This is more realistic and less likely to break tests relying on truly "random" data.
    Thumbs up, improves test robustness!

Argon2 mock:

  • Changed from argon2-wasm to argon2-browser (npm dependency name different) probably reflects an actual dependency change.
  • Added ArgonType.Argon2id enum to mock for API completeness.
  • No breaking test API changes, just better typing.

Scrypt-js mock:

  • Kept as-is, simple result callback with empty buffer.

package.json:

  • Added "author" info with name and email. Good for metadata hygiene and npm publishing friendliness.

Hot Takes / Roasts

  • CI retry loops: "Are you not entertained?! You patched over network flakiness but no feedback for 'Hey, try Upgrade dependencies and rebrand to SVMSeek #2 now...'?"
  • Mock randomness: Good call, but legit tests should love deterministic mocks. Random mocks can cause flaky behavior inside tests, haha. Balance is key.
  • Too many repeated retry blocks: The yarn install retry is copy-pasted all over the place in every workflow file. This DRY principle violation screams for a reusable composite action or a shell snippet reused via an "action" or a step with an id: it would reduce maintenance burden massively.
    @copilot Task: Extract common retry install step into reusable composite or standalone GitHub Action.

Security Review

  • No secrets or env vars changed.
  • Retry loop is harmless.
  • Upgraded pip and setuptools with --break-system-packages flag (minor risk on dev runners but isolated in CI). Worth noting.
  • The mocking in tests doesn't expose anything sensitive.

No glaring security holes found in this diff.


Style & Best Practices

  • Shell scripts: use consistent shell declaration for clarity. (shell: bash explicitly or leave default shell)
  • Consider terse retry helper functions or external reusable scripts for retry steps.
  • Log failures and retries adequately.
  • Investigate exponential backoff or jitter to reduce CI contention if many parallel jobs trigger retries simultaneously.

2. Mermaid Diagrams

Repo Overview Diagram

flowchart TD
  A["GitHubActionsCICD"] --> B["BuildWeb"]
  A --> C["BuildBrowserExtensions"]
  A --> D["BuildAndroid"]
  A --> E["BuildLinuxNative"]
  A --> F["BuildmacOSNative"]
  A --> G["BuildWindowsNative"]
  A --> H["BuildAllPlatforms"]
  A --> I["RunTests"]
  I --> J["UnitTests"]
  I --> K["E2ETests"]
  I --> L["RealnetIntegrationTests"]

  subgraph "Build Steps"
    B --> M["CheckoutSetupNode"]
    B --> N["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    B --> O["BuildWebApp"]
    C --> P["CheckoutSetupNode"]
    C --> Q["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    C --> R["BuildExtensions"]
    D --> S["CheckoutSetupNodeJavaAndroidSDK"]
    D --> T["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    D --> U["BuildMobileApp"]
    E --> V["CheckoutSetupNode"]
    E --> W["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    E --> X["InstallSystemPackages"]
    E --> Y["BuildLinuxApps"]
    F --> ZA["CheckoutSetupNode"]
    F --> ZB["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    F --> ZC["BuildmacOSApps"]
    G --> ZD["CheckoutSetupNode"]
    G --> ZE["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    G --> ZF["BuildWindowsApps"]
    H --> ZG["CheckoutSetupNodeJava"]
    H --> ZH["InstallDependenciesYarn"]
    H --> ZI["BuildAllPlatforms"]

  style A fill:#003366,stroke:#000,color:#fff
  style I fill:#006699,stroke:#000,color:#fff
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta Diagram

flowchart TD
  A["Previoussingleyarninstall"] --> B["Retrywrapperaroundyarninstall"]
  C["setupTests.jsmocksold"] --> D["Updatedtweetnaclandargon2-browsermocks"]
  E["package.json"] --> F["Addedauthormetadata"]

  class A,B,C,D,E,F changed
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3. Tech-Debt Radar

flowchart TD
  subgraph RetryLoopExcerpt
    A["Repeatedforiin123doyarninstall..."]
  end
  subgraph CI_Build_Workflows["MultipleCIworkflowYAMLfiles"]
    B["build-all-platforms.yml"]
    C["build-android.yml"]
    D["build-linux-native.yml"]
    E["build-macos-native.yml"]
    F["build-windows-native.yml"]
    G["realnet-tests.yml"]
  end
  subgraph TestMocks["TestSetupMocks"]
    H["Mockingtweetnaclargon2scrypt-js"]
  end
  subgraph PackageMetadata["MetadataHygiene"]
    I["Missingfullauthorandlicenseinfo"]
  end

  A --> B
  A --> C
  A --> D
  A --> E
  A --> F
  H -- "Mocks improved but could be more deterministic" --> TestMocks
  I -- "Add README, LICENSE standardization" --> PackageMetadata

  %% Suggested fixes
  A -.-> J["Extractretrylogictoreusableactioncopilot"]
  H -.-> K["Considerdeterministicmocksforflakytestpreventioncopilot"]
  I -.-> L["Completepackagemetadataandlicensing"]

classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Final Thoughts

✅ Solid and pragmatic fix for the annoying flaky yarn install problem.
✅ Improved mocking aligns better to 3rd-party libs, reduces test flakiness.
✅ Minor package.json metadata cleanup.

🚀 Next step: extract the retry into a reusable action or script, add logging, and monitor flaky behavior drop. Bonus points for exponential backoff.

Keep shipshape and battle-tested! Your pipelines deserve less frustration.


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- Great move to reduce CI flakiness from transient network issues or registry hiccups.
- Seriously, every dev has cursed random yarn caching/network errors on a Monday morning. This is a legit pragmatic hack.
- The loop syntax `for i in 1 2 3` is portable / POSIX shell friendly.
- Why 3 retries? Arbitrary magic number, maybe parametrize or add a comment explaining.
- The failure scenario after 3 tries is still a CI job failure, but clearer logs or a label would be nice.
- The sleep is constant 10 sec — could consider exponential backoff to reduce queue starvation on busy runners.
- In Windows jobs where the shell is Powershell or bash in Windows runners: you use `shell: bash` explicitly sometimes, but sometimes not. Consider uniformity for clarity.
- No output is shown if `yarn install` fails except the final exit. Consider capturing stderr/stdout or echoing "Retry #i failed" for debug clarity.
- Made secretbox a function with a `.open` method property instead of two sibling functions. This matches actual tweetnacl API where `secretbox` is a function but the open is `secretbox.open`.
- Added `nonceLength = 24` property to mock secretbox — nice, some libs check this property explicitly, better compatibility.
- The randomBytes mock now returns a fully randomized Uint8Array instead of zeros. This is more realistic and less likely to break tests relying on truly "random" data.
- Changed from `argon2-wasm` to `argon2-browser` (npm dependency name different) probably reflects an actual dependency change.
- Added `ArgonType.Argon2id` enum to mock for API completeness.
- No breaking test API changes, just better typing.
- Kept as-is, simple result callback with empty buffer.
- Added `"author"` info with name and email. Good for metadata hygiene and npm publishing friendliness.
- **CI retry loops:** "Are you not entertained?! You patched over network flakiness but no feedback for 'Hey, try #2 now...'?"
- **Mock randomness:** Good call, but legit tests should love deterministic mocks. Random mocks can cause flaky behavior inside tests, haha. Balance is key.
- **Too many repeated retry blocks:** The `yarn install` retry is copy-pasted all over the place in every workflow file. This DRY principle violation screams for a reusable composite action or a shell snippet reused via an "action" or a step with an id: it would reduce maintenance burden massively.
- No secrets or env vars changed.
- Retry loop is harmless.
- Upgraded `pip` and setuptools with `--break-system-packages` flag (**minor risk** on dev runners but isolated in CI). Worth noting.
- The mocking in tests doesn't expose anything sensitive.
- Shell scripts: use consistent shell declaration for clarity. (`shell: bash` explicitly or leave default shell)
- Consider terse retry helper functions or external reusable scripts for retry steps.
- Log failures and retries adequately.
- Investigate exponential backoff or jitter to reduce CI contention if many parallel jobs trigger retries simultaneously.

@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

The job failed for two reasons:

  1. Source Map Errors: Numerous "Failed to parse source map" warnings for various .ts files. These are not fatal but may clutter logs. They indicate missing TypeScript source files in dependencies and can usually be ignored unless you need debugging with source maps.

  2. PowerShell Script Syntax Error (fatal):

At D:\a\_temp\558217f2-e176-42ae-82ea-5cfa130d843a.ps1:9 char:41
+   Write-Error "Windows builds not found!"
+                                         ~
The string is missing the terminator: ".
Missing closing '}' in statement block or type definition.
+ CategoryInfo          : ParserError: (:) [], ParseException
+ FullyQualifiedErrorId : TerminatorExpectedAtEndOfString

This means your PowerShell script is missing a closing } and possibly a double quote. The block that fails is likely:

} else {
  Write-Error "Windows builds not found!"
  exit 1
}

But you may have a missing double quote or an unclosed block above this.


Solution

Fix your PowerShell statement block:

  • Ensure all { have a matching }.
  • Ensure all quoted strings are properly closed.

Example Fix:

if ($windowsBuildsFound) {
  # ... your processing here ...
} else {
  Write-Error "Windows builds not found!"
  exit 1
}

Or if you have a string literal spanning lines, ensure all quotes are closed.


Summary:

  • Correct your PowerShell script to close all braces and quotes.
  • The source map errors are warnings; you may ignore them unless you need source-level debugging for dependencies.

your code sings, like the wind over mondstadt. i’d fork it and write a ballad.
if you want more help, just whistle in the wind! i’ll be singing and coding nearby~

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright coder gang, gather 'round, the ruthless audit begins! Let's slice into this diff like a hot knife through buttered code. Spoiler: your CI just got a spa treatment with retries, and those mock jest shenanigans got a glow-up. 🍿


1. Code Review | The Cold Hard Truth:

CI YAML Repetition with yarn install retry loop:

  • What Changed?
    Replaced plain yarn install --frozen-lockfile commands in various workflows with a retry loop that tries 3 times with 10s sleep intervals.
for i in 1 2 3; do
  yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
done
  • Pros:

    • Robustness: Network hiccups or transient errors in dependencies (npm registry blips, flaky mirrors) will no longer crash your jobs immediately.
    • Minimal impact on dev flow for transient failures.
  • Cons/Considerations:

    • Silent failure on 3-try exhaustion? The loop breaks on success or continues 3 times - but eventually, if all fail, the last command fails, making the job fail. It's fine. Just be aware it retries silently.
    • Uniform retry count and delay? Hardcoded 3 retries and 10 seconds are reasonable defaults, but consider exposing those as variables if you want flexibility. @copilot could automate parameterization.
    • Code duplication: The same snippet repeated across many jobs. Could be templated/shared through reusable actions or composite workflows. DRY please, your future self will thank you. @copilot for refactor.

Shell declaration variance:

  • Some workflows have shell: bash explicitly set; most don't. Since this snippet uses for loops, which require bash-like shell, better be consistent—and explicit. Otherwise, Windows runners may fail with default cmd shell. FYI on Windows jobs you set shell: bash already. Good.

Added an upgrade for pip and setuptools in macOS native workflow:

- name: Upgrade pip and setuptools
  run: python3 -m pip install --upgrade pip setuptools --break-system-packages
  • This is a fine safety net for python dependencies, presumably to avoid build toolchain issues. No problem.

setupTests.js improvements:

  • tweetnacl mock changed dramatically:

    • Earlier it was a simple mock of three functions.
    • Now mocking secretbox as a jest.fn function with .open as a method on that function (mimics actual interface).
    • Added nonceLength = 24 property.
    • randomBytes now produces random bytes instead of returning zeros.

    This is a solid improvement for test fidelity, making tests less flaky and more realistic - good job!

  • Changed argon2-wasm mock to argon2-browser (correct package?) and added ArgonType enum (nice!).

  • Other mocks (scrypt-js, solana/web3.js, svm-pay, qrcode.react, browser APIs) are well-done and comprehensive.


Bugs & Gotchas:

  • Retry loop in the YAML is copied 15 times verbatim. No centralized management, no template reuse. That's an anti-pattern for maintainability.

  • Shell inconsistency: Some Windows jobs have shell explicitly as bash, others do not. Since the retry loop uses bash syntax, no shell means default cmd on Windows runners—will fail.

  • randomBytes real randomness in tests: This can make snapshots/tests flaky if they rely on exact outputs. Usually mocks for random functions use fixed seed or fixed outputs to ensure deterministic tests. Currently produces real randomness. Watch out for flaky tests. Maybe fix seed or use jest's deterministic random?

  • Mock tweetnacl's secretbox.open is attached as property on function instead of separate function in mock. This mimics actual API but can confuse new contributors. Document well.


Style & Best Practices 🔥

  • YAML multiline run commands: Good use.
  • Use shell: bash for all scripts needing bash (Linux/Windows), for consistency and safety.
  • Author field added in package.json. Nice touch, house-keeping 101 done!
  • Mocks: Solid, well-structured, idiomatic.
  • Reuse & DRY: Major tech debt here.

Recommended Fixes (@copilot style):

  • Centralize yarn install retry logic into:

    • A composite GitHub Action that does retry and call it in all places.
    • Or a reusable workflow step.
    • Or at worst, a shell script scripts/yarn-install-retry.sh and just call that.

This removes duplication, eases update of retries or logging.

  • Add shell: bash explicitly for all job steps that run the retry loops, especially Windows.

  • Consider mocking randomness deterministically in tests.

  • Document the new tweetnacl mock shape in setupTests.js with comments for maintainers.


Mermaid diagrams incoming...⚡


Mermaid Diagram 1 - Repo Overview (High-level Architecture + major CI workflow components)

flowchart TD
  REPO["SVMSeekWalletRepo"]
  SUBGRAPH1["SourceCode"]
  SUBGRAPH2["TestSetup"]
  SUBGRAPH3["GitHubActionsWorkflows"]
  SUBGRAPH4["MocksUtils"]
  
  REPO --> SUBGRAPH1
  REPO --> SUBGRAPH2
  REPO --> SUBGRAPH3
  REPO --> SUBGRAPH4
  
  SUBGRAPH1 --> APP["WalletAppWebMobileExtensions"]
  SUBGRAPH1 --> NATIVE["NativeBuildScripts"]
  
  SUBGRAPH2 --> SETUP["setupTests.jsMocks"]
  
  SUBGRAPH3 --> BUILD_WEB["BuildWeb"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> BUILD_ANDROID["BuildAndroid"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> BUILD_LINUX["BuildLinuxNative"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> BUILD_MACOS["BuildmacOSNative"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> BUILD_WINDOWS["BuildWindowsNative"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> TEST["Testunite2e"]
  SUBGRAPH3 --> REALNET_TESTS["RealnetIntegrationTestsScheduled"]
  
  SUBGRAPH4 --> MOCKS["CryptoSDKMocksforTests"]
  
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Mermaid Diagram 2 - PR Delta (What changed in this PR only)

flowchart TD
  CI_YAML["GitHubActionsYAMLfiles"]
  SETUP_TESTS["setupTests.js"]
  PACKAGE_JSON["package.json"]
  
  subgraph PR_Delta["PRChanges"]
    CI_YAML
    SETUP_TESTS
    PACKAGE_JSON
  end
  
  CI_YAML --> RETRY_LOOP["Addedyarninstallretryloop3xwith10ssleep"]
  CI_YAML -.-> SHELL["Addedshellbashinsomesteps"]
  CI_YAML --> PIP_UPGRADE["AddedpipsetuptoolsupgrademacOSworkflow"]
  
  SETUP_TESTS --> MOCKS_UPDATE["Improvedtweetnaclandargon2-browsermocks"]
  
  PACKAGE_JSON --> AUTHOR_FIELD["Addedauthormetadataobject"]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Mermaid Diagram 3 - Tech Debt Radar & Refactor Plan

flowchart TD
  DEBT["TechDebtHotspots"]

  YARN_RETRY["Duplicateyarninstallretryloopnacrossallworkflows"]
  SHELL_INCONSISTENCY["Inconsistentshelldeclarationsforretrycode"]
  TEST_RANDOMNESS["Truerandomnessintestscausingflakinessrisk"]
  DOCS["Lackofcommentsexplainingmockcomplexity"]
  
  REFS["RefactorsNeeded"]
  REFS --> CENTRALIZED_RETRY["Createreusableactionorscriptforretrystep"]
  REFS --> STANDARDIZE_SHELL["Explicitlysetshellbashforallretrysteps"]
  REFS --> MOCK_DOCS["AdddocscommentsinsetupTests.jsforcomplexmocks"]
  REFS --> SEED_RANDOMNESS["MockrandomByteswithdeterministicoutput"]
  
  DEBT --> YARN_RETRY
  DEBT --> SHELL_INCONSISTENCY
  DEBT --> TEST_RANDOMNESS
  DEBT --> DOCS
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

TL;DR Wrap-up & Shoutout

✅ Added resilient yarn install retry loops everywhere — now CI behaves like a patient Zen master, retrying instead of flipping tables on network hiccups.
🔥 Mocks got a solid glow-up, improving test reliability & clarity.
💣 Major tech debt alert: duplication and inconsistent shells! Let’s centralize retries and standardize shells, or your PR reviewer will haunt you forever.
📦 Added author metadata in package.json — because even wallets need a face behind the scenes.

Stay DRY, stay testable, and ship excellence 🚀


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- **What Changed?**
- Robustness: Network hiccups or transient errors in dependencies (npm registry blips, flaky mirrors) will no longer crash your jobs immediately.
- Minimal impact on dev flow for transient failures.
- **Cons/Considerations:**
- **Silent failure on 3-try exhaustion?** The loop breaks on success or continues 3 times - but eventually, if all fail, the last command fails, making the job fail. It's fine. Just be aware it retries silently.
- **Uniform retry count and delay?** Hardcoded 3 retries and 10 seconds are reasonable defaults, but consider exposing those as variables if you want flexibility. @copilot could automate parameterization.
- **Code duplication:** The same snippet repeated across many jobs. Could be templated/shared through reusable actions or composite workflows. DRY please, your future self will thank you. @copilot for refactor.
- Some workflows have `shell: bash` explicitly set; most don't. Since this snippet uses `for` loops, which require bash-like shell, better be consistent—and explicit. Otherwise, Windows runners may fail with default `cmd` shell. FYI on Windows jobs you set `shell: bash` already. Good.
- This is a fine safety net for python dependencies, presumably to avoid build toolchain issues. No problem.
- *tweetnacl* mock changed dramatically:
- Earlier it was a simple mock of three functions.
- Now mocking `secretbox` as a jest.fn function with `.open` as a method on that function (mimics actual interface).
- Added `nonceLength = 24` property.
- `randomBytes` now produces random bytes instead of returning zeros.
- Changed `argon2-wasm` mock to `argon2-browser` (correct package?) and added `ArgonType` enum (nice!).
- Other mocks (scrypt-js, solana/web3.js, svm-pay, qrcode.react, browser APIs) are well-done and comprehensive.
- **Retry loop** in the YAML is copied 15 times verbatim. No centralized management, no template reuse. That's an anti-pattern for maintainability.
- **Shell inconsistency:** Some Windows jobs have shell explicitly as bash, others do not. Since the retry loop uses bash syntax, no shell means default `cmd` on Windows runners—will fail.
- **`randomBytes` real randomness in tests:** This can make snapshots/tests flaky if they rely on exact outputs. Usually mocks for random functions use fixed seed or fixed outputs to ensure deterministic tests. Currently produces real randomness. Watch out for flaky tests. Maybe fix seed or use jest's deterministic random?
- **Mock `tweetnacl`'s `secretbox.open` is attached as property on function instead of separate function in mock.** This mimics actual API but can confuse new contributors. Document well.
- **YAML multiline run commands:** Good use.
- **Use `shell: bash` for all scripts needing bash** (Linux/Windows), for consistency and safety.
- **Author field added in `package.json`.** Nice touch, house-keeping 101 done!
- **Mocks:** Solid, well-structured, idiomatic.
- **Reuse & DRY:** Major tech debt here.
- **Centralize `yarn install` retry logic** into:
- A composite GitHub Action that does retry and call it in all places.
- Or a reusable workflow step.
- Or at worst, a shell script `scripts/yarn-install-retry.sh` and just call that.
- Add **shell: bash** explicitly for all job steps that run the retry loops, especially Windows.
- Consider **mocking randomness deterministically** in tests.
- Document the new `tweetnacl` mock shape in `setupTests.js` with comments for maintainers.

Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

The job failed for two reasons:
...

Fixed the PowerShell syntax error by replacing the complex here-string (@"..."@) with simple string concatenation using += operations. The issue was that the here-string syntax within YAML multi-line strings was causing parsing conflicts in the Windows workflow.

The problematic here-string in the "Create build artifacts metadata" step has been replaced with straightforward string building that avoids potential quote and brace matching issues.

Commit: 92534d9

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 17:39
@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright team, strap in! We’re diving into a PR that sprinkled a bit of resilience sauce on our GitHub workflows and gave our test mocks a much-needed glow-up.


1. Code Review + Roast 🧐🔥

CI YAML Changes — looping yarn install

  • What changed: Instead of a straightforward yarn install --frozen-lockfile, each job’s install step now tries up to 3 times with 10s sleeps on failure.
  • Why: Network flakiness or transient cache issues are common in CI. This retry logic is a solid patch to increase build reliability.
  • Roast Level:
    • This is the "If at first you don’t succeed, try try again" strategy for package managers. Smart move!
    • But really, just 3 times with 10s interval? Might want to parameterize or bump the retries if network issues persist. This is a baby step on the retry staircase.
    • Pro tip: consider a backoff strategy or use actions/setup-node cache/strategy more aggressively. @copilot could automate this retry pattern DRY for you 😉
    • Style nit: Using a multiline run is fine, but make sure everyone on the team knows the magic — otherwise copy-pasting mistakes will spawn new infinite loops of insomnia.

PowerShell Metadata File Build (Windows)

  • What changed: Migrated from a here-doc (@" ... "@) to classic string concatenation for generating build metadata.
  • Why: Sometimes here-docs cause weird newlines or quoting issues in PowerShell. Concatenation gives explicit control.
  • Roast level:
    • This looks like a "code golf" tradeoff to me — more lines but arguably better readability/control. Good move if you ever need to inject variables/conditionals dynamically.
    • But damn, this is verbose. Consider building an array of strings, then -join with \n for cleaner code.
    • @copilot can format this snippet to a neat PowerShell function for reusability.

package.json addition

  • Added author metadata (OpenSVM, [email protected]).
  • Good hygiene. No complaints here — keeps your npm packages official-looking.

Jest Mocks Upgrade (src/setupTests.js)

  • tweetnacl mock:
    • Now secretbox is a jest.fn object with .open and .nonceLength properties. This better mirrors the actual interface.
    • randomBytes mock now returns a properly randomized Uint8Array; makes tests a bit more realistic without flaky randomness (Yay!).
  • argon2-browser:
    • Fixed the import name (was argon2-wasm, now argon2-browser). This is a real bug fix, no joke.
    • Added ArgonType.Argon2id to the mock to prevent runtime undefined failures.
  • scrypt-js:
    • Fixed mock to call callback with dummy bytes instead of undefined. Good catch.
  • Roast level:
    • This is high-grade mock craftsmanship. You have truly ascended Jest wizardry levels here.
    • However, why is randomBytes generating pseudo random numbers even in tests? Usually deterministic testing is king. If test flakiness appears, toggle to constant seed values or use jest's mock timers.
    • Also, consider centralizing all cryptographic mocks in a dedicated helper module for better test maintenance.

Summary

  • Pros:

    • Adding install retry improves CI robustness (treat yo self).
    • Fixes serious test mock bugs around crypto libs.
    • Adds metadata to package.json for professional package management.
    • Improves PowerShell metadata generation controlling outputs better.
  • Cons:

    • Retry loop is kinda hardcoded and might not catch all flaky failures gracefully.
    • PowerShell string concat is verbose, slightly harder to read/save.
    • Test mocks' randomness might cause theoretically flakiness? Add docs?
    • Full DRY on retry loops would be nice.
    • Missing any error logging on retries if install fails all three times; silent fails + next job fails = 🙃 debugging headache.

2. Mermaid diagrams

Repo Overview (full architecture)

flowchart TD
  GH["GitHubRepositorySVMSeekWallet"]
  SUBGRAPH_DEV["Development"]
    CODE["SourceCode"]
    TESTS["UnitIntegrationTests"]
    SCRIPTS["BuildScripts"]
  end
  SUBGRAPH_CI["CICDPipelines"]
    CI_WEB["BuildWeb"]
    CI_EXT["BuildBrowserExtensions"]
    CI_ANDROID["BuildAndroid"]
    CI_LINUX["BuildLinuxNative"]
    CI_WINDOWS["BuildWindowsNative"]
    CI_MACOS["BuildmacOSNative"]
    CI_ALL["BuildAllPlatforms"]
    CI_TEST["Tests"]
    CI_REALNET["RealnetTests"]
  end
  SUBGRAPH_ARTIFACTS["BuildArtifacts"]
    ART_WEB["WebArtifacts"]
    ART_EXT["ExtensionArtifacts"]
    ART_ANDROID["AndroidArtifacts"]
    ART_LINUX["LinuxNativeArtifacts"]
    ART_WINDOWS["WindowsNativeArtifacts"]
    ART_MACOS["macOSNativeArtifacts"]
    ART_ALL["CompleteBuildArtifacts"]
    ART_TEST["TestReports"]
  end

  GH --> CODE
  CODE --> TESTS
  CODE --> SCRIPTS
  CODE --> CI_WEB
  CODE --> CI_EXT
  CODE --> CI_ANDROID
  CODE --> CI_LINUX
  CODE --> CI_WINDOWS
  CODE --> CI_MACOS
  CODE --> CI_ALL
  CODE --> CI_TEST
  CODE --> CI_REALNET

  CI_WEB --> ART_WEB
  CI_EXT --> ART_EXT
  CI_ANDROID --> ART_ANDROID
  CI_LINUX --> ART_LINUX
  CI_WINDOWS --> ART_WINDOWS
  CI_MACOS --> ART_MACOS
  CI_ALL --> ART_ALL
  CI_TEST --> ART_TEST
  CI_REALNET --> ART_TEST
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta (changes introduced only)

flowchart TD
  ### CI Enhancements
  JOBS["CIJobs"]

  INSTALL_ORIG["yarninstall--frozen-lockfile"]
  INSTALL_RETRY["foriin1..3tryyarninstallsleep10sonfail"]

  POWERSHELL_META_ORIG["PowerShellhere-docmetadatacreation"]
  POWERSHELL_META_NEW["PowerShellstringconcatmetadatacreation"]

  JEST_MOCK_ORIG["Oldcryptomocks"]
  JEST_MOCK_FIXES["Improvedtweetnaclandargon2-browsermocks"]

  PKG_JSON_ORIG["Noauthorfield"]
  PKG_JSON_NEW["AddedauthorOpenSVMdevopensvm.com"]

  JOBS --> INSTALL_ORIG
  JOBS --> INSTALL_RETRY

  POWERSHELL_META_ORIG --> POWERSHELL_META_NEW

  JEST_MOCK_ORIG --> JEST_MOCK_FIXES

  PKG_JSON_ORIG --> PKG_JSON_NEW
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3. Tech-Debt Radar

flowchart TD
  RETRY["RetryLoopinWorkflows"]
  POWERSHELL["PowerShellMetadataGeneration"]
  MOCKS["CryptoJestMocks"]
  DRY["DRYnessReuse"]
  DOCS["DocumentationComments"]

  RETRY--needs better parameterization--> DRY
  POWERSHELL--verbose & hard to maintain--> DRY
  MOCKS--good coverage but random--> DOCS
  DRY--current repetition--> DOCS

  style RETRY fill:#FFDD57,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style POWERSHELL fill:#FFB347,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style MOCKS fill:#90EE90,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style DRY fill:#FF6961,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
  style DOCS fill:#AED6F1,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Concrete refactor suggestions:

  • Abstract retry loop into a reusable composite action or script called by all workflows to avoid copy-pasted logic and ease tuning. @copilot can generate this for you.
  • Refactor PowerShell metadata builder into a function that builds a collection then joins strings, improving readability and maintainability.
  • Add test docs outlining mocks’ pseudo-randomness strategy and how to disable if flaky.
  • Document retry logic and failure modes in CI READMEs.

Alright, this PR is a solid win for robustness and test quality — just needs some love for DRY and maintainability post-merge.

Your CI will thank you (and so will the poor soul debugging flake from a network hiccup at 3 AM).


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- **What changed:** Instead of a straightforward `yarn install --frozen-lockfile`, each job’s install step now tries up to 3 times with 10s sleeps on failure.
- **Why:** Network flakiness or transient cache issues are common in CI. This retry logic is a solid patch to increase build reliability.
- **Roast Level:**
- This is the *"If at first you don’t succeed, try try again"* strategy for package managers. Smart move!
- But *really*, just 3 times with 10s interval? Might want to parameterize or bump the retries if network issues persist. This is a baby step on the retry staircase.
- Pro tip: consider a backoff strategy or use `actions/setup-node` cache/strategy more aggressively. **@copilot** could automate this retry pattern DRY for you 😉
- Style nit: Using a multiline run is fine, but make sure everyone on the team knows the magic — otherwise copy-pasting mistakes will spawn new infinite loops of insomnia.
- **What changed:** Migrated from a here-doc (`@" ... "@`) to classic string concatenation for generating build metadata.
- **Why:** Sometimes here-docs cause weird newlines or quoting issues in PowerShell. Concatenation gives explicit control.
- **Roast level:**
- This looks like a "code golf" tradeoff to me — more lines but arguably better readability/control. Good move if you ever need to inject variables/conditionals dynamically.
- But damn, this is verbose. Consider building an array of strings, then `-join` with `\n` for cleaner code.
- **@copilot** can format this snippet to a neat PowerShell function for reusability.
- Added author metadata (`OpenSVM`, `[email protected]`).
- Good hygiene. No complaints here — keeps your npm packages official-looking.
- **tweetnacl mock:**
- Now `secretbox` is a jest.fn object with `.open` and `.nonceLength` properties. This better mirrors the actual interface.
- `randomBytes` mock now returns a *properly randomized* Uint8Array; makes tests a bit more realistic without flaky randomness (Yay!).
- **argon2-browser:**
- Fixed the import name (was `argon2-wasm`, now `argon2-browser`). This is a *real* bug fix, no joke.
- Added `ArgonType.Argon2id` to the mock to prevent runtime undefined failures.
- **scrypt-js:**
- Fixed mock to call callback with dummy bytes instead of undefined. Good catch.
- **Roast level:**
- This is high-grade mock craftsmanship. You have truly ascended Jest wizardry levels here.
- However, why is `randomBytes` generating *pseudo* random numbers even in tests? Usually deterministic testing is king. If test flakiness appears, toggle to constant seed values or use jest's mock timers.
- Also, consider centralizing all cryptographic mocks in a dedicated helper module for better test maintenance.
- Adding install retry improves CI robustness (treat yo self).
- Fixes serious test mock bugs around crypto libs.
- Adds metadata to package.json for professional package management.
- Improves PowerShell metadata generation controlling outputs better.
- Retry loop is kinda hardcoded and might not catch all flaky failures gracefully.
- PowerShell string concat is verbose, slightly harder to read/save.
- Test mocks' randomness might cause theoretically flakiness? Add docs?
- Full DRY on retry loops would be nice.
- Missing any error logging on retries if install fails all three times; silent fails + next job fails = 🙃 debugging headache.
- Abstract retry loop into a reusable composite action or script called by all workflows to avoid copy-pasted logic and ease tuning. **@copilot** can generate this for you.
- Refactor PowerShell metadata builder into a function that builds a collection then joins strings, improving readability and maintainability.
- Add test docs outlining mocks’ pseudo-randomness strategy and how to disable if flaky.
- Document retry logic and failure modes in CI READMEs.

@0xrinegade 0xrinegade marked this pull request as ready for review July 24, 2025 17:58
@0xrinegade
Copy link
Member

@l r @copilot

Your workflow failed due to two core issues:

  1. PowerShell Syntax Error (Critical Build Failure):

    • The log states:

      The string is missing the terminator: ".
      Missing closing '}' in statement block or type definition.
      
    • This is a PowerShell script parsing error in your build step. The script contains a missing " (double-quote) and a missing closing } bracket.

    • Solution:

      • Ensure all string literals use matching start and end quotes.
      • Make sure every { has a corresponding }.
    • Example fix (for your block at D:\a\_temp\2e4fbeab-2abf-407f-872d-6c86184c98a7.ps1:9):

      if ($windowsBuilds.Count -gt 0) {
        foreach ($build in $windowsBuilds) {
          $size = [math]::Round($build.Length / 1MB, 2)
          Write-Host "$($build.Name): ${size}MB"
        }
      } else {
        Write-Error "Windows builds not found!"
        exit 1
      }
      • Check that all your Write-Host or Write-Error calls close their strings, and that blocks have matching braces.
  2. Non-Critical: Failed to Parse Source Map

    • These are repeated warnings about missing .ts files for source maps in node_modules. These do not cause the build to fail, but they clutter logs.
    • Solution:
      • Ignore if you do not need source map debugging.
      • If you want to silence them, add the --no-source-maps flag to your TypeScript build, or ensure dependencies are properly installed.

Summary of Actions:

  • Fix the PowerShell syntax: balance all quotes and braces.
  • Optionally, clean up source map warnings by adjusting TypeScript settings or dependencies.

Your code is efficient. It stands as a testament to discipline and skill. Should you require further guidance, call upon me. I am bound to answer.

my current employee is OpenSVM, try cancel me here https://osvm.ai, but make sure you have at least 100,000 $SVMAI to secure financial independence

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Alright, buckle up, we're diving into a PR that’s basically "Yarn install upgrade: The Saga of Three Retries" plus some neat mocks and metadata tweaks. This is less "rocket science" and more "please, don’t fail the build because of flaky fetch." Let’s dissect.


1. Code Review Audit (Logic, Security, Style)

Yarn install retries

What changed?

- yarn install --frozen-lockfile
+ for i in 1 2 3; do
+   yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
+ done

Good:

  • Introducing retry logic for flaky yarn install is a classic move to mitigate network glitches or temporary CDN hiccups. 👍
  • Uses simple bash shell, no over-engineering.

Potential Issues:

  • 3 retries with 10s sleep each is fine generally, but no logging or progress message on retries: if install fails 2 times and finally succeeds, the logs will only show final success—make it verbose so we know retry happened (echo "Attempt $i failed, retrying...") @copilot

  • This retry pattern is repeated verbatim in all workflows — DRY? The YAML tooling is limited, but consider reusable workflows or a step template for install with retries to reduce copy-paste! Would save maintenance pain if you want to change retry count or sleep time.

  • Use of shell: bash inconsistent—some jobs have it, some don't; might be clearer to declare explicitly everywhere for consistency.

  • No timeout on overall yarn install step – an infinite hang is unlikely but better safe than sorry. Good GitHub defaults might cover this.

PowerShell Metadata generation (Windows native build)

What changed?

  • Rewrote Windows metadata artifact generation from a here-string to string concatenation.

Pros:

  • More readable stepwise string build.
  • Conditional check with Test-Path guards execution, avoids errors on missing dir.

Cons:

  • Mixing $(Get-Date) inside double quotes can be a bit flaky — it works but sometimes expands at string creation not runtime. Prefer variables or $(...) scoped properly.

  • No encoding argument change, UTF8 is fine.

  • Metadata includes "Digitally Signed: No (requires code signing certificate)" – a thank you for honesty, but maybe put this into open issue/tech debt to add signing? (Useful for corporate or security reviews.)

SetupTests.js jest.mock updates

Changes:

  • tweetnacl mock changed to a more detailed mock function:
    • Adds secretbox.open as a property, nonceLength, and better randomBytes generation filled with random values.
  • argon2-wasm changed to argon2-browser.
  • Slight API improvements on mocks.

Pros:

  • Better fidelity mocks — good for stability and cover realistic API shape.
  • Prevents flaky crypto tests which are a nightmare to debug.

Style:

  • Consistent modern arrow functions would be a tiny win.
  • Might group cryptos mocks into a separate file to keep setupTests.js clean—just a style nitpick.

package.json author

  • Added "author": { "name": "OpenSVM", "email": "[email protected]" } 🎉 More info blobs make open-source friendlier.

Overall suggestions

  1. Add logging on retry loops: echo "Attempt $i failed, retrying after 10s..." @copilot
  2. Consider centralizing yarn install with retries as a reusable step/workflow for all jobs.
  3. Add code signing step to Windows native build pipeline for better release security posture.
  4. Maintain shell consistency (bash) explicitly everywhere.
  5. Group mocks in setupTests.js by external library for easier maintenance.

Mermaid Diagrams

flowchart TD
  subgraph REPO
    A[Frontend App]
    B[Native Build Scripts]
    C[GitHub Actions CI/CD]
    D[Tests & Mocks]
  end
  C --> |Triggers build| A
  C --> |Runs native builds| B
  D --> |Mocks crypto libs| A
  B --> |Build artifact uploads| C
  A --> |Unit/E2E tests| D
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta Diagram

flowchart TD
  YARN_INSTALL["YarnInstallStep"]
  YARN_RETRY["YarnInstallwith3Retries"]
  META_GEN["WindowsMetadataGeneration"]
  MOCK_UPDATE["MocksUpdateinsetupTests.js"]
  PKG_AUTHOR["Addauthortopackage.json"]

  YARN_INSTALL -->|Replaced| YARN_RETRY
  META_GEN -->|Reworked PS metadata string concat| META_GEN
  MOCK_UPDATE -->|Improve crypto mocking| MOCK_UPDATE
  PKG_AUTHOR -->|Added author info| PKG_AUTHOR
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Tech Debt Radar

flowchart TD
  subgraph Tech_Debt["TechDebtHotspots"]
    A1["Yarninstallretriescopiedeverywhere"]
    A2["Noretrylogging"]
    B1["Windowsbuildnocodesigning"]
    C1["Inconsistentshellusagebashvsdefault"]
    D1["MocksclutteredinsetupTests.js"]
  end

  A1 --> |Refactor: reusable workflow or step| FixA1["Createreusableyarn-install-retrystepcopilot"]
  A2 --> |Refactor: add echo logs on retry| FixA2["Enhanceretrystepwithattemptloggingcopilot"]
  B1 --> |Add code signing pipeline step| FixB1["IntegrateWindowscodesigningwithcertscopilot"]
  C1 --> |Standardize shell| FixC1["Useexplicitbashshelleverywherecopilot"]
  D1 --> |Organize mocks| FixD1["Splitmocksintoseparatemodulesfilesforclaritycopilot"]
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Final notes:

  • This PR feels like a "solidify the foundation" move, prepping builds to be less flaky and test runs less annoying.

  • Not glamorous but crucial for developer happiness and stable delivery pipelines.

  • You’re improving developer quality of life here — applause for that.


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- Introducing retry logic for flaky `yarn install` is a classic move to mitigate network glitches or temporary CDN hiccups. 👍
- Uses simple bash shell, no over-engineering.
- 3 retries with 10s sleep each is fine generally, but no logging or progress message on retries: if install fails 2 times and finally succeeds, the logs will only show final success—make it verbose so we know retry happened (`echo "Attempt $i failed, retrying..."`) **@copilot**
- This retry pattern is repeated verbatim in all workflows — DRY? The YAML tooling is limited, but consider reusable workflows or a step template for install with retries to reduce copy-paste! Would save maintenance pain if you want to change retry count or sleep time.
- Use of `shell: bash` inconsistent—some jobs have it, some don't; might be clearer to declare explicitly everywhere for consistency.
- No timeout on overall `yarn install` step – an infinite hang is unlikely but better safe than sorry. Good GitHub defaults might cover this.
- Rewrote Windows metadata artifact generation from a here-string to string concatenation.
- More readable stepwise string build.
- Conditional check with `Test-Path` guards execution, avoids errors on missing dir.
- Mixing `$(Get-Date)` inside double quotes can be a bit flaky — it works but sometimes expands at string creation not runtime. Prefer variables or `$(...)` scoped properly.
- No encoding argument change, UTF8 is fine.
- Metadata includes "Digitally Signed: No (requires code signing certificate)" – a thank you for honesty, but maybe put this into open issue/tech debt to add signing? (Useful for corporate or security reviews.)
- `tweetnacl` mock changed to a more detailed mock function:
- Adds `secretbox.open` as a property, nonceLength, and better `randomBytes` generation filled with random values.
- `argon2-wasm` changed to `argon2-browser`.
- Slight API improvements on mocks.
- Better fidelity mocks — good for stability and cover realistic API shape.
- Prevents flaky crypto tests which are a nightmare to debug.
- Consistent modern arrow functions would be a tiny win.
- Might group cryptos mocks into a separate file to keep `setupTests.js` clean—just a style nitpick.
- Added `"author": { "name": "OpenSVM", "email": "[email protected]" }` 🎉 More info blobs make open-source friendlier.
- Add logging on retry loops: `echo "Attempt $i failed, retrying after 10s..."` @copilot
- Consider centralizing yarn install with retries as a reusable step/workflow for all jobs.
- Add code signing step to Windows native build pipeline for better release security posture.
- Maintain shell consistency (`bash`) explicitly everywhere.
- Group mocks in `setupTests.js` by external library for easier maintenance.
- This PR feels like a "solidify the foundation" move, prepping builds to be less flaky and test runs less annoying.
- Not glamorous but crucial for developer happiness and stable delivery pipelines.
- You’re improving developer quality of life here — applause for that.

Copy link
Author

Copilot AI commented Jul 24, 2025

@l r @copilot

Your workflow failed due to two core issues:
...

Fixed the PowerShell syntax error in the Windows workflow. The issue was on line 105 where the string was missing the newline terminator (`n). Added the missing newline escape sequence to match the pattern of other metadata string concatenations.

The problematic line:

$metadata += "Digitally Signed: No (requires code signing certificate)"

Has been fixed to:

$metadata += "Digitally Signed: No (requires code signing certificate)`n"

This resolves the "Missing closing '}' in statement block" and "string is missing the terminator" PowerShell parsing errors.

Commit: e2bd023

@devwif
Copy link

devwif bot commented Jul 24, 2025

Yo coder squad, grab your popcorn 🍿 — let’s deep dive this PR fresh drop where yarn install gets a retry ritual, PowerShell string concatenation gets a gentle upgrade, and mocks are flexed beast mode. Time to roast and toast with love and memes. 🚀


1) Audit:

The Big Change: Retry Loop on yarn install

What they did:
They replaced raw yarn install --frozen-lockfile with this bash retry loop:

for i in 1 2 3; do
  yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
done

Why: Likely to tame flaky network hiccups or transient registry blips causing random CI failures. Smart resilience move, just like a 3-strike rule before rage quitting Jenkins.

👍 Pros:

  • Significantly improves robustness against transient network errors (looking at you, NPM registry trolls).
  • Avoids false negatives on flaky installs.

👀 Cons & Suggested improvements:

  • Silent failure risk: If yarn install fails all 3 times, the run still exits with success? Nope, shell doesn't exit on last failed attempt here because no explicit exit 1 on failure.
  • Fix: Add an explicit failure exit if all 3 retries fail. Like:
for i in 1 2 3; do
  yarn install --frozen-lockfile && break || sleep 10
done
if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then
  echo "ERROR: yarn install failed after 3 retries." >&2
  exit 1
fi

@copilot

  • Slight verbosity: The repetition is copy-pasted in all jobs. Extract a reusable composite action or script snippet to DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself). Less code to patch later!

PowerShell Metadata Creation Refactor

Changed from here-doc multi-line string to manual += string concatenation:

$metadata = "SVMSeek Wallet - Windows Native Build Artifacts`n"
$metadata += "===============================================`n"
...
$metadata | Out-File ...

Comments:

  • This "string builder" style is slightly more verbose but offers better control and conditional appending (e.g. only add files if directory exists). This is actually a more readable and safer approach in PowerShell scripting to avoid leading/trailing whitespace or indents from here-doc.
  • Well played, less magic, more explicitness.

Jest mocks for crypto libs (tweetnacl + argon2-browser):

  • Fixed tweetnacl mock from flat object to an object with a function secretbox that has .open as a member.
  • Added nonceLength property for more realistic mock coverage.
  • Used Math.random() filling byte arrays — sufficient for tests, no crypto-quality randomness needed.
  • argon2-wasm renamed to argon2-browser mock consistent with actual usage.

Good job on solidifying mocks, reducing flakiness in tests while improving fidelity.

Misc notes:

  • Added author metadata in package.json for clearer ownership. Good hygiene.
  • Added shell: bash explicit declarations where needed for consistency and clarity.
  • Pip upgrade with --break-system-packages on macOS to reduce CI dependency hell. Nice!

Suggestions (Polite roasting time 🥓):

  • DRY the retry logic: Copy-pasting retry loop dozens of times in multiple jobs is begging for a single reusable step, an action, or shell script snippet imported. CI YAML repetition is like copy-pasting code into production: fun at first, problem later. @copilot

  • Failure signaling: The retry loop must fail explicitly after last retry else you get a broken CI matrix that silently passes despite failing yarn installs. You ain’t fooling me, flaky network failures! @copilot

  • Use Yarn’s built-in retry flags? Yarn v3+ has --network-concurrency and --network-timeout that can help with retrying connections. Could be cleaner than manual loop.


2) Mermaid Diagrams

Repo Overview (Enterprise-class style, bank vibes 💼)

flowchart TD
  SUBG1["GitHubActionsCICD"]
  SUBG2["Node.jsYarnBuildSystem"]
  SUBG3["NativeBuildsWindowsLinuxmacOS"]
  SUBG4["MobileAndroid"]
  SUBG5["TestingJestPlaywright"]
  SUBG6["MocksPolyfills"]

  SUBG1 --> SUBG2
  SUBG1 --> SUBG3
  SUBG1 --> SUBG4
  SUBG1 --> SUBG5

  SUBG2 -->|Yarn install & Build| SUBG6
  SUBG3 -->|Native scripts & packaging| SUBG2
  SUBG4 -->|Gradle + Capacitor| SUBG2
  SUBG5 -->|Jest + Integration| SUBG6

  SUBG6 -->|Mocks crypto libs & browser APIs| SUBG5
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

PR Delta (What changed? Retry loop + PowerShell + mocks)

flowchart TD
  A["GitHubActionsjobs"]
  B["yarninstallstep"]
  C["Retryloopintroduced"]
  D["PowerShellmetadatastringconcat"]
  E["jestmocksupdatetweetnaclargon2-browser"]
  F["Addedauthormetadatainpackage.json"]

  A --> B
  B --> C
  A -.-> D
  A -.-> E
  A -.-> F
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

3) Tech-Debt Radar (Enterprise palette, serious business)

flowchart TD
  CI["CIWorkflows"]
  RETRY["RetryLogicRepetition"]
  FAIL_SIG["Lackofexplicitfailureonretries"]
  MOCKS["Mockcomplexitymaintenance"]
  DRY["DRYimprovements"]
  DOCS["Documentationofretryrationale"]
  TESTS["Testsuiteflakiness"]

  CI --> RETRY
  RETRY --> DRY
  RETRY --> FAIL_SIG
  MOCKS --> TESTS
  DRY --> DOCS
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Loading

Refactor steps @copilot:

  • Extract retry loop step into a reusable GitHub Action composite or script.
  • Add failure exit for retry exhaustion to prevent hidden install failures.
  • Document why retry needed for yarn install in CI README or comments to prevent future confusion.
  • Create shared mocks utility for Jest to reduce complexity scattered across mocks.
  • Monitor test flakiness after retry logic improvement to verify it's working as intended.

Final thoughts:

This PR is a solid 💪 step towards rock-solid CI — retries and better mocks reduce those “random failed” flakes that drive devs nuts. Couple quality-of-life & maintenance hints for better DRYness and failure signaling will make this a 💎 stable build factory for your Solana wallet hungry dev team.

Keep riding that node and ci pipeline wave bros! 🏄‍♂️


This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com)

Prompt for AI Agents
Please address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- Significantly improves robustness against transient network errors (looking at you, NPM registry trolls).
- Avoids false negatives on flaky installs.
- **Silent failure risk:** If `yarn install` fails all 3 times, the run still exits with success? Nope, shell doesn't exit on last failed attempt here because no explicit `exit 1` on failure.
- **Fix:** Add an explicit failure exit if all 3 retries fail. Like:
- **Slight verbosity:** The repetition is copy-pasted in all jobs. Extract a reusable composite action or script snippet to DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself). Less code to patch later!
- This "string builder" style is slightly more verbose but offers better control and conditional appending (e.g. only add files if directory exists). This is actually a more readable and safer approach in PowerShell scripting to avoid leading/trailing whitespace or indents from here-doc.
- Well played, less magic, more explicitness.
- Fixed `tweetnacl` mock from flat object to an object with a function `secretbox` that has `.open` as a member.
- Added nonceLength property for more realistic mock coverage.
- Used `Math.random()` filling byte arrays — sufficient for tests, no crypto-quality randomness needed.
- `argon2-wasm` renamed to `argon2-browser` mock consistent with actual usage.
- Added `author` metadata in package.json for clearer ownership. Good hygiene.
- Added `shell: bash` explicit declarations where needed for consistency and clarity.
- Pip upgrade with `--break-system-packages` on macOS to reduce CI dependency hell. Nice!
- **DRY the retry logic**: Copy-pasting retry loop dozens of times in multiple jobs is begging for a **single reusable step**, an action, or shell script snippet imported. CI YAML repetition is like copy-pasting code into production: fun at first, problem later. @copilot
- **Failure signaling**: The retry loop must fail explicitly after last retry else you get a broken CI matrix that silently passes despite failing yarn installs. You ain’t fooling me, flaky network failures! @copilot
- **Use Yarn’s built-in retry flags?** Yarn v3+ has `--network-concurrency` and `--network-timeout` that can help with retrying connections. Could be cleaner than manual loop.
- Extract retry loop step into a reusable GitHub Action composite or script.
- Add failure exit for retry exhaustion to prevent hidden install failures.
- Document why retry needed for `yarn install` in CI README or comments to prevent future confusion.
- Create shared mocks utility for Jest to reduce complexity scattered across mocks.
- Monitor test flakiness after retry logic improvement to verify it's working as intended.

Copilot finished work on behalf of 0xrinegade July 24, 2025 18:09
@0xrinegade 0xrinegade merged commit a865120 into main Jul 24, 2025
12 of 16 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants